Soooo I really wanted to like this pizza, I did, but it was awful. I read that they changed…read moreownership, and man I really wish I had the chance to try them before they did. Older reviews and pictures looked bomb so I decided to give it a shot. Friday night we ordered 2 cheese pizzas and a chicken parm sandwich. Today is Tuesday and I've been trying to force my kids and the neighbor kids to eat it there's still a whole pie in the fridge that's about to go in the trash. Like imagine how bad pizza has to be that I can't get 8-11yr olds to eat it. I did try one slice I don't know how to describe it, kind of like frozen pizza but worse bc you've obviously paid a lot more for it than you would have a frozen pizza. Let's not even talk about the chicken parm sandwich that I tried to "fix", and I still couldn't save the rubbery chicken they put in there. That all wound up in the trash as well. I hate throwing food away, honestly I hate it, but I couldn't stomach anything we got from them.

UPDATE - I was given a refund…read more Ordered delivery and it was an hour late and ice cold. After we heated it back up it was mediocre at best.

I was very impressed by their pizza, I went in with lower expectations and was surprisingly pleased…read morewill definitely be a return customer

Waited too long to try this local Gahanna pizza shop! Tasty pies (always) & the staff is a really…read moregreat group of people that are friendly & provide awesome service. Cant wait for another pizza night soon

Out of town and hungry, Yelp's suggestion did not disappoint! We stopped in early around 4:30 after…read moreskipping lunch. While we waited for our pizza, we were delightfully surprised with how flavorful the bread sticks and marinara sauce were! Soon the pizza arrived with a classic NYC style crust, thin but with both a crunch and chew! Still looking at the menu, we were enticed by the dessert calzones: a "Buckeye or Flutternutter." We opted for the latter and it was deliciously decadent! What a great find and treat we had visiting Columbus!

Friendly staff. Extra thin style crust…read more Delicious plum tomatoes sauce. Carry out works best.

All I can say is wow wow wow! Out with friends for karaoke…read morewent to a bar that didn't serve food however Angie's is next door I asked them if it was possible for me to order the pizza and take it over to the lounge and when they said yes it was on!!! I ordered a medium pizza it was hot ready and crunchy and there's a window to the opposite side of the lounge where you pick up your order and have a seat and eat. 10 out of 10 will come back again and just found out that there's a Whitehall location that I can try near where I live. The best part about the pizza in my opinion was the right amount of sauce. Red sauce can be overpowering and on this pizza it was not. The pepperonis were nice and oily in the middle like little oil puddles of goodness and the crunch on the crust . The medium size was just right for two people who were very hungry and singing karaoke. Thanks Ange's! Elite ya later

Lady working was sweet and the pizza done on time, but I just could not eat it! Small pepperoni…read morebaked to perfection, but that cheese they use is stinky and tastes horrible!! Very noticeable, pungent aftertaste. Threw the entire thing out after dissecting it layer by layer to see where the horrible taste was coming from. The cheese. Sadly will not ever order it again.

Stopped by one late morning and was very impressed the food and service. The Chicken Tikki Pizza…read morewas phenomenal and not too spicy. The thin crust supreme was also very good.

Ever since I first tried this place, I've been nothing but satisfied. Everything is prepared in a…read moretimely manner, the service is good and the food is delicious and filling. I've had the "build your own" calzone, lasagna, wings, pizza and fettucine alfredo (added chicken) and salad. Never had an issue and always met with a smile. I usually order online, being a member and I enjoy how easy it is to accumulate points towards discounted purchases. You all definitely have to try this place out.

When I moved from Philadelphia, Pizzeria NY was like a taste of home. Authentic NY-style…read morethin-crust pizza. Pepperoni Pinwheels are a meal in themselves. True story - my step-daughter and her husband visited NYC. They tracked down the place that was supposed to have the best slice in New York. "It tasted just like Pizzeria NY," they said.

White pie is incredible! Unfortunately no gluten free options. Staff is great, quick turnaround.read more

Love the pizza! We order extra cheese. We started with a side salad. The service was great as…read moreMary was busy working the entire room. There are TVs available to watch. The restaurant is quiet enough for a conversation. This is a neighborhood restaurant and the family works there. We will be back!

The works pizza was plentiful loaded. Good sauce with a decent crust. I'll have to try something…read morewith less toppings by the time this arrived to my door the pizza was pretty soggy most likely from the super fresh toppings. Regardless majority of the pizza was eaten! It's a pretty cool spot right next door to a drive thru and a bar.

Gahanna Pizza Plus is amazing. They are consistently great. They have amazing subs as well…read more. A guy who worked there for years bought the place which I think is really cool. Plus he still delivers pizza, I love his work ethic & how he isn't afraid to do whatever is needed... You won't be disappointed

Been meaning to come here for ages, but we always forget about it till we've already gotten supper…read more Today, storm coming, Sweetie wanted pizza, and this is one of the closest local joints. Called and ordered easily (aside from kitchen noise.) 25 minutes, not bad at 630 on a Friday. They were jumping when I got there. Super friendly and professional. Got our food, headed home, car smelled great. Pizzas looked great. And tasted pretty darn good. K got cheese, said the sauce was "too spicy." I didn't think so at all. Sweetie got pepperoni and liked it. I got pepp and sausage, and a 6" sub. The pizza was pretty good: medium-thick crust, perfectly cooked, good sauce, good cheese, plenty of good toppings. Some complain about the sausage "bits" but I liked them. The sub is small, but I did that on purpose since I was getting pizza too. If you want just a sub, get the 9" at least. Perfect Italian sub: good bread, good meat and veggies, held together well. Gone in a flash. Standard menu: pizza, subs, salads. But a few interesting specialty ones, like Lorraine, Florentine, Greek. Price was reasonable for as much food as we got, and the quality. I'd go back.