They're definitely a bit pricey, but since we were in town, we decided to try all of the classic flavors. Honestly, the chocolate chip was the standout -- rich, gooey, and just really satisfying. The others didn't have much flavor and were kind of missing that oomph factor we were hoping for. The shop itself was clean, and the guy behind the counter was friendly and helpful, which we appreciated. We stuck to the classics this time, but maybe next visit we'll branch out and try some of the other flavors. read more

See all

Insomnia cookie is the perfect late night snack. It's open late for those moments you get cravings. They have such an assortment of cookies from your classic to your seasonal flavors. I ordered the snickerdoodle and the apple cider donut. Both freshly baked and oh so delicious. They also serve ice cream at this location. The store is small and has a few seats inside at a high counter. The employee was cordial when she took our order. I love a good insomnia cookie. read more

See all

Man... talk about a late night snack. Even though I knew this was going straight to me getting love handles, I couldn't resist and I was so happy I did. Getting ice cream on top of any of their cookies is to die for. Especially this location is smart, being next to bars / restaurants it is a fantastic place to hit up after any of your events. Plus, the service was too notch - the service honestly gets a 10/10. I didn't get his name, but he knows who he is, and I would literally go back just to support him & their crazy amazing cookies. If you've never been to Insomnia Cookies, you are definitely missing out. Even if it's out of your direction, make the trip! Highly recommend. Personal Review: 9.1/10 read more

Insomnia Cookies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Ok. So after countless mention of this from my daughter I decided to stop in here. The place is very small but I guess this would be fine as most people who come would just order and take their cookies/ ice cream to go. I ordered few of the chocolate chunk cookies. I asked the young lady if these are freshly made everyday. She stated that it is pre-made and we simply throw it in the oven to bake. I would have been content if the price of each cookie was not $3.30. Nothing spectacular about the cookie. Bit small for the price. Yes it was warm, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside but would not come here again for an overpriced average cookie. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Chocolate Chunk - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I used to love Insomnia Cookies, but the business has really gone downhill in the past few years. I ordered a 10" deluxe cookie cake with a "Ur my fave" message on it, and with buttercream frosting piped around the message and under it. I opened the box, and not only was there no piping on it, but there was also only about a teaspoon of frosting holding the message onto the cookie. This is unacceptable, and I feel completely scammed out of over $40 for this f-ing joke. I called the store and complained, and the woman only said that they were phasing out piping the frosting, even though the app still shows the product the way it was before, as of today. I asked her if they were at least lowering the price, and she said that it was a financial/corporate matter. I am extremely disappointed in what used to be my favorite place to get cookies. Until you change your policy or stop jacking up the price for what have become mediocre, pre-made cookies, I will not come back. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Barely any frosting underneath - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

We left Bacino's and walked down the street, on advice from our friend who NEEDED an ice cream sandwich. I waited a bit and got a double chocolate mint cookie. It was a little crowded but the line moved quickly. The staff was very friendly but a little distracted. The cookie was great, just enough chips and mint, maybe a TINY bit stale tasting! I should have heated it up, I did not eat it there (VERY small space, made for take out) so maybe that made a difference. I was glad (!) to see the calories listed next to each cookie. They're good for sharing, esp the deluxe cookies, which I will get next time. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Neon insomnia - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

GO TO WRIGLEYVILLE LOCATION-I wouldn't typically leave a review from Insomnia, because if you want cookies, Insomnia has great cookies. The cookie overall was as expected, great nothing to write home about but as expected. This review should encourage you, when making a decision between this location and the Wrigleyville location, go to Wrigleyville. For an evening in the middle of the week, I would think Insomnia would be grateful and appreciate a long line of customers, but boy was I mistaken. I get it, people have bad days and can be overwhelmed but my god it should not take 30 minutes to get a cookie and ice cream. Specifically it should not take 20+ minutes to order. Additionally, if there's a line, sitting in the back on your phone in the view of customers should not be acceptable. Again I get that large orders, people paying in cash, and five people in line can be a lot, but if it's too much, close or send people to another location. Five stars on cookie with ice cream, negative stars on service. read more

This location, possibly many others, doesn't care what cookies you ordered. They send you whatever they feel like sending. If you are out of a particular cookie, you have our phone number. Pickup the damn phone and call us. Instead, I just dispute the charge. read more

We got insomnia cookies and it was delicious. It was crispy from outside and soft from inside. It was mouthwatering, warm and good. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

