Italian Oven of NY consistently delivers fresh, high‑quality ingredients in every dish. Even items that aren't usually my preference still taste good because the quality really comes through. The service is also very good, whether dining in or ordering takeout. The pizzas are outstanding truly some of the best you'll find anywhere. The crust, cheese, and toppings all feel thoughtfully sourced and well executed. The pastas are also excellent, with that same fresh, clean flavor profile. The only thing that keeps me from giving a full five stars is the inconsistency with the Italian torta dessert. It's delicious, but the presentation varies: sometimes it comes with strawberries, other times it doesn't, and it even differs from table to table. When it's made the same way every time, it's a perfect finish to the meal. Overall, Italian Oven of NY is a reliable, high‑quality spot with great food, great service, and ingredients that speak for themselves. read more

I did a DoorDash order from Italian oven and arrived very quickly. I had a salad and wings. The wings were Thai chili flavor and they're baked! Not fried. Sweet and savory with a smidge of heat. The salad was arugula, goat cheese, sliced almonds, and clementines. The salad seemed a little bit pricey for what it was and I was glad that I had the wings. If I were to order that salad again, I would definitely get some kind of protein on it. I ordered a bottle of Pellegrino not realizing it was a giant bottle and not one of the smaller ones. The pizzas here look really good and I think I might grab one of those next time. read more

Italian Oven of NY - WOOD FIRED WINGS - Italian Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

I went in on a Tuesday evening around 7 for dinner. It wasn't busy but there was no one at the hostess stand. I had to approach a worker about being seated. It took about 10 mins for my server to approach my table. Let's say what went well: Decoration is cute, food portion size good, drink was drinking. Nice and strong. The food came very quickly. And the Salmon was cooked how I wanted it evrn without being asked of my preference. Now the not good. My table was wobbly. The bread I was given was hard. My order was the Salmon Oreganata. This dish comes with spinach and a white wine sauce. This dish needed soooo much more, but the description made it sound so good but execution was not done effectively. I requested fresh pepper which didn't not change anything, as even with the pepper it was still lacking. The salmon was not seasoned and tasted like it was eating fatty meat. The sauce was super tart which made the spinach tart. I added salt to it but it made no difference. I wound up taking it to go but then threw it away. I will not go back. 2 stars given for the drinks and the quick delivery of the food. read more

See all

Cool space. Pizza was light & had good flavor but needed to be thicker in the center of crust to hold up the pizza. They have olive oil on the table too which is nice to dip the crust in. It was cool they had a vegan cheese option. MELANZANE PIZZA was our favorite but the crust was too thin in the center. The staff were nice and well versed in the menu. This place was a little pricy for the portion size and quality since the base price was high and was an additional cost to substitute or add. read more

Italian Oven of NY - MELANZANE PIZZA, & vegan MARGHERITA PIZZA with hot honey ( couldn't really taste the hot honey) - Italian Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Probably the BEST pizza we have ever had in New York area. The pizza is super juicy and tastes fresh. The broccoli rabe mixes so well with the garlic sauce. The service staff is very friendly and attentive. The ambiance is casual and relaxing, we saw two tables celebrating birthdays. read more

See all

This Italian restaurant has a wonderfully intimate atmosphere with low lighting that strikes the perfect balance--not too dark, not too bright. The overall vibe feels romantic and relaxed, helped by the soft, low music and a pleasant crowd that adds to the charm without being overwhelming. It took about five minutes before someone came to our table, but once service started, the staff was attentive and friendly. Our food arrived in roughly nine minutes, and it was absolutely worth the wait. The Alfredo sauce was incredibly creamy with great flavor, and although the grilled chicken leaned a bit more toward the "grilled" side, it still tasted very good. We finished the meal with their homemade tiramisu, which was a lovely way to end the night. The space itself is clean--the floors mostly so, the tables spotless, and the whole place smells fresh. Even the bathroom was clean, which is always appreciated. Overall, it's a cozy, romantic spot with good food, attentive staff, and a comfortable atmosphere. I'd definitely return. read more

