Amazing service! funny owner who cares about his customers. great bagel. highly recommend.

The bagels were delicious but the cream cheese use for the lox spread and on its own was off.

Great food, great service, and a very nice environment. Jack may seem mean and nasty but once you get to know him he's just joking around and tryna have fun. read more

We were staying in a beach house close to this spot so decided to try it out. I ordered a toasted sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese. (Note: if you pay with cash, it's cheaper). I also got an iced coffee. They have ample seating while you wait for your food. The bagel was nicely toasted and the cream cheese was good. I wouldn't get coffee again though. read more

Recently came in over a week long trip while renting a house in LBI and had a good to great experience each time we stopped in. The man at the counter was very pleasant when we stopped in for coffee in the morning and chatted us up while we made our cups our way. He also explained what bagels/muffins they had and seemed genuinely happy we stopped in. Since we were only staying a block away, this was a no-brainer for our morning cup o' jo routine. read more

delicious bagels. got the everything egg, so good. wow this hit the spot. sure to be back!

I would give zero star but then I needed to put 1 star in order to write this review. First, zero star for not allowing paid customers to use the restroom . The guy (I guess the owner) was a super grumpy guy. I just paid him $50 for lunch and he would not let me use the restroom! He kept it locked. I had to hold until I got to a rest stop 1h later. Total jerk! I don't like spending my hard earned money supporting a business owned by jerks. Second, zero star for charging $17 roasted veggie wrap with chicken that was inedible because the wrap was totally mushed in the balsamic sauce. I was hoping to eat it in the car while driving home but ended up throwing away the wrap, wasted $17 and starved on my drive home. I'd recommend the owner remove this dumb item from the menu - the wrap cannot hold up in a runny balsamic sauce!!! read more

Best bagels on the island! They are huge and one of the best pork rolls, egg and cheese I've had. I've only had take out from here & they are quick and friendly. read more

Jack's NYC Bagels and Deli - a hand holding a sandwich - Delis Near Me - N Beach Haven, New Jersey

Just what you need near your shore house. For coffee. For a bagel in the morning. For your sandwich for the beach. read more

Jack's NYC Bagels and Deli - Egg cheese pork roll on a roll - Delis Near Me - N Beach Haven, New Jersey

Horrendous service. I order 1 sandwich and a drink and I'm told it's $26, I kindly ask to be explained how my total is $26. I'm then told to relax and calm down when I couldn't be more calm just asking how my total became so high. I'm then told that everyone makes mistakes and I should be more mindful to the cashier since she misunderstood me and my total should be $16. I don't think you should go around telling customers to relax and calm down when all they're doing is politely asking why their total owed is what it is..... very strange, don't recommend this place to anyone. read more

Ordered sandwiches for our entire family this morning - everything was accurate and food was ready fast! Not to be dramatic, but the Taylor ham & egg on everything bagel was the best breakfast sandwich of my life - highly recommend! read more

I was working on LBI, stopped at Jacks NYC Bagels, walked in to place an order, there was a gentleman with gray hair sitting at a table, and a girl standing behind the counter watching tv, the gentlemen looked at her motioned to her, pointing to me. The girl turned looked at me, then turned back and continued watching tv. I think if he was the owner he would have gotten up and said something to her. He just kind of shook his head. Really how RUDE can you be. You are getting paid to do a job. Do it! If I was the owner that rude bitch would not be working with the public. She would not be in my restaurant. To the owner hire someone who wants to work, be sociable, maybe someone that care about your business and they're job. She was really rude! Hire better help. Mark A read more

Great breakfast sandwiches made to order on super fresh bagels! Quick service. Our go-to every weekend!

Best sandwiches in LBI! Jack is awesome! The cheesesteak is incredible. Homemade bread and great quality meat. You must check it out

These people need to go back to customer service school. They are so RUDE. I thought it might have been just a bad day but the three times we were in there it was each time. First they complained about toasting the bagel stating it sets off the smoke alarm and refused to toast it the second day. The third day the counter man was so Rude and made me feel like an idiot for asking for a bagel! Just a bagel! Nothing else, no toasted No sandwich! Then, the menu said they had gluten free bagels and when I asked for one he told me " They don't make them anymore"!!! What a load of crap!!! They are called Bagelino and come prepackaged in a bag! 2 plain bagels and a container of Philly cream cheese for $10!! Oh, I guess I should be honored that He told me to have a nice day! It certainly didn't start that way at this establishment! Very disappointed to support a local business with this kind of service. Maybe the sandwiches are worth but I will not be back! read more

Seriously all the reviews about his attitude.....who cares!! The bagels are really good. I guess this New Yorker didn't mind his attitude and maybe gave it back to him. But his everything bagels with cream cheese is the real deal and a shmear read more

