Caveat: we haven't vacationed in Mexico since the late 80s. So this resort-specific review might in fact reflect more on Mexican vacation culture than the Marina El Cid; we don't know. Caveat emptor.
Marina El Cid offers pleasant grounds and a decent, if fairly large, layout, but our visit was marred by a specific 'party-time' vacation culture and unpleasant resort sales pressure (and then institutionalized contempt from declining all offers, paid upgrades, investments, and excursions).
The sales pressure in fact started even before we left Cancun airport, but then continued at the Marina El Cid check-in desk (to upgrade our room at USD $100/night) as well as with the 'concierge' (to join their loyalty programs, to entertain their time-share investment, to buy various day-trips and excursions). Our luggage was held hostage until we heard their investment pitch, only released to us once we firmly declined all offers.
From that point on for the rest of our vacation, it was obvious to me that we were second-class citizens at Marina El Cid. Dinner reservations between 600pm and 900pm became virtually impossible; Wi-Fi codes now cost USD $60 per device. Room housekeeping was spotty; the front desk would hang up on us mid-sentence.
In the end we made it work, but it was work to make it work.
The restaurants and food were excellent, if slightly inconsistent. Coffee was severely hit and miss; some undrinkable, but the chai lattes at Mercado rivalled anything we've had anywhere else in the world. Room service was 24-hour and one of the few services that our second-class status didn't seem to impact.
The pools themselves were well-maintained, and both infinity pools (a huge draw, for us) were beautiful: we highly recommend the adults-only infinity pool on the Ventus side.
But the combined Marina El Cid - Ventus - Ventus Ha complex is large (by Cuban, Jamaican, and Dominican Republic standards) and large means loud. Perhaps this is Mexican vacation culture, but it was very difficult to find a beach/pool-oriented corner of the complex that wasn't spoiled by throbbing dance music and/or elbow-to-elbow crowds of loud, personal-space-oblivious vacationers. There were three tiny spots for loungers outside of these cones of noise, and of course they were immediately 'held' by selfish resort guests and their synecdoche towels.
Marina El Cid, if you're reading this: you need to revisit your efforts to supress the 'reserve lounger by towel' practice and actually enforce the completely ignored signs you uselessly have up about it. It's infuriating. Dozens and dozens of loungers are held by towels every morning, many of which are not retrieved until 4 - 5 hours later (by my timed observation). I learnt that many Platinum Club members are residents at your resort for 6+ months a year, and that apparently comes with severe entitlement: they believe themselves to be outside your explicit 'guest' policies.
And wow, it was busy in the week leading up to Christmas. There was a marked increase in population density during that time - and many were large parties of multi-generational families. There were lots of loud people everywhere and they brought their obnoxious behaviour with them. Pool etiquette was borderline: I never got actually hit by a nerf football being thrown over all our heads, but it was close. I watched little kids pour full margaritas into the pool without much reproach from parents. Table manners were appalling: people wearing grimy baseball hats even at the nicest, most formal restaurants there; eating with their mouths open, elbows and forearms on the table, poor behaviour by children going unremarked. But is that a problem only at Marina El Cid? Or in all Mexican all-inclusives? Or everywhere now, for that matter? I don't know.
I do know that our dinner at Kobo, the Japanese teppanyaki restaurant was to be our nicest, most formal dinner, and it ended up being the noisiest experience we had there. The table behind us was full of very loud, very drunk guest who were screaming their appreciation for the cooking theatrics. Screaming. Several guests were wearing grimy baseball caps and eating with their forearms on the counter. Ugh. Luckily, the food itself was superb.
At the end, I suggest that in-depth research is critical before you book a holiday: if you're looking for a vibrant, higher-energy, high-population party vacation scene and you have a budget for upgrades, and/or fortitude for time-share sales pitches, then Marina El Cid could be a great choice; if you don't value those characteristics, you may want to keep researching. read more