Visited 4/15/26 @ 11:30AM Got Buffalo Pizza, Supreme Pizza Food was great Service was good Restroom was clean read more

The Highlands hottie was so good we had it for lunch one day and went back the next day for dinner. Cesar salad is big enough to split between two people, the cashier was...in a bad mood I guess (both days). But the pizza was amazing! read more

Highlands Pizza Place - Highlands hottie and buffalo chicken - Sandwiches Near Me - Highlands, North Carolina

My DH and I stopped in on a recent trip to Highlands. We had been shopping and asked where to get a "good salad," and were directed to Highlands Pizza Place. We ordered the Greek Salad and the Gorgonzola Salad. Both were fresh and flavorful. It is quick-service, where you order at the counter and then they bring it out to you. We both enjoyed our salads. read more

SOOOO GOOD. Stopped in while walking around town and this hit the spot. Wasn't too heavy. Did not have any leftovers read more

Highlands Pizza Place - Sandwiches Near Me - Highlands, North Carolina

This is a fun little stop in town where lunch and dinner is always going to be good. It's a pizza shop, don't expect fine dining, but do expect good food in a light environment. It has the old pizza shop type vibe. You order your meal, and take a number, and they will bring the food to you. I got their 6 wings with garlic parm as an app and they were very tasty and cooked well. I also got their Italian Sub and got it hot. It comes with chips and a pickle. The sub is very flavorful and perfect sized. If there is any draw back prepare for a slow food delivery. I hit during their lunch rush and local businesses clobbered them with large pizza orders which slowed down their kitchen staff for things that aren't pizza. Beyond that I'll go back because it is a nice and fun place. If you're looking for a good food selection (10" personal pizzas up to large, and a ton of sub sandwiches) this is the place. read more

See all

Food is excellent! Can get pretty busy but definitely worth the wait! No complaints! Their lasagna special was delicious and the salad included was superb! Every pizza we've tried was oh so good! Sandwiches too! read more

Stopped by on a rainy afternoon in Highlands. It's a fast casual spot where you order at the counter and they bring your food to the table. Sandwiches were great, delicious bread, toasted nicely. The Italian beef has marinara but tasted better than expected. read more

Highlands Pizza Place - Steak sandwich with Au Jus - Sandwiches Near Me - Highlands, North Carolina

See all

The supreme pizza and the calzones are absolutely delicious. A definite must get. The mozzarella sticks however are a definite no-go. Yuck. read more

Great casual pizza and Italian food in the heart of Highlands. Best place in town for taking the kids to dinner. Friendly staff and take out or eat in. read more

We had the pepperoni pizza, garden medley pizza and 2 Greek salads. The best pizza i have had in a very long time. The crust was crispy and ingredients were fresh. Loved the casual atmosphere. The staff were super friendly. Going there again tonight. read more

Amazing Pizza. Affordable prices and good sandwiches too. During the NFL season I like to watch the games.

Service was terrible, which is a shame because the food and ambiance is great! Order takeout or do not come in.

Delicious giant pizzas! I don't know that there are any other options in the area but you probably wouldn't want them if they had any. Every trip up here it's become a tradition. read more

This is nearly perfect pizza. I ordered a supreme pizza and the large is truly immense! The pizza is a little more than an average chain pizza restaurant, but the pie is far and away superior to any chain restaurant, too. The toppings were fresh and plentiful, the cheese was just the right amount and the red sauce was zesty and full of herbs. The only thing keeping this from being "perfect" is the crust. While the crust was good and cooked thoroughly, it's more like the crust from Mellow Mushroom and less like the charred crust of a NY style pizza. To be fair, they don't advertise as a NY style pizza, but that's the kind of crust I prefer above all others. I even prefer a brick oven coal fired pizza that has some snap and char to it. All things considered, this was a VERY GOOD pizza and well worth the price. We had left overs for 3 days! The staff were very friendly and the business is easy to find right off Main Street in Highlands. There is usually plenty of free parking and there is seating in the restaurant, too. The restaurant was neat, clean and cozy inside. Great place for a family or even a date night pizza. This was a great find nestled away in Highlands quietly making some of the best pies in WNC. read more

We came here after a Yelp search. The woman at the counter was friendly and patient with us. We ordered a small pizza and an appetizer calzone to share. The gentleman who brought it out to us was friendly as well. The chicken alfredo pizza was delicious ! The calzone was decent but there wasn't much ricotta cheese in it. It's a small establishment but there were more tables to sit at than it appears. It was decorated nicely. They thank you for coming as you walk out. I would absolutely come back here for the pizza ! read more

Extremely good people and gives back to the community and has extremely great pizza !!!

