It's been a lifelong dream of mine to eat at the Hyeholde, and it finally came true over Thanksgiving weekend! Many Pittsburgh millennials grew up watching the Miss Jane etiquette video which took place in the Hyeholde... if you know you know! This fancy restaurant is as beautiful on the outside as it is on the inside. Definitely take some time to check out the gardens if you go during the day. The food is stellar. I was blown away by the sweet potato gnocchi and the exceptional bucatini with oxtail. The desserts are also top notch, especially the crème brûlée! This is certainly an expensive establishment, and the quantity of the food does not quite match the price. But the quality certainly does! Every bite is exceptionally crafted. Our server Colleen was extremely kind and attentive. This was a great experience start to finish, and I'm so glad I finally went! read more

See all

We have wanted to dine here for years and we got our chance this week. We had reservations for dinner on Wednesday evening and arrived a bit early. We weren't sure how long it would take to get there coming from Latrobe since we had to deal with rush hour traffic through Pittsburgh. Even though we arrived early, we were immediately seated at our table. And we were greeted by our server right away who gave us a few minutes to review the drink menu before coming back for our orders. Alex was a very attentive and entertaining waiter. Drink specials were interesting but I opted for a Grey Goose dirty martini. I asked for it to be extra dirty and it was! Others chose a Nasferatu and a Redrum. They all enjoyed them. Now the food...everything was top notch. Our table ordered the Delmonico, the Halibut and the evening special of locally foraged chanterelles with house made gnocchis as entrees. We also had the Sherry Bisque and Grilled Peaches as appetizers. As a side I ordered the Truffled Pierogies. Desserts were Crème Brûlée and a Mango Sorbet which was refreshing and light. Because he was so busy our server forgot the Charcuterie plate we ordered as a starter. But honestly, he did us a favor, we were totally sated with the food we had. We didn't need it. We would have like to try the house made meats, but another time! As far as the venue, it is simply one of a kind, beautiful and elegant. It along with the food and the service makes this a dining experience, not just going out to eat. We are so fortunate to have this level of culinary excellence here in western Pennsylvania. On the drive in, I said it was a really long way to go for dinner and it had better be worth it. It did not disappoint! We will be back again for sure. read more

See all

Verdict: Hyeholde is perfect for a special occasion dinner. You'd never suspect it's so close to the airport! We ate there on a Friday evening, when it was not crowded at all. They have tables and chairs tucked into a variety of locations upstairs, downstairs, and even outside. We sat in the 2-story "living room" with a big stone fireplace and a view to the garden out front. The meal began with house-made crackers and warm rolls with salted butter and marmalade, and the lux aeterna cocktail for me (it citrusy champagne drink). It continued with a house salad for him (large) and the beet salad for me (small; I thought the cracker croutons were too salty). He had the beef cheek (robust portion), while I chose the quail appetizer (perfect for a small appetite). We finished with the strawberry mousse and nectarine cakes. It was good but not knock-your-socks-off amazing. Comparing the menu prices (we paid $100 per person with tip) with the picnic basket prices ($95 for 2), you are evidently paying for the presentation and service rather than the food per se. I would certainly be willing to come back to try a picnic, or maybe for a cocktail and dessert, as the rest of the menu wasn't that exciting to me, although I hear the charcuterie boards are a specialty. Honestly, if I hadn't already made reservations for our up-coming birthdays and anniversary (Monterey Bay Fish Grotto, Eddie Merlot's, and Fish Nor Fowl), I would have come back in July for the dinner and magic show package that starts at $65 per person. Parking is by valet, and most of the restaurant (including the restrooms) is not handicapped accessible. We had to go down 2 steps to get our table, and the sex-segregated restrooms are on the second floor. (The ladies' room was amusingly decorated with framed 19th-century Godey's Lady's Book fashion plates against wallpaper with an 18th-century country frolic print...in a "medieval" establishment.) read more

See all

Wow. From the service to the ambiance to the meal itself, everything was perfect. The architecture of the castle itself is beautiful. Between dishes, we were told about the love story behind Hyeholde and its roots. We had an intimate corner spot upstairs which was wonderful. All of the dishes were exceptional (we had charcuterie and the cheese board, the short rib, and the chestnut pasta). Will definitely be our new special occasion spot. read more

