Decent pizza option in Nantucket if you aren't wanting to venture out for the evening. We ordered in and had no issues with delivery. It was a little cold and lacking in flavor overall but not bad. Probably wouldn't order again but it might be better in person and the delivery guy was really nice. read more

Ordered a $37 custom pizza with pepperoni, bacon and extra sauce, got a nasty plain cold pizza for "Claire" (not my name). This is the second time this place has been the absolute worst delivery option on the island. These is even after i called MULTIPLE TIMES this evening to make sure they knew my order and where to deliver it after last time. I called the restaurant six times after our poor delivery driver was told by Sophie's to bring this pizza to us and got no answer. Guess we'll have to get our money back via disputing the charge? This place shouldn't be allowed to operate a delivery service. read more

Sophie T's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Great place for some good pizza on the island. The pizza was and fresh. I had the pineapple and ham. My wife had the cheese. The sauce was great . Price was right. read more

This is the best slice of pizza I've had in a long time. The crust was perfect and there were seven different choices of slices of pizza. Looks like a nice little Pizza place clean, comfortable and plenty of seating. How do you beat that? I just had a slice of pizza so I can't tell you much about the service. This place is very close to Stop & Shop. read more

Sophie T's Pizza - Exterior - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Unfortunately, I was disappointed with my simple cheese pizza. The crust was tasteless and soft, no crunch. When I ordered my pizza, I was told it would take 40 minutes .... ok, so when showed up it took an additional 30 minutes ... and then getting a mediocre pizza. read more

Absolutely beautiful pies , light sauce no flop . Portnoy would approve! And that goes for 5 other island visitors as well! You have us sold next time we order pizza! read more

Sophie T's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Great Pizza and service. The owner Bharat, is wonderful. This place has something for everyone!

Ambiance was Boston through and through!! Staff helped stream the playoff game on the TV. Service was quick and pizza was delish!

Don't come here expecting NY pizza, lol. Came here and got a couple of slices. Make sure the cashier knows you only want one slice of 2-meat pizza or call it pep/sausage instead. I didn't realize her mistake until I had left; just figured the prices island-high. In any case, the crust is very doughy, but soft. Plenty of sauce, cheese, and topping. It's about $5/slice, which I think its the going price these days. Goes well with a drink from the chickenbox across the street. read more

See all

Customer service and timely deliveries are not priorities. Sophie T's Pizza gave me a one hour delivery time of 9:30 after I paid for my order. I called at 9:46 to inquire about the order and was told the order was out for delivery and would arrive soon. I called again at 10:20 and the woman who answered the phone told me it was on its way. I asked her to cancel the order and refund my money and she said there was no one on site who could do this for me. The pizzas arrived at 10:53, cold and congealed. There is a certain amount high-priced bad service one tolerates here but this was over the top. read more

Great little sub shop. Pizza is great and the steak and cheese is yummy with peppers. Chicken parm is also yummy. Service is great

Great pizza and quick bite. Great service and food super friendly staff Highly recommended read more

We were told 40 min when we ordered over the phone. Came 40 min later, was told it would be another 15 min. Asked again in 20, was told "it's coming. We're going as fast as we can. Next." Holy sass. Didn't get order until 30 min after that. If you're backed up, fine. But don't tell us 40 min if it's going to be an hour and a half. Didn't get a single sorry or even apologetic look?? read more

I ordered delivery and my order came very quick. The pizza was absolutely delicious, full of flavor, full of toppings. Absolutely delicious. I will 100% be back and highly recommend anyone wanting pizza on Nantucket get their pizza at Sophie T's! Five stars read more

Sophie T's Pizza - Large Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

If you're craving just like a normal regular pie pizza, this is the place. They have perfected their Greek salad & dressing and we always have the best experience ordering from here. read more

Born and raised in New Jersey and recently relocated to Nantucket, this is a taste of home and a brand new experience rolled out, topped with sauce and cheese, and baked just right. We ordered over the phone for pickup, which made me feel like a kid again. And, what is pizza if it's not nostalgic? I would choose Sophie T's whether we were in New Jersey, Massachusetts or even Italy. read more

