I love walking into random places and telling the people behind the counter to choose my meal. Just serve me whatever the hell you want and hope for the best. I mean seriously, if you work there you should know what's good, right? I didn't even ask what they served me. So your going to have to show them this picture. This dude behind the counter hooked me up! The flavors were insane. The salad, the fooken salad! How do do you make a salad that gives you a chubby!?!? I have no idea what kind of pizza he gave me, but it beats the glory hole I was at last week! I'm not a big beer drinker but I let him choose the menu. He served me a lager called Taco Truck. Perfect pairing. I wish there was a Hail Mary pizza in North OC. HMP thank you. Truly, best meal I had in a minute! read more

See all

Don't forget the salad! And don't be fooled by the name; the "lettuce salad" is so much more than lettuce. They mix up tender salad greens with some leaves of fresh herbs, mint, cilantro, and dill caught my delighted attention. Over all they add a startling quince vinegar/lemon dressing that is light and bright, complimenting the greens. It comes in two sizes, but Jerry helpfully informed me the small salad would be enough for two, and he was right. Service, as before, was efficient and friendly, and the rocking' tunes mixed progressive with classic rock. read more

Excellent pizza. Cool interior, though small dining area. Good, easy counter service. Price is up there but servings are pretty large that you can easily take food home. Mushroom pizza and calzone is an easy 5/5 star. Definitely come for the mushroom pizza 'cause damn. Caesar salad was okay.. a bit light on the dressing and personally would skip. Has a service charge for living wage but it seems that its replaced for a tip (?). 4-4.5 out of 5 stars. read more

See all

Hands down the best pizza in the hood. Beatrix and Pep is our go to. Don't skip on the salad. It's full of herbs and the dressing is light and refreshing. I can eat this combo for days. The guys at Hail Mary are so great. Cool date spot. read more

See all

Came for dinner on a Saturday night. It was busy but there were tables available. Service was nice and friendly. I was surprised how large the menu was and it took a while for us to decide. We ended up getting... - Belly Goat pizza: good flavor but was soggy from all the toppings - Charred Cauliflower with lemon tahini and dill - Fire-Grilled Carrots with bacon jam and cumin yogurt We really enjoyed the cauliflower and carrots and were surprised how good they were as sides. Nice mix of flavors, sauces and herbs. They actually stood out to me more than the pizza we got! read more

See all

I walked in fully convinced I'd just grab a slice because I "wasn't that hungry." Fast forward a bit, and my friends and I had ordered two whole pizzas and somehow each demolished four slices. So yeah... that plan didn't last. The pizza was that good. What really stood out was how balanced everything was--the pizzas weren't greasy at all, the crust had the perfect bite (not too hard, not floppy), and the flavors were spot on. I also loved how creative they were with their vegetarian options, which isn't always easy to find done well. We ordered the Bella Fungo and the Marinara Supreme, and both were packed with flavor and seriously satisfying. The space itself is pretty small and low-key, with not much going on in terms of ambiance, but honestly that just adds to the charm. Don't let the hole-in-the-wall vibe fool you--this place is serving some truly bomb pizza and is 100% worth stopping by. read more

See all

Great food. Great service. Cool little spot. Mushroom & onion slice: 10/10. Lots of mushroom and delicious crust Mac & cheese: 7/10. It tasted really good (it's cheese & penne), but pricey for the portion ($13) Arnold Palmer: 10/10 read more

See all

Amazing pizza. Our plan is to eventually work our way through the menu. Friendly staff. Great place!

We absolutely love this place. The pizza is really, really good. Service is friendly as well. The Lambardo (?) was our favorite. The crust is absolutely exceptional, and the toppings were delicious. Ambiance is extremely casual. Highly recommend this spot for good pizza in LA. read more

Hail Mary Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

See all

4+ Pizza spot located in Atwater Village. A few friends and I went here to get some take out to watch a game back at a buddy's house, so I can't speak to the vibe inside (although I've been here for brunch at a restaurant that occupied this spot in the past). Ordering was really easy. You can order online and they give you an estimated time when your order is ready. We parked close by and one of us ran in to pick up all the food. It was a really easy process. As for the pizza and food we ordered the Pep Pep, Margherita Supreme, some Charred Corn Ribs, and the Hail Mary Caesar. I thought everything was tasty. Just a really convenient pizza spot with quality pizza and sides. Definitely would love to come back and have an experience of dining in as well at some point. read more

