Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Herttys Bakeshop

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open 10:00 am - 5:00 pm

    Herttys Bakeshop Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Herttys Bakeshop

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Herttys Bakeshop

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Custom Cakes 1,575 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Pastry Factory

    The Pastry Factory

    4.2
    (21 reviews)
    15.5 km

    First time customer, and my last time. If you're wanting to buy overpriced, tiny, stale cupcakes,…read morethis is your spot! Don't waste your money! I needed some cupcakes for a gathering, and I saw the reviews so I thought I'd give them a try. I got up early to be there when they opened so I could have a good selection. I was pretty disappointed when I got there and there weren't that many options. I was also surprised at how small they were. The decorative topping is very simple. Then, when they said they were $4 a cupcake, I was even more surprised. If I hadn't made all the trouble to get here and if I didn't really need the cupcakes, I would have gone someplace else. I thought to myself, these better taste amazing. I bought a dozen cupcakes and made sure I got at least one of each flavor. Once I got home, I dug into one, just to see how they were. Once again, I'm disappointed. They don't even taste fresh. WTH?! Now I'm regretting serving the rest of them, because what if they aren't good as well? So disappointed. I got feedback from those at my event and the consensus is these aren't good. All of the cupcakes were dry, crumbled and fell apart when you tried to eat them. What makes matters worse, the owners don't care.

    Could be my favourite stop in the North Market. Not my doctor's. lol. My sister was excited to find…read morethis place. She has something going on where everything must be gluten free. Like the cupcakes she bought a dozen of and refused to share. Don't nothin' ever change? Italian creame and snickerdoodle were the rave of today. It all tastes great, too! I had the Blueberry crumble cupcake and wished I could have two. They have a lot of unique flavours but take caution some things are extremely sweet. Ask first. The young lady that waited on us was friendly and helpful. The crowd wasn't too bad, I suspect it was the crummy weather that kept all the Ohioans inside today.

    Photos
    The Pastry Factory
    The Pastry Factory
    The Pastry Factory

    See all

    Kittie's Cakes

    Kittie's Cakes

    4.2
    (117 reviews)
    17.8 km
    $$

    Once again, Diane and the team made one of my loved ones' have an exceptionally yummy Birthday!…read moreThank you all for helping me! Everything was beautiful and delicious!!!! *I did ask for the writing to be in orange (the Birthday girls favorite color plus would look great in a carrot cake) but other than that, everything was great!

    The shop is very cute and has good vibes. I was very excited to try it, especially after seeing…read morethat they make my favorite flavor of cake/cupcake: German chocolate. However my overall experience was disappointing. The staff were not friendly and seemed annoyed when they had to find my cupcake order. After they found my order, they seemed annoyed that I wanted to order a drink. I ordered a matcha latte and it was just okay, but pretty pricey. The cupcakes themselves were severely disappointing. They were extremely tiny for the price. The cake was very dense and off putting. The frosting was also dense. I'm an extreme chocolate lover and did not enjoy the chocolate cupcakes and frosting at all. Everything just tasted very heavy. Their vanilla cake flavor and batter was better. It was slightly less dense and more palatable, but for the price I will not be ordering it again. Due to lack of service and food/drink quality and taste I will not be coming here again. There's better options in Columbus for this price point.

    Photos
    Here are the mini cupcake flavors:  3) s'more 3) classic 3) coffee toffee crunch 3) classic buckeye
    Here are the mini cupcake flavors: 3) s'more 3) classic 3) coffee toffee crunch 3) classic buckeye
    Kittie's Cakes
    Mele kaliki macha seasonal drink

    See all

    Mele kaliki macha seasonal drink
    Our CupCakery

    Our CupCakery

    3.9
    (95 reviews)
    3.4 km
    $$

    Quaint cupcake shop that start you off with the base cupcake and then you can pick what type of…read morefrostings and extras etc. It's kinda like the Chipotle of cupcakes. My standard for cupcakes are different than the general masses as I feel like the ENTIRE cupcake should be a complete entity taste wise and one component shouldn't outshine the other. For example, the toppings and icing they put on top of the cupcake is STELLAR but the actual bare cupcake itself tastes like one of those cakes box mixes like DUNCAN HINES, or PILLSBURY. The entire cupcake should be good not just one half component of it. Nevertheless they've got all different types of candies, bon bons, they bake wedding cakes, and host private parties so what do I know‍. Apparently DUBLIN loves the hell outta em because it was constant traffic of folks in and outta there making purchases.

