Elijah is always a wonderful server! Lobster escargot is such a wonderful app I get it every time! This steak house is one of my fav steak houses in Columbus and the outside seating area is really nice in the summer. What I really like and wish I caught more of is the live music they have during the week inside! read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Filet Mignon - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

REVIEW BY: Avila.Eats on TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube Service: staff were friendly and very talkative. A little pushy and dismissive of boundaries. Concerns of food were not taken seriously. Ambiance/Atmosphere: dimly lit, fairly quite setting. A little darker than you'd want. Food: 1. Pretzel bread is soft and has a strong pretzel flavor. Well salted. 6.5 2. Steak tressel was well cooked medium. The garlic added a beautiful back end flavor and the mushrooms were soft and well salted. The crusting on the steak was well done. Steak was tender and well seasoned. 7 3. Gruyere gratin is soft and had a subtle but tasteable seasoning. The cheese sauce was watered and tasted mostly like butter. The flavor was very weak. 3.5. I asked for extra cheese sauce to help and although it brings it up to a 4. It was still quite weak in flavor. 4. HP burger is nicely charred and well seasoned. Tender. The HP sauce is fatty and smooth with a nice flavor. Bun is slightly sweet and airy. 7.25 5. Deconstructed smore is warm, rich, and smooth. All elements blend beautifully into a molten rich brownie lava cake. The marshmallow fluff is smooth and creamy. Graham crackers add a nice crunch. 7.25 6. Banana foster butter cake was warm, soft and buttery. Bananas add a great flavor and the warm butter cake pairs beautifully with the vanilla ice cream. Cold and warm combo is delicious. The alcohol didn't fully burn off and you get a subtle taste with the slight burn. Honestly not mad at it. 6 read more

See all

Great dinner while @ a conference. Set menu for our group but great choices & everything was delicious. Service very friendly. We had shrimp cocktail & other apps to start. I had the salmon dinner which was excellent.i didn't eat my dessert as I was full from dinner but they looked great! Highly recommend! read more

We had a couple of great dinners there a few weeks back. The fresh salmon was really amazing and we got great service at every meal--first in the front and then by the back bar from Bethany. We also enjoyed the Brassfield wine options and look forward to coming back in 2027! read more

If you're looking for top steakhouse in Columbus to try, you definitely need to give Hyde Park a go round! It's a classic steakhouse ambience, with excellent service. You need to order a martini when you come here; they have my favorite espresso martini in the city! Every dish is prepared & cooked to perfection; and are very fitting portions for a proper steakhouse. The red velvet cake truly is colossal & can feed your whole table! It's incredibly decadent & is the best way to end a great experience. The steaks are the star of the show, and taste incredible! They have a beautiful porterhouse, & the steak kosar is my personal favorite! read more

See all

We are trying to be Friday night regulars! Love sitting at the bar. Awesome service from Dave, Blaze and Katie. Amazing French onion soup. And the double chop salad is my new fav. The urban Meyer sirloin is very delicious too. read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Bar area - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I miss Midwest steak and Hyde Park is the best of the best. Amazing filet, wonderful garlic mashed potatoes and perfect wine pairing. Wow. read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Amazing filet, wonderful mashed potatoes and perfect pairing with wine. You will love it. Loved Matt at the bar and wonderful experience. - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

i dined there yesterday the vew awesome and i like the way they but nice cups classic and everything The waitress cool vibes but the reason i do 3 star is reception when i come there there trying kick me out cuz just they here accent from me that's so unwelcomming and embarrassing in the same time is happened yesterday and to night 2 different womens when i come back cuz i like it the Caesar salad read more

Dinner was a disappointment I so told management on a separate review Staff was very accommodating but something was remiss in the kitchen with the steak and scallops I had the same steak a few weeks prior and it was so good that this is why I ordered it again. For over $350 for two people one expects more read more

Friday night date with live music and great food. What else do you need? Service was great, our server was super friendly and checked on us regularly. The live music was a total vibe. The black cherry old fashioned was prob my fave OF version in short north. Do yourself a favor and get the shrimp cocktail! Amazing!!! The steak, potatoes, salad and bread basket were all just as amazing. read more

See all

Noisy!! Gave me a serious headache as it was crazy loud!! Good food if you don't mind the rude loud people!