See all

Hail Mary, the Pizza is with thee. Hail Mary Pizza is a local pizza joint located in Atwater village, offering a wide variety of creative sourdough pizzas, "LA Style", similar to New Haven, but with slightly less crunch, and a trendy, laid back vibe. I've been wanting to check out Hail Mary for some time, and on a lark decided to pick up a pie on the way home. I got the One, Two Punch Pizza ($26), a pepperoni, fennel sausage, and hot honey masterpiece. The crunch and crust were excellent, there was minimal flop, the meat was succulent, the cheese tangy, and the honey a little spicy to boot. The vibes for Hail Mary are excellent. The music reverbs, the artwork is bold and unapologetic, the menu is a giant chalkboard, and the theming hilariously heretical. Pray for us sinners. The value is fair, with each pizza feeding one very hungry or two peckish individuals, or about $15-25 / person. I cannot comment on the service as I did takeout, but the staff all appeared friendly and hard working. Blessed is the fruit of thy oven, Mary. I will soon be returning to break bread (and a beer) with the bros at your business. Truly, this is the happening hangout for us heathens. Hail! Food: 4.5/5 Ambiance: 5/5 Value: 4/5 read more

See all

Hail Mary Pizza is located at the Atwater Village. This pizza spot treats you like you are family. The first thing you notice here is the open kitchen. There is a guy tossing pizzas and he will greet you. There is also a guy by the counter to ask you how your week is going. Then he will take you to the counter to take your order. This is a sit down spot and the chef might come over to talk to you about his food. The pizza, wings and salads are affordable. This is a perfect spot for a family meal. read more

See all

BEAUTIFUL EXPERIENCE. It made me want to cry happy tears. The mushroom pizza was so good it made me feel like I was on shrooms. 10/10 experience. I think that was legit the best pizza I've ever had. I felt the love bruh read more

Nice ambiance, friendly staff and great selection of food. We always order the Beatrix ( plain cheese ). It's pretty good, but as one reviewer stated they use too much tomato paste in the sauce. Leaving it sweet and pasty. The crust itself has no crispness to it, just soft and fluffy, which might be ones preference. But I find myself placing it on a pizza stone at home and baking it another 10-15 mins to get the crunch I want. The prices aren't too bad. I was able to buy one cheese pizza for regular price and get a second one for only $3.14 on pi day ( March 14th ) which was very cool of them. read more

Went to Hail Mary in Los Feliz with my brother. The space is smaller than I expected but super cozy and cool. Service was good, though the water was rather warm so I had to ask for a cup of ice to cool it down. Probably better to grab a beer or wine. Pizza was still tasty and hit the spot, exactly what I came for. read more

See all

Small eating area Good location Hard to find parking, so the walk will build up your appetite Nice staff Expensive Pizza is phenomenal. Sourdough pizza. NICE Broccoli was solid Experience was well worth it 100% going back read more

See all

I really want to give this place a better review because the staff were so nice here, but their pizza needs major work. The sauce has too much tomato paste in it, making it too sweet and thick. The pizza was scantily clad with a few tiny pieces of mediocre quality mozzarella -- for a dish that basically has 3 key ingredients, don't skimp on quality or quantity with one of the majors. And the crust was okay, but kind of dry and flavorless, something akin to what a novice cook would make at home. This was definitely not a classic margherita pizza you'd expect to pay for. Corn ribs were surprisingly flavorful and delicious, but a bit too much sauce on top. Highly recommend. If you're a local, you might walk here for an easy night out, but based on the pizza alone, not work a trek. The service staff are so nice though -- so warm and welcoming! read more

A proper thin crust pizza. Lots of interesting variations on toppings. Ordered take out and the preparation was speedy. Very much appreciate that you can split the pizza between a couple different topping selections given the options. Meatballs were terrific, big and lots of sauce great for sopping up with the pizza crust. Very much looking forward to going back. read more

The pizza here is in Stanley good! High-quality ingredients, the dough is perfect and the pizza is baked well. I also love their salads and sides, be sure to save room for dessert, it was absolutely delicious! Service is very friendly, they are so hard-working and really care about what they do. The food is packaged well to go, but they do also have Tables for dine available as well. Metered parking on the street, highly recommended if you're looking for a quality pizza in the area! read more