    I had a wonderful time at the 'Bake and Decorate Your First Birthday Cake' class! Linda and Tom…read moreboth provided excellent hands on experience with baking a cake from scratch, making icing and decorating a cake. They gave tons of helpful tips and tricks throughout the class and I left there feeling empowered that I could take this on myself at home! Would recommend to anyone looking to get into baking and decorating! Oh, and the cake turned out DELICIOUS!!

    Photos
    The gingerbread kit we were provided.
    The gingerbread kit we were provided.
    Birthday cake cupcakes, and one vanilla and two cookie dough
    Birthday cake cupcakes, and one vanilla and two cookie dough
    Our CupCakery

    See all

    Pistacia Vera

    Pistacia Vera

    4.6
    (951 reviews)
    17.9 km
    $$

    I've heard nothing but great things about this cafe, so my expectations were high - I'm happy to…read morereport that this place is worth the hype! We were gifted tickets for the German Village picnic Giftory experience which gave us two macarons of our choosing and two vanilla shortbread cookies for free. We chose the raspberry chambord and pistachio macarons while also ordering two pistachio cloud matchas. All of the desserts were excellent. The raspberry macaron was very fruit forward while the pistachio was more subdued, but still had a spot on flavor. Even with sugar coating the shortbread cookies, the touch of vanilla made them taste light. I could easily see myself eating far too many of those. The star of the show was the matcha. 10/10! I've never had a pistachio flavored drink, so I was a little hesitant, but wow, I'm glad I ordered it! The matcha base wasn't overly sweet nor was the pistachio foam overly salty. Perfect mix of sweet and savory. Even thought the line was out the door, it moved at a decent pace and our drinks didn't take too long to receive. I'd like to try the strawberry matcha next time, but I'm not sure if I can pass up the pistachio Highly recommend!

    Overpriced and overhyped! Visited with a few friends when it was still chilly out and waited in…read moreline to order a mocha, a ham and cheese croissant and a chocolate macaron. I think the issue is with the chocolate they use for the mocha but it had such an odd flavor that I couldn't bring myself to finish it. The croissant was fine and not memorable and I won't say too much on the macaron because I think I just realized I'm not really a macaron person so I can't fairly judge them there. The cafe is itty bitty and there is absolutely no seating inside so it's more of a grab and go situation. There are a few seats outside so hopefully you can snag a seat when the weather is nicer. Overall, I think there are a lot of other good coffee shops in Columbus that I don't see myself going out of my way to come back.

    Photos
    Elote Croissant ($5)
    Elote Croissant ($5)
    Patio seating
    Patio seating
    Cocoa Buttermilk Loaf cross-section ($12)

    See all

    Cocoa Buttermilk Loaf cross-section ($12)
    Resch's Bakery

    Resch's Bakery

    4.4
    (384 reviews)
    19.9 km
    $$

    New location, same great service and taste!…read more I have tried donuts in many states and countries and I have yet to find one better than here. Well, if I'm honest there was this Amish stand at a farmers market in Central PA that had outstanding donuts, but they only sold them a few times a year and I have no idea how to find them! This trip, I got the big boy donut, a white icing cake donut, and a pretzel. The big boy donut is a huge glazed donut as big as your head. That's right, you can hold it up to your head and it will be just as large!!! This time, however, they put a twist on them and added icing to a few. I know, sweet on top of a sweet sugary donut seems like overkill, and it was. But come on, anyone willing to eat a donut as big as his head has no problem with something super duper sweet! The other items were equally good, and I liked their new larger location. They even added a few new items since I was last there like donut holes/bites. This place continues to reign as the donut king in my estimation, and the fact that they FINALLY accept credit cards now is a huge win.

    I see why this bakery was so popular when they moved locations! It's huge and filled with donuts,…read morecookies, cakes - you name it. All at a decent price too. I like that you have to take a number before getting called to order. This makes it easier to walk around freely and decide what you want as opposed to standing in line and not having a view of what's available. I kept it simple and only ordered an apple fritter for myself. While it was a bit underdone in the center, I think it's because of the huge apple chunks. It was very soft and deliciously sweet though. I'd absolutely return to try out their bow tie donuts and danishes!

    Photos
    Resch's Bakery
    Resch's Bakery
    Resch's Bakery

    See all

    Herttys Bakeshop - customcakes - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...