Jeremiah's is an Jax favorite for us. My youngest can't get enough as she chooses this place over everything else for a Yummy treat. The Italian ice here is good and has a distinct flavor and consistency to Jeremiah. I often find myself trying the new flavor combinations and profiles they have to offer. However, the customer service here is non-existing. They are just not in the business of making their customers fill welcomed. read more

See all

Today was very busy and I thought I must end it with ice cream so of course I hit up the one and only Jeremiah's Italian ice. The service was great and I chose a cookie butter in vanilla soft serve swirl. It was very delicious and great for a cool but sunny day. I loved the cashier because she had great energy and wanted to make sure that I was pleased with how she made both orders. Jeremiah's is always a great way to fill a sweet craving. read more

See all

We get this every time we are in the area. It's open late, the service is fast, it's always poppin. Pleasantly surprised to see they added toppings to their menu. YUMMY read more

See all

I love Jeremiah's Italian Ice especially on a hot summer evening! This location is consistent and always great. My favorite ice flavors include: cookies & cream, cotton candy, peanut butter, cookie butter and caffè latte. The gelati is my go-to. The vanilla and chocolate soft serve are both tasty. I normally go with vanilla since it seems to pair well with most ice flavors. The employees are helpful and polite. Pay them a visit today! read more

See all

I usually go to Rita's, but I was near Jeremiah's so I thought I'd stop in there. Never seems to be anyone in there now. I know why they don't even carry the most popular flavor of lemon ice lemon ice very strange. read more

This was my first time trying Jeremiah's. You go up to the window and order. There's seating around the corner (about 3 tables and a bench). The guy at the window took my order and it came out probably 30 seconds afterward! Excellent service. I think the concept is interesting -- what I got was Italian ice and ice cream mixed together. The texture kind of took a second for me to get used to. The peanut butter flavor was pretty strong, and the chocolate ice cream was yummy! It was dripping all over the place, so I think it would've been nice to have the small portion in a medium sized cup. When I got to the bottom, it was all just chocolate chips. The small was big enough to share, so that was nice! Overall not my favorite, and maybe I would like a fruity flavor more. Still I'm glad I tried it! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Peanut butter favorite small - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I love Italian Ice and my friend is always raving about Jeremiah's Italian Ice, so I was really excited to try this place. I went on a Friday night, and there was a pretty long line, but the wait was pretty short. When I got the window, I was a little overwhelmed by the amount of flavors. They were really nice in letting me try a few flavors. I settled on mango and passion fruit layered with soft served ice cream. I'm not sure if the batch was a little off for the mango, but the flavor was very light and didn't have that mango punch I was looking for. The ice cream was delicious, but I would probably try some other flavors next time. I do like that there is outdoor seating to enjoy your treats. Great location for families or date night. read more

See all

service was horrible gave my friend chocolate ice when she wanted vanilla and punished her by holding her ice cream hostage, she was so hungry. we became so embarrassed we had to hide in the car, where i am hunkered down at the moment of writing this review. and while writing this we heard gunshots coming from the area. i am crying while we speak, good thing we all have our ice creams except for our friend (its still hostage) read more

Went with my husband and son. Hubby placed an order For 3 ices and attempted to pay and was refused because he was paying with a $100. bill. he was told they only take $20s Cash is cash and there's such a thing as pens or lights that detect counterfeit, if that was even their concern. And since it was later in the evening (9:30pm) I'm sure they had enough to make change 10 times over. I'm sorry that's just ridiculous. I left and most likely won't return. and since I'm already annoyed, let me tell you real chocolate Italian ice does not have chocolate chips in it. read more

Oldest treated us to ice cream after we looked at houses with her. I really didn't want a slush or and was surprised to know you could get a soft serve cone. I got the mixed swirl on a cake corn and was very satisfied Better than McDonald cone and the machine works. The workers were very patient and pleasant with their customer as well. read more

Always yummy treats and friendly service. Plenty of seating, although it is along a very busy street. Clean atmosphere and stays open late. Super yummy gelati's! read more