While vacationing on island we decided to try the ACK Mack pizza. It was phenomenal! We loved every bite and can't wait to get it again next year. Customer service was great also Would recommend! read more

Alright, time for a re-review: This place is currently awesome! I pooh pooh Nantucket food sometimes, but Sophie T's defies the trend this year. Folks are friendly, the pizza is quite good, and shockingly well priced. Think: normal, real world prices ($19 for a large; $12 for a small)! The crust is a tad bit thicker than a typical New York style crust, but not by much, and the dough has a lovely, slightly chewy bite. Tomato sauce is, as it is on a properly low brow NYC dollar slice, slightly sweet, not at all acidic. The amount of mozzarella (nothing too high brow on the regular cheese) is perfect. Toppings are well distributed and not applied in a stingy manner (I'm looking at you, Pi), of high-enough quality for us. Even the gluten free crust is excellent: Not crisp and crackery, but soft, somehow chewy. Again, it was slightly thicker than our ideal, but whatevs. That's completely forgivable in light of that surprisingly excellent texture. This must be our new favorite place for takeout on Nantucket. Unless El Rincon somehow magically reopens, I don't think this place is going to have much competition in our family. read more

See all

There are much better options on the island such as Pi. Soggy, flavorless slab of dough.

GF pizza was good. Better than most GF take out pizza options. I would defiantly order again. Wedge salad was not so much. No bacon? Bacon is a Key ingredient of the classic wedge! We added grilled chicken to the salad...again, not so much. The chicken was just not good. No flavor, kind of fake in texture and had a bad flavor! read more

Wow I had a truly terrible experience with the Sophie T's Nantucket online delivery service. Initial order indicated upto 1hr 50 min wait but in the end waited close to 3 hrs for cold pizza. Restaurant couldn't help me ("we don't do the delivery ourselves"), delivery services is a 1-800 number, delivery driver didn't have a hot box. And to be honest, the pizza wasn't good either. read more

Gotta love the Yelper that thinks because he's from Boston he automatically has high standards for pizza. Yea, Pizzeria Regina is terrific pizza (rolls eyes)(rolls eyes again) (rolls eyes a third time). He probably gets excited when his car passes a Papa Ginos. Yup, Papa Ginos is from Boston, too. It is OK pizza. It's made in the NYC style, and I should know that style, having lived there (and yet surprisingly I don't hold NYC style pizza in the highest regard). Good ingredients. What's nice is that Sophie T's offers other things on their menu, besides pizza. They have sandwiches, wraps, and other red-sauce entrees. Prices are OK for Nantucket. It's very hard for these these small mid-island shops to keep their prices low, so kudos to Sophie T's for not branding my bank. There are a few tables for table service, but many customer's opt to get take-out. The staff gets bonus points for being really nice in their very busy and hectic atmosphere read more

Sophie T's Pizza - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Delicious pizza! We ordered 4 pies from here for takeout and thought it was really good! Almost comparable to NY! Only wish they had delivery as we had no transportation! read more

Not sure what I'd do without Sophie T's. A restaurant that serves top notch pizza by the slice until closing? Now that's a rare find. I'm also partial to the Italian sub which is excellent. Special shout out to Mary for friendly fantastic service. They run a tight ship and expedite so quickly the wait is minimal even at peak business hours. They also happen to have my favorite tiramisu on island, you can't go wrong with Sophie T's. read more

You already know that I'm a pizza aficionado always on the lookout for good, NY-style pizza. So it's no surprise that when on Nantucket I'd resume my search for a good slice! Sophie T's is my go to place when in ACK. Good pizza at reasonable (for Nantucket, anyway) prices. Use your GPS to find this place, as it's tucked away in a somewhat hidden shopping center that you cannot see from the main roads. But well worth the extra effort! read more

Horrible and rude! They treat customers like we are doing them a favor. Go here if you want to be treated like crap. My order was wrong and even asked her to double check and it was still wrong when I got home. Several better choices. Almost $50 bucks for cheese pizza and chicken wings. Won't go back. You've been warned. read more

