We got the penne alla vodka and Tagliatelle & Chianti Short Ribs. The short ribs were definitely my…read morefavorite and even though I was really full, I completely finished the plate. We chose to be seated outside in the patio area and it was such a nice setting. The service was also great and I look forward to coming back here.

How lucky am I to have lunch at Gaetano's twice in one week! Until this week, I had only been here…read morefor dinner. We came for lunch on Tuesday and again on Friday because we wanted to pick up a Burke Williams gift certificate nearby--only to discover they're closed on Tuesdays. Oh well, that gave us a good excuse to come back Friday! Gaetano's has a new lunch menu. On Tuesday I had the Salsa Verde Steak Sandwich, and on Friday I tried the Gaetano Sandwich. Both were delicious and definitely won't leave you disappointed--or hungry! She had the Roasted Butternut Squash Ravioli both days and loved it so much there was no reason to try anything else. It wasn't very busy at lunchtime, so we didn't need a reservation. The restaurant was comfortably air-conditioned, which felt especially good on a hot, humid summer day. Great food, relaxed atmosphere, and two very enjoyable lunches in one week. We'll definitely be back!

Margarita pizza was excellent. Service was excellent! The two folks that were working there were…read morevery friendly and appreciative for my business. I will definitely be coming back.

This place is fire !!!!!!…read more Considering the location which is the only done fall Cause they should be a staple in Hermosa or manhattan Pizza and pasta are fresh Italian ingredients used and great service Not a bad thing to say about the food or service stright Italian no fluff One of the best

Small Pepperoni pizza , I thought I had fresh mozzarella, well seasoned pizza. Not at all, The…read moreportion size unbelievable for a family of 3. The flavor reminds me of fresh well blended flavors. Different levels of taste hitting you taste buds. Ordered online and my delivery was great, puzza was still hot and gooey ooey cheese. The fact it wasnt greasy says a lot to me. Crust alone, can be garlic bread. Thats for the ppl of non crust eaters. Cant beat that combo. Over I can tell this place will be one of my faves. I love to try new restaurants. Just from the pics of restaurant Im excited to visit this weekend. I'll post pics for you community snd always keep you posted on my reviews. Trust when one of our fellow yelpers suggest. I do check them out, so many to choose from. But its an Food Journey, that keeps me going. Thank you for stopping by, have a great day.

Got pizza here recently as my husband wanted to try them out. Found it mediocre and walked away…read morerather confused at the high Yelp ratings..

this iz a familystapke food mega style you will take home everything is preped made fresh nothing…read moreshort to say but awesomely savory and well delish i feel in in new york when i go a throw back big on flavors once you come it will not be your last visit ....thank you for your dedication and foodmanship to stay open ...stsy blessed rosario family love your food

I love supporting mom and pop restaurants and this looked like a proper old school pizza place. As…read moreothers have mentioned it's about 25-30 minutes for a pizza if you call in your order so no big deal there.. a small pepperoni can feed 2 or 3 people as it's loaded with pepperoni and has a flaky lightly crispy crust.. it's delicious for sure. Wish I had seen the B health score in the window before I had eaten but maybe it was for the best. The pizza was great and the service was very nice.

Great, no frills spot for a quick casual lunch or dinner. Cannot beat the pricing here for the…read morepasta -- I was stunned since most other Italian restaurants charge at least $20-25 for teeny tiny portions. It isn't the best pasta you'll ever have, but it's good and comfort food style. Service was super friendly and the restaurant itself is cute on the inside. Has the ambiance of a fast casual sit down place so don't expect it to be the date night you dress up for.

best, freshest, healthiest, most mouth-watering italian food, ever... no contest!!!…read more you need to try it to believe it! no brown lettuce leaves or old protein choices... this is not a chain restaurant, & they value & thoroughly appreciate their loyal customers!!! MAMA SAYS' TAKEOUT CONTAINERS ARE ECO-CONSCIOUS & DEMONSTRATE THEIR RESPECT FOR OUR ENVIRONMENT! THE LARGE PORTIONS MAKE IT ALSO MORE AFFORDABLE. love this place!!!

Had food catered. Portion size for 25 people was very generous. The chicken Parmesan was a bit too…read moresalty and not that great. The cheese ravioli were decent. The highlight were the meatballs, those were my favorite. Seasoned well and delicious with every bite. The garlic bread was oily but good. Also had Caesar salad, standard.

