Bagels are stale and hard as a rock. Had to throw it out. Maybe a sandwich or something would be better, I'm not sure. The cream cheese was good, just very limited. read more

Spent 70 bucks on wings and they didn't give a single dipping sauce. No blue cheese, no ranch, nothing. For that price I could've bought frozen wings and my own ranch and been happier. Will never re order from them. read more

I'm big on smells and as soon as I walked in I smelled that fresh bagel smell and I was ready to order. Service was good and attentive she listened to every detail. My only complaint was how the sandwich was stacked but still worth going back. read more

Grace Deli And Bagel - Inside - American Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Delicious egg sandwiches. Friendly service. Huge menu with great breakfast choices and sandwiches and salads. You can't go wrong. Reasonable prices. read more

It has amazing service the employees are all very sweet, The food is delicious and they also have a students special! The vibes are overall amazing!! read more

Absolutely inedible chicken wrap. The chicken cutlet was soggy on the outside and that weird chewy texture inside. Asked for no onions got onions. Grilled chicken wrap - again chicken gross and chewy. Asked for balsamic on the side- no balsamic. Also got charged $3 more per wrap.. had to question the total and she rudely pointed to the wrong sign. The owner/manager had to tell her I was right. read more

I always order food from here on uber eats they make the best egg sandwiches and they're very fairly priced. food is always delivered hot and is great quality. read more

Grace Deli And Bagel - American Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Horrible experience. Stopped in on the way to the ferry with plenty of time to grab a sandwich some drinks and head over. After waiting 20 minutes, while watching people stand around behind the glass they finally started making the sandwiches. After the first ten minutes the guy at the register tells us they're working on it. Then another five minutes the guy making the sandwiches let's us know they have a lot of online orders. After 20 minutes we asked the guy how much longer to which he says "I don't know they're making it. There were orders before yours". Mind you when we got in there was 1 person ahead of us and 1 person waiting. We now watched five other groups come and go after us plus the people before us go. After the 20 minutes the guy started making our sandwiches as we can literally see through the window. Horrible experience. Slow beyond belief. Random I'm assuming employees coming in but not working as they look like they went for a run just walking around chatting with everyone sweating on everything. Avoid if you want your food in a timely manner or don't want sweat all over it. read more

I have come here many times. It's convenient to text your order. The food overall is ok. The people are very nice. But I do suggest you check your food to ensure your food is correct. I usually order breakfast. They aren't cheap with the meat and eggs which I like. I also like that it's close to me. The price is average. They also serve lunch but I am not as familiar. read more

Grace Deli And Bagel - Inside Store - American Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

got an uber eats for breakfast. bagel was rubbery and stale, and not fresh. side home fries had a gray hair in them and were more of like a baked sliced potato with interesting choice of spices on them. home fries also had some pieces of potato that were undercooked. stale egg sandwich almost cold. paid $20 to have it delivered read more

Food is nice hot and fresh. It's always busy but they move fast . Nice lady at the front taking orders and taking money is quick and on point ! She's great always need a good worker like that ! read more

the chicken salad was great so yummy, great,delicious. every time I pass by their I will stop and get some food . the deli was neat clean and friendly people. Love it read more

In love to wake up every Sunday with the best BconEggAnd cheese sandwich Everyone is so nice ! Delicious breakfast all the way!! read more

horrible do not come here, i waited 25 minutes for a Greek omelette wrap, I got hot coffee and paid 15$ for both, and I asked after waiting forever and he said it still wasn't ready, I ended up asking for a refund, he gave me back $10 so i paid $5 for a hot coffee and got out of there! worst customer service experience, never going back read more

I get delivery from them offer. Everything comes quickly and well packaged Food always tastes great! read more

This deli is the best! We love the egg sandwiches and the homemade oatmeal! Always fresh and delicious!

