This place is awful. My pizza was not even cooked. In the service was also very very rude. People hurt my feelings.

Such a good establishment! Yummy authentic NY style pizza, I love it reminds me of home . All the employees are super nice ! Continue the great work read more

So glad we live a couple mins away. We're new to Ohio and we're from Queens, NY. The pizza's pretty close to the real deal. Problem is it's not consistent from visit to visit. And don't understand how 16" pies are considered extra large in this state. That's a small in NY. Regular pies are 18". Looks like slices were sold many years ago. Should bring that back and open for lunch! I don't mean a few slices under a heat lamp, actual pies of different kinds ready to sell by the slice. With all the local businesses and homes, fast, cheap, lunch should kill in Pickerington! read more

The big mistake I made all those years ago was driving past this place, assuming it wasn't designed for the normal family. That, mainly because the bar next door was always flooded with the rowdy crowd that bled over into the front of this spot. End result? I missed years and years of enjoying some REALLY good New York style pizza. Keep in mind that I'm a Chicago Deep Dish style pizza, so if you're going to give me a different kind, you betta bring it! And I don't just mean the actual pie. My wife and I walked in and were prompted greeted by Ryan, the owner's son. He was a kind gentleman, eager to introduce us to his family's creation, sharing a bit about his family history and the development of their restaurant. We decided to eat in and order the house specialty: Paps Special. This consisted of sausage, pepperni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers and banana peppers. We hate mushrooms, so for a small amount, we subbed out the mushrooms for Old World Pepperoni. Wise decision. Mannnn, this pizza was delicious! Vegetables cut fresh, meat well-seasoned, pie cooked the perfect amount of time, crust with the right, buttery texture. It didn't take long to create it and I swear it took less time for the two of us to EAT it. We enjoyed it so much that days later, I was back to pick up two more for my family at home! ...and yes, they loved it. My only disappointment was that my sons didn't want to ride down and eat it there (lazy buzzards). Nothing like pizza hot out of hell's fire... Check this place out and as always, be sure to tell 'em Kenny sent ya! read more

Pizzeria New York - Had to come back for two more! - Pizza Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Outstanding pizza. I always judge a pizza place by the quality of their cheese pizza their cheese pizza was amazing. Really good work.

Good option if you want to mix up pizza night! If you like NY style pizza, this is a decent option to get your fix. It definitely can't compete with the real deal but is close enough. Ordered a large cheese and large pepperoni for takeout and the family loved it. read more

See all

Closest you'll get to NY pizza in cbus. Not you cheap value pizza night but the quality is good.

Best NY Pizza available love it to death Steeler fans as well!! But that's it read more

Worst service experience I have ever experienced. A bunch of kids ruining a business with terrible customer service and service skills. Food was good but the service sucked ass. I hope the owner of this business actually reads this review, you have lost customers today that was their first time and last. Food was good but not good enough, there are too many choices to come to a place like this and be treated this way. read more

Pizzeria New York is not bad. It's exactly like it's authentic. This is still a pretty good try for Ohio. It sells pizza by the slice, weekdays at least. They also have sandwiches and subs. It didn't have any pizza by the slice on a weekend. It could have been out. They weren't that busy the last time. It's more of a carryout. They do have lots of seating. It looks kind of sparse inside. There's not much interesting going on. It has chairs and tables of course. There's a couple TVs on the walls. Besides that there isn't much of an atmosphere. This is reflected in how quiet the inside is. I had the vegetable sub. It's about $7 for the footlong. This is good even though it's not an excellent sub. I got it without cheese. Pizza sauce is good to add on this I could eat something from here again. Maybe not pay for it. They are kind of expensive for the amount the give you. read more

Pizzeria New York - Vegetable Sub - Pizza Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Pepperoni Pizza On a scale of 1 to 10 I'd give this a 5. Don't expect it to taste like New York Pizza. New York Pizza read more

This small business doesn't care about customers. They use cheap ingredients, and cut corners wherever possible. Their pizza is barely edible, and the owner expects to sit on her heiny all day long while her underpaid underlings are expected to do all the work. I would never recommend this business to my worst enemy. I honestly don't know how this business is still chugging along. Please take my advice and stay clear of this business! read more

authentic NYC pizza this place is delicious. i used to live in nyc and this pizza is the real deal. notches above chain pizza i highly recommend read more

Great Pizza. Not like the usual thin crust Columbus-style. Friendly and fast service.

We found pizza that replicates a true NY pizza! Having just recently moved to the area, I was not liking the standard pizza throughout the Columbus area. Who cuts a pizza in squares? Columbus area pizza joints. Pizzeria New York was not cheap on the ham, pineapple and bacon toppings. A large pizza was actually a large! I'll be back read more

Pizza was DELICIOUS! Everyone we encountered were super friendly! Definitely will make the hour trip back to try it again!

