Cancel

Open app

Search

I Scream Gelato

2.0 (2 reviews)

I Scream Gelato Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - I Scream Gelato

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - I Scream Gelato

You might also consider

Hope's Cheesecake

Hope's Cheesecake

4.6
(172 reviews)
1.8 mi
•$$

This was my last stop on my way out of town after a short but fun few days at the gulf. I knew I…read morehad to try this spot after I saw it ranked as the best cheesecake in Alabama. I popped in fairly early on a Saturday, early enough that I was the only customer. This place is covered practically floor to ceiling with every variety of cheesecake imaginable, in individual portions to giant shareable cakes. There are a few other treats available too, like cookies. After browsing the flavors, I decided on a small sized turtle cheesecake. I think it was maybe labeled as individual but I comfortably shared it for a smallish dessert with my parents. My one disappointment was that all the smaller cheesecakes I could see were in circular servings (like a large hockey puck) instead of slices. I don't know if I'm just bad at looking for things or if they don't sell slices anymore, but I made out okay with my dessert. Service was very friendly and welcoming and got me rung up quickly. I took a quick bite while it was still cold and then saved the rest for about 1.5 drive up to our lunch spot on our way home. It held up pretty well in the air conditioned car. The bites were delicious both times. It's a pleasantly thick and creamy cheesecake. I enjoyed the chocolate cookie crust though I wish there'd been slightly more of it. The turtle toppings on top really added extra tasty flavor, though I only found chocolate and caramel -- no nuts despite it being a turtle cheesecake. That was kind of a bummer, but I still really liked my dessert. I'd happily get this same cheesecake again. Definitely worthy of a try if you find yourself in the area!

Well, they are back to selling the infamous Key Lime Hope Bars, but they are totally lacking in…read morequality! They used to taste like they were made fresh daily. Now, they taste frost bit from being in the freezer so long. I would have thrown it away, but I forced myself to eat it at the price I paid. And speaking of, way too high! I will not be going back! Last try! And, what a shame when I'm in Gulf Shores so often. It's a bummer, it's not like it was years ago! I used to recommend to everyone, but I won't be doing that anymore. Not gonna refer someone to spend that kind of money and be disappointed too.

Photos
Blueberry Cheesecake in Box
Blueberry Cheesecake in Box
Blueberry Cheesecake
Blueberry Cheesecake
Chocolate Cheesecake

See all

Chocolate Cheesecake
Jesse's On the Bay

Jesse's On the Bay

4.5
(502 reviews)
8.9 mi

Super great restaurant for those on vacation at Gulf Shores! Daisy was super sweet and attentive ,…read morethe restaurant was scenic and clean, and everything tasted amazing!

My husband and I had gone over to Fort Morgan pier, fishing from 9:30-11. We were hungry…read moreafterwards, and I had heard great things about Jesse's by the Bay. I was aware we needed to get dressed up to have dinner there, because it's white tablecloth at night. But, I hoped we would be welcomed with our casual attire for lunch. Sure enough, we were kindly greeted at the entrance and seated right away. We had the nicest waiter, Alex. He said he'd worked there awhile and seemed to love his job. He did great describing the entrees and answering all questions. He sold me on the food, by the way he took pride in their preparation and presentation. We had the following for lunch: Apps- Oyster Jesse Crab & Tasso Gratin Entree- Fish sandwich (Redfish was served today) @ MP ($25), and we chose house made fries as the side. One of the best lunches ever,'in this area. Can't wait to go back for dinner! It will definitely be one our go-to places. Anxious to try everything on the menu. I highly recommend it to anyone, who doesn't mind paying the price for good, quality food. To add, the view is lovely! All the windows in the restaurant face the bay. You can eat outside, if you want a completely clear view.

Photos
Beautiful dining room
Beautiful dining room
Crab Dip
Crab Dip
Sazarac

See all

Sazarac

I Scream Gelato - gelato - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...