See all

We love Hyeholde for the charming ambiance, architecture, attentive staff, and delcicious food from starters through dessert. They offer unusual wild game options that you don't find elsewhere, although I'm not as adventurous so I choose the more mainstream offerings. They have different dining areas on both the first and second floors. If you have mobility issues, I recommend requesting the first floor because the steep, narrow steps to the second floor can be a doozy, although that's typical of old architecture. I give the servers a lot of credit carrying food up and down those stairs! They provide valet parking as soon as you arrive at the front door. For that reason I'm not sure if self parking is even an option? read more

I have heard nothing but amazing things about hyeholde and I now officially know why. This is one of the most amazing & magical places Pittsburgh has to offer. Dinner in a literal castle that has so many rooms and hidden tunnels you just have to see (before or after one of the most delicious dinners you'll have) our waitress was AMAZING and gave us the full tour when we were finished. I will absolutely be back. It is stunning and the food is some of the best I've had in Pittsburgh. This place is full of history and it's just so wonderful! Worth a check out for ANY occasion! read more

See all

The atmosphere and the ambience are so cute and picturesque. Unfortunately the food and drinks fall flat. We saw really cute cocktails on Instagram so we decided to give Hyehold a try. The drinks looked nothing like they did on Instagram, because completely different ingredients were used. Strange. Take down that recent post if you're not going to serve those cocktails, it's misleading. The food was fine, but the portions were TINY and everything was average. I ordered the chicken and it was alright but my vegetables were so hard I could barely cut them with a knife. The crème brûlée was good but the chocolate spoons were way overkill in my opinion. I couldn't taste anything but melted chocolate. I can see how people would like it, but it wasn't for me. Service was outstanding. read more

Hyeholde Restaurant - Chicken dish - New American Near Me - Coraopolis, Pennsylvania

See all

Excellent service and food. Ambiance should be experienced, it's different: an old building nestled in the Moon Twp woods. I love Elk steak and hadn't had it in years, but lo and behold it was on the menu: Very well prepared. And, the wine list is broad, and fairly priced. The breads should be served for dessert with their apple butter spread, excellent. A very nice experience. read more

The food and presentation was amazing. All the food was very fresh and some was even grown on the property. Plan to be here for a few hours as the service is slow and there is an outdoor area on the property that you can explore. They have a beautiful garden and patio area. There is also complementary valet parking when you pull up. read more

This is my favorite restaurant in the neighborhood. The food is amazing, I've loved almost every dish I've had there, and Chef Chris is so creative, it's wonderful that he's back! The servers are some of the best around also. I recommend the Hyeholde to people often, it's perfect if you're looking for a romantic place. read more

I went here for my birthday with a few friends and had such a good time! The atmosphere is so fun from the moment you turn into the driveway. It gives a medieval castle vibe from the outside. Inside is so cozy. The only thing I would say is to make sure you're not in a rush when you come here. It's definitely meant for you to spend time and enjoy your company, which was great for my birthday! The food and cocktails were really good. The portions are small, which is to be expected, but everything was very fresh. The reason for the 4 stars is just because it was pricey for nothing to blow me away. read more

Food - Excellent Ambiance - Pleasant Service - Proper - mostly Pretentious - overwhelming so Attentive - very Friendly - not read more

A special place for a special night out, service can't be beat. I also love their themed evenings for Halloween, Honey Harvest, and Dickens to name a few. read more

This review took me a little to write, because i think im still honestly just confused. we came here for dinner during their 'picnics in the garden' experience where we had a nice table set up in the garden for us to have a gourmet picnic. my husband surprised me for my birthday. we were seating at our private table by the hostess, and brought our preselected picnic menu a few minutes later. the food was delicious. we had a lovely time. but no one came to check on us. NOT. ONCE. we ran out of water, were planning to order another drink and no one stopped by. since it was dinner time, the sun was starting to go down and we started to get bit by mosquitoes- still no one stopped by. i was dumbfounded. did they forget about us? we waited for our server to come back and bring our check, but they never did. we sat there until after the restaurant closed honestly thinking we got forgotten about. so we had to use our cellphone lights to walk back up to the reception space and find someone. they said 'that is the experience'. never in my life have i spent $300+ on a meal and never been checked in on once the food arrived. so we paid in the lobby space, standing there by the exit door. not only that, but on the receipt was the expectation to provide a tip - which we did, but given the fact we weren't checked on or given any service was just weird. i enjoyed the food, but the overall experience was negative. i was covered in bug bites for a week. maybe you get better service if you sit inside, idk. read more

