Ordered takeout on my first visit. When I called over the phone, simply say your order. They do not ask for your name, which could make life difficult if your memory isn't great. I settled with the BBQ Chicken Wrap, which was favorable and not too messy. It also comes with french fries. You can add bacon to the wrap and even a burger for an extra $. Now, to get to the pizza on my next visit. Customer service was good for the most part, greeting and getting the order to me. There are plenty of tables to eat inside, which look clean and organized, including all around. read more

Great pizza great service !!! You can eat there but I prefer to eat it at home.Try it you'll love it

I haven't been in here in quite a while, in part, because the guys behind the counter tend to be rude. somethings never change. They didn't say anything offensive to me, but they just come off a bit too familiar for my liking. The cheese calzone was OK but at $8, I'll pass next time read more

Goodfellas Restaurant & Pizzeria - menus - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

Service is ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE!! I've been there on many occasions & always leave mad because of the rude service. This time was worst than before!! Pizza was still cold & all I asked was to also have it cut in half, which I guess was too much. So rude & disrespectful!!! Never in my life, will I EVER return to this place. I don't want to make it a racial thing but it's obvious they pick & choose who to be respectful too!! Thank you but no thank you for your horrible service!!!! read more

Classic, authentic NY pizza! Slices, whole pies, wedges...great casual place for lunch or dinner. Lots of space for dining in. The service is great and these guys have a good sense of humor. Always have to stop in for at least a slice when I am in the area. read more

Goodfellas Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

The waitress who served us was so incredibly kind. However, the food is just bad. Pasta was mushy and overcooked, veal was dry and bland, the sauce gave me instant heartburn. Pizza was ok, not great. It looks like it hasn't been renovated since the 80s but I'm guessing nostalgia is what people here are looking to buy. I really wish I had something better to say but the only reason it gets 2 stars is because of the lovely waitress. read more

We have been getting our pizzas and heros/subs here since they opened. Their Meatlovers pizza is excellent. The sub rolls are always fresh and perfectly toasted and filled to capacity with your favorite selection. T. read more

Best pizza I have had in a very long time. Haven't seen pizzeria that you get choices of slice with fresh mozzarella and pepperoni or ground beef. read more

Goodfellas has been a staple in the area for a long. Best Sicilian pizza in the area as well. Their plain pizza is top notch as well! Super fast at getting you your food, whether it's a slice, pie or entree. Keep up the great work Goodfellas! read more

I've been going here for around 9 years. Service is quick, employees are super nice, food is delicious! Only good things to say about Goodfellas. Totally recommend coming! read more

Their combo pizza is excellent. I don't have anything else to say so post this review.

Good food. Got there a little late and they still sat us. Service was good. Food was better. If ever in Red Mill, Ny area go check them out. read more

Goodfellas Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

See all

What is it with this place? As soon as you walk in the gentleman behind the counter is VERY stand offish. Then as we order we look over and see a picture on the wall that a child must have drew, it has a family, and underneath one of the people is clearly labeled as "Mexican". Why would you have that hanging up? We get the pizza, and well, nothing to separate them from any other pizza place. Regardless, I'll take my business elsewhere. Pizza places are a dime a dozen. read more

Ordered a pepper and egg hero which was delicious. However, in checking my receipt, there was a 50 cent charge for take-out. WTF? Last time I give them my money. I'll go back to Gino's in Poughkeepsie. They don't play these games. read more

Staff is rude, even to kids. Food is far below standards. Pick another spot to go to. Not worth the money.

Ordered a spaghetti & meatballs - was too small like kid sized (price was $9). He said he brought breadsticks - there were none. The spaghetti was encased in too much (baked) cheese. The round aluminum container was not filled up to the top. There was no plastic fork in the pizza box. I did get many packets of grated cheese which I did not need. The delivery took about 30 to 45 mins to come. After I ate it I was still hungry. The meatballs were overcooked & dry. They were not really meatballs but meat slices. Very unimpressive. read more

Good pizza, calzones, garlic knots. Sat down for actual dinner and it wasn't amazing. Calamari wasn't too good for an Italian place; all rings like the frozen type. The vodka sauce had good taste but was more of a tomato sauce. Spaghetti & meatballs were very good though! Also nice people. read more

Goodfellas Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

I went I. In a Sunday at about 4:15 pm. I ordered a chicken roll and I root beer. The root beer was good but the cup was filled to the rim with ice and it was $2.59 for a medium soda. Probably about 10 or 12 ounces of liquid. The chicken roll was mozzarella cheese with about 4 small cubes of chicken. And the cheese is nothing to write home about. Very chewy and bland. The sauce was ok, again nothing to write home about. The two men working there seemed to be focused on the game on television. A few people came into the dining room when I was there and it seemed that they were a little annoyed to have to deal with them. To be fair, it was a Sunday afternoon, very very slow and maybe they were just chilling during the slow part of the day but the food was not great. read more

Had a slice of Sicilian today ~ delizioso! (Or should I say Ochen Horoscho!?) My review stands, very good food guys. And they were almost friendly! read more

Had the misfortune to stop for a couple of slices today. Slice of white, which had barely any flavor. No garlic taste what so ever & needed salt badly. Slice of buffalo chicken which horrible. No flavor at all. Threw it in the trash. $7.00 for two bad slices. NEVER AGAIN!!!!! read more

Every time I eat here or order pizza it's always good not oily not greasy very good food.