Ordered for large catering for 50 guests- got the short rib papparedelle, penne Ragu, chicken…read moreParmesan and bolognese!! All were fantastic and the guests asked where it came from! They delivered right on time. Thanks so much and kudos!

The Food Was Really Good, I Like The Pizza But The Garlic Bread Tasted Like A Crouton. The Service…read moreWas Also Good Too, The Worker Brought Our Pizza Out Too, The Ambience Needs More Work, If You Sit The Very Front Table Inside The Building Like I Did You Can See The Whole Street, But The Place Is So Small That It Only Has One TV In It. Overall This Place Is Good.

Got a Sicilian Thick Crust pizza and a small salad. A very tasty pizza. The pizza crust was crispy…read moreespecially the edge. The sauce had the right balance of tartness and saltiness. The cheese added a nice creaminess. The carrots in the salad were pickled so it gave a little bit of zing to the salad. Service was very friendly and helpful. Dining is available both inside and outside. Parking is available in the street and also in the parking lot behind the store. Between the corner, edge and middle squares, the edge was my favorite.

Best place for pizza with good amount of topping. Pasta is so yummy and we love their meat sauce…read more Their dinner plates are hearty and big. Their dressing is a garlicky red wine vinaigrette. Love dipping my pizza crust in it! Service is good. At busy times, it can be slow but the servers are super nice and apologetic. The restaurant is old skool red booths. It has that Italian restaurant charm. You walk in and you're greeted by the delicious smell of pizza in the oven, tomato sauce, & garlic. Come here asap as they are closing on 12/31!!

Sad to see this place is closing. It was nostalgic. My dad used to take my mom and siblings here…read moreall of the time when we were kids. My dad has passed and we heard this location was closing. We all came to eat here but it was toooooo pack. We did manage to get a table for four but the rest of our party of 19 did not get to enjoy one last meal here. The lasagna was delicious. The pizza felt a little soggy in the middle but it still tastes good. I believe our lasagna came with salad that we didn't receive. But it's okay. Service was great even though the wait was long for food, service and seating. I'm telling you.... It was PACKED!!! The Italian sub was subpar. I expected more. But glad I got the lasagna lol. The fountain drinks were good and crisp. Lots of parking but because it gets packed it fills up quickly. Small spot.

Ghost Town born n raised. We use to have pizza n Corona's delivered to us on the corner. Don't live…read morehere anymore but I had a taste for their meatball sandwich. Walking in this place was a bit amazing. They have come a long way. It's a beautiful establishment, friendly service and the good food was still the same it did not disappoint. My husband n I had not been back here for over 30 years and I can't wait to come back. Sorry no pics

You gotta try the spaghetti very good spaghetti here I highly recommend a must try ! Haven't had a…read morechance to try other things because I just love the spaghetti

Finally tried the Burratino's trendy black onion pizza!…read more One issue we found is that we didn't really know where to park. Update: The black onion really didn't suit my tastes. But I did enjoy the italian sausage and basil. Still so glad I got to try it. I heard many people say that the black onion was sweet, but personally, It didn't taste sweet to me. The sauce was quite overbearing. The comments were right about one thing: it was very tangy. However, the good news is that my family loved it. If the family loves it, then it really has the potential. We loved the ambiance! The restaurant is very clean, seriously spotless. Based on our experiance, we also found the restaurant is empty. The plants outdoors really set the vibe. I love how it feels like you are in a garden. The inside feels like a typical pizza place. Very calming, and cool temperatures. Their pizza is fresh and everything is done well. The service is outstanding. For anyone who is new to the place, the waiters will bring you the pizza after ordering. They came as soon as possible and everything was delivered well. While I wasn't a fan of the black onion marinara, I do believe that we will come back in the future and try a few different pizzas. I am still willing to think that maybe I didn't order the right thing and that there is more flavors to try. Thank you Burratino's Brick Oven Pizza for the good experiance. I am willing to try the restaurant again.

We ordered the Mercedes to get a good sampling of the flavors. Taste did not disappoint. The dough…read moreis a different story -- crust is more tough than chewy, and the edges were more hard than crispy. Service isn't the best. The staff were okay, respectful and helpful, but you'd need to allot about an hour for your takeout order to finish. Can't say anything about the ambience as we didn't stay to eat there. I may want to try it again, but likely not in the near future.