I took my 1993 4Runner to Greg's the other day because I wanted to sell it to a buddy and make sure it is in good condition. I already knew about worn front wheel bearings causing that unmistakable metallic grinding noise when going faster than 5 mph. The price of 92$ for a general inspection seemed to be pretty steep, but from the list the guy at the counter showed me I figured they would do a thorough job. Being a bit of a grease monkey myself I didn't really want them to fix anything straight away but was merely looking for an expert opinion, mostly because I am not that familiar with the particulars of a big Toyota truck.
The list of items to repair I received the next morning was long, all together more than $2500. Going through the items one by one I got a little suspicious. First of all they claimed that I would need a new power steering pump for 620$ and that would be causing the noises I heard. They also diagnosed the loose wheel bearings but obviously didn't consider those to be a big problem, they didn't even show up on the suggested list of repairs. After pointing out the fact that I am well capable of distinguishing between the squealing noise of a power steering pump and metal grinding on metal the guy at the counter told me that their best Toyota expert had taken a look at the car and was sure about the diagnosis. If they'd taken the car just around the block I am sure they'd revise that statement. And if they had checked the power steering fluid reservoir or its return hose they'd probably not recommended the expensive pump replacement but rather reattached the lose hose and refilled the fluid, which fixed the problem within 5 minutes and for less than 5 bucks. Interestingly none of the fluids where checked, neither was the car taken on a test drive, as indicated on the work order sheet. The completely empty cooling fluid obviously didn't cause any concern.
Next on the list was a missing fan shroud, which was estimated at 175$. I just bought the part at Autoparts Warehouse for 50$ and was able to install it within 3 minutes, all it took was removing the main cooling hose and 4 sheet metal screws.
The next item, a leaking transfer case output seal spreading grease. Guess, what? The power steering reservoir with the lose hose is right on top of the transfer case, and all I could find was power steering oil spilled all over the case.
After all this crap I decided to take the car to an independent mechanic, this time checking the online reviews beforehand; something I should have done with Greg's Auto. The guy, No.1 Japanese Auto Repair in Greenwood, fixed the broken wheel bearings for under 300$ and also took a look a the idler arm, which Greg's diagnosed as being loose (330$). Apparently there's minimal slack in the bushing, nothing that needs costly repair.
The last item on the list was a break service. According to Greg's, my front pads where down to 3 mm and the back shoes down to 4. I order replacement pads online and had too realize during replacement that there where at least 12 mm of breaks left in the front, and about one cm in the back. So even the suggested break service (495$!!!) was complete bogus.
I guess there are two possible explanations here: Either the guys at Greg's did a terrible job during the inspection, in which case the 95$ are a joke, or they deliberately suggested costly but totally unnecessary repairs. Either way, I would never ever take my car back there again. Instead I can only recommend No.1 Japanese Auto repair. The guy is very reliable, fast and competent. He will only repair what needs repairing and not try to screw you. As a matter of fact, the cost for the wheel bearings repair turned out to be less than what he initially estimated, and that is something that has never happened to me before with any other car mechanic. And stay away from Greg's, unless you want to spend a lot of money for nothing. read more