So Memorial Day weekend 2026 our halibut fishing crew rolled into old town…read more Our guest of honor was my father in law who grew up in the Eureka area. Instead of Babes pizza this year my father in law led us to PAUL'S LIVE FROM NEW YORK!!! Rolled into Paul's and examined the menu in a giant pizza booth adjacent to the kitchen. As the fish crew was discussing the order a pizza chef revealed himself over the wall and told us we needed to order the 6-meat King Kong!!! Sign us up brother! I couldn't find King Kong on the menu! Awesome it's top secret. So order up...one 18 inch pepperoni pizza, one hitman, one King Kong, and two sausage rolls. That's a Yelpstar elite order folks. Pizza rolled out piping hot and fabulous. The food was 5-star tasty and from sea to shining sea some of the best NYC style pizza I've tasted. Thanks PAUL'S LIVE FROM NEW YORK! I'll be back.

I feel like this spot has a lot of potential here but just misses the mark…read more A local spot, very popular. Not so much for dine in as more for take out and third party. You can do a simple slice or grab whole items as well. The space is big, just seems informal and the decor is little to be desired. It's like being in a warehouse setting, cold and flat. The communication within the staff is lacking a bit. After placing an order, it took 15 mins for them to realize they had over sold an item, and let us know after we had sat down, which then delayed part of our order after we chose a new item. In the end the food was decent.

The best ever Pizza Thrower is back - My favorite the Tomato -Onion-garlic (just right) at $4.50 a…read moregiant slice (2 for $8! Also). Across from City of Eureka building on 2nd St

Everything. The toppings had no flavor nor did the sauce. The crust was like shoe leather. This…read moreplace was recommended so I gave it the benefit of the doubt. I should have followed my instincts after seeing the food pics.

Pizza Gago catered our wedding. Not only was it unique, it was affordable. Gago was communicative…read moreand accommodating. Our vegan guests loved the vegan options. Having our guests feast on the delicious grazing board and spinach artichoke cheesecakes while the pizzas cooked was the move. I would highly recommend hiring Gago for your next event and/or trying what he has to offer at local farmers markets.

All flavor no fluff. Creative combinations…read more My stomach feels good after eating their pizza. Other pizza's with loads of cheese and more dense crust can be tempting and even make my mouth a bit happy for moment but my stomach feels dense afterwards. The crust has chew and structure though not like a cracker (which was a pizza trend elsewhere that I wasn't liking but also not fond of the bread like flavorless thicker crusts (not talking deep dish which a place in Bay Area did well somehow). I forget the owner's name..begins with a P I think ....anyway very hard worker who puts his head and heart into producing his products. They do catering too..i looked it up on FB or Instagram and was amazed at how many other things he makes and how delicious it also looked. I'd give 6 stars if that was an option and they had some oregano or other herbs on the side to put on pizza if we like ...pizza places in general used to do that and haven't seen it anywhere. Oregano is easy to grow. Some might find it pricy for the lightness of the pizza so if you need a hearty meal their pizza might not do it for you. I have only had their pizza at the farmers market and it tastes so good i have to use will power not to eat the whole thing . I save half for the next day and sometimes add an egg on it for breakfast. Reheating in cast iron pan brings the crust back to life and I don't put it in the frig overnight to also keep the crust good and i turn the pizza upside down so crust not soggy but with his pizza no much chance of that cause he does some sort of dough magic that makes his crust hold and not soak up the toppings.

The waitress was super friendly and attentive. Good sense of humor. Everyone ordered something…read moredifferent, from chicken wings (even the super hot sauce), burgers, chicken sandwich - all good. Visited on a Sunday afternoon. Plenty of seating. Slightly loud due to a couple of pool games, but overall, great place.

best place to watch sports in Arcata big space with tables…read moreand bar seating lots of TV's I come here when the Padres are playing the A's or giants because my MLB app is blacked out good beer selection great burgers and apps excellent service there's a club attached that I haven't checked out yet

A simple little "food shack" across the street from target selling darn good sandwiches... it's…read moretheir twist on a banh mi. I pulled up, and the lady comes out to talk to me, she asked me if I had been there before and I said I didn't. She said take a look at the menu, and I will come back to you. It turns out she was going back-and-forth between being the cashier, and taking orders. If they had a box, it wasn't working. I decided to go with the pulled pork sandwich on a baguette, I chose all of the veggies, with no cheese or avocado, which was extra price. I requested the barbecue sauce, which was the non-spicy version. The sandwich was excellent. The baguette was a very high-quality roll, the pulled pork was savory, and all of the veggies were nice and crisp. The barbecue sauce tasted like it was a vinegar based, and it had a great "Tang" to it. It provided a nice pop of acid to offset the richness of the pulled pork. I could only finish half of my sandwich, and I had the other half for dinner. The sandwich came out to $14 and change after tax, , which was reasonable for such a good sandwich. The reason I'm taking off a star, is because of the wait time. The wait time from when I pulled up till when I pulled out with my sandwich was roughly 15 minutes. That's quite a wait for a sandwich. You can order ahead online, but you still have to wait in the line to pick up your food. They do delivery, but they only do one delivery run a day at 11 AM, and so you have to get your order in on time. They shouldn't have the person running back-and-forth between being cashier, and taking orders as well. Maybe have another person taking orders. Hopefully the next time I come back, the wait won't be so long. I wish these guys would get a "brick-and-mortar." They would do very well. Thank you!

A little drive-up building that caused me to feel a little dubious at first, but it was wonderful!…read moreThe girl working the window was great, my food was done before we even finished the transaction, and it was delicious.

grest burgers…read more Amazing staff The Citrus surprise... probably the best milkshake ever.

They make a really good classic burger.i miss this place after moving away.its what a real…read morehamburger should taste like

This is a perfect place to eat and enjoy the warmth of the staff. The breakfast was delicious, but…read morethe service was fantastic. Even though we were just passing through, if I ever return to Eureka, I would definitely come back to eat here. Highly recommended.

Stopped at this restaurant for dinner with my family. The food was great, and the portions were…read moreplenty. We liked the family atmosphere, and all the employees were friendly. We were served quickly, all our meals were hot, and server was always present for our needs. She seemed happy to be at work ! Our server,(young blonde girl)should be recognized. We will be back !

Pulling up to our hotel in Arcata, CA, we noticed the sign for Kebab Cafe. I mentioned it to my…read morewife. When we checked in she asked about food places and everyone at the front desk said the food at the Kebab Cafe is awesome. 'Nuff said. Diane went to get us some food. We ordered pork, beef, vegetable and chicken kebabs. We added a dinner plate with chicken, rice and a veggie kebab. It also included cabbage, tomato and cucumbers. We also ordered a couple of rounds of pita bread. The food was absolutely awesome. Diane said the place was clean, the people were friendly. They were very nice and very efficient and willing to answer any questions. There were a lot of people in and out ordering and picking up food while she was there. If we are back through Arcata, we will go there again. Great find. Try it out.

Stopped by Kebab Café recently and had a nice experience overall. I ordered takeout and everything…read moretasted fresh and well-prepared. The gyro sandwich was definitely the highlight.. it was a great size, very filling, and had really enjoyable flavors. The hummus was good, and they give you a generous portion, though it only comes with a small piece of bread, so I would have loved a bit more to go with it. Overall, it's a solid spot for a quick and satisfying meal. I'd happily come back again, a reliable place when you're craving a tasty gyro.