DISCLAIMER: I'm a born and raised New Yorker. So when I see someone say "Pizzeria New York".... expectations jump! I know the people are from Queens, which is cool. But honestly, if they tried to serve this pizza, this food, in Queens, they'd be out of business within months. The dough is ok, but it isn't NY. Nor is the sauce. Pizza is actually pretty good based on Ohio pizza standards, but not NY. I ordered the garlic knots. They weren't good by ANY standard. The garlic flavor was almost nil, and two of the five weren't cooked all the way, and there was raw dough in the middle. Lastly, we had a pepperoni calzone. THERE WAS NO RICOTTA in the calzone. NONE!! In NY.... that never happens. Ricotta is a CORE INGREDIENT in the calzone, so how there was NONE is beyond me. There was also more pepperoni in it that on the pizza. Layers and layers of pepperoni, with a bit of mozzarella.... that ain't a calzone where I come from! Side notes: the sauce tasted like it came from the can, and was a bit bitter for me. I like a sweeter sauce. Could be the tomato they used, not sure. Also, the pepperoni was a bit too spicy. I was hoping for a bit more, as they're from NY. I hope they do well, again it's a better pizza than a majority of pizza you'll get in the area, but it's still a far cry from NY. read more

I'm updating my review. We gave them another shot. They have a decent pizza. But they still get one star. I ordered a Paps special with no peppers - no banana peppers and no green pepper. We had delivery- by the way the delivery guy was great. The Pizza was covered in banana peppers. Its official, we like to support local. Will give multiple chances. But we are done, there are way too many pizza places in the area to try this one again. read more

Horrible... this is my 4th time giving them a chance... it gets worse each time... and it has nothing to do with the Pandemic. The cheesy garlic bread is good... and that's not a compliment... it's garlic bread. Just get rid of New York in the title. I don't even want to eat the crust only like I do at most places when I don't like the pizza... I just don't have anything good to say about this place. read more

Pizzeria New York - Cheesy Garlic Bread - Pizza Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Pizza is amazing! We get pizza from this place almost once a week at this point, and they don't even deliver to our address!

We split a sub and order of pepperoni rolls. We really wanted to like this place. Order issues online. It doubles the charge of what your getting. So I called. The lady was super! However I specifically asked if the rolls comes with sauce and was told yes. We didn't get any sauce. When picking up the order had we not already placed an order we may have not stayed if dining in. Left a lot to be desired all the way around. read more

Pizzeria New York - Italian sub and pepperoni rolls. - Pizza Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

It was our first time trying this place. We ordered a supreme pizza and loaded fries. I really wish we spent our $54 elsewhere honestly. The pizza looked amazing but it was such a disappointment. It was extremely bland, no flavor with any ingredient on that thing. I tried to give it a little boost with the garlic butter but even that was flavorless. The loaded fries were super hot, yayyy!! But when it's topped with a cheese sauce and very little bacon, that's a cheap loaded fry to me. I would've loved to see actual shredded cheddar cheese melted on it with a good amount of bacon pieces, but sadly that wasn't the case It looked like I'm going to be sticking with Grapevine pizza from now on because it's not worth going elsewhere anymore. read more

This is a tiny pizzeria. There pizza is definitely new york style. The atmosphere is pretty chill and laid back. If you order delivery expect a slight delay. I nornally do a large pie. I always request extra sauce. If your not big on a saucy pizza normal is fine. But from this shop I require heavy sauce. The pizza is tasty. Ny friend loves ther pizzoans. There garlic and cheesey bread is tasty. Ive also done there spaghetti and meatball just kinda average. Its a spot that I tend to repeat often. If you are looking just for one slice that is delicious as well. You wilk get what you pay for. Prices are on the higher side. read more

It has "New York" in the name, so of course I rolled down to Picktown for pizza night. Pizzeria New York sits in a strip mall. Inside is a large dining area with plenty of tables (sadly, they were all empty, with one exception, on this Tuesday night). Most of the Yelp gripes about this place seem to focus on service. For me, the pizza rolled out at the promised time and it was served with a smile. PNY lives up to its name with a very solid New York style pie. The crust is thin, slightly crispy and foldable. There are no giant air pockets under the rim, but you do get some nice doughy chewiness around the edge. The sauce is nice and tart with just the right amount applied. PNY uses fresh mushrooms (thank heavens!!!). The peps were good, but nothing remarkable. Of course I also had to order the pepperoni rolls. While the menu said it was an order of 6, I only got 5. That said, they're pretty large and an excellent value ($3.99 for the box), so no gripes. These rolls consist of pizza dough around cheese and pep, all rolled up the way you would roll them croissants out of the can that I so love to use for "croissant dogs" at home. You also get the yummy side-car of marinara for dipping. PNY was definitely worth the trip. If I lived closer to Picktown, I'd definitely be in here more often. Like the sign outside this place says, "There's a big difference between the big chains and the Independent Pizzerias. Come on in and we'll prove it to you!" Indeed, they did. read more

See all

The closest to New York Pizza as we've found in central Ohio Definitely a hidden gem Fantastic, fresh pizza. Just went for a basic pep and onion. It was so good we ordered two to go Friendly staff with quick service We'll definitely be back! read more

Excellent pizza plenty of toppings great taste and excellent service. The food was prepared fast and correct. I will definitely come back here again read more

