We stop here once a month. It's the best Greek restaurant in the area. Our favorite lunch is the lamb Shawarma sandwich special ($15.99) with Greek salad and ice tea (5 star best). We top it off with a rice pudding shared. Always friendly, it's a family restaurant we have enjoyed when visiting North Naples read more

See all

The twins are at it again lol! At our favorite Greek Restaurant in Naples. I ordered the lemon orzo soup and Chicken Shawarma and Dave had Greek Salad and spicy Lamb Shawarma! Both were super fresh and delicious with onions. peppers, tomatoes and tzatziki. Then to top it off we shared a rice pudding! No dinner tonight after this delicious and filling meal. So happy to visit here once a month. The owners are friendly and make sure everything is perfect, read more

See all

We love this place. The moment we walked in the chef was welcoming us My wife wanted a falafel sandwich to take to the beach and watch the sunset. The falafel balls are to die for. Once you bite into it the rich green color of the garbanzo mixture you know it's going to be delicious. We had falafels in Israel and they don't compare to Greek island cafe. We keep going back. read more

Enjoyed fast and friendly service on a Saturday night. When you walk in you are greeted and enjoy the smells of fresh Greek food. My wife had the hummus pita and I had the special with gyro pita and salad. The tzatziki was fresh and different than I have had at other places and I really enjoyed it, almost hints of mint or dill. The place was very clean and had a lot of options. Next time I'll try the lamb chops. read more

Greek Island Cafe - Gyro special - Greek Near Me - Naples, Florida

Ordered the gyro and lamb pita. Was so good. If you're unsure what to order I would recommend the gyro wrap with the house chips. Everything here is homemade and delicious :) read more

Came by today for lunch, had been here in a long time. Wasn't disappointed. Got my usual tuna salad on Peter with chips on the side and they were made to order and tasted awesome. Stephanie behind the counter was a great host. read more

Very disappointed since I drove out of my way for some Greek food, and also was starving. Seemed like an authentic Greek atmosphere..small cafe..colorful I ordered my favorite...Detroit sytle coney island, coke...to start. Perhaps the worst coney I've had..ever. low grade bun, hot dog was cheap...beef...not sure where is was from. Worst was the the sauce....runny, filled with "a few pieces of meat, and onion" I immediately was disgusted. So I actually order the Greek lemon soup....just as bad...thin...runny . The cook had no gloves on...! read more

We have a craving for Spanakopita. Many Naples friends recommended Greek Island Café. We tried for an early dinner. This is a family operated restaurant. The owner greeted us warmly and staff is welcoming. I ordered the Spanakopita dinner with a Greek Salad, grilled vegetable and rice. Wife ordered a chicken wrap. You can smell the food as they prepare the order. The Greek salad was well prepared with fresh tomato, peppers, onions, cheese, chick peas and olive. The dressing has a lemon taste which is very refreshing! The Spanakopita's phyllo dough is very flaky and crispy with a comforting filling of spinach and feta cheese. The vegetable is grilled and steaming hot! This is one of my favorite Greek dishes. They are simply delicious and savory. Wife loves her chicken wrap. She wanted to try their Pastichio, Schwarma and Kofta on our next visit. This is a great casual place with friendly service and great food! read more

See all

We tried this cute little spot in Naples. The food is very fresh and good. We got the saganski, lemon soup, spinach pie dinner and a gyro with a red wine. Everything was very tasty and good portions. Our only complaint was the lack of service. We sat quite a while constantly throughout the meal. Waited for menus, waited for waters, waited to order and waited for drinks. Never checked on us and we needed several things during the meal. Could never get a worker. If they hire even one agile worker as a waits person, it would really help. We heard all the tables around, needing and pleading for things. Hire more, we will be back happily. read more

See all

The owners are lovely. The gyros were fab. Great for takeout for a large group since they offer a broad selection to please everyone.

i really don't understand how this place gets decent reviews? Both my wife and I are Greek so we know authentic Greek food. The spanakopita was bland and the Greek salad only had a teaspoon of Feta cheese. We called the owner after our poor meal, didn't seem to care. My friend also tried it and had the same experience. read more

A go to place for a traditional Greek meal. Small tiny almost a diner that serves excellent Greek choices

Amazing! Spanakopita so good. Walk in and welcomed with a smile. Can't wait to go back read more

We walked in at 7:20 knowing they close at 8. There was only one other table dining. Waitress rolled her eyes when we asked to sit at a table that wasn't right next to them. We put our order in immediately. The waitress knew it was taking much longer for the food to come out than it should and said three time, just one more minute. The bechamel was so burned on both dishes that it was inedible. The waitress asked how the food was, so we told her not very good. She said, that's how we make it. Didn't argue with her and didn't eat the food. She took 25% off one dish. read more

Delicious, fresh cooked from scratch Greek food. Very friendly staff. Highly recommend.

My wife and I rented a house nearby while vacationing in FL, and we found this place while driving to the beach. I looked them up on Yelp and saw they had good reviews and pictures of the food looked good. We arrived on a Thursday as soon as they opened @ 11pm EST. I was warmly welcomed inside a few minutes early, and the lady who takes the orders was a genuinely kind and cheerful Greek woman. She was a pleasure to speak with during and after I placed my order. I gave my order to go: 2 gyros, side of fries, pirogies, and a chicken kabob. Everything was made fresh, and when we ate it, it was delicious! See pics for reference. I'd definitely recommend this place if you have a hankering for a gyro! NOTE: I didn't eat inside but it is a basically a small diner inside w/ a Greek theme. It's clean and inviting should you choose to dine-in. read more

See all

The food was excellent. I ordered a gyro, and it was absolutely delicious, full of flavor and perfectly made. Unfortunately, the customer service didn't match the quality of the food. The ladies at the front seemed uninterested and had no personality, which made the experience feel less welcoming. I'd definitely come back for the food, but I hope the service improves to match how amazing the meals are. read more

Service was great, the workers there were really nice. Food was delicious and served to me very fast. Would definitely recommend and going back there soon. read more

Best saganaki in town, hands down!! The Italian beef was phenomenal too. The people that own this place are super friendly.