See all

Pulling up to this beautiful restaurant you feel like you r back in time .. the ambiance is old snd rustic inside this grand castle. The food was nothing short of delicious. It was my birthday and it delivered everything we expected. Our server was very good and spaced the food out perfectly. The taste and presentation was gorgeous. Can't wait to go back to eat outside in the fairytale garden we hear is truly majestic! My husband had the elk tenderloin and myself the braised beef ! The apple butter was top notch ! They serve with the rolls . Very special place ! The valet gentlemen were very talkative and welcoming also ...very nice staff. read more

See all

Disappointed. Great server, nice atmosphere. Some meals excellent, tho Elk tough. Worst was a member of the party got food poisoning from a chicken dish (quite certain of it) Got a lukewarm "sorry" and we'll check and be more careful (on second call) Not what I would expect read more

Our experience at this restaurant honestly could not have been any better. My older sister and her now fiancé had their surprise engagement party here. We booked the private room in the front of the restaurant which comfortably held 10 people. The staff was also very accommodating and willing to do whatever to make this night perfect, which it was. Food and drink: We started with two charcuterie boards which were fantastic. There were many different meats, cheeses, and bread options that all paired together perfectly. Our cocktails were so yummy. We tried a handful of different ones, and they all were phenomenal. My personal favorite was the pomegranate one. Each of our main courses were cooked wonderfully and tasted amazing. You can not go wrong with anything on their menu. The meat dishes were tender, while the fish dishes were light and flaky. Each was also full of flavor. I personally did not order any soup, salads, or shareable sides, but the other people in our party said they were fantastic, specially the Mushroom Fricassee. We ordered coffee once our empty plates were taken away and everyone loved it. The coffee was extremely rich and the perfect drinking temperature. Service: Alex, our personal waiter for the night was extremely polite. His service was truly unmatched. I have been to my share of fancy restaurants in and around Pittsburgh, and the way he treated us was better than any service I have had elsewhere. Every time we left the table for any reason, he would fold our napkin again by the time we got back. He asked to take our plates and cups when they were empty before grabbing them, and kept our beverages full throughout the whole night. I VERY strongly suggest requesting him to be your waiter if you try out this restaurant. Ambiance: As I said above, we booked the small room in the front of the restaurant. It very comfortably fit 10 adults. The room was super cozy with the fireplace, wood finishes and exposed brick. I would recommend this room to anyone looking to have an intimate celebration with top notch service. Overall, I will be returning to this restaurant in the very near future. From the service to the food to the ambiance, there was not one thing that could have made this experience better. read more

See all

If you want unique and locally sourced food then this is the place for you. Did I forget to mention, that this place is set/decorated as a medieval and exquisite atmosphere making it romantic and intimate. Now then menu is not for the faint of heart and if you are a picky eater, then this place may not be for you. The chef is takes passion in the food they cook and it shows by recommended cook temperatures, food pairings, and portion size. My wife got the Delmonico steak with mushrooms and potatoes and wow it was amazing! The sauce (some sort of Demi glaze) and the potatoes were amazing! I got the lamb rack medium done and dang was it the best lamb I had in a long time - the portions were generous but just enough. Highly recommend! The macrons at the end were delightful. Pricey but we will probably be back! The staff was top notch and did not try to sell you on anything - their recommendations were stop on! read more

Hyeholde Restaurant - Our wine selection with some decor and seating arrangements in the background. - New American Near Me - Coraopolis, Pennsylvania

Our family thought we had reservations for my son's birthday 2/28 but when we arrived, there was no record of the reservation. Thank you to the staff who were wonderful and were able to seat us ! The food and service was excellent as always ! read more

If you're used to dining at a family-oriented chain restaurant, this isn't for you. I attended a wedding reception and everything was off the charts. Service outstanding! Food delectable! Ambiance unmatched! It's expensive, but a special place for treating yourself, like a birthday, anniversary, etc. I would be go back to treat myself, maybe on my birthday. The architecture has a European feel. read more

Another visit and another 5 stars. I love this place so much. Went for NYE and it was spectacular. Was greeted with complimentary champagne and the menu didn't disappoint for this occasion. My go to beverage is the pomegranate martini. Also, fair to say that I'd go simply for their homemade crackers that they serve. Lol. Quality at every level even with the coffee as they serve local Nicholas Coffee. Highly recommend for all occasions. read more

See all

Food outrageously good, creative, fresh! Service top notch. Ambiance quiet, private, romantic!

