Islamorada Fish Co is a great scenic restaurant for sunset. There is a massive amount of outdoor seating so everywhere has a beautiful view. There's even tarpon that's swimming around that you can watch and feed while you're waiting for your food. I bring a lot of friends here when I get visitors to the keys. I would say the food is average or above average but the beautiful scenery makes it worth while to come here. Pretty much all the seating is outside so if you're a person that needs air conditioning, this maybe is not the best place for you. My favorite thing on the menu is the grouper Reuben. It's actually pretty delicious. Also the poke bowl is really good. I'm pretty sure they have a good Happy hour special too, but I never make it here in time for happy hour. read more

Islamorada Fish Company - Poke bowl - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Lunch on the water? Yes please. You definitely don't come here for food. It was fine but nothing special to mention. Will I seek it out when visiting the keys? Probably not. But it hit the spot. read more

See all

The place is amazing, the view and the staff is unforgettable. Highly recommended and our server Rafael was the star of the show, thanks Rafael for allowing to enjoy this afternoon, it felt like family and we will definitely come back!!!! Isalmorada !!! Fish Company !!!! read more

Horrible service. We sat at the bar and ended up leaving because we were completely ignored. We asked to be moved to a table, hoping the service would improve, but unfortunately, we received the same lack of attention. Very disappointing experience. read more

We were on the hunt for a good breakfast spot in Islamorada, but before we could eat, my boyfriend had to make a quick stop at Bass Pro Shops to pick up some fishing gear. That's when I noticed a sign saying they served breakfast so i figured we'd check out the menu and wow, I am SO glad we stayed! The breakfast here is phenomenal and such a bang for your buck. The portions are generous, the quality is amazing, and everything was absolutely delicious. I ordered the Crabby Hash which was two perfectly crispy crab cakes topped with onions, peppers, smoked gouda cheese, creamy lobster sauce, and two eggs any style, served with crispy, golden hash browns. It also came with a choice of toast, pancake, or biscuit. I went with the pancake, and it was so fluffy and delicious it could have been a dessert. My boyfriend went with the Country Fried Chicken which was lightly breaded chicken breast smothered in sausage gravy and those same perfect hash browns. He loved every bite. We came here by chance, but now it's a definite must stop for us. If you're in Islamorada, don't overlook this place for breakfast it's right on the water too with a great view too. We saw some tarpons, Jelly fish and even a manatee swim by read more

Islamorada Fish Company - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

They had ocean views and a man playing music. The food was just okay, though. We tried the wahoo wrap and mahi tacos. The mahi mahi was overcooked and something else on the tacos had a competing taste that didn't mesh well. The wrap was good. This is a mega restaurant and they have service designed to rotate a large number of people in and out, and it shows. I don't even mean that in a bad way. read more

See all

The ambiance is second to none. The water views were outstanding. Lots of beach and tiki hut seating with water views wait staff were fast and friendly. The food was very good. Fish and chips, crab cake sandwiches were yummy. Plenty of parking. Would recommend to everyone. read more

See all

Located by the original Bass Pro Shop, plenty of parking and an amazing atmosphere. Sitting outside, you can see the large tarpon fish in the water. There was some live music there. We only stopped in for a quick bite, ordering the Wahoo Dip, the Alligator bites and the Coconut Shrimp. Our server was friendly and attentive. The Alligator bites was seasoned well and the batter was perfect. With some tobasco sauce, lemon and spicy ranch, it was very good. We did eat it with some of the Wahoo dip and I thought it was a good pairing. We loved the Wahoo Dip, it was nice and refreshing and our server offered us some more crackers to go with it. The coconut shrimp was also delicious, especially their sweet & spicy sauce. Would have loved to be able to try the rest of their menu. Definitely recommend! read more

See all

Great food and ambience! Ellie was amazing and went above and beyond. Made up for the hostess not even acknowledging our existence when she seated us! read more

Islamorada Fish Company - Scallop and Blackened Shrimp & Scallop Pasta - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

our server Rafael was amazing, the service was spotless and the food out of the world. the ambient is wonderful and the shows great for kids and adults. read more

I had to write a review because we had a very good experience on July 26th, 2026. They were very busy which is always a good sign. Our server was Cherlne?(spelling) and she was very nice and we got our food quickly. My wife loved the shrimp tacos and I loved the baked oysters; they were huge. There was a guitarist/vocalist named Dennis and he was excellent. Sang Allman Bros., Eric Clapton and Piano Man from Billy Joel. We love Islamorada so we'll go back again. read more

It is a must-visit for the view, but I was not impressed with the food or the service when I visited. I will be back and hope to have a better experience with those. read more