If you want a casual Greek salad for lunch with home made hummus, this is your spot. The hummus is fab and the Greek salad dressing is homemade. Oila! read more

Food was so good. Definitely a good lunch place. I had the chicken Scharma sandwich and hubby had the gyro both excellent. Started with their homemade hummus with homemade hot pita bread Was out of this world. read more

We had Gyros and asked for tzatziki sauce for the gyro and we're not told they would change us $1.25 for it without telling us. We asked why we were charged and they said it the policy of the cafe. We were not able to take the unused portion home. This cafe is dirty and would not recommend. Do not go! read more

All the food I've tried is very good. The gyros are amazing and hummus is spectacular. Service is good.. great spot to eat

Food, service and ambiance were amazing. Food is being cooked in front of you by the owner of the place. Amazing service by the waitress Jessica, all other costumers around us seemed happy and pleased with everything. Definitely try it out Best Greek food in Naples indeed.. read more

Greek Island Cafe - Greek Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

This is the real deal! True authentic Greek food from a warm friendly family. They do a great job keeping it real! Try the Greek Salad, Hummus, and Gyros. Enjoy read more

Small place with nice Diner vibes!!!Service was great! Food was great! The owners are kind. They have a bar you can sit at to eat or cafe tables. I noticed people can sit outside & dine with pets along. Give them a try! read more

We ate outside. Service was excellent and food was excellent. Chocolate shake was tasty. My wife had a telapia sandwich that was the fish of the day. It was well seasoned and cooked just right. I had a chicken Schwarma in pita bread. I asked for it spicy and it was just the right amount for me. Good options for gluten free or vegetarian. Brief chat with the owner and our server. Both were very pleasant. Definitely recommend. read more

Very nice Greek family that owns the restaurant. Always good food and good service! A great place to order takeout!

The food was fabulous and the service was excellent!! we had moussaka with a Greek salad and a platter with falafel and dolmades and pita. Great place for lunch. read more

Amazing food, great atmosphere and you always feel at home when going there I would highly recommend!

What a find! One of the best falafel pitas I have ever had for lunch. Had to come back the following week just to confirm...... Yes, confirmed! lol. Ingredients are so fresh. Falafel with the sesame seeds is a must! Tasty coleslaw too, and good french fries. This will be my new regular stop for lunch. A very kind chef (who I think may be the owner too?) who takes pride in his cooking. Wish there were more places like this. Highly recommend! read more

I had the falafel in a pita and baklava for dessert. The fresh flavor of the Falafel and the crisp delicious bite of the Greek salad and the creamy sweet tzatziki sauce was an awesome combination. So very well prepared. The place lacks atmosphere and perhaps that adds to the whole experience, I suppose. If I only had enough room for the baklava. read more

The food was phenomenal and the service was great! Very authentic Greek food with good portion sizes! Would def recommend!

Excellent family style Greek. Love the tzatziki sauce and the flan is home made. Not fancy but delicious.

Looking for a place for lunch and found this little diner by chance. Delicious food and great service. Felt like I was a guest at someone's home. Will definitely be back. read more

Good food. Service is okay. Not the friendliest over the phone while placing takeout order or while picking up. Forgot salad toppings. But food was good overall. read more

Tough not giving this place a 5 but I was overly impressed with so much. This place has "regular weekly visit" written all over it for me. It's just a quick bike ride away from my doorstep. I stopped in today on my way to the park. It's bright. Clean and welcoming as you walk in. It's a nice open space, makes you feel good about eating at a place that seems so clean. I was highly tempted to get the Italian beef since it proclaimed to be Chicago Style but knowing the extremely high standards I have for Chicago Italian beef sandwiches (the undoubted Elvis of Beef sandwiches, of course Michael Jackson being brisket of course since he's from the Midwest and is saucy af) I didn't get that and chose to get their house speciality the gyro. I rarely pay my own back for good decisions but I literally reached over and patted myself on the back and danced a bit as a took my first huge bite. It was exceedingly good. Pita, gyro meat, onions, tomato, tzatziki... I like how well the pita was toasted, how the onion and tomato was seasoned, the sauce was masterfully blended as the small things like the onion being so finely sliced, it helps get the flavor in the bite without overpowering the bite. The server was wonderful and filled my water consistently and was overall pleasant. I enjoyed this so much and I always get a little excited when I find a good spot nearby. I will be back (in my terminator voice) You should come and eat here and be happy like all of us! Reviews don't lie! read more

The Greek Salad and Chicken souvlaki pita were out of this world! 10/10! Cannot wait to come back

Simple, understated strip mall restaurant. Friendly staff, limited seating, they also offer take-out. Sometimes the best food is found in this type of environment. Started off with an appetizer Greek Trio, which was dolmadakia (rice and spices wrapped in grape leaves), hummus and tzatziki served with warm pita bread. Then, tried the Lamb Shaw Erma, (lamb with grilled onions and grilled tomatoes, with spices topped with a sesame tahini sauce, all wrapped in a grilled pita. (Choice of spicy, mild or regular). I opted for spicy, the flavor was out of this world. Incredible flavor, just the right amount of heat, all. Fresh ingredients. Also had a side of homemade onion rings, very good. read more

This place is go to stop if you are looking for quality Greek food in the area. Staff is very nice, food taste like they were cooking for family. Overall good atmosphere, amazing flavor. Recommend the lamb shawarma, falafel & hummus read more