Been here a few times and the woman bartender, I wish I knew her name because she's always amazing. However tonight, the gentleman helping her ruins the evening by arguing with me about the wine he poured. I wanted a nice quit evening to relax but that was ruined mid dinner. Unbelievably and it will be my last visit there because of this experience. I normally visit 1-3 times per month depending on my business travel. You can have great food but terrible staff can ruin a good thing in an instant. read more

I wish I took more pictures to add to this review! We made a last minute reservation on a Saturday night, but it was no problem for our party of 4. We accidentally headed to the wrong location but they said it was no problem that we were a few mins late! We got a great table on the other side of the bar which had a great view of the band! The band was great and added to the ambience! Our waiter was fantastic! Helpful with wine and dish recommendations! We all loved everything! The basket of bread is interesting with pretzel rolls! I had the Filet Kosar with lobster and it was cooked perfectly! The menu and dinner was pricey, but well worth it for a special night out! read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Flaming Butter Cake - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We were happily surprised tonight with our experience at Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse tonight! KEANU our server was absolutely delightful, I definitely recommend asking for him specifically. The warm buttery pretzel bread was great. And we paired the Tomahawk with the zesty calamari, spinach gratin, and garlic mashed potatoes and it was lights out. The butter cake texture is better than Mastros and even though no heavy cream...I'll take the ice cream and bananas foster fire presentation on top of my butter cake any day. The cook on our med rare tomahawk was just about as perfect as Peter Lugers in Brooklyn (not Vegas.) can't wait to come back! read more

Well unfortunately a slightly below average experience. Ambiance is good. Staff is pleasant. The downfall was I heard this place was the BEST! They feel very short of best in class. They served cold to lil warm sides and when we requested a warm one they still served a cold one. Checks and balances are missing. Too bad with such a friendly accommodating staff this meal fell short. Also they serve warm soda bottles over ice. That immediately flattens the drink. I will say I was hungry and although plain and lacking flavor the steak was tender and ate the entire piece. They charged us for everything and the said they wanted to offer us dessert for the inconveniences however none of us wanted any. You'd think they would've comped something on the bill then but nope. read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Forgot my butter so they brought me a dry steak. Then brought be like warm butter in hindsight. - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I had a very great experience here. It was my first time and I will definitely be back. Ordered the 22oz porterhouse and shared it with my boyfriend. They offered to cut it up for us so it would be easier to eat. Staff was nice and friendly. We asked if they could take our picture and they did it without any complaints. They had live music playing and it tried the atmosphere together. read more

See all

It's been a while since I returned to this Hyde Park location. The ambiance is fabulous as always. The service was good -- efficient and polite. They have an extensive wine list and I really enjoyed the Cabernet Sauvignon I ordered. The wedge salad was quite good -- large enough for two and we shared. I should have asked for the dressing on the side though as it was drenched in the blue cheese. We ordered and shared the 40 day aged ribeye (26 oz) special that we shared among the two of us. The steak was extremely tender and you could taste the funkiness of the aging process (in a good way --- not over the top). However, the steak was also over-salted in a few places, which was disappointing. The side of spinach and mushrooms was pretty good. The chocolate torte was excellent! Very rich so I was glad the server brought a cup of milk out to cut the richness. read more

See all

I don't know how Hyde Park doesn't have 5 star reviews on Yelp but I hope this review helps anyone making a decision on where to go for an upscale experience. I love the high street location because sitting outside is sooo amazing when the weather is nice. Nothing beats the gorgeous classy old school steak house vibe and their servers are so wonderful. Now let's get to the good part, the food. When I tell you this was one of the best steaks I've had in Columbus I mean it. This thing was cooked to perfect and the flavor was unbelievable. Every steak I have had at other places has been terrible in comparison because all I want is Hyde Park's steak. We got calamari for the appetizer and it was gone within minutes it was so good. Their bread is also some of the best bread I've ever eaten (we got extra bread it was so good). You can't go wrong with any of the sides but the mashed potatoes were amazing. If you're looking to splurge on a delicious meal. Please check this spot out! read more

