Cousin time eating pizza! Got a few appetizers! The calamari and the bruschetta were so good! The honey badger pizza was probably my favorite. The hot honey with the soppressata is such a great combo! We also got the goodfella pizza and pepperoni! read more

Definitely a new server, but he really tried. Food was good, but the salad was really pricey. Would prefer a smaller options that didn't cost $16. It was a waste really. The meatball sub was good. The ravioli appetizer was a nice starter - sauce options were good. Nothing amazing, but it was a decent meal. read more

One of my favorite local pizza places. We come here for lunch during the week almost monthly. The staff and pies are always great. The pizza is NY style which I prefer. Between two of us, we always order two large pizzas so we have leftovers to take home. It looks crazy on our little 2-top table, but we make it work. I've never had a bad pizza or experience at this place. I definitely recommend it for dine in or take out!!! read more

My first time at Goodfellas was an absolute delight. The food, service, and ambiance were all top-notch. It's a family-friendly restaurant that deserves a solid five stars read more

Great Pizza! was staying at the Residence Inn next door went in for a pizza the first night I stayed and it was awesome! Crust was just right cheese pull was great and had great flavor. went in the next night looking to try the lasagna but the kitchen was backed up and taking 45 minutes minimum to get orders out, said thanks to the bartender for letting me know so I left and came back 2 days later and tried the lasagna and it was really good as well! cool cozy banquets and tables kind of what you think a place called Goodfellas would be like inside read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - Meat Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

See all

It was empty when we went in, which makes sense since it was an odd lunch time but the ambiance was still good. The service was fast! The mozzarella sticks were the best part of our meal, if you get anything from here get the mozzarella sticks. The pizza was ok, I understand what the other reviews mean by a soggy crust. I wouldn't say it's soggy, but it's definitely very soft and weak. Oftentimes my pizza would break off from the crust, if that makes sense. It was a fine pizza, but not the best and I definitely wouldn't come back for the pizza. read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - Homemade Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

See all

Yum!! it has been a few years and we wanted to take the hubs to try this. Goodfellas did not disappoint! ;) He tried the chicken Parmesan and said it was wonderful. I tried the Goodfellas woodfired pizza and I would go back for it again. Mom tried the meatball hero and side salad. She said it was delish. The restaurant was really clean and it has a very hip vibe. We will be back. read more

See all

Goodfellas is always a go-to when we have a pizza or Italian food craving. The service is amazing and the pizza is our favorite. Its fresh, flavorful and authentic! read more

Best Italian food place around! The atmosphere is very nice, and fun. Staff were kind and helpful, and the manager was very awesome. Would highly recommend! Pizza is amazing, and the spicy peppers and chicken pasta was delicious! Great place! read more

I Uber eats a small meat pizza with spicy honey sauce. It came still piping hot, including the sauce! There were 6 slices each slice was huge at least for me who is used to eating thin crust. From the first taste all the way to the last bite it was phenomenal. It was a pizza experience like no other. That spicy honey sauce is Magnifique! If you have never tried this place it is a must. Make your own decision & review. read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - How it arrived! - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

See all

To start with the good. The food was actually pretty tasty. I got the Italian nachos since it seemed like something different. I enjoyed the fried pasta with the toppings on top. However, the jalepenos threw me off. It took away from the Italian flavors and I thought just the banana peppers would be better. The server was friendly once I got seated. To the bad now. When I walked in I had a long wait. The place was empty but only had the one server who I guess was also the hostess. Three of us were waiting for tables up front. I would not have had an issue with this but the manager/owner was sitting at the bar playing on his computer. That's the time to step up and help out your staff and serve your customers. Being that oblivious is not a good sign. read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - Italian Nachos - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

Levi is a great addition to this place! He's very cordial and solves issues immediately without excuses! We've been coming here a long time He's the best thing since Austin! Great hire! read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - Beer price - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

Had lunch today at this location. The pizza is wood-fired with a light, crisp crust and very flavorful. The atmosphere is laid back and relaxing with nice and modern decor and very clean. Our server (Ella) was friendly, knowledgeable about the menu items and provided great service. The manager (Mark) was very personable and engaged with the guests to ensure their dining experience was positive. You have the option to dine indoors or the outdoor patio. We will return in the future and recommend if you're near The Colony area. read more

See all

Nice clean and comfortable place. It's right across parking lot from hotel I was staying at. Went for a dinner and a lunch. Did not try the pizza as I had pizza twice the week before. Dinner was a spicy chicken pasta dish served with two soft garlic breadsticks. Portion size was great, good flavors, not drowning in sauce. Lunch was a chicken tuscon salad. Had a lot of chicken on top in strips. Salad was wonderful, though I wish the bowl itself was larger to hold the actual salad. Service was bright and cheerful and you can pay at the table. Beer list could be a little bigger but hey, convenient location was great. read more