See all

Best pizza in LA hands down and it's not even a question. This place is such a vibe. From the service, to the music, to the ambiance, WE LOVE HAILMARY! They use sourdough for the pizzas, making it healthy(er) so guilt free lol They have refreshing salads and amazing apps too. This is not your average pizza spot. It's elevated and it's amazing. They also have a great selection of beer and wine! Definitely try this place out. 5/5 easy! read more

Hail Mary Pizza - One, Two Punch - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Came here for dine LA and will definitely be back. My husband and I tried the half house salad, it was amazing, love the light and refreshing dressing they make in house. Then we had the one, two punch, but they were able to change the sauce to their regular marina. It was amazing. The pepperoni they use really is incredible and the hot honey was delicious. We ended with the two salted chocolate chunk cookies which were very chocolate forward. Their lemonade was also super tasty. Super friendly staff, and the inside of the restaurant was nice and toasty. Can't wait to come back and try more from their menu. read more

Hail Mary Pizza - Lemonade - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

It's a solid spot in Atwater Village, known for their sourdough crust pies. The menu mixes classic flavors with a few creative options that all come together well. We tried the Ave Shallota Pizza, Lilo Unscripted Pizza, garlic knots, Moroccan spiced wings, and Basque cake. The Lilo Unscripted pizza and Moroccan wings were the standouts for me -- both had really good flavor. The other items were solid and rounded out the meal. It's an easy place to grab a pizza, share a few apps, and enjoy a casual meal. Works well for hanging out with friends or picking up a pie to go. read more

See all

The place is so cool with art on the wall. The food was delicious! My favorite was the pizza and charred corn ribs. The staff were also very welcoming and helpful with recommendations. I will definitely be back read more

See all

Hail Mary Pizza has a cozy neighborhood vibe to it. Inside, they have wooden booths and neon, colorful murals, and brick walls. There's always a good lively playlist. The giant chalkboard wall menu has innovative and amusingly named offerings. Pep Pep: The mozzarella covered slices have a super thin crust that becomes plump and doughy at the edges. Pep 1: The large pepperoni-shaped slices of Spanish chorizo slices are smoky with an interesting spice mix. Pep 2: The sliced jalapeño peppers are pickled. The honey and tomato sauce provide a sweet counterbalance to all the savory and spicy ingredients. I'm not typically a fan of pepperoni, but Hail Mary's take on pep is nice. Ordering: You order at the counter by the menu, and they'll bring the pizza to your table. Or they'll text you if you're taking it to go, which let's you really around the neighborhood while you wait. read more

Hail Mary Pizza - an image of hail mary pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

See all

Really tasty pizza! Took it to go, wish I could've had it fresh but it was still yummy at home. It was quick delivery too! I don't know how the place looked but i'll go one day. read more

Food was delicious! Service was super friendly and quality people! The restaurant was clean and had an awesome atmosphere! read more

Hail Mary Pizza - The Tropic Thunder - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Wow what a pizza haven especially for foodies who want to try different types of pizzas!!! We pulled up on Cinco de Mayo and got to try their exclusive Mole Pizza which was sooooo good!! Their Hail Mary Caesar was delicious. The sliced Parmesan and croutons were so flavorful. We also tried their essential - Pep Pep Pizza - a jalapeño pepperoni pizza with honey drizzled on top, as well as The Belly Goat which was refreshing with goat cheese and veggies. Service was so great and the food came out so fast and so fresh. It's such a fun spot with art everywhere and is right smack on Glendale in the midst of all the shops and eats in Atwater Village. It's family friendly but still a fun spot for casual drinks and catch ups. Mouth is watering writing this review read more

See all

We've ordered out and yesterday made a pick up order so it was the first time I saw the interior. My 9yo was enthralled by the vintage Pacman table arcade and the mini claw machine. Staff was warm and cooks were friendly and smiled (which is rare so you know they must be treated well). We usually do the Margarita pizza, a pepperoni, the chicken wings, and a slice of cheesecake to share. The basque cheesecake is bananas, I dream about that cheesecake. The pizza is solid, excellent crust, superior ingredients, and great prices. Local spots are charging $41 for what they charge less than $30 for. That's a massive difference and the five stars account for the excellent quality you get for that price point. I'm going to try to make it a habit to dine-in so we can enjoy the local spot feeling and kiddo can play pacman. I'm picky and I felt like this spot hits all the right notes. read more

What a delicious pizza joint!! I was very surprised at how delicious the wings and pizza were. Service very friendly and they have beer too.