See all

Food was delish but service was 10/10! Seriously, our waiter was amazing, quick, patient and super awesome. We had a table of 11 and anytime we needed anything, he was there. Myself and two friends split the jumbo lump crab cocktail which was delish and plenty despite sharing it. We also split the Ryan Day ribeye , mashed potatoes, and wild mushrooms. We had leftovers. Everything was perfectly prepared. Had a great experience. Highly recommend read more

See all

As many times as I've been to HP, I've actually never tried their happy hour. We finally were able to make it! The short north location has a b pretty big bar which lots of room but it was still filling up quickly. We split the chopped salad (not on HH but my favorite), the carpaccio, and tenderloin sliders. All were great! One star off because receiving two slides for $14 kinda felt wrong. 3 would've made more sense but they were small and a super small chunk of steak so I don't think I'd order them again. The carpaccio was good. I did have to ask our server for both bread multiple times as well as the happy hour menu. He was the only bartender not telling people about happy hour... read more

See all

The food was AMAZING! Our waiter was one of the best we have came across. The two women that checked us in at the front wasn't very friendly or welcoming. We didn't let that ruin our time. Can't wait to visit again and drink more of their amazing wine and food. read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Filet Mignon, 14 oz. New York Strip Steak, Brussel Roasted Brussels Sprouts, Sauteed Spinach & Mushrooms - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We celebrated our daughter's birthday here recently and enjoyed some high quality and delicious food and drinks. From wagyu beef carpaccio, smoked old fashion, to bone in steak, 4 cheese Mac & cheese, and more were all super delicious and cooked to the perfection . Classy interior with a gentle ambiance. But...I wouldn't say, personally, that I had a good time, & here is why: Service wise, Our server did everything he supposed to m. He brought out a complementary birthday dessert for our daughter when it was time, in addition to the banana frost we ordered . but he also has been doing things that were so subtle, he probably didn't even realize it, that made me feel very uncomfortable. 1st, as i was checking out the Rare Spirit drinks menu, he said something like this " these are very expensive drinks, why don't you look at the ones on the other menu" and closed the rare menu then pulled the bigger menu in front of me. 2nd, After he brought my smoked old-fashioned to the table, without saying anything, he walked right off to bring things to another table, then he came back around and said to me "YOU could've taken the drink out by yourself", as a travel food blogger, based on my experience the waiter always take the drink out of the smoke box for the customer, especially for a high-end steakhouse like this. This was a first to me. ‍ 3rd, when he was making the Irish Coffee, he was rushing to put out the fire on the sugar cube by using anything he could find on the table without considering if it was sanitary or not ... seriously, what was the rush. 4th, this waiter never had a smile on his face and has been rushing the whole time he was serving us, despite we were the very first customers for that day, there was no other table when we first arrived. There were no small talks like most the high-end restaurant waiters will do. I certainly understand it's not required, but it is a unwritten etiquette. @WineDinenVacay do recommend this restaurant to all steak lovers & foodies, at the same time....Highly recommend management to conduct staff retraining on appropriate service etiquettes in settings like this. read more