We had our first experience here the week of Valentine's Day . Sorry for the delay but a review is better than no review. I say ' Experience ' because that is truly what we received from the time we arrived to the time we left. The evening started with professional valet parking service and a whimsical entrance into the front door . We were greeted by coat service and kindly received to our table . Our server was knowledgeable about the menu items, attentive, and personal. We were made to feel like their special guest and that made for a special night. The cocktails were made well and reasonably priced for the setting. The food was well prepared and presented. We ordered appetizers, entrees, and dessert and left satisfied. We dined upstairs in a room with slanted ceilings and two windows that allowed view of the snow falling slowly outside . The vibe was calm , casual elegance, and no rush. The appetizers and desserts were by far the most memorable and unique. We would definitely come back again for another special evening. read more

See all

Very, VERY nice place tucked away in Moon. The food is amazing - the new chef really delivers. It's a bit pricier than most people have to spend, but for an anniversary or other special celebration, it's perfect. Four stars only because it prices out most people and food just as good is cheaper downtown. Get their maple old fashioned. That was a highlight of my last visit, along with the lamb. read more

Amazing food, great service and beautiful atmosphere. A must for a date or anything you want to celebrate.

What an amazing dining experience! Outstanding staff and service -- especially from our server, Aleanet. She's so professional, attentive, and polished. The cuisine is incredibly delicious. Their Hyeholde cocktails and the wine selections are also excellent. Every offering was the best -- and so creative and tasteful. The Hyeholde building itself is remarkable and beautiful -- and the multiple, small dining "chambers" allow for a quieter, intimate dining experience! I need to return often! Many, many thanks! From the early 10/31 birthday guest! read more

We were in the area on business and stumbled across this lovely abs historic restaurant. We were seated at a very nice table overlooking the gardens. So pretty! Our server was extremely attentive. We started with an old fashioned cocktail and a pomegranate martini which were both good. We also shared the beet salad, the wild mushroom appetizer, and the halibut. The mushroom appetizer had a gorgeous presentation. The halibut was tasty and mild but it was cold. We asked for it to be more heated through but it was still pretty chilly on the inside. For dessert we had the blueberry pavlova with house made blueberry ice cream. It was good too but a little sticky - we would have just went with the ice cream. Overall, though, a beautiful experience certainly worthy of a special celebration or date night. read more

See all

Great experience in a unique setting with fantastic food. Read the book the building of the Hyholde and then visited for 25 year wedding anniversary. Such a cool place. Great service and the elk met all my expectations. Great history and great food what could be better. read more

Found was not great. Waitresses or waiters are so quiet no smiles. It's a strange place for the expense.

Hyeholde has been on my list for awhile and we finally had a chance to try it. Simply put, it did not disappoint. The historic nature of the building and grounds provided the perfect setting for an incredible meal. The service was on par with the best fine-dining restaurants but in no way stuffy or off putting. If you're looking for a place to celebrate a special occasion or just want to have a a great dinner, look no further than Hyeholde! read more

See all

Such a beautiful property to enjoy a dinner out. We were seated in the patio room with views of the courtyard. Our server was friendly and knowledgeable about the menu options for the evening. We started with the mushroom bruschetta which was the perfect combo of savory and salty. For main courses, I had the gemelli pasta (yes more mushrooms) and hubs chose the braised shank with truffle pierogi and sauteed cabbage. Both dishes were just delicious. The hardest part of the evening was choosing which entree since there were so many that just sounded divine. For dessert, we got the affogato (praline ice cream topped with espresso) and the chocolate peanut butter mousse. The only 4 star part of the show would be awarded to the cocktails. They were ok (but not showstoppers as I would I expected for the ambiance). The staff allowed and encouraged us to explore the property and take in all that was available. We were blown away by the history and beauty that has been maintained. We will definitely be returning for another night out. read more

Food, service and atmosphere were all outstanding!!! We will be back for certain in the near future!!!

I love this restaurant. It's cozy, romantic, unique and the food is seasonal and fantastic.

