As a former New Yorker, I consider myself an aficionado of great pizza…read more Anytime I'm near Haddon Heights, this is my go to place. The pizza is the best I've ever had! Their Sicilian slice is airy and crispy with an amazing sauce. Their plain slices are just as good. A very impressive selection of pies and an excellent staff make this a must try. I love this place.

Hands down, absolutely, the best pizza and Southern Italian food in South Jersey, maybe all of…read moreJersey. The owner-chef has an inspired take on everything from pizza to steak sandwiches to his amazing wings, as well as a Caesar salad with some of the best homemade dressing I've ever had. His menu even includes an elegant assortment of full traditional Italian dinners. As an Italian American myself, who misses his Nonna's nearly lost own homemade "gravy" every Sunday, I can honestly say we are very lucky to have such an extraordinary, nationally recognized culinary experience in our little but grateful town!

This is by far the best PTO (Johnsarotti) by far We have…read morefamily in Fla. that have driven up just for the Johnsarotti

Heard about this pizzeria & the infamous Jonhnarotti through their reviews on Facebook…read more..... Placed 2 orders & were ready in 15 minutes Very clean restaurant, reminds me of the pizzerias in the 70 & 80's .... So nostalgic! Great memories going for pizza on Friday nights.... Friendly service.... Most importantly Johnarotti delicious! Very light dough, crunchy on outside & soft inside.... Not like your typical heavy pizza dough panzarotti....Large serving..... Only complaint just a little salty but plenty of cheese & sauce!

Ordered a plain pie for a few guests we had over, and I'd heard good things about the King of Pizza…read morespots in the area. Online ordering was easy, and I placed a well done plain pie, though it sadly didn't seem like that part of the order was followed correctly. When I picked it up, the pizza was hot and ready, and the gentleman even read back "well done pie" to me at the counter. Since it wasn't really cooked well done, the dough ended up too chewy and the crust was way too chewy, making it a bit tough to get through. The pizza tasted fine overall, but I've had better elsewhere, so maybe the sandwiches or wings are the stronger items at this location.

Great ponzarotti. Crispy and fresh. Very talkative and personable staff. Will stop here again!read more

5/5 taste 5/5 cool with kids destroying the establishment…read more 6/5 staff friendliness 5/5 tour guiding the menu. Awesome pit stop on our family road trip

This was a gem. We found it while getting off major highways, heading to Rowan University…read more Service was excellent. Many selections of slices. The BBQ chicken and the Italian Trio were among our favorite. Crisp and chewy crust, good seasonings, flavorful sauce. Try the garlic sticks - reminded us of freshly baked pizza crust - so good!

Everything we have tried from this place has been good. My husband loves the mild wings. I usually…read moreget the wing zooms with hot sauce on side. We tried the chicken Alfredo pizza and it delicious. I just had a cheesesteak from here and it was seasoned perfectly. I took a bite before taking the pic. Lol Also great customer service when ordering no matter what time of day. Highly recommend you try their food.

Nice guys and I'm sure they serve some good stuff but it's not pizza. At least in my opinion I'm…read morefrom New York.

Speaking as a North Jersey-born I am going to say that this pizza is beyond exceptional. Stepped…read morein once and had a chat with the owner, who explained to me that his sauce was homemade from his family and that makes it even better and also explains the deliciousness of said pizza sauce. I would strongly recommend this pizza to anybody in New Jersey, not just the unfortunate souls stuck in South Jersey pizzaland. Slices are delightfully generous and still worth the $3 given inflation. A saving grace when funds are low.

Great pizza from a local shop. Great taste, and the size of the pie was a pleasant surprise...def…read morebig enough for 2 or 3 hungry adults. I got a cheese pizza with mushrooms, and the amount of toppings was very generous! If you're tired of small, overpriced pizza from the chains, this will be a nice upgrade. Sadly, I don't live in the area, but if I did, I'd make Montero's my go-to place.

