There's a particular kind of joy in feeding your college kid something that didn't come from a drive-thru window or a dining hall steam tray--and this place delivers that joy in butter, spice, and just the right amount of indulgence. Tucked into Auburn's dining scene with an upscale-casual pub charm, it's become our daughter's favorite spot to "take us" when we visit--which tells you everything you need to know. After a semester fueled by ramen and an alarming quantity of Chick-fil-A, she heads straight for the spicy penne crowned with perfectly cooked filet medallions. A wise choice. They don't take reservations, and yes, you may linger outside awhile on a busy night. Stay. It's worth it. For those of us with Gulf Coast roots, the menu reads like a love letter: blackened catfish done right, crispy crawfish tails, and cheese-laced grits that feel like a warm welcome home. The fried green tomatoes are a standout--golden, crisp, topped with grilled shrimp, and finished with a balsamic glaze that somehow works beautifully, even if it strays from tradition. The shrimp and grits, the catfish, the pasta--all hits. Cheesecake for dessert, especially if you're loyal to a graham cracker crust, is non-negotiable. Dim, cozy, a little whimsical (don't skip art in the hallway to the bathroom), and staffed by people who seem genuinely happy you're there. We'll be back. Often. --Chance & Becky *All Ahead Slow* read more

Hamilton's On Magnolia - Beautiful, delicious tower of fried green tomato goodness - New American Near Me - Auburn, Alabama

See all

Cozy and dark. The staff was very friendly. Crab cakes were yummy. The single pour wine could be improved. But they have nice options for bottles. Everyone in our party seemed pretty satisfied with their food. read more

Great food. Nice space with indoor and outdoor dining. A favorite for meals when visiting my Auburn student.

Being in a college town and going to a dinner restaurant is a slightly odd experience. When the most popular local meal is a pizza slice left on the coffee table after a prior night's party, it's natural to some skepticism regarding the town's place in a world of finer dining. Hamilton's is generally not the kind of place where college students go. As a matter of fact, it would not an unreasonable bet to say that the majority of them will not step into Hamilton's a single time during their entire education journey. Some lucky students might be able to score Hamilton's when parents are in town and footing the bill. Otherwise, it's just professors and graduates. The pork tenderloin at Hamilton's is incredibly delicate and if it isn't already, it fully deserves to be the signature dish. Juicy, flavorful and peppered just enough. Salmon salad is solid as well. The food complements appropriately to the old school design and wooding paneling of the place, with a menu focused on traditional American kitchen. The staff are mostly college students. Some decent wines are present on the list as well, so if parents are paying, go for the Cakebread bottle. This is good, quality, all American food. read more

Hamilton's On Magnolia - Salmon salad - New American Near Me - Auburn, Alabama

See all

Sunday dinner. 1st time here for the 3 of us. Our server was very friendly. Nice drink menu. I had the cucumber salad to start-wow unusual. Think cucumber spirals with feta cheese! It was delicious! Hubby had a Caesar. Out table had Scallops:grits, Rib eye & I had the Mahi sandwich w/fries. All were Excellent! The guys had crème brûlée & Cheesecake for dessert. Nice place to eat & great vibes too! read more

Amazing food! Great service! Excellent wine selection!!! I totally recommend this place!!

We found the food and service to be just adequate. Nothing stood out as being worth coming back for. There are other restaurants in that area that have better food read more

The staff down at the hotel recommended Hamilton's and I'm so glad I was able to stop by. On a Monday night, it was very packed, so I suggest you make a reservation. Since it was so packed, there were no available tables available and the wait was going to be super long, but I was lucky enough to find seat at the bar. I was immediately greeted by the bartender who was very slammed. I felt bad for her because it was so busy, but she handled everything like a pro! I decided to order a side salad and the fresh catch of the day, which was Cod and it came with shrimp and wild rice. Everything was very delicious. The side salad was such a nice helping that I pretty much got full off of just that. I was able to try the Cod and shrimp. It was good too. The fish was definitely fresh, but seasoned very well and the jumbo shrimp was buttery and tender. I also noticed that Hamilton's also had live music, which was an added bonus. All in all, great visit to Hamilton's. Definitely recommend! read more

See all

Stopped in on our way from the hotel to the airport while our passengers were at the Auburn football game. Sat at the bar. Both bartenders were friendly and welcoming (as is the case with pretty much everyone I've met in Auburn). I had a club sandwich with fries and tea. My copilot had the sesame seared tuna. Both of us enjoyed the meal. The couple sitting next to me had pork tenderloin and they said it was delicious. I hope to visit this establishment again soon. Thanks for the quick service and a great meal! read more

I was in town for a work trip with 4 colleagues Had the fried green tomato and shrimp appetizer with the hot shrimp too. Very good. For entree, I had the scallops on cheesy grits. Also very good. Nice atmosphere and great service. read more

Great food and service! We dined outdoors, and unfortunately that space was pretty small - but great for people watching. It gets busy - so go early or be prepared to wait. read more

So good! Great atmosphere! I love the salad with salmon! Great drink specials during the week too!