See all

I've been here a few times. I've been here for lunch and dinner. Each time I'd had one drink and a small pizza. The first few times I paid $30 for one drink and a pizza. The visit was pleasant, and that's why I went back and recommended other people to visit this spot as well. Last week, I went in for lunch. I ordered one drink and one pizza. My total was $52. I just went to another nearby establishment that has been in business much longer and their lunch deal (one drink, one pizza) was $14. I won't be going back to IO, because they obviously don't know the area they're catering to. There are plenty of other Italian places in this area to get a great lunch deal. read more

See all

Our party had The OPP Pizza Fettuccini Alfredo Penne with grilled chicken Cheeseburger with fries Dessert was torta (similar to lava cake) Everything was delicious, the decor is very nice and staff is very attentive There are 3 TV screens and music playing (great vibe) read more

See all

Ordered takeout from here a few weeks ago and was very impressed. Husband is from the New Haven area and talks down on our Italian food here (I know...) and even he was happy. Decided to dine in last night and the food was spectacular. Really good pizza and the best penne vodka I've ever had. Friendly and fast service too. Seems a bit pricey but you get what you pay for. We have 90,000 mediocre Italian restaurants in the area and I'm willing to pay a little more when I can confidently expect a good meal. Sad that it was super empty on a Saturday night. I really hope they last. read more

Best Italian food in Westchester. As a harsh critic, the food, the service, everything about the place. 10 out of 10 stars. If you haven't tried this place your really Missing out. read more

Italian Oven of NY - Italian Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Had a group of six of us go here on a Friday night. First thing is we got charged an 18% gratuity. Unfortunately, I usually tip much higher than that but felt obligated to go along with that number. I dislike being told how much to tip and usually start at 20 and work my way up from there. Unfortunately the service was OK but not great, probably due to the Self limiting tip factor. We were also concerned that on a Friday night at 6:30 at the restaurant was only about a third full. Great location to the residence Inn where we were all staying for baseball games, but concerning long-term for their longevity. Had the salad and the vinaigrette was true vinaigrette, which was great. Very light Dressing. read more

Wanted to update my review as A/C is up and running, I went for dinner on Sunday and it was great!!!

A friend and I had dinner last night and enjoyed every bite. Clementina salad, meatball sliders and the Ortolana pizza (Zucchini, Fresh Mozzarella, Eggplant, Cherry Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Cream, Parmesan, Shredded Provolone) were all excellent. The pizza in particular had a soft, chewy crust. A really good old fashioned, a few glasses of cabernet, and delicious cheesecake completed our meal, along with freshly filled cannoli. Service was very attentive, and the vibe was quiet and friendly. I would 100% recommend this place for a nice, casual dinner. read more

Went to celebrate my birthday with my family. The staff was great. We had appetizers pizza calamari wings. Those were great. We loved it, but we didn't care much for the pasta. but overall the service was great. The ambience was nice with Christmas season nicely decorated. It wasn't crowded which I was happy about lol. read more

The food is great and the service is amazing. It's a nice chill fun family friendly restaurant.

Not a good experience. I ordered the spaghetti Pomodoro the pasta was too Alden te and the sauce was soupy no taste what so ever. I had to wait for my waitress to pay my check. I which she disappeared for a while not a pleasant experience read more

The ambiance matches the service provided by; fun, fresh, welcoming and vibrant. Their food options was exciting that I wanted to order one of everything just so that I can sample everything. With a lil self control we order appetizers , soup, pizza, dessert and some cocktails. Every bite was amazing. Can't wait to go back! read more

Quick and tasty. Really yummy tortellini soup. Just what I needed. Used to be Fortina. Just as tasty

Menu was a bit limited. Service was friendly. Quality of the food was good, but not extraordinary.