The only "real" pizza in the area. As an east coaster this pizza speaks to me in ways the weird square cut Ohio pizza cannot. The crust is the right thickness to bend and always cooked just right. It's like a little slice of home right here in Pickerington. read more

Pizza is amazing and it's got the NY feeling and taste! Love it, when it is correct. It's run by a bunch of teenagers. They don't care! Order has been messed up numerous times and when ask to speak to manager/owner you get nothing. Ordered here about 2 weeks ago and was told 35 mins, I get there and it's just going in the oven so had to wait another 20 mins. Tonight, trying to give a local restaurant the business once more but then again, all the kids are not paying attention. My order was not even started yet and I called it in 45 mins prior. Start listening or paying attention to your customer base,they're the reason your open. read more

Our favorite beloved pizza of 18 years has suddenly changed its style of making their pies. Delivery is no longer available here so hubby picked it up. We had a 16 inch pep and 14 inch pep and mush all for $50. None at the table were able to finish our meal as the crust now tastes like something from Papa Johns. Makes me sad.I used to rave about this place read more

If you are craving NY style pizza, this is the only place in the area. With that said, they are inconsistent and pricey. Sometimes the pizza is great; other times it doesn't taste like a NY pizza and you will pay top dollar. read more

I'm from NJ and I have a hard time finding pizza that I like when I'm not in the NJ/Philly area. This place is solid. The crust is really good, pizza thickness is really good, cheese and toppings are good. My only complaint is the sauce. The sauce is just a little off. I'm not sure what's wrong about it, but it's not right. All things considered, this place makes a nice pizza. read more

Always love our pies! Nice change to the standard central Ohio style pizzas. Quick delivery too.

Ordered 3 pies at 430 for pick up at 6pm......they didn't even start order at 5:55 Not a happy customer.almost pissed enough to leave. Wtf????? read more

Long-time resident of Pickerington but we tried PNY for the first time. Unfortunately, not impressed. They seem disorganized and they were trying to figure out what happened to someone's order when I approached the counter. If this is authentic New York-style pizza, it was a bad example. The crust was great, but the center of the pizza was not cooked - it was soggy (maybe their oven is too hot - bakes the outside but leaves the center unbaked). Virtually no sauce. When the pizza was picked up, the toppings slid off the soggy end. Oh well, we had to try it. read more

Being from NY, I am always in search of the NY style taste away from home. I must hand it to Pizzeria NY for having the best NY style pizza and the best pizza I have had in Ohio so far. These guys nail the smell, texture, taste and look of pizzerias back home, and it is most awesome. I highly recommend this place if you are looking for an accurate taste of NY style pizza. read more

Believe it or not, this place really does get close to New York-style pie. It's thin and foldable. You can taste the oven on the perfectly crisp/soft/chewy crust. If it's not at its freshest, the crust can seem a little tough. In general it's good stuff, though. It's helpful to keep in mind that it's freakin' NY-style pizza outside of NYC. If I remember correctly, beggars cannot be choosers. You can buy whole pizzas or single slices. The pepperoni is the best. Sure, it's greasy, but who's kidding themselves that pizza is health food? If you don't dig on the 'za, the garlic knots are darn good. They have lots of salads and pasta. I can never resist the pizza. The also have RC instead of Coke or Pepsi. Rock! And the word around the campfire is that the calzones are terrific. I'll try one soon. They have a small-ish bar and a stage. I'm not sure who rocks the stage in a strip mall in Pickerington...I'm not sure I want to know. read more

Moved here from NY a few months ago & I've been looking for good pizza shops. A lot of pizza spots near Columbus claim "new york style" but this place here is it! Thin crust & the cheese is just right! Thank you! read more

Pizzeria New York - Pizza Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

We recently moved from Northern New Jersey to Columbus, and BOY do I miss the pizza. I have been searching all over central Ohio for a decent slice. Pizzeria New York is the closest thing I have found to NY style pizza so far. This is a nice little spot... nothing fancy but the staff is friendly and the Pizza is delicious. They also have some Italian entrees on the menu such as lasagna and spaghetti. We tried the cannoli for desert which was also very good. Pizza is available by the slice or whole pies. Very kid friendly. read more

About a year ago I waited 50 minutes for a mediocre pizza so I stayed away, went back tonight to try it again and it was deja vu all over again. Waited 50 minutes for an underbaked pizza with bland flavor. Never going back. If you want New York style pizza in Columbus, try Adriaticos on campus. read more

I wish I could have not given any stars. After a 20 minute wait we checked to see when it would be done and they said 5 more minutes, it took 10 more ( I think they forgot to make it ). They people that ordered behind us received theirs after 10 minutes(they ordered pepperoni & we ordered mushroom and onion). When they finally brought it to our table I asked if it normally took 30 minutes and all he had to say was " I think we had a big order come in sorry". The sauce was tasteless and runny. Even the thin crust was cooked correctly it also had no flavor . We ate one slice each and left the rest sitting on the table. We won't even give this place a second try like we try to do because of what I have written above. read more