Working close to this deli we frequent it multiple times per week. The staff is always courteous and friendly, as well as fast. Nice when people care about others time strapped lives! The roast beef is homemade, and if you prefer it well done they are quick and happy to toss it on the grill. Speaking of the grill.... EGG SANDWICHES ALL DAY!!! Always nice when you feel like a late day bacon, egg and cheese (i ask for salt/pepper/ketchup). My two favorite sandwiches, since I am a chicken cutlet fan are as follows: Chicken cutlet club. Chix cutlets with bacon and American cheese melted followed by Russian dressing. The listed sammy comes with lettuce/tomato but I order without. Have never been disappointed, very consistently prepared. Second favorite is chix cutlets with honey ham and melted swiss. Followed by honey mustard sauce. Nice tangy honey mustard and prepped perfectly. Recently I was in the mood for a bacon/lettuce/tomato with lightly applied mayonnaise. Not a difficult sandwich but easy to do poorly. They nailed it! Inside you aren't winning any design or feng shwei awards, but it is always clean and lively. The standard potato and macaroni salads are made fresh daily and not overly dressed with Mayo. Graces is always worth the trip, even though we frequently use the free delivery option! read more

Grace Deli And Bagel - Front signage - American Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I came home to Long Island from Virginia for a Fire Island vacation. One thing I always need to get is a bacon egg and cheese with salt pepper and ketchup. I stop here because it is a place I have stopped before. But today I was just not impressed. Most times we stop here on the way home and get a hero. From what I remember they were good. But as far as stopping in for a breakfast sandwich I won't again. The sandwich looked ok. The biggest issue was the eggs. They were just dry. Question if they were real eggs. I that good old fried egg but that's not what I got. The place seemed a little dirty as well. It just looked a little run down. I guess I should have paid more attention to the over flowing garbage outside the door. Hint hint. I actually left the freight ferry and passed and bagel deli on Main Street. I almost stopped there but passed it but because I knew of this place already. Probably my other mistake. Maybe when I leave I will try the Main Street place. read more

See all

I have yet to try my food because I came to pick it up after calling it in and the two ladies behind the counter were reaching in and out of the bagel cases, toaster oven and the deli case with out any gloves on, extremely unsanitary, especially for ready to eat foods. The younger guy at the register and older guy had on one glove each, which I doubt had been changed. The guy at the register was nice but that for me isn't enough reason to return to a place where cleanliness and the safety of customers isn't held to a higher standard. Hepatitis, and this new virus floating around are not a joke, people can get sick. read more

If I could I would give 0 stars. I ordered breakfast sandwiches on the Uber Eats App (wasn't their fault) and they messed up my whole order. The avocado was rotten, black, and the turkey was dry and hard. I ordered an egg everything bagel, bacon, eggs, & cheese and home fries on the side. I opened it up and there was an Everything bagel (Not an egg everything) with bacon and eggs with home fries on it with cream cheese in a cup. I also ordered a diet Snapple and they gave me regular one with a flavor that I didn't order or want. The most frustrating part is that on my receipt everything was how I ordered it. I was really excited to try out this place. I would not recommend! There are way better places to get breakfast sandwiches! read more

Stupid idiots. I placed an online order because I was in meetings all morning and to my surprise they never even checked that an order came in. 45 minutes of my husband waiting and they didn't even start the order! Why have online ordering if you don't check that you have orders? And the staff aren't even kind. It's like they don't even want to be there! Close down then! read more

This Deli is great the morning crew is awesome but the afternoon crew not at all. The girl at the register is super nice but the guys behind the register not so much. It took them 15 minutes to get started on a salad and even then they had to ask around what was supposed to go in the salad and even asked me If wanted one of the pre-made salads. It seemed like to much to ask for a fresh made salad. Even while they were making it and I was standing right there they asked the girl at the register if it was a small or large salad did not even considered to stop and ask me what I wanted. I would always look forward to picking up breakfast because the owner is always super nice and accommodating to everyone but the afternoon crew not at all. read more

If I could give them a million stars I would. NEVER EVER DISAPPOINTS!! (And I'm picky af) fist place ive ever gotten a mushroom omelette from and it's not delivered soaking wet. The prices are amazing. The food taste soo good!! I am soo grateful I found this gem of a place. read more

The absolutely best reuben sandwich around! The owner is so nice and kind and his employees are super awesome! Thank you! read more

Delicious bacon egg and cheese on a roll. $4.33 including tax and it came with a small iced tea or lemonade.