Lackluster pizza. No one in my party liked it. Loud environment. Unappealing decor. Service was fine. There's some very good pizza within a 15 minute drive so I don't really see a reason to return. read more

Our first time there. We ordered a pizza with mozzarella, broccoli rabe, sausage, and hot peppers. It was tasty. We also ordered the Italian salad with grilled chicken and an order of baked clams. The salad was also tasty, but the clams were so salty as to be inedible. We sent them back. The staff/manager couldn't be more accommodating. They apologized and offered to have them remade. Truly very nice. The restaurant was fresh and fun as far as ambiance. It was good, but not good enough for me to drive the 30 minutes or so to get there. read more

Had a late lunch at the Italian Oven on Saturday. the pizza is amazing!!! Delicious hot and fresh from their oven. The arugula salad was fantastic and the dessert torta was to die for. the wait staff was very attentive. the experience couldn't have been better. can't wait to go back. read more

Mediocre food. Nice staff. Good location I hope things get better for them in the future

The food here is delicious! The garlic, oregano, lemon rosemary wings are just beyond! Caesar salad was delicious, great sangria and great service. We sat at the bar and Chrissy was serving us. She was really thoughtful and provided impeccable service which is hard to come by nowadays. Only complaint is regarding the chairs, they are painful but I hear they are replacing them. read more

I came here a few months ago and tried it out and I was not impressed at all with the taste of the pizza, tonight we gave it another try and I'm not sure what they changed but wow what a difference!!! tonight we had the Margherita Pizza, and a pizza blanco for myself and my husband , our friends had the pesto pizza and the AnnaMaria, she couldn't stop saying how great the pesto was with the nuts on it, Steve had the AnnaMaria and he was blown away by the taste. We even took a pizza to go for later, Our server Giovanna was so nice to us, we sent our compliments to the pizza chef with the manager and the pizza chef came by the table to say hello and introduced himself, Caesar was so grateful for our compliments and made us feel so appreciated for sharing them with him. Next time we come in and there'll def be more next times. I promise to try a dessert pizza. Thank you from Julie & Charlie read more

I visited on Monday, 08-25-25. What a wonderful experience. Food, atmosphere and great service. Easy parking and outdoor dining is a plus. I will tell all my family and friends as well as visit regularly. read more

Unfortunately, this restaurant is in the old space of Fortina, which had great food and a much cooler atmosphere. The Italian Oven has mid level food, at best. The server, Chrissy, was very good, however. They made the very poor business decision to have Fox News on the giant tv behind the bar. What a poor choice for any business but especially in an area as diverse as Yonkers. I will not be returning. read more

Fantastic food and the pizza was OUTSTANDING. Great atmosphere and service was phenomenal

This is an amazing restaurant to get the best pizza around. Service is excellent!! A great place for happy hour to just sit and enjoy the ambiance and chat with the friendly staff. read more

Have been here several times for lunch during the week , the food was delicious & staff was great ! Went over the weekend , the food was different and ambience was too loud with club music. Highly recommend for lunch during the week not dinner on a Saturday ! read more

Good pizza, god sandwiches, worth your time to try it out. Nice folksy good atmosphere. Do it.

Went to the Resturant and sat inside with my family, ordered appetizers first and then the waitress took our dinner order everything came out together. The food was not good at all. The wings which were hot wings had an odd flavor, fries were soggy and cold, pizza was undercooked and the cheese and topping slid off the slice, chicken parm tasted frozen or left over. Drinks were basic Pepsis in a sippy sized cup not for adults for over 3 dollars each. What seriously turned me off was the amount of Small Natty bugs flying around the food. Spent half the time swatting them away and trying to be party of the dinner conversation. Every 10 seconds they were trying to take our plates away but when it was time to pay the bill no one around lol. I left feeling sad after we paid the bill .we did not order dessert. I wanted it to be our new local spot but sadly the disappointment of the food, the price for pizza, wings,chicken parm and mozzarella sticks ,natty bugs, thinking how many I actually secretly ate the being interrupted every 5 min asking if we wanted the food wrapped in a Resturant that had 2 other tables including ours.This was my second attempt I went and did take out the first week they were open order was wrong but we ate it anyway figuring it was kinks it's new nope it it was poor quality at an expensive price. And sadly I won't be back. Best of luck read more