Truffle pasta was insanely good and the prime beef absolutely delicious!! Natasha was a great server who anticipated our needs throughout the night. read more

I've been to a lot of really great restaurants, so when I tell you that this peculiar little place tucked away in Moon Township is phenomenal...trust me. We went on an uncharacteristically cool June evening and sat outside on the patio, which was a truly lovely spot. There's a big stone fireplace which the server kept going by adding an occasional log, and the entire area is surrounded by greenery and lovely landscaping. The inside of the restaurant is labyrinthian and full of interesting architectural quirks, antiques, and charm. The service was great. Our server, Brett, was extremely knowledgeable about the food, attentive without being overbearing, and generally just a pleasure to interact with. The food was really top-notch, and the portions were generous--we barely had room for dessert, but we powered through because they've just hired a new pastry chef and the server told us he's incredible and pointed out the specialties on the dessert menu. We took his advice on ordering and I'm so glad we did! Appetizers: foie gras (excellent), beef tartare (surprising flavor profiles, totally delicious), charcuterie board (this is a must, their house-made lardo spread is amazing, and everything else on the board was delicious too) Entrees: beef short rib (tender and delicious) and lamb pappardelle (delicious, huge portion) Desserts: roasted strawberry pavlova (exquisite) and honey cake (perfection) Cocktails: I forget the names, but one was a smoked whiskey something-or-other and delicious, another was bourbon with citrusy elements and also delicious, and my dining parter had a sweet, rum-based cocktail that he enjoyed. Overall they were well-balanced and generously portioned! read more

See all

Food, service, and atmosphere were great! Nothing bad to say, amazing experience and beautiful place.

Our second restaurant meal in over a year was in the same place as the first, Hyeholde. The celebration of our 48th anniversary was perfect. We sat outside in the garden on a warm spring evening. The service and food were perfect. We shared the green salad and had the chicken and halibut entrees and shared the rhubarb desert. Everything was excellent. We're glad that Hyeholde has survived the difficult conditions of the past year. read more

See all

One of my absolute favorite places for date night. Super cute old world ambience and always a great meal.

Hyeholde Restaurant offers a great ambiance, many delicious foods and friendly staff #yum

We checked out Hyeholde as part of our special event host research. We were thinking we should probably try the food if we were considering having our event there so we made a reservation for dinner to follow our meeting with their events planning manager. The Round Room space is a separate facility with floor to ceiling windows, a separate bar and restrooms, room for 100 at round tables, and a green lawn area for seating or cocktail hour just outside. It's really perfect for a wedding! The restaurant itself looks like an old European house with thick wooden timbers that were harvested from an old barn when the original owners built the place themselves. They were a husband and wife that married in the early 1900's and the wife always wanted to live in a castle on a hill -she just didn't know she was going to help build it brick by brick! They raised their family upstairs and opened a restaurant downstairs. The restaurant is still owned and run by one of the daughters who is now 82. The Round Room was built later and operated as a Cabaret for some time. Adriana, our server, was excellent! Bonnie, in their events planning area, was terrific too. Even the valet parking guys were nice. The grounds are green and inviting and the restaurant itself is warm and rich with history. There are some really neat New York Times cartoon paintings in the den/library room and a lovely outdoor patio with a stone fireplace. Our dinners were really delicious! I had the filet and my partner had the scallops. They were both cooked perfectly. I tried their sherry bisque which was just okay, to be honest, as it's lacking a protein in my opinion. They need a lump of crab or something in it to really make it shine but the flavor was good and it was served nice and hot. My partner tried the citrus cured wild salmon appetizer which was very good although the salmon could have really shone if it was a little thicker cut so it didn't disappear as much under the crème fraiche. It had a nice flavor profile. The filet came with a Boursin potato stack that was outstanding and some very fresh tender haricots verts. The scallops were served over a bed of saffron couscous that included a few delicate mussels and some pieces of chorizo and a delicious side of braised fennel. We were so stuffed, we passed on dessert but had a really good port to cap off a truly memorable meal. Adriana gave us a tour of the entire house when she found out we were considering the Round Room for our event. She was very gracious and informative. That's how we learned all about the husband and wife team and the history of the Hyeholde. They do romantic picnics on their grounds in the summer which sounds so perfect for a special anniversary! We definitely want to try that too. read more

See all