First time eating there after church today. Had the lobster bisque and a Caesar salad. Excellent food and service; but the loud, head banging music will keep me from going back. read more

We went last night (Sunday, 12/21/25), and were seated immediately by a friendly host. We sat behind the bar near the window. Our server gave us waters promptly and asked if we were ready to order as we just sat down. We requested a couple more minutes to look over the menu, and she left. We waited and waited, and pretty soon, 45 minutes went by with no one coming back to our table. I notified the bar tender we were heading out. My wife and I have been wanting to try Hamilton's for a very long time and made the trip from Birmingham to have such a bad experience. read more

One of the best restaurants in Auburn, great location, excellent menu with delicious choices. The service is very good, but because of its popularity it's very noisy! We love it. read more

I am only giving this review based on the system to get a table at Hamiltons. I was concerned when i looked to book a reservation for Saturday night while in town and realized they don't take reservations-that was a red flag. But the group wanted to show up Sat night and see if we could get a table. When we arrived around 7 you could barely get inside due to all of the people standing around in the small bar area. We were told that you have to stay inside because they only call your name out loud!! We asked can you not text us - there is no room here to stand and wait. No we don't do that. After standing near the back of the bar area and having to constantly move because of staff trying to go and come from the bar -we realized the young girls running the table list were calling out names so softly you couldn't hear them. When we questioned them about how are we supposed to hear our names being called they had no response. We did finally get a table after about 45 minutes. But then you are surrounded by the people waiting on a table- not a relaxing enjoyable meal at all. What i do not understand in this day and age of technology is a restaurant owner treating its customers this way !! Are they watching by remote cameras and enjoying the show ?!! Why not incorporate a texting policy or give out restaurant beepers ? First and last time for us. The waitress even apologized to us. She had come over from the other Hamilton location. She said how difficult it is for the servers to navigate the waiting crowd to serve the customers. read more

Just go you will be glad you did. The fettuccine is wonderful. The atmosphere is great . Service is top notch.

Saturday lunch. Food was ok. The best thing we ordered was the bang bang shrimp and the fried green tomato appetizer Service was great. As well was the ambiance. Salmon and chicken was a little over cooked. However, will return to give another try when in the area. read more

See all

Visiting the area from California for our nephews graduation from Fort Benning. We decided to take a little drive into the Auburn area and stumbled upon Hamilton's. Let me just say that Hot Roast Beef Sandwich was amazing. Tender roast beef, perfectly soft bread, it was super delicious. My sister-in-law had the chicken tenders that were also very good, along with the cucumber salad. Oh and the sweet tea, yum! Our server was very attentive, and he had that southern hospitality and charm. We will most definitely be back, when we return to the area. read more

Amazing service! Such great blackened salmon! Atmosphere was very good too, will def be back read more

Hamilton's On Magnolia - Salmon Salad and Burger - New American Near Me - Auburn, Alabama

Great food. Nice location. Very relaxing, but feels upscale. Love the food and service

Dinner with friends on a Wednesday early evening. Checked all the boxes for us where food and service are concerned. My blackened salmon was cooked perfectly. This is a popular spot so noise level is high and the later you arrive the more likely you'll be waiting to be seated but it will be worth the wait. read more

I forgot to take photos but oh my goodness our meal was so good! We got a blackened salmon over salad, lobster bisque, seared ahi, and creme brûlée for dessert. SO GOOD. Wouldn't expect any less from here honestly. read more

Hamilton's On Magnolia - Creme brûlée and chocolate cheesecake! - New American Near Me - Auburn, Alabama

Food and service was outstanding. Just what the wife and I needed. The lighting was also on point and it felt cozy on a cool winter's evening . read more

Hamilton's On Magnolia - Catch of the day and shrimp with a Hollandaise sauce I believe. - New American Near Me - Auburn, Alabama

Hands down one of my favorite places for a meal in Auburn. The food is always great and the ambiance is cozy and the service on point and friendly! read more