See all

This place says it's world renowned. Maybe for horrible service. The hostess acts like the world owes her a living and is the complete antithesis of how a hostess should be. I ordered New England Clam Chowder, I got conch chowder. They switched it to clam but believe me Progresso is better. The wife ordered a trio of small sliders, one chicken,one pulled pork and one burger. It was on their specials menu. They brought out three pulled pork sliders which we quickly sent back. We should have simply left but waited 20 minutes to get the correct slider trio. I will give the waiter credit he did get the water right. Places that simply don't care about customers shouldn't exist. With all the other water front restaurants in the keys. Drive by this one! read more

Beautiful outdoor dining. If you're looking for the best sunset view for dinner and cocktails this is your place. Easy parking. If it's chilly out they have heaters which keep you very warm. The Pina Colada was delicious. We had raw oysters to start. They had excellent salty fresh taste. Large Stone Crab claws. Seafood pasta. The view created a beautiful ambiance while you ate in the relaxed beautiful Keys. read more

See all

Don't be fooled with the beautiful view. Service was horrible. Food was over fried. Fish was flavorless. Fries were cold and warmed up. Will not return. read more

We sat outside near the outdoor bar area for lunch. It was a really cool environment not too hot. They've got a lot of fans outside. The food was delicious. My husband had the grouper Reuben, which he said was fantastic and I had the fish and chips. The fish was very crispy and cooked perfectly and we had excellent service. read more

We enjoyed the food, drinks, and laid back acoustic music playing live in the nearby tiki hut.

Service was marginal at best. Took 10 minutes to see the server she was nice but the bar was very slow. We come to the keys quite a bit and have not tried this place before and unfortunately will not return or recommend. This place. read more

Fabulous Sunday afternoon in the Keys. Good food and drink and fabulous service ! The waitress was helpful, was well versed in the menu and made excellent suggestions Enjoyed stone crab, conch fritters, Caesar salad,coconut shrimp! Well worth the drive from Kendall read more

Had an absolutely wonderful dinner at Islamorada Fish Co with our server, Riley! He was very informative about the menu and suggested we order the dinner special featuring a fully fried yellowtail with rice and vegetables. We also had a half shell of oysters (on the sweeter side) and a crab cake to start with a bottle of white wine for the table. It was our first time eating this type of fish (and prepared as well) like this and certainly won't be our last. This is also a great location to watch the sun go down and take pictures with friends and family. read more

Islamorada Fish Company - Grouper - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Slow getting the food out. Good was just okay. But it was walking distance from our hotel.

Place is a novelty to watch and feed the Tarpon. There is a nice view being on the water as well. We sat at the bar outside and ordered drinks and the calamari. The bartender really only acknowledged my husband and not me. If the calamari is any indication of how the rest of the food is I wouldn't recommend it. It was very chewy and we didn't end up finishing it. read more

See all

Has Become Our Go To Stop when We Arrive in The Keys. Food, and Service is Always Excellent. Love The Tiki Hut, and View Also!

Their breakfast is the best in the Keys! I used to go to LoraLei, but since they raised their prices and the quality stayed the same, I chose Islamorada Fish Company hands down. The service, quality and quantity are unbeatable. Beautiful Tiki atmosphere right on the bay. You need to try it! read more

Islamorada Fish Company - Their breakfast menu - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

We stopped here for dinner on a Friday night. We were able to get a table right near the doc with a nice view. The menu had a little bit of everything on it. We both ordered fresh fish dishes and were not disappointed. Our server was very nice and told us that the Tarpon under the doc would go crazy for the shrimp tails left over from our appetizer. The tarpon gobbled them right up. Before we knew it a family of manatees came in to visit! They hung around for most of our dinner. It was an amazing experience. read more

Absolute disgrace to seafood, They used to have my favorite fish sandwich on the planet now just about everything is inedible. I don't know what happened but it's really gone down hill. Not only does it taste like frozen seafood but everything we ordered was also over cooked. You used to be lucky to get a seat, now half the restaurant is closed off and still has empty tables. I'll never come back unless drastic changes are made. read more

The food was absolutely amazing. Our waiter was Rafael. He went out of his way with the kids & knew exactly how to make our experience wonderful. He made my birthday even better than expected. His patience with handling a big group was the best. Thank you so much Rafael. We will definetly be returning soon!!! read more

Enjoyed some good food and had delightful service from Nadya! However, I was surprised to see an employee exit the restroom without washing his hands, and unfortunately, we found a fishhook in our meal--definitely a shocking experience. read more

I have been looking for shrimp cocktail and they have it nice and fresh. We also ordered the shrimp tacos very good and for desert the key lime pie in a huge cup it was delicious we couldn't eat it all it was huge. read more