See all

Let me preface this with the following public service announcement: "The reviewer is recovering from acute shock due to the amount of his final bill, and may or may not be homeless by the time you read this review." With that said, let's begin. My wife and I wanted to take advantage of Happy Hour so we sat in the lounge. The bartender, Blaze, said that if we planned on ordering food, we would be much more comfortable at the bar (roomier). He was right. The place felt sophisticated but old, like when you go into any mall these days. It hasn't changed a bit since the 90's. This isn't a bad thing. First we ordered cocktails. I ordered "The Best Espresso Martini You've Ever Had" (that's what they call it" and my wife ordered the Hibiscus Cosmopolitan. Both were very good. Was it the best I've ever had? No. Apparently, they use bottled cold brew which doesn't taste as fresh as espresso or fresh made cold brew. No biggie though. For an appetizer we ordered the Five Cheese Spinach Dip which was mostly spinach and we loved it. As an aside: how come restaurants never include enough chips or in this case crostinis with their dip? Oh well. My wife and I shared the 22oz Porterhouse, Sautéed Asparagus, and the Potatoes Gruyere Gratin. However, my man Blaze failed to mention that the entrée does not include any sides. THEY ARE EXTRA, so FYI. We also both ordered a glass of Merlot to go with our steak. Perfect pairing BTW. Everything was absolutely delightful. The steak was one of the most flavorful, juiciest cuts of meat I've ever had. We truly had a lovely evening. Great food. Great company. Fun bartenders (Shout out to Blaze!) Would I go back? Most definitely. Would I let someone else buy me dinner? Absolutely. read more

I started off with the bacon, was so big and delicious I couldn't finish it. Ended up taking it home and eating it the next morning, just as delicious. I got the steak, medium... was perfect. Little sweeter. Highly recommended, 5 out of 5. read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - The size of their cake is astounding - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We recently went to Hyde Park for Happy Hour. The ambience is classic for an upscale steakhouse. Happy Hour deals are pretty sweet ($8-10 specialty cocktails) as well as discounted appetizer-type food items. Happy Hour runs from 4:30-6:00 Mon-Fri in the bar area only. We arrived right at 4:30 on a Friday and the entire bar was full by about 4:45. The only slight downside is that they don't have any draft beer. They do have a few TV's in the bar area, and the bartenders were happy to put on requests. read more

See all

10/10 experience. My friend and I sat at the bar and ordered two rounds of drinks and entrees. The bar was beautiful and well kept. The bartenders (Dave & Katie) were very personable and sold us on their special for the night, the bourbon butter ribeye, the highlight of the night. It is the best steak I've had the pleasure of eating in quite some time. Crispy crust and perfectly cooked center. We also enjoyed the double chop salad that was fresh, crisp, and served with a creamy buttermilk ranch. We both got the Born A Star martini that came out fast and was a great balance of sour and sweet. Highly recommend! read more

I absolutely love Hyde Park downtown Columbus! It's one of my favorite places to get steak in the area. The service is impeccable- everybody tries to connect with you and it seems as if they really care. This is a great place for a special occasion or just dinner out. No matter your reason for coming, I can assure you that you will be impressed. My go-to meal is the filet mignon (size dependent on my hunger) and a side of mashed potatoes. After, I love to get the chocolate cake. All of the food is very flavorful and dense, so come hungry. As long as your kids behave, it's certainly kid friendly although I've noticed most diners don't bring their children. If you're in the mood for an incredible dining experience, Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse Downtown is for you! read more

Great food and service. Would recommend a reservation but they are able to accommodate small groups at the bar area or a small table with a little wait. Very clean place with a lot of good high end options for both food and drinks read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

A perfect dining experience. Professional staff, delicious steaks & sides, and refreshing cocktails. The wine list is vast, as well. Our go-to is the Arlington location, but we had an event downtown and opted for this location "on the cap," as it is built on an overpass, though you'd never know it. Parking is a challenge, as you can imagine. So, COTA, Uber, cab, or valet if you must. But why drive? Enjoy your cocktails. From the moment you're greeted to the minute you finish your meal (which likely means a dessert or special coffee you didn't realize you desperately needed), you are pampered by attentive, top notch waitstaff. The food is so good, you'll be full and try to figure out how you can consume more. Just remember, they do carry out, too. When a special occasion arises, this is a solid choice. But you can make ordinary days special by winding up here for dinner. Cheers! read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - It's happy hour, every hour. - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Food? What food we never received our drink order! We were seated at the bar tonight, not our first time here, but certainly our last. My co-worker was taking his wife here for dinner this Saturday after the game, but that's not happening. Also, the hostess stand bare acknowledged our presence. I assure you this place needs to check themselves. Windows being dirty are a true sign the business is in decline & doesn't care anymore. We ended up at Mitchell's where we were greeted, seated & served immediately. No wonder Mitchell's rating is higher. Our bartender was a female, who should not be in that job. Hate giving anyplace a bad review, but the public needs to know the facts. read more

