Pricey, that's the first thing I have to say about this place. Secondly food is very very good. Posting late, but we're there for Valentine's Day. Had a wonderful time. And not rush rushed at all. read more

See all

Cozy atmosphere and amazing food. The staff perfectly paced our meal and we never felt rushed. Started our meal with the Aranci, house made bread, and some drinks. The pasta dishes were absolutely delicious. The shrimp and lobster in the scampi were perfectly cooked. The espresso creme brulee paired with a cup of coffee was the perfect ending to the evening. Don't sleep on this location, worth the drive for food, service and ambiance. read more

See all

Our family dines here often. The food is always consistent and delicious, and the staff is great too! read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Glenshaw - Italian Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

See all

Came for an office Holiday gathering of 20. We were sat at a long table that sat us comfortably. We did have a limited menu to choose from which had a few options ranging from chicken parm, gnocchi to pizza. As well as appetizers that included stuffed peppers, they had a kick that hit you 3 bites in and shrimp scampi, which was very flavorful. My opinion the drinks were the best thing on the menu. We all ordered different drinks and when I say they were strong, they were strong but good strong. Staff were very friendly. Overall location is a nice size. Not too large. I do need to add, for our large party we were seated in the middle of the dining area. I don't believe they had any closed or back rooms that were able to accommodate our party. read more

A cozy and inviting place to go. We had dinner at the bar, it was a full house but comfortable. Great bartender Sean! When he pours a drink it was a work of art! read more

See all

The ambiance was pleasant. Service fine. Food good. The price point was simply too high. The food portion doesn't match the price. My guests chose this place. I personally wouldn't go back. Others might find it worth the price. I can understand why people are going out to eat less. read more

I had a bad experience at the Mt Lebanon location but the Glenshaw location was lovely. Service could have been better but the food was delicious! read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Glenshaw - Tiramisu - Italian Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

See all

Food was cold despite waiting 10 minutes for it to come out. Quality of both the pizza and rigatoni with meatball was mediocre at best. Price was too high for the experience. Will not likely be back. read more

Sat at the bar & it hadn't been cleaned before we sat down. Waited another 7-8 minutes & watched one busy bartender trying to keep up & two others doing absolutely nothing from behind the bar. Won't be going back read more

We came in as first timers for my birthday, I've always wanted to try it. The good- the bread and oil were very good. I ordered the lasagna, it was fine, nothing extra. My husband had the carbonara pasta, he seemed happy. The wine was a generous pour. On to the worst service we have had in a long time. Server greeted us- took our drink and appetizer order- she brought our drinks. Didn't see her again for THIRTY min! The food runner brought our appetizer, then brought our entrees.... Never saw our server, not checked on once. She finally stopped , I complained about waiting for another glass of wine- she did comp a second glass - she was awful- ruined the whole night out. Dinner was $135 for 2 people- it wasn't cheap by any means. We won't be back. read more

This was probably the most disappointing meal that I can recall in some time. We ordered takeout: pizza and rigatoni. Although we waited for the food for several minutes beyond the estimated time for pickup, it was not hot. The pizza was small for the price and the serving of rigatoni was over priced too. The meatball was excellent and their sauce is good but it felt like a rip off. read more

This was the first time here for me and my girlfriend and we very glad that we chose the restaurant, which we believe is one of the best in the area. I requested a booth and we were given a choice booth in the bar, the downside being that diners are too close to each other. A loud party was seated next to us as we were toward the end of our meal. The host was pleasant, and we were seated almost immediately on a busy Saturday night, thankfully with a reservation. Server Ryan was excellent: engaging, friendly, and attentive despite having a lot on his plate. Service was slow, likely because the kitchen had a lot of food to prepare, but a leisurely meal was fine with us. Our zucchini fritti, pizza with sausage and rapini, and mushroom paperdelle pasta in a cream sauce, were all outstanding and the portions were good. The zucchini was served with a delicious, smooth tomato sauce. A friendly busser asked if we wanted extra parmesan cheese, which we did. He brought over a container with a nice amount of it, which we sprinkled on the pizza and pasta dishes.The restaurant is more pricey than most: $16 for the zucchini appetizer, $27 for my pizza and $31 for my girlfriend's entree, and the entrees are accompanied by nothing but bread and a tasty oil mixture. Comparing it to my favorite neighborhood Italian restaurant, it comes up short on price. Franco's Trattoria offers a generous portion of delicious chicken parmigiana and soup or salad for $25. We will return to Il Pizzaiolo. We enjoyed it. -- read more