I would add a photo but I already ate my bagel. The gluten free bagels here are AMAZING!!!! Service is amazing as always. Grace is the #1 breakfast place here in Bay shore! read more

I want to eat barbecue wings and they're trying to tell The ketchup sauce that they put wings is barbecue sauce.

A nice breakfast. Fast and courteous service. Best of all, when you get a hero, they really pack in the meat. Not stingey at all.

my first review ever... I love this place and couldn't take seeing all the poor reviews. this place is a friendly down to earth deli, the guy that runs it is the sweetest guy ever, the staff are all very friendly and nice too. the food is what you should expect, nothing too fancy but it's fast and it's good. I walk in order, and my food is ready in about 5 mins, its hot, fills me up and tastes great- there are no complaints there. the ambiance of the deli is also what is to be expected, it's a deli; if anything it makes me feel calm. I recommend the sesame ginger salad(: read more

Great place! We tried the Yankee Stadium Panini and Cubano panini. Both were fantastic. Good prices, and friendly owner Mike. We will definitely be back on our next trip to Long Island! read more

The food here is really good, but the service is indifferent (at best) and slow. We placed an order online. When we arrived, the woman behind the counter said they hadn't received it and that we must have placed it at their other shop. Fortunately, they called over there before we left and found that the other shop didn't have an order for us either. THEN they checked and saw that they had gotten our order, just hadn't picked it up. I'd ordered a $9 quinoa salad that the guy said they were out of. He suggested I pick another salad, and when I asked whether we could just get a refund instead, he said no, because the money went to the internet. So I wound up getting $9 worth of like lettuce and limp mushrooms, missing the broccoli I'd asked for. No real apology for any of this. We used to come here fairly often but won't be back. read more

Just a simple stop, figured i give them a shot. great food, cozy & friendly.. Sandwiches are awesome & many options.

The chicken tenders and fries are probably the best I've ever had. Good prices and student discounts which are awesome

Went in for lunch and noticed everyone to be wearing their masks below their noses. Instead of walking out like I should've i stayed and ordered. Upon ordering a simple turkey, bacon, lettuce tomato sandwich. I was served a scrambled egg, cheese, and lettuce tomato sandwich.... As i went back in to exclaim my wrong order, the girl at the counter insisted and snarked thats what I ordered at the counter. Trust me when i say i'd have to be clinically insane to have ordered a sandwich with that combination. When i told her my order again and received my order and opened it up again it wasnt even close. Instead of going back in to have a senseless argument with some one who doesn't even know how to wear a mask properly, i decided to cut my loses. read more

The food is amazing. Always fresh. The service is great, including delivery. The owner is onsite and very cordial. Always a great experience whether picking up food or catering a party. I highly recommend. read more

I love this place. The staff is friendly and the food is fresh. Great breakfast sandwiches and you can even text in your order!

Love their BEC in the morning. They are always so friendly and quick! Became a loyal customer overnight.

I always loved their food, no complaints with food - but multiple times i've been in there they've never worn their masks when cooking food or behind the counter. If you are concerned about employees mask wearing - not the spot for you. read more

Honestly, this is the best deli in Bay Shore. Great food, fair prices, and everyone is so friendly! Coffee is always fresh and they even have a way to text in your order so you don't have to wait for it. Love coming here for breakfast. read more

Usually food is good depends on the cook i think. Asked for a grilled pastrami it was only warmed up not cooked at all. read more

Grace Deli And Bagel - This is not grilled pastrami... Its just warm. Disappointing - American Near Me - Bay Shore, New York