We rent rooms 21&22 they join together which we love - the doors open between them so we can all…read morehang out together or shut them for privacy..we really like that they are upstairs with a great view of the bay from the deck - we hang out and have cocktails and apps to watch the sunset - which is all you could want after a beach day and the nice hot outdoor shower. They are also decorated so cute and beachy. This place is a little slice of heaven with everything you need, we don't have to lug beach chairs, towels or bicycles on the ferry, they have BBQs if you feel like cooking but so many places near by to just relax with a cocktail and dinner - what a GEM!

Beyond my expectations! Booked a room for me and my daughter for her birthday weekend. It was…read moreperfect, the room was clean bright and beautifully decorated even the ac was on when we got there! The beds were so comfortable my daughter didn't want to leave haha! Everyone was so nice and the staff so helpful. So looking forward to going back very soon! Thank you for a wonderful weekend!!!

Love this place, relaxing, fun, energetic, and accommodating. From what I read, this location…read moreserved was lifeboat station in the early1900s, thereafter Fire Island Hotel and Resort for thirty years. Recently renovated by new owners has transformed into a boutique hotel. The Fire Island Beach House offers beach bungalows, king standard, rooms, two queen standard rooms, duplex beach cabins and beach lounge suites. The landscaping is artificial grass or sand along with picnic tables, and lounges. They also have games for everyone, such as corn hole. What I really enjoyed was the poolside service. The servers are attentive and ready to attend you without leaving the pool area. The bar space has a laid-back beachy appeal with tables on a patio to enjoy drinks and meals. The beach is also enjoyable without the rules that exist at other Fire Island Beaches. The Hotel also provides chairs to bring onto the beach. Overall, we had a wonderful lodging experience, and we surely return next summer with family and friends.

The room was clean and modern. Very overpriced…read more No one checks the room or removes wet towels; you have to get more at the desk. UNHEATED POOL. The main reason I chose it was for the pool. Ice cold, we couldn't jump in. Staff was nice.

Cool for an overnight stay. Included 2 beach chairs and an umbrella. Included plenty of bikes, the…read morechains popped though. I wouldn't plan a romantic getaway here but ok for an overnight stay.

Small hotel with about 8 rooms--great location right next to the ferry (yes, beautiful boat ride to…read moreget there--about 25 minutes) and right in the heart of town near shops, markets, ice cream shops, and restaurants, 2 block walk to beautiful beach. Room closet had free beach chair, umbrella. Staff (owner) very nice and attentive to all my needs. I've been coming for 30 years and plan to keep coming back. Place neat and clean. Yes, 4 shared bathrooms but that means a couple can have 2. Never had to wait. Irving R. June 26, 2025

Listen if you're looking for a 5 star resort then go to another part of the world. This is Fire…read moreIsland and expect anything to happen. For everyone complaining about px it's a 5 month a year business. Our experience was top notch, stayed at the main house employees were excellent, they provided a cart w chairs, umbrellas a lock, towels, bikes, free kayaking, water,ice free breakfast along with other locations you can use. Room was small but it's we just used it to sleep and shower. BTW shower was awsome. Spent time in the main courtyard with our friends, employees were attentive. I can also see an issue staying at the off site locations being loud. Looking forward coming back next year.

Nice staff and great text communication. Alarms went off in hallway outside our room both nights…read more Needs coffee maker in room. The restaurant (CJs) and mini bay club affiliated need serious cleanup. Nice people but room for serious improvement.

We stayed here this past weekend and it was excellent. Great location, right off the ferry. We…read morestayed in a two bedroom apartment. It was very nice and extremely clean. The hotel provides beach chairs, towels and umbrellas. You can also make use of their bicycles, but we enojes walking around town and down to the beach. The hotel has a great restaurant attached, The landing , which has excellent food...and really great drinks. The Hotel also has a wonderful candy and ice cream shop with some of the best ice cream ! We also got to meet the Hotel owner, Harvey, who is most definitely one of the kindest person that I've met. We had some much fun and relaxed... just the perfect weekend escape!

The rooms are extremely small and provide only the bare minimum. While they were clean, the…read moreaccommodations did not justify the price, especially with the added housekeeping gratuity. If an emergency comes up and you need to leave early, don't expect much flexibility. Be sure to read the cancellation policy carefully before booking. I would recommend looking at other accommodations if possible.

This is actually a review for the Blue Waters, same ownership…read more Someone's finally got it right. You want a fast break, you don't want to house hunt, you don't have enough people for a share, you don't want to stay in a horrible depressing flea bag for in-city rates - you just want a room that doesn't scare you for the few hours you are going to actually crash in it before jumping up to greet the dawn by the bay, hop on a loaner bike and take off, or walk till you drop on the beach. Clean, ready, secure, this is all you ask. Here you go. I hope to make it out this summer. Blue Waters saved me from the Fire Island Hotel. Nuff said.

I wish I could give this place negative stars. The people who operate the homes are extremely…read morecondescending, rude, and disrespectful. We are in our late 20s and we were treated like teenage trouble makers. If you want to use this facility, interact with management as little as possible

Interesting architecture in fire island, a 9 room guest house with pool…read more Our garden level room was freezing with no way to turn off the AC. Management is pretty unknowledgeable about running the place, property maintenance was almost nonexistent. Hot water failure for a day with no notice from mgr's. Pool, however, is a bright spot .

We had such an awesome weekend here. The guesthouse is so nice, neat and organized. Thank you to…read moreall the staff for your hospitality. You guys made us feel so welcome. If the management could put Netflix in all of the guest rooms that would be AWESOME!

Best little boutique hotel! The room was nice, the friendly other guest that stay here as well. The…read moreisland is magical and this place will make your experience that much better!! Beach towels, umbrellas, chairs, patio, dishes, stove, fridge... Plus they'll hold your bags on check out for a few hours so you can enjoy the rest of the island and their facilities like the community deck and beach shower. Will be back for a lifetime!

Just got back from a weekend at Dune Point and can't wait to return! We had the studio with private…read moredeck, and although small, it was perfect. The hotel provides chairs and umbrellas for the beach They were very accommodating and friendly making traveling with our pet a breeze. While you're here check out Cherry for lunch and Sandcastle for dinner. If you're coming from Manhattan, select the "getaways" option when you purchase your train tickets. For $32.50 you get R/T LIRR, shuttle and ferry tickets. Couldn't have been easier getting out to Fire Island.. can't wait to return!

My friends were visiting me in Bay Shore and I set up a stay for them here last year and they…read moreabsolutely loved it! Liz the general manager was incredibly kind, attentive, and accommodating. The property itself is gorgeous and super cute (great Gilmore Girls/New England B&B vibes!!). The room was clean. My friends thought everything was super comfortable. Check-in was seamless. Breakfast was super tasty and fresh! Highly recommend!!

The property is professionally maintained and the room accommodations are wonderful; all nicely…read moreappointed. We have had three opportunities to stay at the Bay House and have never been disappointed by the service and hospitality. The morning breakfasts were absolutely scrumptious. They also are eager to accommodate any special food requests. Recently they hosted my sisters 70th Birthday party and it was perfectly managed and they made all her guests feel special. Eddie & Cindy