The Scrooge that I'm guessing runs the place is extremely unprofessional and rude. Placed an order for subs with extra pickles and chicken fingers with bbq sauce and they forgot them both and gave us attitude when we went back to get them. I feel bad for the younger staff that works there as it's apparent they are treated just as poorly as the customers that have the misfortune of dealing with this grump. The sandwiches were "sub" par at best and the way me and my family were treated there after the business made a mistake made it clear they don't deserve our business. There are plenty of other places nearby to get sandwiches on the island where they don't forget parts of your order or give you an extra side of attitude. read more

Way to expensive! 35 bucks for two sandwiches that's just crazy The sandwiches were good but if you get a sandwich on a small roll versus a sub. The sandwich should be cheaper. read more

Excellent service and the freshest food. Called in an order the night before and they had it ready for me before the store opened. The bagel sandwiches were still hot and the amount of bacon was more than plentiful. Find your way to one of the 2 locations or both you wont be sorry read more

This place's specialties are a suck sandwich and despicable customer service. If you're looking to indulge in a delicious sandwich served with a smile, look the other way. Jack, I used to dream about being a teacher or an astronaut or a doctor but I've decided my new passion in life is to dissuade any potential customers from ever entering your deli. I was given the wrong order and then refused any kind of refund or exchange. Was given the excuse "you left the store with it". If I ever unravel my sandwich to check for accuracy while standing in the store, call the ward and check me in because that is psychotic behavior. I'm thinking about starting a GoFundMe for the unfortunate employees that are suffering under his reign. Jack is the epitome of crotchety old man and I hope he either learns compassion or his business suffers tremendously. read more

Oh Jack. Where do I start? Genuinely THE worst customer service we've ever experienced. Gave us the wrong order, called to ask if we could bring it back, then was berated by the owner, and denied any sort of refund or exchange. Told me he couldn't help me because I had left with the sandwich. HUH??? Who would ever unravel their sandwich and open it in the store to check before leaving. I'm thinking about starting a deli next door and only hiring the poor souls who work for or have worked for this dimwit. He treats his employees like GARBAGE. Hopefully he pulls the bagel, that must be shoved so far up his ass, out and becomes a decent human being sometime in the near future. read more

This was my first visit to LBI and Jack's. I agree with others' reviews about the store owner. He was rude and unhelpful, which didn't make sense considering our party of 12 spent at least $25 per person for lousy sandwiches and lousy service. Preparation took anywhere from 10 to 30 minutes wait so the entire party ate their sandwiches ate different times which made our time together interesting. The owner never acknowledged the delays probably because he was too full of himself. Too bad the quality of their food doesn't match his ego! My sandwich arrived last, a 30 minute wait, and consisted of a chicken cheesesteak on a roll that could've seconded for a saturated sponge. Don't bother with this place unless you want to overpay for below average food. There are plenty of other better places in the same vicinity. read more

This place will never get my business again. Called to get two breakfast sandwiches and the guy answers with a "what do you want?" The guy who was working in there wasn't just rude on the phone but he continued to be in person. Place clearly doesn't care about customers. I wouldn't of even cared if the food was good but I could've gotten a better bagel at McDonald's. $20 for two dry bagels? I'll pass. read more

Came here for breakfast sandwiches which were pretty good. Reason for the 1 star... the owner berating the staff while we can hear. Yelling and belittling teenage girls because they didn't ring food into the register right is reason enough for me to never enter this establishment again. This grown man should be ashamed of himself. read more

1 star is for the food. Pretty decent breakfast sandwiches. As for the service, the owner/cook is not a nice person. We observed him tell yelling at his staff and treating them poorly, actually made us all feel quite uncomfortable. Would not go back because of how uneasy I we felt. read more

I've been coming to LBI for over 20 years and have tried all the other bagel shops in and near beach haven. These are the best bagels on the Southern End of the island! The bagels have the right proportion of chewy crust and tender inside. They are hand rolled, which you can see in the texture. The toppings are generous and they have a lovely selection of different bagels. If you miss good bagels on vacation, you must come here. read more

Best bagels on LBI with more toppings on top and bottom of bagel than any local competitor

Good food, great service. Walked in for a breakfast sandwich and was very happy. Nice bagel, good portion. Good place to bring my toddler. We loved the BB muffin. read more

"Jack" or whoever the large bald man who seems to run the place is straight up miserable and rude. Now maybe that's the true NYC experience. That being said, the food is Incredible. Take the good with the bad I guess. Pro tip: give it right back to him and he'll cower down and maybe even smirk. I'd eat there again. read more

Delicious breakfast sandwiches! Two fried eggs, cheese and sausage on a toasted bagel. Friendly service on the phone and in person. Will definitely be back. read more