Current fav is the Key West Tropical Gelati - it's a refreshing mix of fruity flavored Italian Ice with soft serve. Don't want the Italian Ice? Get the soft serve. Wanna skip the dairy? Get the Italian Ice. Can't decide or just want all the above? Get the Gelati TIP: Make sure to download the app to earn points & free treats. Theres also BOGO, $ off, % off promos. If downloading an app isn't your thing, you can also sign up on their iPad at the order window with your phone number. read more

See all

Service is always friendly, outside seating, and delicious treats. This Italian ice is SO good and the combinations offered are great. I've been here a few times and everytime, I leave with a smile on my face. A must for this Florida hot weather! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

This place is so good! The cashiers are always very friendly and helpful. They give great suggestions and let you try samples to help you build your perfect cup of Italian ice. I've had Italian ice other places but this places is the best since they have so many flavors and offer choc and/or vanilla icecream as well. 10/10 read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Friendly and quick service! The free samples are great to help you try all the great flavors. If you're not an italian ice person, you can order the soft serve instead and vice versa. The outdoor seating area is the perfect spot to sit in with good weather! read more

Super cheap delicious gelati!!! Gelati (at least according to store description) is Italian ice layered with your choice of vanilla/chocolate/swirl ice cream (almost custard?) and this combination is absolutely delicious. They have a good variety of Italian ice flavors including both classic fruity varieties and others such as cookie butter/cookies n cream/ peanut butter etc. I'm told that their Italian ice flavors rotate so they may have some new goodies in the future. They also give 10% military discount and if you download their app you get a free small size gelati which was good enough to satisfy my sweet tooth. They allow you to get up to 3 different Italian ice flavors. Highly recommend, will try again in the future! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Mango + blueberry + black cherry with vanilla ice cream - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Before I get into this review, I want to give a shout out to Zoe and Sawyer! I believe my family have found friends for life (or until they go off to college and force us to make friends with the next group). Before I went to Jeremiah's I didn't know I had options other than Rita's. My only interaction with Jeremiah's was a pre-packaged ice cream cup that tasted freezer burnt. I wish I had experienced the deliciousness in person first. The samples, oh the samples made it so hard to decide. I appreciate Zoe suggesting her favorites - cookie butter and coffee. I added my special touch of peanut butter, and I almost lost my mind. The creaminess of the ice cream, and the flavorful ice makes for the perfect Gelato. I will try not to make frequent stops on my way home, but I can't make any promises! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Amazing Gelato--cookie butter, peanut butter and coffee with cookie butter crumbles. - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Stopped in here with my girlfriend and her parents for an after dinner dessert. Staff was wearing masks and gloves. It was kind of unfortunate that samples were difficult to do, especially with the long line. Its a walk up place, so social distancing is personally enforced, but you cant order unless you are wearing a mask. They have a ton of great flavors that range from fruity, so decadent, coffee, to chocolate, and you can mix and match however you want. Some are more refreshing and icy. Others are more rich and desserty. Staff is mostly young but they seemed really cheerful and friendly. Its always a good sign when you see local police stopping in for a treat. The prices are reasonable, the service is good, the frozen treats are tasty. What more could you ask for? read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

We went to Jeremiah after Mavi to enjoy our gelatos. What a treat. They do have sugar free options. We beat the kine before the mad rush. Our coupon had trouble scanning but the manager was right there to assist. I had the sugar free sour apple. My wife had the p nutty Gelato. What a wonderful desert to end the night. When in mandarin, do what people in mandarin do Go to Jeremiah's and get a Gelato. You won't be disappointed! We weren't. The end period. read more

See all

Jeremiah's is such a gem! I friend turned me on to them when I first moved to Florida. Now when I am in the area on hot days like Saturday I stop by. I am assuming everyone had the same idea as well as there was a line going toward the street. I didn't mine the line as it gave me time to set up my account for their new mobile app where you can get a small treat for free! The menu they offer provides a variety of options and I was unsure if I wanted to go with a refreshing flavor or a sweet treat which is why I love that you can try samplings. I tried the featured flavor lemon and basil with vanilla ice cream and it was superb!!! I know some may think it sounds like an odd pairing...like the folks behind me in line ; ) However it is a very refreshing creamy taste with the ice cream. It definitely hit the spot! One of my favorite flavors is the cookie butter which my daughter ordered. The staff is always friendly and do a great job of getting you in and out even when they only have one window open. Download the app and come out and try something different, you may end up with a new favorite. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Loyalty app...get a free treat - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