My daughter wanted to stop in. We all got cookies. To be honest, the cookies were average. The place is small, and was packed. The milk was overpriced. What am I missing? Three contributing factors as far as I can tell 1) Next to DePaul 2) Next to bars that are open late 3) Delivers cookies until 3AM. IMO, you have to respect a place that delivers cookies until 3AM, now that is devotion. I'm thinking the go to here for the late night munchies is probably the cookie/ice cream sandwiches, kind of like if Ben & Jerry's delivered ;) read more

See all

Oh You are high. We all know it. Get the ice cream add-on. Great cookies. 8 more characters. read more

I sent a surprise delivery of cookies, milk and ice cream to my student @ DePaul University. The delivery was super fast and my son definitely loved the treat! He even gave me a shout out Thanks Mom on Snapchat. I will definitely be ordering again. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This place never goes wrong. I've been to 5 different locations and the consistency is wonderful. I must say though - Birmingham has the best cookies I don't know why! LOL I ordered a 6 pack to share with co-workers and needless to say only 2 made it back to the office. :) would definitely visit this location when back in Chicago. It's on a block that is close to transpiration and walking distance so great location. Most staff are okay but not super over the top so it works for them. read more

Soft, sweet and sugary and everything nice is the way I'd describe Insomnia's cookies. I've been to other cookie exclusive bakeries and ended up disappointed because I think my cookies are the best thing since sliced bread and none could compare. Well, Insomnia Cookies definitely rival my own creations. They are seriously so good! My friends and I got a mix of the Deluxe Cookies yesterday - Smores Deluxe, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup and Triple Chocolate Chunk. All were so friggin huge and so flippin good, I can't even pick a favorite. The cookies are served warm & nice n gooey just the way I like them. They put them in a cute pizza style box for you to take them to go. They are open and deliver cookies until 3am! read more

See all

This place is unreal. Like every cookie is cooked to perfection. It's SO warm and filling. I'm obsessed. read more

So the tiny lil irony to this is i was seeing my cardiologist and run up on this place. I'm really not a sweets person. HOWEVER, ya just gotta see these gems. Nothing to the place actually and if you not looking for it you might drive right past it. After a clean bill of health from the heart doc, I treated myself some peanut butter, chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin and macadamia nut cookies. What was that? Ya think I over did it? Pictures worth a thousand words read more

Insomnia Cookies - Check out my writeup on these lil nuggets of gold..... - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I've heard good things about Insomnia Cookies and I read that they recently opened a store in Lincoln Park. I came by with a couple of my friends and we got a dozen of their cookies. We got everything and while some were good, the peanut butter cookie was so raw. I am a big lover of cookies that are soft on the inside, crunchy on the outside. But this one fell apart and left a huge grease stain on the parchment paper. I liked their snicker-doodle, white chocolate and chocolate chunk. I was a little bit disappointed by how small they were. I still think Potbelly's has a better sugar cookie though. Must be those huge sugar crystals. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Cookie offerings! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

No matter what city I'm in, these cookies have never disappointed me. Late night sugar dispensary offering up warm treats in a quick and friendly manner. Both traditional and deluxe cookies were available, though not all the flavors. Decided on the S'more Cookie ($3.60) and a bottle of milk ($3). Cookie is warmed up - crumbly soft with intense chocolate flavor and the right amount of marshmallows inside. Milk is your standard fare, necessary with the rich baked goods. Weren't that many people on a Sunday night, so we were able to get a seat inside and enjoy. Always a good decision to stop in after a few drinks. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Cookie menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I am one of the biggest sweet fanatic and insomnia cookies are way more sweeter than I expected. I bought a box of dozen to share and plus it was $10 deal so why not?! I just wish I was warned that I just eat the cookies RIGHT AWAY because after a little while, it hardens. Unlike other people, I like for the middle of my cookie to be at least soft and that's not what I got from insomnia cookies. This place would be awesome if you are planning to eat it right there and then but taking it home, it's not an ideal thing to do unless you like hard cookies. On another note, the staff was really friendly and helpful since it was my first time there, I was sure how the ordering process works. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Cameron and Dominick great when taking my order. Every time I came to the store to purchase cookies the service from either individual was amazing. They both have an enthusiastic approach when it comes to customer service and as a customer I am proud to refer people to this location. read more

I stopped by while on a walk. I did not regret coming in. I ordered double chocolate mint and the deluxe chocolate peanut butter cup. I was not expecting them to be served warm and gooey. What a wonderful surprise! They were gone in two seconds. If i am ever in chicago, I'm coming back for the oatmeal raisin! read more