I had lunch here on a beautiful summer day while visiting Auburn. I sat on the patio. My server was Drew. He was great. Very attentive. The restaurant had a lobster bisque on the menu so I absolutely had to try it. I would rank it as a 3 among others that I tried. I could taste tomato and maybe pimento. Not bad. I ordered the crab cake as an appetizer as well. I enjoyed it. Primary crab meat and not a lot of breading which represents a true crab cake. For my entree, I order the blackened chicken fettuccine alfredo. The chicken was well seasoned. The sauce had an herb flavor which was different. The sauce didn't taste like it was made from scratch but it was still enjoyable. I had an overall great experience. I would return again. While I dined outside, I did check out the inside of the restaurant. It gave me date night vibes and the area is great for a night walk after dinner. read more

Went out for dinner with a few friends and the restaurant had such a lively and fun atmosphere the food was flavorful and portions were generous read more

The service and atmosphere was great! The fried green tomatoes could be better and overall the food was ok but not overwhelming. Would try again though when in town again. read more

We are there Saturday morning. Everyone from the hostess to the bartender to our waiter was amazing. And the food oh my. Perfect as well.

Had dinner here with my coworker. Of course the food was delicious, but the underrated part of the experience was the service. Our server, Brynli was amazing! Her attentiveness and attention was definitely worth mentioning. Great experience and we will be returning! read more

The fish and shrimp was great. Tuna with the wasabi sauce was very strong. Cold by the window.

It was fine. Decor and vibe we chill and comfortable. Really loved the atmosphere. Food was over rated. Fried green tomatoes over breaded and sauces were not good at all. Grilled shrimp was simple and delicious. Lobster bisque was really good. Salads were really good but dressings tasted bottled. Roast beef sandwich was just ok. Not good flavor development, au jus was odd. The fries were just bad. Dumped out a a freezer bag and served unseasoned bad. I think they just need to tweak a bit to ensure they stay on their food game and stay at the top of auburn charts. Hard to climb back after you fall off. read more

When you imagine Harry and Sally (from When Harry Met Sally, let's not be too dense) in a restaurant together, it's hard not to imagine it being a restaurant like Hamilton's. Low lighting and conversations all around allows for a private yet social dining experience. My favorite dish in Auburn - the chicken provençal - is on their dinner menu, and the desert options allowed for a shot at some beautiful crème brûlée. The bartender made a good drink as well, and the experience overall was relaxing and entertaining. read more

Hamilton's On Magnolia - chicken provençal, pasta, grilled asparagus - New American Near Me - Auburn, Alabama

See all

All great!! Goooo!! Blackened chicken a must. Bar area great too!! Ribeye was one of the best too!!

We decided to go to Hamilton's on Magnolia while touring the Auburn campus. The restaurant is a typical high end steakhouse/restaurant that would be perfect for that after golf outing, business meeting or date night. Crowded, busy and loud....and serving plenty of cocktails at the bar. We ordered Crab Cakes and Spinach and Artichoke Dip for appetizers. Both shined and were gobbled up quick. What a great start!!! I also ordered the Lobster Bisque because I love Lobster Bisque....and I certainly was glad that I did. WOW!!!! For entrees, We ordered the Filet and Shrimp and Grits. Seriously Amazing!!!! The Filet was so good, and the Shrimp and Grits were wiped out in short order. Paired excellent food with excellent service and our dining experience couldn't have been better! We will be back again whenever we return. Kudos Hamilton's....you knocked it out of the park!! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!! read more

See all

The best food I have put in my mouth by far in a long time!!! Service was great! My husband got the pork tenderloin and it was melt in your mouth tender! I got the mahi mahi sandwich and my daughter got the burger. We also had the crab cakes for app. read more

Amazing love this place, I have been here many times and always on point. Service is great and make you feel at home

Hamiltons is the best restaurant in Auburn! They never miss. Lunch menu is just as good as dinner. Food, service, and ambiance are always 10/10. The only thing I do not like is that you cannot make a reservation. Definitely recommend Hamiltons when you are in Auburn. read more

Hamilton's On Magnolia - Chicken Prov - New American Near Me - Auburn, Alabama

See all

Great restaurant. Crave cakes are amazing- lots of meat!! The chicken Provençal was delicious. The bread pudding was also delicious.

This place has great service and great food. The biggest problem is the lines that often go very long as does the wait.. But that's only because the food is excellent and the service is wonderful. Great place to get a late night by it after the Alabama Auburn football game. read more

Hamilton's On Magnolia - New American Near Me - Auburn, Alabama

See all