Great food and delivery worked great! We've had it twice over the past weeks- so easy! Thanks for making dinner so enjoyable

Definitely a great family friendly pizza location on the island. The pizza is a standard NYC pizza which is approachable for kids. They have unique slices you can try on the go. The best part of Sophie T's is the hospitality they provide to their guests. Every visit was pleasant. It's refreshing compared to other places on the island. read more

Best pizza on the island and yup also gluten free. Thin crust but lots of flavor in the sauce and fresh toppings. And the cookies are pretty good too. Service is quick and friendly and it is a easy place to get in and out of. read more

GREAT chicken mushroom soup- and the Pigvicious pizza is to die for. Wonderful crust, friendly staff. LOVED IT! read more

Basic and solid pizza. Staff was friendly and working hard to meet the demand. Ordered a take out on a Friday night when it was clear everyone else had the same idea. The dining area is small and, when I was there, full of people. The women working the counter looked frazzled but were polite. Have to admire when you know it must be stressful and someone keeps positive. The pizza is basic but good. A step above Dominos and nothing exotic. read more

We went to Sophie Ts twice while on the island. Delicious and Perfect in a pinch. We ordered the Margarita Pizza and the the Balsamic Chicken the first time around . The Balsamic Chicken was the fan favorite. I would also recommend the Cheese Pizza as well for something simple but very delicious. We ordered this the second time around before our ferry ride home. read more

First time having Sophie T's pizza and I can say it's one of the best we've had anywhere. Great pizza! Fast and hot. Can't wait to order again read more

We ordered one large and two small pizzas for take out. We were quoted 20 minutes on an early Friday evening. The pizzas were ready and hot as promised. The owner (I think) and staff were friendly and attentive. We digged in as soon as we got home and we were not disappointed at all. Great hand-tossed crust. Perfect light tomato sauce. The veggies were tender - not too crisp and not too soggy - a perfect balance. While we didn't eat inside, the interior is super cute and welcoming - not your typical pizzeria joint - a thoughtful and unique decor. We are from Boston and we have high standards for pizza (Pizzeria Regina, Salvatore's, Polcari, and Nino's). We will absolutely return - this place is awesome. Ps - the salads and subs look spectacular too! Pps- my daughter read all of the reviews and insisted that we leave positive review for Sophie's - I couldn't agree more. read more

Good pizza, had a gluten free option that was one of the best gluten free crusts I've had in a very long time.

If you want very good pizza at a reasonable price (Nantucket reasonable), this is your place. We have a lot of guests visit during the summer and you can order a variety of pizzas without breaking the bank. The buffalo chicken pizza is a favorite of my kids. If you haven't tried it, you should. Sophie T's is also conveniently located across from the Stop N Shop on Sparks Avenue. read more

I was treated with very poor customer service. I just wanted to note this. This caused me to choose not to order and I plan to not return. Although we are busy and stressed at work at times. Being kind is simple & remember courtesy is Contagious. read more

I've been here twice now and both experiences were bad: the first time, I got slices for takeout, which tasted old and soggy. Not ideal, especially at $6/slice. The second time, I went in to sit down and the service was terrible. There weren't many people here, but it still took our waitress forever to even get to us and bring water. After ordering an appetizer and some pizzas, we waited over 30 minutes. Finally our pizzas came, but still no garlic bread. After asking multiple times, and lots of waiting, it was eventually brought over. Frustrating for what should be a quick and casual dinner, but ended up taking ages and wasn't worth it read more

Good thin crust pizza. Spicy pepperoni. Garlic bread with cheese & marinara is a keeper! Nice location away from craziness of downtown. read more

Sophie T's is about one thing- quick, cheap, good pizza. There is none of that fancy touristy BS, it's just real good New England pizza. Highly recommended, unless you are looking for frilly tourist pizza. This is just about the only place on island where you can get good pizza for around 10 dollars a head. read more