Insomnia Cookies - My two cookies were gone within minutes. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Okay so it was a Saturday and a nice day so my girlfriend and I wanted to head out for dessert, especially getting out and being inside all day due to Corona Virus mayhem (plus we need to do something lol) You have to pay street parking. There was no line due to Corona virus. The staff were friendly and helpful. I selected the cookiewich with moosetrack ice cream with chocolate chunk and sugar cookie as a sandwich. Wish they had more flavors but the flavor I selected was really great! I do like you can select two different types of cookie to make your cookiewich. Overall the dessert was fantastic! I would come back here for the cookiewich. First time being here and I like the first impression of the place. I would not be surprised if there was a line during the summer time with no virus going around lol. Cheers! read more

See all

I was in the mood for a random brownie so I went to the Insomnia by Loyola. They were out...I nearly cried. I called the next closest one to the area and spoke to Josh. Josh at the Lincoln Park location understood my "need" for this brownie. He was such a great person on the phone AND in actual person it made my journey for the random brownie such a wonderful experience. Also my brownie was DELICIOUS! read more

Fast delivery, great cookies. Comes in a cute box which helps keep the cookies fresh longer.

Best cookie place ever!! Went here at 3:50 am and they were still nice I got the brownie ice cream cookie sandwich and your midnight craving will be satisfied!! Loved it!! Except don't go late at night bc there's a bar down the street and drunk people will bother you so make sure you go with someone!! :) read more

Insomnia Cookies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

You can't go wrong coming here for some sweet craving to end your night. I went to a different location before but I think all location as I been to (insomnia cookies) never disappointed me. I would definitely come back here for my cookies or cookiewich craving! read more

Insomnia Cookies - Cookiewich: snickerdoodle and chocolate chunk with moose-track ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Omg what a brilliant idea that is.. warm cookies whenever you need on your doorstep! When in Chicago we were visiting it was really cold outside and we ordered some warm yummy cookies at midnight to eat with our milk! The delivery guy came with a smile on his face and warm cookies! Ahh those cookies put smile on my kids' face! Definitely an amazing business idea.. wish we had some here in California too! read more

I ordered cookies for my boyfriends birthday requesting 2-3 day delivery. They forwarded me a tracking number the day I placed the order and 3 days later the package still had not shipped. I called customer service and they said they could deliver the cookies a week and a half later, well past his birthday. So I ended up having to cancel the order. Very disappointed. read more

Had the mint chip ice cream sandwich with a peanut butter and double chocolate cookie. First, I noticed the chocolate morsels were perfectly warmed, a+. Then, the sight of the broken peanut butter cookie underneath, made me sad, but I hoped the taste would cancel the look, and it did. The eats are on point and made up for the presentation disaster served on a paper plate. 3 stars all for taste Happy that this is open till 3am Geared for the young kids/students in the DePaul area read more

Insomnia Cookies - Double chocolate, mint chip, peanut butter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Definitely the worst Insomnia Cookies location I've been to. Bad enough to leave this review. Every time I have gotten cookies from here, delivery or pick up, the experience has not been the best. My first delivery order ever took over an hour and one of the cookies had been half eaten. I was given 2 free cookies with my next order for this. That next order, delivery also took over one hour. I picked up from here one time after getting my nails done next door and checked the box as I walked out to find I had been given two M&M cookies instead of chocolate chip cookies... gotta love it. I thought I learned my lesson and placed a free delivery order tonight two hours in advance to be delivered at 8:45 PM. It is 9:20 PM and the order tracker still says my cookies are baking. I think I've learned now. read more

The cookie was very ______! I wouldn't know because I never got my cookie. My estimated time was 40-50 minutes and it has been now 2+ hours. As we called explaining the situation, we were answered by a very mean lady that had absolutely ZERO idea how to speak to a customer. Instead of apologizing she insisted that their estimated time was not guaranteed. Not at any moment did she apologize for anything nor seem to care about their terrible, terrible service. We only ordered one cookie. The location is 1 mile away. My friends were watching the Thursday Night Football game with me and had to go home because the game had ended and could not wait anymore for this cookie. Lies, deceit, disappointment, and a total failure! This place deserves 0 stars! read more

I ordered at 5pm and at 6:45, still no delivery. I called them and waited nearly 35 minutes and they didn't answer. I went to the main Grubhub screen and it said they had closed and would reopen at 8:45. Grubhub was great but Insomnia has terrible service tonight and has lost a fairly regular customer. read more