The Pizza Place is the best place in town for incredible service and food! Eat in or take out. read more

Flat soda. Could've been better. Seemed family owned which is nice. It would've used a little more flavor when it came to the menu items, pretty bland taste. read more

One of the top Pizza places Tito has ever been to. Tito is a pizza connoisseur having lived in New England most his life...this place rivals anywhere he has been! And you can take that to the bank! read more

Ordered a large Hawaiian pizza to go and the flavor of the sauce and cheese were outstanding! It was a great pizza.

I love this place! We were trying to find a place to eat on a Saturday afternoon. If you blink you could miss the door. We each got a 10" pizza and they were all great. The crust is seasoned well and the three cheese pizza was very flavorful. Only complaint is they seem to be short handed but that seems to be a common theme nowadays and you could tell they were doing their best to keep things moving along. There is plenty of seating, despite how it looks when you first walk in. read more

Highlands Pizza Place - Menu - Sandwiches Near Me - Highlands, North Carolina

See all

We had calzones and a large salad from Highlands Pizza. The food was wonderful and the service was fantastic! We will definitely be back again. read more

Just what we were looking for on a Friday night! The Greek salad was more than enough for 2 to share. We each got a 10" pizza-both delicious- and had leftovers. (We saw the large go by and as some reviews noted, it is large!) Service was great, ambiance is a pizza joint, which is what we wanted after a day of hiking. read more

The best gluten-free pizza I've had in a long time! So yummy and so accommodating we came in and ordered probably 10 pizzas with some being gluten-free and the team worked diligently and carefully to get our orders ready. so glad we found the spot. We will absolutely be back!! read more

Delicious pizza, salad, and wings! Food came out quickly. Some of the best pizza I've had in a long time. Staff was friendly and helpful. Very accommodating with our toddler as well. Nice atmosphere for a relaxed lunch or dinner. We're from out of town but will return the next time we visit Highlands! read more

Honestly I don't even know how this place is in business. I guess since it's the only game in town? Pizza tasted like cardboard and the girl working there was very rude. We got the veggie pizza and Hawaiian pizza. Do not recommend. Also $65 for 2 pizzas and a beer read more

Great pizza, great service!!! We love their pizzas, they're prices are awesome, and their service is even better:)

Great food! Wife got a calzone and she said it was the best calzone she has had and she pounds down calzones anytime they're on the menu. I split a pizza with my two boys and it was great! The staff were friendly and service was great. My wife realized she forgot her purse, she was probably buzzed from all that mozzarella, we went back and the staff had the purse behind the counter! We ate at the restaurant, don't let the entrance deceive you! The restaurant goes way back and opens up to several booths in the back with TV's and a nice restroom! Highly recommend this place! read more

We ordered a Pizza with four of our favorite toppings and it was delicious! And also ordered the Greek Salad and we loved it as well!

New owners have brought a fresh approach to this once tired pizza shop. Pizza was great with one of the better crusts I have had. Salads were a step above with homemade croutons and plentiful fresh veggies. Great casual spot (perfect for families) in the heart of Main Street. read more

I came to Highlands Pizza Place on a Sunday for lunch. The meatball sub and potato salad were very good! Quality ingredients, and that's how potato salad should be made in my opinion. Definitely come here to eat when visiting Highlands. Nice people, good food! read more

Ordered a muffuletta sandwich which was worth 4/5 stars but took over 25 minutes to get it. Meanwhile, a couple came in over 5 minutes after me and they got their pizza 5 minutes before I got my take out. Never said they were sorry so I said something about it and the manager told me in a loud voice sandwiches take longer. Can't recommend you eating here unless you order, go shopping 30 mins and come back read more