Service was good, food was standard fire oven pizza, cheese bread was great! We came to watch some NCAA basketball, not a great place to watch a game. But if you're in town and are looking for good pizza this is a good choice. read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

Food was good as usual but service was very poor. Cooper was our server and 1. Ordered water with lemon (came with no lemons) 2. Asked for straws - never received. 3. Ordered a large Caesar salad - never received it. 4. Only dropped off our food and came back to see if we wanted dessert once we were done eating. My husband's water was empty for the entire dinner and Cooper passed by the table at least 4-5 times but never stopped by to ask if we needed anything. He only had 2 other tables. My daughter has had him as a server before and vowed never to dine in again. No excuse for this type of service when the restaurant is less than half full. read more

This place has very good tasty food, with friendly staff and attentive service, and the atmosphere is nice and relaxed and enjoyable.

Goodfellas' pasta is amazing! I honestly go there for pasta, not for pizza, but their pizza is good, simply not my taste. Service was prompt and very friendly. It's a little small but well decorated and clean. They have great lunch specials! You can get a drink,a salad and a main dish for $12.00. read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

The customer service here was amazing! We came in for lunch on a Sunday with a group size of 10 and the waitress was nice and attentive. For the healthy eaters their marinated salmon salad was a 10/10 and of course the pizza was cooked to perfection. Will be back read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - Bar area - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

Great pizza here! We had great service as well and it was clean and just what you'd expect for a pizza joint! Go grab a slice! It's good stuff! read more

Our first time here and it was great! Gluten free pasta was perfectly cooked. Our server, Mariana, was so sweet and attentive! We look forward to trying the pizza next! read more

We sat down at the bar and were greeted with warmth by Levi and Serenity. This with my fiancée and I's first visit to Goodfellas, and we're blown away with their service. We entrusted them with their recommendations of the burrata and 2 16" pizzas. The start of the burrata was an excellent start with fresh juicy tomatoes and their burrata was needless to say perfect!! They informed us that pizzas could be made with half and half options. We tried the Honey Badger, Mediterranean, Smoking Good fellas, and the off menu option Burrata pizzas. The pizzas were mouthwatering with flavor and the crust was perfect! WE WILL BE BACK!!!! read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - The Honey Badger, Mediterranean, Smoking Good fellas, and the off menu option Burrata pizzas. - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

See all

Excellent pizza! Wife had the artichoke spinach pizza (1/2) and I did the meat lovers. Service was a little slow but used that for an excuse to drink some wine . It is a good family restaurant. Stop by and you won't be disappointed! read more

What an incredible visit to Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza we had on a recent Saturday evening. We were meeting friends to have dinner before attending a musical at local high school. Our friends lived in The Colony and were frequents diners at Goodfellas. We were not led wrong; our visit was fantastic. First off, Goodfellas has an extensive menu. Wow, everything is on it when it comes to Italian food. We had a hard time making a decision. While we were "surfing" the menu, we ordered a couple of appetizers, Classic Italian meatballs and Garlic Bread. I apologize for not grabbing a photo of the platters, but everyone dug in. Both of the appetizers were so delicious. The meatballs had an incredible texture, so moist and tender. My wife and I finally decided on our entrees. She decided to order the "Chicken Goodfella's." A beautifully constructed entree of fresh chicken breast sautéed with scallions, shallots, garlic, white wine & cream and tossed with penne pasta. I opted for the Stuffed Rigatoni with Chicken and Artichokes. The entree consisted of stuffed rigatoni tossed with sautéed diced chicken breast & oven roasted Artichokes sundried tomatoes in a Gorgonzola cream sauce. Service was very relaxed which gave us time to visit with our dear friends. After short wait, our entrees were delivered to our table piping hot. Oh, my goodness, both of our entrees were so delicious and ample. We could have easily shared one of the entrees. The sauces were rich, creamy and decadent. We all thoroughly enjoyed our visit to Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza. We'll definitely make the drive to The Colony again very soon to explore more deliciousness on the menu. read more

See all

Goodfellas Pizza has always had amazing food. The pizza, pasta, appetizers and salads are consistently delicious. That part has never been an issue. Unfortunately the service is where things fall short. Tonight we tried to get a table and were told by the hostess that they did not have room for us. Instead of being welcomed and given the option to wait, we were simply turned away. We ended up going to Hideaway Pizza instead. It is disappointing because a simple approach could have completely changed our experience. Something along the lines of "Thank you for coming in, we have a bit of a wait this evening but we will get you seated as soon as possible. Can we offer you something to drink while you wait?" That is hospitality and it is not complicated. The food here is fantastic, but until the staff improves their customer service and learns how to make guests feel welcome, it is hard to fully recommend. read more