The pasta was great. Only thing to note is there is a corkage fee of $50 per bottle of wine which other locations do not have. The calamari was also really delicious. Seating was ample. Service was super nice read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Glenshaw - Italian Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

Il Pizzaiolo was a nice little date night spot. It was just my girlfriend and I so we showed up without a reservation and they still sat us at the area near the bar without delay. The complimentary bread and oil was very nice and definitely got me in the mood for a plate of pasta. I ordered the shrimp and lobster scampi and it was absolutely delicious. My only gripe with the place is the serving sizes don't reflect the prices, I feel like they could dish out a little more for a $30 plate of angel hair noodles. All and all we had a great time and definitely would recommend trying this place out if you're in the mood for a nice Italian meal. read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Glenshaw - Shrimp and lobster scampi - Italian Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

See all

A very nice and classy place for dinner! We love coming here. There is always plenty of parking and the inside is very cozy and comfortable but still romantic. We always have food service and the food is top notch. They make all their pastas in house, so we always go for pasta. They also have food appetizers, salads etc. a little more expensive but it's worth it! read more

I've had great service and wonderful food. i've been there a few times and it's always stable, timely and efficient. Plus the food is really great if you like classical Italian, this is the place for you. read more

Service was perfect! Gianna was helpful, pleasant, cheerful, and all around excellent! The ambiance could be described as rustic class. Absolutely beautiful! The food was the best I ever ate! I don't mean the food was really good. Everything I ever ate was just for sustenance. This food fed my soul! read more

Food was mostly made from scratch. Everything we had - ragu, pizza, salad, and kids meals were delicious! The kids meals were awesome for our kids offering pizza or buttered noodles. This was a fantastic experience and unlike many places in the region with frozen pre made food. You could taste the freshness. We will be back! read more

Had an early family New Year's Eve get together. We had a group of 8 and gotta say the service and experience were great. Everyone liked the food and were happy with selection. Only negative was the price. Definitely on the high end. Either way would recommend just bring your wallet!! read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Glenshaw - Pizza Diavola Pizza. Tasty - Italian Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

The bread and oil to start was very good. Our waiter was attentive and more than one person waited on us which was nice. The chicken parm wasn't anything special. It was good, but something was missing. The food was very pricey, but everything came out quickly. Will probably come again, but will order something different. read more

See all

I really enjoyed this restaurant's ambiance and food. The pizzas and entrees were all so delicious. I now have a new love for lemon chicken and capers (Pollo Limone). It had the perfect tang/zesty-ness mixed with savory. Also, the side of potatoes were to die for!! I would definitely come back just for this chicken and the cannoli dessert! read more

See all

Cold wedding soup they said because they just opened for the day, extremely expensive wine. I got the Ragu with Papardelle and amazingly it was tough to chew was actually much better the next day when I heated up at home read more

I thoroughly love this restaurant in any location! This one is very close to our house so it's a nice convenient drive when I'm craving a good woodfired pizza. The pasta is so good too! And they make a killer martini. read more

Mostly good, but crazy expensive. The burrata appetizer was very good, as was the arraccini. The pizzas were just ok. A little floppy. The staff seemed intent on grabbing empty plates even while we were still eating and there were very few other customers on a Sunday afternoon. We won't be back. read more

We stopped in for a late dinner and so glad we did. Our server Sophia was amazing, best service we've ever had. She was knowledgeable about the menu and her suggestions were great, we loved everything. Can't wait to go back...best date night! read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Glenshaw - Eggplant & ricotta appetizer. - Italian Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

See all

Overpriced for the food. Server was terribly slow and seemed confused most of the time.

Food is really good. Ambiance is modern Italian, nice and lit, could use another TV or 2 if your are going to have 1 in bar. Those are the 2 stars. We had 3 service attendants behind the bar during our visit. The male tender only made drinks and took regulars orders if they wanted to interrupt his conversation. We got drinks upon arrival and stuffed peppers. They had to fly the f16 to Sicily for right spice but after 45 minutes we got them. DELICIOUS!! Upon peppers arrival our unattended server graced us with a "would you like anything else to eat?" Oh yeah, we do, but we had to put that in 20 min prior after interrupting the other server behind bar. So basically after he didnt realize we ordered our 2 Entrees with other server, 20 min later after everyone at bar( who all have changed over since we arrived) and new customers start getting their entrees before us. So after whole bar has their entrees before us( some ate soup/salad/apps) before as well. Nothing said by anyone besides the kitchen is busy and the Ribeye takes a while to cook medium? Then asked server for check and after she attends to everyone else in place besides us, we ask bar back girl to get our check which she does for us. Please promote the bar back. She is only one who does what you ask of her. read more