This was my second visit, and yet again, exceptional, beyond delicious, wow. And the service, wonderful all around.

The pizza is really good, but unfortunately the salads are an overpriced disappointment. This time I ordered the Caesar salad with chicken--the chicken wasn't tasty and seemed like low-quality meat, and the dressing didn't have much flavor either. Overall, it was just kind of a bummer. Previously, I also tried their seasonal tomato salad and wasn't impressed. It was overly oily, and the tomatoes were saggy and didn't taste fresh. I'd recommend skipping the salads altogether and sticking with the pizzas. The Pep Pep and Roni are my usual favorites and never disappoint. read more

Just had the best pizza from Hail Mary - a Beatrix with added sausage, goat cheese and fig.

This is excellent pizza. It's pricey, but worth it. High quality ingredients and nice employees

My new favorite pizza! I got it to go on DoorDash so I can't review the actual store/restaurant but this is my new favorite pizza! I can't believe I haven't ordered from here before. I got the Roni, side of ranch and pickled jalapeños and it was SO good. Quickly made with care and delivered by the door dash driver. I definitely sugguest! read more

Hail Mary Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

See all

Very cool spot! The owner was super friendly (I think he was the owner). Came for my husband's birthday - we were "pizza hopping" and they were our first stop. Their Roni pizza was pretty pretty great! I would definitely order from here again. Casual vibes. Was quiet when we were there. read more

Hands down the best zero flop perfect pizza I've ever had in my whole life! I used to hate pizza, until I discovered the beauty that is sourdough pizza at Hail Mary. I could easily eat a whole pie & feel light as a feather because of the high quality clean ingredients. This is the best pizza in LA, SoCal, anywhere you go. The owner, Jeff, is always there hands on making sure each pizza is dished out to perfection. And don't skip on the gourmet salads, wings. bites, & natural wines. Hail Mary is a tasty experience so I encourage to indulge! Current fave custom pizza: Red sauce, burrata, basil, Calabrian chilis, Jalapeños, & Pepperoni read more

See all

I'd like to rate this higher, but I found that the system inside was slightly offputting for me personally. There's no outside seating and the indoor seating requires you to order and then find a table. I personally found that really stressful on a hot day. Whilst it was cool to have an exposed kitchen so you can see your food being made, there's no space to queue and cooking inside made the room super hot. That said, this place is really cool and does have a nice vibe once you're seated. The staff are friendly and accomodating. The menu is great. There are so many options, with innovative pizza toppings and lots of very well thought through sides. We had a basic margherita pizza (always a good test) and it was divine. The sides which were particularly notable were the meatballs (that sauce...!!!) and the salads. They don't drown their salads in dressing, making them subtle and easy to graze on. I'd probably order this as delivery or to go, personally, though I bet it's really nice on a cooler day/ when it's quieter. read more

Great craft pizza. It's almost like a neopolitan style pizza, but definitely thicker and firmer. The crust has a nice chew and is flavorful. The pepperoni is chewy with crisp edges, which is always a plus. There are a variety of artisanal type pizzas here and am pretty sure there's something for everyone! Parking is street or neighborhood. Make sure you look at the sign postings. read more

Hail Mary Pizza - The The Roni with Calabrian chilis (costs extra) - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

More neighborhoods need a pizza joint like Hail Mary Pizza, serving unique delicious pizza with creative flavor combinations. I like that they also have monthly limited edition pizza like the Lilo Unscripted that I got - a take on the classic Hawaiian pizza. The other pizza that my table got, Lord Cheesus, was pretty good but didn't knock my socks off as much. Could just be the choices of cheese, but it's more personal taste. Nevertheless, with enough variety of pizzas here, it'll be hard to get bored and I'll be sure to come back to try more. Now if only they can do half and half so I can try two different pizzas at once read more

See all

Even their plain cheese pizza is not so simple, packed with a lot of flavor. I love their text deals they send, kind of keeps me in the loop as to what's going on. You can really taste the quality, my son was a fan, and he's a pizza connoisseur so Hail Mary has my vote as one of the best pizzas in town. read more