YE Gurl Says: This Is What Ice Cream Is Supposed to Taste Like at Graeter's Ice Cream Whatever happened to good old-fashioned ice cream? You know--the kind made from cream, sugar, milk, and a little bit of magic. Before every frozen dessert needed a chemistry degree's worth of stabilizers, gums, and ingredients you can't pronounce. Well, the closest thing I've found lately is Graeter's Ice Cream. This is the real deal. The first clue? The employees are getting a full upper-body workout every shift. That ice cream is dense. Thick. Stubborn. The kind of product that doesn't surrender easily to a scoop. Meanwhile, some of these other places are serving ice cream so soft it starts melting while you're still deciding on toppings. Not here. This is straight-from-the-cow's... well, you know. And the crowds tell the story. On a warm day you'll find: Families lined out the door Kids running around with sticky fingers Parents carrying napkins like emergency equipment Drips on shirts that nobody cares about because summer has officially begun That's how you know an ice cream shop has become part of the community. I've only had one milkshake from Graeter's before, and I swear it kept me full for the entire day. Granted, I'm not a heavy dairy consumer, so when real ice cream enters my system my body immediately recognizes that something significant is happening. This visit took us to the old neighborhood of Upper Arlington. The beau confidently ordered a double waffle cone like he had something to prove. Meanwhile, I stood at the counter doing what every true Virgo does: conducting a full cost-benefit analysis. Milkshake? Sundae? New seasonal strawberry sundae? The internal spreadsheet was going. In the end, I landed on the Dip Strawberry All the Way Sundae, and honestly, it was exactly what I needed. Sweet strawberries. Rich ice cream. The right amount of indulgence. It tasted like the official start of summer. And at about $8.50, only 50 cents more then the beau's double waffle cone, it felt like one of the better dessert values I've seen lately. YE Gurl Insight: Sometimes the best food experiences aren't about innovation. They're about doing a classic thing exceptionally well. Graeter's understands that. Final Take: * Rich, old-school ice cream texture * Generous portions * Great seasonal offerings * Family-friendly atmosphere * Worth every napkin you'll need afterward YE Gurl Says: If you're looking for a sign that summer has officially arrived, skip the fancy desserts and get yourself to Graeter's Ice Cream. Order the sundae. Watch the kids running around with sticky hands. And remember what ice cream used to taste like. read more

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Graeter's Ice Cream and I must say, it was an absolutely delightful experience. From the moment I walked through the door, I was greeted with warm smiles and a friendly atmosphere. However, it was Sarah Gerkin, one of the associates, who truly made my visit exceptional. Sarah's enthusiasm and passion for ice cream were evident from the start. She guided me through the extensive menu, patiently explaining the unique flavors and recommending some of their most popular options. Her genuine excitement was contagious, and it made choosing my ice cream even more enjoyable. Not only was Sarah incredibly knowledgeable about the different flavors, but she also took the time to answer all of my questions, ensuring that I made a well-informed decision. Her expertise and genuine interest in helping me find the perfect treat were truly remarkable. As I savored my chosen ice cream, I couldn't help but notice Sarah's exceptional customer service skills. She effortlessly engaged in conversation, making me feel like a valued customer. Her friendly demeanor and attention to detail truly enhanced the overall experience. I also observed Sarah's interactions with other customers during my visit, and it was evident that she treated everyone with the same level of care and attention. She went above and beyond to accommodate specific dietary requests and made sure that each person left with a smile on their face. In addition to her outstanding customer service, Sarah's efficiency and organization were commendable. Despite the bustling nature of the store, she managed to maintain a pleasant and calm demeanor while ensuring that every customer was served promptly. Overall, my visit to Graeter's Ice Cream was made exceptional by the outstanding service provided by Sarah Gerkin. Her passion, knowledge, and genuine care for customers truly set her apart. I highly recommend visiting Graeter's and experiencing the exceptional service firsthand, particularly if you have the pleasure of being assisted by Sarah. read more

Inside---very quaint and homey and sophisticated looking. However, I'd like to see a little quirky spin since it is an ice cream place. Staff---very polite and patient. When I was in there I sampled about 6 different ice creams before settling on my chosen and they were so patient and actually offering up different suggestions to help me find my ice cream. Ice cream---delish! Very creamy, not overly sweet, and tasty. I had the blueberry pie ice cream which actually has some blueberry crust in it and a scoop of cinnamon ice cream and a scoop of their fresh whipped cream and it was delish. It was like having a slice of blueberry pie w/ ice cream. Prices---a little pricey, but worth it for fresh made ice cream. read more

The best ice cream ! I'm from Michigan and graters is the best. Service was great. They all are very helpful. The manager was in the store today and very friendly. read more

Ice cream was great, staff worked quick, would recommend the mint chocolate chip!

This is the best ice cream on the planet. There is no comparison. Just try it. read more

awesome ice cream! come often, since they have different seasonal flavors. read more

hit or miss, sometimes burnt sometimes raw. Never in the middle

the whole graters's experience is lost on me

Good ice cream at a reasonable price.