Visiting from out of town. We felt like pizza and ordered from Goodfellas. It was absolutely amazing! We ordered the Smokin Goodfella 16" and it was one of the best pizzas we have ever had. The peppers and sausage was a perfect compliment. It has a slightly sweet background to it. But it worked very well. Overall, I wouldn't look at elsewhere if we were to visit again. Excellent price, excellent pie. read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - Smokin Goodfella 16" - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

See all

We went on a Sunday for lunch and got the ravioli and a pizza. Both were delicious and the presentation was nice. Our server was very friendly and attentive. It was nice and clean and comfortable. A gem in the neighborhood! read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

The only bad choice concerning Goodfellas is not coming here. It's one of my favorite Italian restaurants. Today was not different, we had the chicken and pepper's over angel hair pasta, it's chock full of chicken and peppers really enough for two. Additionally we got stuffed rigatoni with artichokes, again lots of chicken and artichokes. They have the best Caesar dressing I've had and they tell me it's made in house This is a must stop The service is always great read more

See all

Cooper is awesome! Food is great. All the staff is dope!¡!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

We had the best time at this unexpected gem! First of all the staff is so nice and helpful and has a joke and smile to share. The drinks were good and the fried ravioli appetizer was yum! We split the Honey Badger small pizza and still had leftovers to take home. That pizza was incredible I would take home one daily if possible. Then we splurged and tried a cannoli and the limoncello cake and it was SO worth it! We left miserably full but with a great love for this cool little spot. Definitely a must check out. read more

Juliana was an absolute pleasure! My new favorite pizza spot in all of Texas!!!!!!!!!

Pizza was awesome!!! Service was great! Place really cozy! I would definitely come back again read more

Cooper's soft caresses made my skin tingle, my mouth water, and my senses explode with awareness. The way he moved while delivering my delectable delights was glorious, sensuous and has become a core memory. Cooper wasn't just our server, he was our guide across a culinary delight that donned generations, ages, times and moments. read more

My husband and I found this restaurant by accident. We are so glad we stopped! We ordered the Burrata tomato appetizer and the Goodfella's pizza. We experienced flavor in every bite! Amazing! Our server, Candace, was attentive and friendly. We WILL be back! read more

Clean, great service by Candance. Great food. Had fried ravioli. Meatball sub and 12" inch sliced sausage and pepperoni pizza. Dessert slice of Limoncello cake read more

See all

We got pepperoni pizza (cheese pie pizza with pepperoni topping). It was pretty good, but it was a little floppy. I definitely had to eat it with two hands. read more

Goodfellas Woodfired Pizza - Cheese Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - The Colony, Texas

Outstanding food Big group of us - had the calamari, Italian nachos, and meatballs for apps. For the main dish had the lasagna. All were exceptional. Will definitely be returning. read more

Stopped in for dinner. Ordered the ravioli, which were pretty large and very tasty. Ordered the strawberry mixed salad came with poppy seed dressing on the sides, asked for balsamic, which took a very long time to get to me. Pizza was brought out before I was able to finish my salad, after waiting for so long. Tried the cauliflower crust and did not care too much for it. Will return to try the regular crust since the pizzas were very flavorful. read more

See all

Goodfellas was our go-to for pizza since it opened. We haven't had the chance to back since the new owners took over, so I sat at the bar for a glass of wine while I got a pie to-go. It was better than before!! Wood-fired matters, and it was excellent. It's a good restaurant layout, nicely varied menu (everything's good), and good service. I think the toppings are more generous now than under the previous owner. A couple of other observations/suggestions. It was more quiet for a Friday night than I expected, but maybe that's because I was there early. I really enjoyed the live music on Friday nights, especially Tony D. Blakely picking & singing, and it seems that has gone away. Also, I think it used to have a friendlier atmosphere, but maybe that was because we were there so often that we got to know all the servers. As I was getting ready to leave, I started a brief conversation with the new owner. Very friendly and enjoyed exchanging thoughts and anecdotes. Have servers, managers, whoever go around and say hi even if I'm not in your section; check in on me anyway, smile and chat for moment. If a customer doesn't want to chat, you'll know soon enough. Overall great food, solid service, and we'll be back! read more

To begin with, our waitress was very friendly and accommodating. The toasted ravioli was the highlight of our meal. The Goodfella salad, with its creamy Italian dressing, was delicious, fresh, and satisfying. We also ordered the Santinos pizza, which was very good and filling. We will definitely return when we're in Frisco. read more