I am sad we didn't try this place sooner. I noticed that a lot of people complain about price but I do think this is a great place with quality food. It has great ambiance and my first thought was I should take my family here next time they are in town. We really enjoyed everything and will be back to try more. There aren't really many options like this in the area! read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Glenshaw - Diavola Pizza and Stuffed Banana Peppers - Italian Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

A more upscale Italian restaurant that has fresh ingredients. Tried an order of ravioli and it was delicious. Don't mind paying more for fresh ingredients when worth it. Service good. read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Glenshaw - Ravioli - Italian Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

One of my beloved restaurants that has been a staple for many years. The 2nd location is breath taking in interior design. It's done so well that you want to stay longer and not have to leave. The food is very fresh and cooked to perfection. Appetizers, soup, salads, pizzas pastas and main courses are offered. I always get pizza when I go because it's so good. They have a full cocktail menu as well as great wine and beer selections. Outdoor seating and indoor tables for larger parties make this stop for a good time! Oh and they do have a good happy hour. read more

See all

Was very good. Fancier pizza/pasta place. Staff was very friendly. Pizza was very good it is on the smaller size about 10 inches read more

See all

I'm really surprised by the negative reviews - we had a wonderful experience here for Father's Day lunch. The outside seating was lovely and everything we ordered was DELICIOUS! Calamari was crisp and not oily at all - Caesar salad was so light and packed with flavor, not at all like the usual thick, white dressing most are accustomed to. The roasted vegetables and meatballs appetizers were two other standouts. And their focaccia bread is awesome - like can't-stop-eating-it awesome. Everyone really enjoyed it and our waitress was very attentive and friendly. And don't forget to order dessert! They were excellent as well, especially the tiramisu. Can't wait to go back! read more

Delicious food and good service! Nice ambience as well. This restaurant deserves better than 3 stars. read more

See all

A group of three of us ordered calamari, a pizza salsicce and a pasta (Paglia E Fieno) to share. The calamari was thinly battered, crispy, and tender. Yet it was missing a component of flavor and seasoning. They also only served the "rings" and none of the mini tentacles. Pale and a bit disappointing. The pizza had a delicious flavor and the crust is soft and airy. However, the crust holding the toppings are so thin that the sauce seeps through the thinnest part that the texture is off putting when you put it in your mouth. The pasta probably was the best of the three. The presentation is very nice and the cream sauce is delicious. I might come back to try another pasta dish or to try the clams that were sold out early in the evening. Overall, a bit expensive ($54 + tax&tip) but the service is good and some of the dishes here might be worth the price. read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Glenshaw - Italian Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

See all

We had not been here in a while. We stopped for Sunday dinner. We had Chicken Marsala and Shrimp and Lobster Scampi. Both were delicious. We shared a salad and dessert and still brought home leftovers. Highly recommend. read more

Amazing good and service - great atmosphere! there pizzas are amazing. Prices aren't bad either

Food is good. Not great. Service is average. Not great. Prices are a little steep so be prepared. $24 for a 4 cheese pizza. $30 for lasagna. And no, that's not family style. That's single serving lasagna. These are NYC prices. Bring a family of 4 and you better have your Black Card on hand. We just moved into the area and this is one of the few places around. But we can't drop $400 every time we want to grab a few drinks and some pretty basic italian food. I would say give it a shot and make your own decisions. Everyone has a different comfort level with price. Other's may think it's a deal. read more

For the prices they charge, I expected really good food and service. Neither happened. It took an hour to get our food and when it came, the $22 pizza with 6 slices was ok, but nothing special. The eggplant dish for $29 came with no pasta, and no salad. It was not tasty and the texture was off. Just layers of gummy eggplant in cheese and sauce. For a $7 side salad, I expected a really great side salad. It was iceberg with 2 tomatoes and onion. In my opinion, this place is way overpriced for the food and the service was not good. Just so disappointing. read more

One of our favorite neighborhood joints. Not cheap but the food is always delicious and they have an awesome outdoor patio and fireplace. The servers are always friendly too. Definitely an older crowd but it's nice to have a solid option out this way. read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Glenshaw - Pollo Scarpariello - Italian Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania

Local Italian restaurant with plenty of seating and nice ambience. The prices are high and the food is mediocre. IMHO. read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Glenshaw - Sad looking pizza topping distribution, for the price, you expect better quality. - Italian Near Me - Glenshaw, Pennsylvania