Went recently and walked in restaurant during raging pandemic to find no employees wearing masks and the TV pointed toward the customers was tuned to Newsmax which, if you're not aware, is that crazy network that spreads Trump's lies as if they were true. They could also at least TRY to be pleasant to their customers. They act like they are doing you a favor by letting you give them your money. I have experienced this every single time that I have been there. The pizza wasn't bad but I will never return to Goodfellas. read more

This review is only about the pizza, as I haven't tried any of their other dishes. Great pizza! Lots of variety if you just want to get a slice or two. My favorites are the lasagna slice and the sausage/peppers/onion slice. Big slices. The decor and service are average, but if I'm just getting a slice of pizza, I really don't care about that. One of the places in the area that's more similar to NY style pizza. read more

Jessica was our waitress .It is such a pleasure to be greeted with a smile. Jessica knew all the rite things to say and do. Quality service start to Finnish Tonight my wife and I had the best dining experience that we have had in the past year. In the mood for good Italian we tried Goodfellas for diner.The entrée's were pipping hot.Generous portions. I had the home made Lasagna with a side of sausage ,my wife had tortellini Alfredo ,Jessica offered broccoli or chicken added , we said yes. Both chicken and broccoli added and it was fantastic. On the way out we told the owner about our experience . He was genuine I'm stoping on my way home Wednesday for one of their amazing brick oven pizzas. Great service and great food! read more

One of the best grilled chicken salad I've ever had!! . Fresh and delicious!!! Extensive menu options and various pizza options the pizza look delicious! read more

Goodfellas is number 1 in this area. The food is great. I always compare other places to Goodfellas and no other place beats it. The guys that run it are nice they make you feel welcome. The pizza is great to. They are reasonably priced. Very affordable for a family to go have dinner there and enjoy themselves. read more

I had the stuffed rigatoni al la vodka. It was excellent- lots of homemade sauce- cooked to perfection! Always the best pasta here!

So at first glance I thought the set up of the place was cool. But that's about it. I got a to go order and they completely messed it up. On top of that it didn't teasr good either. I would give this place a 2 and a half if I could. I'll give it one more shot if I'm ever over that way again. read more

I see this address is wrong. Because I go To Good Fellas Pizza at 47 Vassar Rd, Poughkeepsie, NY 12603. After going there that pas 15 years, I know pizza, Pasta and Poughkeepsie. Know the three P's is almost as important as knowing the three Good Fellas, Sal, Brian and Tony. They are the best. I always have a good time eating, drinking and laughing with these guys. They know how to make a great pie. And I never leave town knowing that the pizza I ate there is seldom reproduced anywhere else. Please don't take my word for it. Just head on over to Red Oaks Mill, 47 Vassar Rd, Poughkeepsie, NY read more

My favorite pizza place around. Always has the best pizza, garlic knots, fries and chicken Parmesan. Have been eating here for 21 years and won't stop anytime soon! By far the best pizza you can find around. I never go anywhere else! read more

I've been to Goodfellows maybe eight times in the last two years. The guys behind the counter are not very friendly. I usually get pizza which is doughy and bland. I think with all the pizza restaurants in the area, I will avoid this place in the future. read more

I love Goodfellas pizza. Also, I love their lasagna, spaghetti and their salads. Just finished half a pie of pepperoni and mushrooms. Boy, was that good. I think Sal and Brian are the best. Freddie is really good, too. I recommend Goodfellas pizza in red oaks mill to all my my friends. read more

WOW, am I the only one who has experienced a decline in customer service and quality of food at Goodfellas in Red Oaks Mills? I spoke with an owner this evening about my concerns. He was there when I picked up my order. How can an owner let food be served to customers without managing the quality of the product? It wasn't busy in the restaurant. In fact the owner was sitting on the prep table just behind the pizza case. I ordered a meatball parm. I ate a few bites and realized there was no sauce. I didn't finish it. An hour later my stomach is sick. I throw up. The cavalier argumentative attitude of the owner, once I have expressed my concerns and sickness has this 20+ year customer looking elsewhere to satisfy my Italian cravings. I'm taking the leftovers to the Board of Health to be tested. read more

First time I've been here but very impressed. Pizza delicious and well worth the price. I haven't tried their other food yet but if it's anything like the pizza then I'm in!! read more

AMAZING DINING EXPERIENCE!!! The waitress is one of the best and most accommodating ones I've ever seen!! To top it off, the food was good and came out fast so we weren't waiting forever. Will definitely be back!!! read more

I have been going to Goodfellas Pizzeria for over ten years and every time I've gone I have not been disappointed yet. The staff is friendly and very accommodating and the pizza is excellent whether it is fresh or sent into the oven for a warming. As soon as you walk in you can smell the fresh pizza and the multitude of flavors that await your decision, from Chicken Marsala to White to Buffalo Chicken or even just plain cheese! I've taken many a friend here and will continue to give them my business read more

my Teenage Daughter and a friend ate a this pizza place last night she ordered a personal pizza and a soda and they had the nerve to charge for $14... and for the same type of pizza and drink at Pizza Village that she went to a few weeks ago was $3 less. So before this pizza place can charge such I high price they need to have the quality of Pizza to back it up. I have not been there in over 15 years and now I know why... the staff are also very rude!!! read more

Great food; large portions at extremely reasonable prices. Waitress ALWAYS friendly. The 2 guys can be a little more friendlier. Pizza joint who sells beer....negative:does not deliver. read more

A local staple. Pizza is best (most authentic) on the block.... Could be their ovens.

Over priced slices. Had a pepperoni and a spinach one $7.00? Won't be eating here again not so much because of price shock but simply because it wasn't that good either. Yuk read more