Great cookies, but absolutely useless delivery drivers. Orders are always late and wrong. Half of the time the delivery doesn't arrive at all. Complete waste of time. read more

Fell in love with this place when I visited NYC last year. I'm so sad that when I visited their Chicago location for the first time excited that there is one in my Midwest Hospitality Home Town , the service was horrible. The guy at the register was cold. Mean. Uninterested. Not helpful at all and j actually felt like I was disturbing his day by coming in to purchase what they were selling which ironically is how he gets to have a job during these challenging times. Tough to admit that the customer service in NYC was better than in CHICAGO??? Never ever coming back. Thanks for the huge disappointment. read more

They deliver until 3am, is this what heaven looks like? You can get 1 cookie.. or a dozen.. or 500. If you want 500, they can make you 500 in ~1.5 hours. Once again, is this what heave looks like? Chocolate chip cookies were great, a balance between crispy and soft, the chocolate chips were melted. I'd pass on the snickerdoodle, could use more cinnamon and sugar. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

This is crazy... but when I went to Insomnia a couple days ago, the workers were able to match my face with my previous review. They apologized and I spoke mainly to Max and he gave me 3 free cookies + an ice cream scoop to make up for that day! He said it should have never happened and I should have been warned beforehand that they can't make the cookiewich which I asked for last time I came here. He talked to my sisters and I the entire duration we were there up until we left (they weren't busy). He even asked if I wanted anything else (on top of what he already gave me, but I declined). Then I I asked him if he would get in trouble for giving me the cookies and ice cream.... Max and his co-worker said that anytime they have a bad incident, they try to make up for it. I brought up the fact that most of their 1-2 star reviews are due to delayed deliveries. They explained to me that when customers order 16 cookies and they only have 12 at that moment, they have to make another 4 which takes 15-20 minutes. And then when they are really really busy, they just can't keep up with the orders no matter how fast they work mainly because they can only fit so many workers back there and they aren't like Dunkin Donuts where they keep their cookies sitting on the shelf. They try to make them fresh, otherwise they aren't keeping their word. Something else to keep in mind if you're coming on a MONDAY NIGHT. They get their ice cream deliveries on Tuesday. When we arrived, they didn't have cookies and cream, cookie dough or vanilla ice cream. So just be aware they may not have your ice-cream on Monday nights. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Excellent concept, disappointing execution. Living near a mecca for twenty-somethings has its advantages. Namely, a decent number of late night dining options. Open 7 days a week from 11a-3a and delivering (yes, until 3), Insomnia Cookies is definitely the most unique player on the block. If it were that simple, I'd give them five stars. Unfortunately, the product doesn't live up to the concept in my book. When I wandered in, jonesing for something sweet, I was disappointed to see the regular assortment of cookies looked pretty much like Subway's cookies in more varieties for $1.35. My double chocolate mint cookie, which was warm, didn't taste that unlike a Subway cookie either; fine, but nothing to write home about. Insomnia also offers deluxe cookies and brownies for $2.75 as well as ice cream. Would I come back? Yes...if Potbelly next door was closed; their cookies are the same price, but bigger and IMO better. Maybe, if they had more exciting flavor combos, I'd make it a destination. read more

Chicago needs more cookie shops. Chicago needs more cookie shops closer to my abode. I enjoyed the fruits of my first visit to Insomnia, but it is too far away for regular trips. The cookies are good, but not trek-several-miles-out-of-my-way good. Big thumbs up for offering a cookie ice cream sandwich. You can't go wrong there. As far as the straight cookies go, I found the s'mores to be amazing, the double-chocolate mint excellent, and the chocolate chunk and oatmeal raisin good but not great. The snickerdoodle was kind of a letdown. So, on average, the stuff here is in the B to B+ range. Like I said, if I lived closer, they would get more of my money, until I died of diabeetus, that is. read more

Its Simple: Cookies Baked Fresh! Served Warm! Open until 3am - DAILY! Great people with great service! YUM! PS: they have ice cream, too read more

Insomnia Cookies - Main menu and store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

All time favorite is s'mores !!!! So warm and gooey . Fresh cookies !!!!!! Love them all read more

Insomnia Cookies - (From left to right ) Mint chocolate, classic m&m, snickerdoodle, sugar cookie , macadamia and red velvet - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Chicago, Illinois