Our company recently moved to a new location, so we've been trying out different Italian and pizza…read morespots nearby. After seeing a few great reviews, we decided to take a chance on Paradise for our Thanksgiving luncheon -- and we're so glad we did. We ordered lasagna, stuffed shells, chicken parm, and cannolis, and everything was gone within 20 minutes. The sauce was incredible, the chicken was tender, and the cannoli filling was perfectly balanced. Our team couldn't stop talking about how good everything was. I've seen a few reviews saying it's overpriced, but I couldn't disagree more. The cost per tray was more than fair -- and let's be honest, everything costs more now. Mom-and-pop shops don't have much wiggle room on pricing, and the quality here absolutely justified the cost. One of the owners, Linda, went above and beyond to make sure we had an amazing first experience with them. We'll absolutely be ordering from them again. Great people and great food -- and it's rare to find a place that nails both. Linda & staff -- thank you for the incredible food and outstanding customer service!

Best Home made meatballs anywhere!! I live in Egg Harbor Twp . Whenever I'm in the area Paradise…read morePizza iis my go to!! Everything is fresh and Home made. The Family Meals are Delicious I have tried everyone of them and they are excellent !! you can't beat the price and large portions !!! Everyone who works there are always Friendly epically the owners !!!

Hucksters. The pizza tastes fine, but they sneak in a…read moresmaller size pizza than you order. It happened to me twice! The first time, we ordered two mediums and when we got home, saw the pizzas were 6 inches in diameter (yes we measured because it was so small!). That time, we called and the manager sent out the correct size to us. We thought that was a nice gesture for an honest mistake. Nope. Yesterday I picked up my large pizza. I thought it felt light when I held the box but I didn't check it either. I mean I trust a place to give me the size I paid for. Crazy, I know. When I got home, I saw they'd actually given me a medium. I paid for a large. So that was the second time. So they're hucksters & do this on purpose. No way will I go there again.

Throwing my Gaetanos menu in the trash…read more Jesus Christ; society needs a reboot to when people gave a damn about things they did and sold, and weren't just trying to do the least work for the most money. Just ordered from here, and my meal was TRASH. Literally, I just threw 6 of my 10 wings ($15 by the way,) straight in the trash. This was AFTER I brought them home, threw them in my air fryer and then sauced them myself. EVERYTHING was soggy as shit. My wings, my cheesesteak. And it wasn't like shit was sitting around; I picked up, and was there so early I had to wait for the food to be made. I shouldn't have to come home and RE-cook my food because it's a sopping mess. Interestingly, the wings and sandwich bread looked like they had been made in a sauna, but the MEAT was dry AF. Just a terrible meal, at $40. Again, WHY WAS EVERYTHING WET?!?? Why did my fried wings have the consistency of a wet towel? Why was my bread dripping through the bag? So upset at this meal. Never ordering from here again. Fool me twice, shame on me. Also, as I was leaving, I noticed that there were TRAYS; like those aluminum serving trays, full of uncooked bacon, just sitting on the counter. Like 15-20 TRAYS of bacon, just on the counter. God knows how long it was there. It should have been a red flag, but my big back ass ignored it. My wife is literally upstairs gagging. Super done with Gaetanos.

Can not say enough about this great place! Staff is wonderful,and the food is always top class !…read more Best pizza in this area ! Will con to get our takeout here!

The pizza and cheese fries are bangin! We order here frequently because it's in walking distance of…read moreour apartment. Recently we tried the cheesesteak and it was ok... lacking on meat and seasoning. The employees are always very friendly and attentive.

Awesome little old school mom and pop pizza place! The "Old neighborhood" vibes! Dang I wanted one…read moreof everything in that case lol! Service was fast!! Philly Cheesesteak and that pizza crust and sauce!! Omg! I can't wait to try more!!!! 110% Fatboy Approved!

Soggy, inedible panzarotti, completely covered in grease. Wouldn't give a refund and justified that…read moreit's because it was fried. I have had plenty of fried panzarotti from other businesses that have never been this greasy. Order from other places, they have better food and customer service.