Stopped here for lunch during our road trip to Key West, and we are glad that we did! Wonderful view, good food, nice ambiance. It was a bright sunny day, and we got a table with the view of the bay. A nice dining experience. Service is good as well. We had the Fried Seafood Combo Basket with coconut shrimps, calamari, fried shrimps, scallops. It was nicely done. There is live music beside the doc and several sitting areas to relax and enjoy the nice view of the bay. read more

See all

We went to Islamorada Fish Company to have lunch and we ordered Fried Calamari and Conch Fritters for appetizer, Fish and Chips, Blackened Shrimp and Scallop Pasta and the Parmesan Grilled Chicken for Lunch. The food was delicious and have good portion. The service was okay and the ambiance is casual and relaxing, as we enjoy the food and the ocean breeze and sea waves. read more

See all

Came here for an early Wednesday dinner. The restaurant is very big with plenty of seating but there weren't very many patrons there. We started with the alligator bites which were sooo good wow. Was truly impressed. We also had the peel and eat shrimp which were really good but too much work so I'd opt for a shrimp cook tail next time instead. I had the guava bbq mahi mahi and it was just ok. The fish was a little dry and tough and the sides were bland. I've heard the sunset here is beautiful but it was overcast and we were there about 2 hours before sunset so didn't get to see it. read more

See all

Nice location on the water, you can see a lot of marine life in the water. But it's a restaurant first. Having said that the server we had was very good, the other servers looked unhappy. The food was tasteless, cocktail sauce was basically ketchup. Fried shrimp didn't seem fresh. Prices are crazy for such poor food quality. Drive past and look for another place. read more

Food and ambiance was great. We caught our own fish on a fishing charter and brought it in to be cooked. We chose grilled and blackened. I would have preferred all blackened. I believe it was 17.99 per person as of August 2024. The bring your own catch came with 2 sides also which we got veggies and rice. The key like aioli that came with the fish is soooo good!! When in the Florida keys, your gotta try the key like everything !!!!The wahoo dip was delish although I wished we had more cucumbers bc we are trying to be healthier. Service was kind of slow but we weren't in any rush. Would come here again for that wahoo dip. read more

See all

Great atmosphere good service food is great you need to come Friday you can come and see the sunsets

Honestly very average food. Nothing to write home about. It's a cool experience to dine over the water and see the loads of tarpon! Service was nice and friendly, but prices... WILD. The fish sandwich was decent, but it comes out looking real ugly. Melted cheese haphazardly thrown on top and falling off the side. Possibly the smallest slice of tomato I've ever seen on a sandwich. Why are they even using it?! Fish dip was good. Mahi tacos were good, best part of the meal probably! read more

See all

I ate at the Dania Beach location years ago and I don't remember being too impressed with it, but my wife and I were recently down in Key Largo and decided to give this location a try. The hostess was very friendly and we were seated right away. There's a beautiful view overlooking the water and there are plenty of tarpon and other fish swimming around. The service was fast and friendly. There food was very good and reasonable priced. They also have a fairly good selection of local and craft beers, of course they also have all the regular domestic and imported beers. The next time we're down in the keys, I'm sure we'll be eating here again. read more

See all

This is definitely one of those restaurants that you have to put in the list when visiting the keys. Walking in was a breeze getting served and acknowledge immediately. There's many options for food in the menu. The best thing obviously is the fish, but you can never go wrong with some fried shrimp. Great to have a romantic dinner by the water or to go with friends definitely recommend. read more

Islamorada Fish Company - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Beloved and I stopped at Islamorada Fish Company for lunch and were delighted with the place. It has a perfect right on the water's edge setting. With its water views, docks, and tiki hut décor, it has that very special laid-back easy-going ambiance for which the Keys are so well known. Adding to that, the friendly wandering chickens and a hostess booth set up outside on a sandbank; all add to the charm and uniqueness of Islamorada Fish. After an appetizer of delicious raw oysters, we both went for their local snapper catch, grilled, blackened, Key lime butter, and with panko. We both enjoyed it very much as did the chickens under our table that eagerly snapped up or lose crumb droppings. read more

Islamorada Fish Company - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

We came during happy hour 3-6, they had a big sign outside boasting the happy hour. We ate and some of the group had drinks - draft beers were supposed to be $3.05z Service was slow, but they were busy so we didn't mind. When we paid we were in a hurry to get back on the road to key west, so I just handed the server the card to swipe given how busy he was. When I got in the car, I looked at the receipt - we were charged full price on the beers, which were SMALL. CRAZY to pay $7 for a beer that is 10oz. Would definitely check all receipts. read more

Islamorada Fish Company - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida