Ok so Ive been here a few times before and its just like any other hardware store. Lots of stuff,…read morevery organized, and employees that will help you if you cant find what you need. Today I had an issue with my car, and was unable to get the correct part to fix it in time to get my car home today. I walked over to here and told the employee what I was trying to fix, and how I was planning to do it. I wish I got his name, because he helped me find what I needed, gave me some different options and methods on how to fix my issue, and was overall very helpful. You can imagine that I wasnt in the best mood having to fix my car on the side of the road, but he definately helped make today less terrible. Honestly this is the vibe i get every time I come in here. The employees seem to actually enjoy helping, and seem to enjoy their jobs. You just dont get that everywhere, and for me it makes a big difference.

They overcharged my kids for paint that was supposed to be affordable for a school project. My…read moredaughter specifically asked for the cheapest gallon, but the staff didn't disclose the price until checkout, where it turned out to be $75 per gallon! This feels deceptive and unfair, especially since it's for a high school activity. Disappointing experience all around and shame on Connetquot High School for encouraging the students use this supply store.

The team at Ace is always helpful and friendly. Specifically Vinnie always puts a smile on your…read moreface at checkout. Today I have to call out Keith who was leaving for the day and walking to his car. He recognized me from helping me in the past and offered to help. He walked me back into the store to get the exact plumbing part I needed...which worked perfectly.

Customer service could not be worse. It used to be excellent under the previous owner, but not…read moreanymore. Prices are beyond outrageous, the staff has absolutely zero knowledge of their products (which are very poor quality these days - and the store does not stand by their products), and no proper understanding of service, not to mention a lazy, very unpleasant attitude, and no regard for longtime loyal customers who now are former customers. Take your business to Home Depot or literally anywhere else, if your money and your self respect matter at all to you. I certainly won't be back, after all these years.

Exceptional.customer service with competitive pricing. They all asked if help was needed throughout…read morethe store. Centrally located and easily accessible for all. Ample parking and bright, clean, organized store to shop in and support local business. A must visit. Cute yeti accessories for all Options galore

The Owner and Manager of this business are some of the worst I have ever come across. They show…read morenothing but utter disrespect to their customers, even after spending thousands of dollars. There are plenty of Ace Hardware locations, do yourself a favor and never spend your money at this one. There is a reason they have the rating they do.

I am sure it's a good store but not for someone who uses a wheelchair. There are displays in all…read morethe aisles so I was only able to get in the entrance I was not able to look at anything in the store and therefore I left and did not make any purchases. Unfortunately this is a common occurrence in many stores that are supposed to be accessible.

Drive to Setauket location, this place never has any stock. Advertised specials never available.read more

I went to Ace Hardware on June 23, 2022, my husband asked me to go for him, I went with a plumbing…read morequestion, not knowing what I was talking about, I asked for help and a worker said I'll get Dan, he knows everything, I spoke with Dan, who was so willing to help me with my plumbing question, he went above and beyond helping me. He set me up with everything I needed to take care of the plumbing issue we were having, with Dan's help my husband was able to fix the problem within ten minutes, I can't say enough about Ace Hardware in Smithtown, but I can surely say Dan is the Man for all your hardware needs. Nancy S

PTry to use a coupon and get so confused that your head spins and the cashier is confused as well…read more I have to say that she was extremely nice but I felt bad for she was confused by the coupon. First, I bought weed b gone...oops wrong one, my fault. I saw the brand, wrong size. Second coupon $5.00 off a $20 purchase.....but wait......don't buy green egg woodchips (****) That's what comes up, an asterisk which means that it didn't qualify.....what? So now I was 2cents short. But thank you to the wonderful cashier, she did the right thing. So.....5 stars to the cashier 1 stars to a store which makes you jump through hoops to use a coupon. Come on now! So, average 2.5 stars, I gave 3 because of the sweet cashier!

An in-and-out kind of hardware store. Good for errands on your lunchbreak kind-of-place. . . they…read morehave everything you could want. You will probably need help from the clerks in finding it, as the aisles are overstocked. In that sense, it feels like an old-skool hardware store, much different than shopping at a home depot. However, be warned, these guys don't care what you're building and their recommendations are half-hearted. . . . they just want to go back to their prior conversations and bullsh*tting: A rush to get you out of here, so old-timers looking to make smalltalk may be disappointed in way of the "experience" of buying things.

Maybe in order to understand mankind, we have to look at the word itself.. mankind. Basically, it's…read moremade up of two separate words - "mank" and "ind". What do these words mean? It's a mystery, and that's why so is mankind. Stocked to the brim with supplies and open early, AAH is run by some knowledgeable guys and conveniently located right off the LIE on Motor Parkway next to Moore's deli (couldn't agree more w/ Elitia here). What it really comes down to with a 4-star review is that I couldn't imagine something a neophyte like I would need for a DIY project around the house NOT being available here, and at a reasonable price.

Nothing can ruin your BBQ more than running out of propane half way thru grilling your steaks…read more However, I have learned.....Ocean Beach Hardware to the rescue! Did you know you can go there and buy bbq tanks? All rental houses in Ocean Beach should have a note on their refrigerator notifying the tenant where to go and get a BBQ tank, Ocean Beach Hardware. They will take your empty bbq tanks too. And if you catch the owner on a good day, he's pretty entertaining....

This place is the pits! I stopped over this morning when they had zero business taking place. I…read moreasked nicely to borrow a wrench to adjust my sit and was politely told by the service person that they are required to charge 10 dollars for me to borrow a wrench. Totally unacceptable and ridiculous. I will not be going back.

This little hardware store has been around for as long as I can remember…read more When major chains are out of what we are looking for Grays always has it in stock and at great prices! This will continue to be our go to hardware store. The staff are the friendliest people you will ever meet.

Packed house - better pray no one breaks wind - very helpful - bring extra cash - only game in townread more

I had a mixed experience at Costello's Ace Hardware in Nesconset…read more The woman at the paint counter was excellent. The store was busy, she was helping multiple people at once, and she still provided great service to me while also taking care of the gentleman waiting for his paint. She handled the situation professionally and was very helpful. The checkout experience was very different. I went to purchase lawn seed that had a yellow sale tag, and the tag also indicated Ace members would receive an additional $1 off. Based on that, I expected it to be a good deal. There were two people behind the counter. One person was helping another customer, and the other man behind the counter yelled "next customer," which felt unnecessary given the small size of the store. Maybe he was having a bad day, but the interaction felt dismissive from the start. When I approached, he asked if I was an Ace member, I entered my phone number, and he proceeded to charge me $11 over the sale price. I pointed out the yellow sale tag on the shelf, and he rudely pointed out that it was last week's sale, which could be seen by the 4/28 date in tiny print. Today is 4/29, so I understand the sale had ended, but the sale tags were still up. Honestly, I did not notice the small date, and I relied on the sale sign that was still posted. He did not honor the sale price and seemed annoyed that I even asked about it. I always thought Ace was more customer friendly, but this experience was disappointing. A simple acknowledgment, explanation, or courtesy adjustment would have made a big difference. Based on this interaction, I guess I will have to shop elsewhere.

STOP HIRING YOUNG PEOPLE THAT DONT KNOW WHAT THEY'RE DOING. I'm 26 and honestly I never leave…read morereviews, but I have to. Young people should absolutely not be working here and neither should people who have absolutely no experience or knowledge on the products sold here. I came in here today and asked for help with a few projects I have at home. A young man helped me and he was nice but kept rushing through helping me and also didn't seem to know what to look for to actually help me find what I needed, he just pretended he knew what he was doing. He also didn't help me find specific things I needed by assisting me to the correct part of the aisles. He rushed me when I was paying as well so much that when I got home and looked in my bag ready to start my projects he didn't pack half of the things I bought. On top of that, he gave me the wrong screws. I WANT MY MONEY BACK.

I used this store in the past,it has since gone down hill. I went in for a return and was given an…read moreattitude by one of the old men. I am hard of hearing and was given an attitude with hand gestures when i asked him to repeat himself. I will never come here again, and it's a shame it's down the street from me. I would rather drive 10 minutes to ACE hardware (a commerical store) than support this store again. You guys lost a customer. All these negative reviews about the employees aren't coincidence. Trust me. Go to ACE or Home Depot instead.

Horrible service can't be bothered helping you as well as priced higher than ace hardware. Take…read moreyour business to Ace plus the owner is a real jerk!