I thought I would try something new so I ordered the special for the day. It was 2 meals for $50 take out only. Mike took my order over the phone he was so patient and kind. I ordered the Petite Twin Filet Mignon and Chicken Milanese served with wedge salad. The steak was the best that I have ever eaten at any restaurant. I will try the Chicken tomorrow, I know it will be delicious because it looks incredible. Sometimes we should treat ourselves to Two meals. I also received Two Chocolate Tortes I was in total heaven. I think this will be my favorite steak spot. This location does have valet parking. I am looking forward to my next visit and dining in. read more

See all

Great appetizers, great ambiance, great service!! I was in town for a conference and the Hyde provided a pleasant end to a long day. I asked the bartender to recommend a drink that was fruity and not too strong. She recommended a white peach martini. The martini was amazing! If I'm ever in Columbus again, I'm definitely back to the Hyde. read more

This is a very swanky place to dine and fellowship with friends and coworkers. The ambiance is absolutely wonderful; however, the food was simply okay. It was very pricey and not as great as other steakhouses such as capital grille and Eddie V's. read more

Went for my friend's 30th birthday dinner. Great customer service, Thank you Sydney and Caleb if I remember correctly! Had 2 glasses of a delicious red wine I cannot remember. But it was a middle grade Cabernet at about $18 a glass. Ordered the fried calamari, was not a fan. They tossed it in a sweet chili sauce which made it soggy. For dinner I ordered off the early nights menu. I had twin filets with the steak griffin sauce which came w/mashed potatoes and fried onions. I also ordered a Caesar salad with anchovies. All very good. I tasted my friend's corn and it was delicious. Overall I would return. But I was not overly impressed. I would definitely recommend going during happy hour or on Sundays where the early nights menu is offered all day. read more

See all

Atmosphere was 5 star. (Love the live music) Service was 5 star. Drinks were 5 star. Highly recommend the old fashioned. My filet was amazing. In my personal top 3. Food was 5 star. All in all, great date spot. Highly recommend. I personally left and made another reservation on my way home. I'll be back! read more

Gave this another shot after my last experience. We asked for bread service this time - be sure to ask if you want it as waiters are not supposed to offer it. Server wasbgreat- very personable and attentive. But our medium rare steaks came back medium- we.did not complain or ask them to take them back as we were dining with another couple and they had been served their meals and we didn't want to delay things. In previous visits last year we never had anything but perfectly cooked steaks. For the price we paid, I think I.will try some.other.options.before.going back read more

One of the best steak houses in the city. Their steak was outstanding, fantastic mashed potatoes, and they make great cocktails. The service is top notch. Great steak house atmosphere. Their Carmel cheese cake and crème brûlée are outstanding. read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Crème brûlée - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Hyde Park is a great spot for a special occasion meal. My boyfriend took me for Valentine's Day and we had a wonderful experience. The service was fantastic, the restaurant had a fancy ambiance, and the food was incredible. We split the Ryan Day steak topped with crab béarnaise and garlic whipped potatoes. The steak was cooked perfectly - super tender and juicy. I'm a seafood lover so the crab topping was a great addition. And you can't go wrong with mashed potatoes! It's pricy but worth it for a special occasion! read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Ryan Day topped with crab béarnaise and garlic whipped potatoes - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Food, service and experience was great! Everything was cooked perfectly and had great flavor. The Brussels sprouts were definitely the star of entire meal. Our servers were super attentive and knowledgeable. Definitely will be back! read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Surf and turf, Brussel sprouts, lobster mac and cheeses, Steak Nicklaus - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

1000/10 food. Perfect place for a holiday dinner. Lovely ambiance, fabulous service, even more fabulous food. read more

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - Steak woody - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all