I just love this place. So many choices and you get to sample anything you want so you can be sure it's what you like. We just get it to go because of the lack of shaded seating area. Another tip is if you order a small ask you get it in a medium cup. They fill things so full and it's so hot in Florida that it's easy to have it melt and make a mess, especially if you're driving. It's just so good finding a way to make it work is a necessity. read more

See all

Best Italian ice and creamy soft served ice cream mixed together in a heavily bliss swirl! Yes please! So many flavors and you can test try any of them. If you haven't been you need to go. I don't do sweets but I will definitely do Jeremiahs any day! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Black cherry Italian ice and an Orange Smash - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Jeremiah's Italian ice is a great spot for a sweet treat on a hot summer night. You order at the window, and there is always a line, but they are quick to take your order and prepare your ice. They let you sample their flavors (they have 40+ flavors) if you do not know what you want. I got the cookies n cream and cookie butter Gelati. I thought it was great! I like the Italian ice part more than the soft serve, so I would just get the ice and skip the Gelati next time. My parents enjoyed their Gelatis. They had fruit flavors. read more

See all

Cocoa's favorite place to go! Lol I don't know if my dog loves Jeremiah's more than I do, she's addicted to those little peanut butter pup cups and they are great to help her from overheating in the summer. Jeremiah's is definitely one of my guilty pleasures, I tell myself it's healthy since it's made with real fruit . Passion fruit is the BEST flavor!!! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Cocoa's Pup Cup - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Wowza! I've been here a few times before, but left because the lone was too long. I was very happy to see the line dow, so I finally stopped in. I tried the sugar free cherry ice and it was so good. I meant to order that with gelato vanilla, but I was on automatic mode and told her mango and gelato! It was so good! I look forward to my next visit here. I signed up for the customer loyalty program online as well. read more

See all

I've made it to two Jeremiah locations in two months. It made a great impression on me. Italian ice? Good! Soft serve? Good! My best advice is to get a small size so the ice/ice cream ratio is evened out. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Lemon gelati - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Very delicious. Good Customer Service a lot of stuff to choose from. I would definitely recommend.

Love what this place has to offer for frozen treats. Sweet fruit flavored Italian ice with normally over 30 flavors available, vanilla soft serve, or my favorite - the gelati which is an alternating layer of both. They have flavors for everyone from chocolate to mango to passion fruit and sea salted caramel. They sell gift cards and have an email subscription option for a free treat on your birthday. They are also now promoting an app that when you download, you get a free treat automatically along with a rewards program where you earn points towards treats. They normally have extended hours to fill that late night frozen craving. Lines can get long in the summer but move quickly with the friendly service. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Yesterday afternoon it was a balmy 62 degrees so what a better way to cool off and eat ice cream outside. I have to admit the brain freeze isn't as bad in colder weather. Seriously though my 3 year old loved Jeremiahs Gelati; she had the strawberry Italian ice with vanilla ice cream while I enjoyed a chocolate vanilla swirl ice cream cone. I wasn't really sure about the gelati, but I tried her's and it was pretty good. I had always thought the sign said gelato and never heard of a gelati before; but now I know. Service was great, the young ladies working were very friendly. We'll be heading back to Jeremiahs in the near future; after it warms up a little. read more

Friendly service , clean environment and generous portions! Loved the colorful atmosphere with cute children's art on the walls.

Love this place, the worst part about coming here is trying to decide what to order. Everything looks so good, and taste even better

This place is seriously the bomb. GO- you won't regret it. Satisfy that sweet tooth! Upon arriving, Staff is very helpful and asks if you have been there before. If you haven't they take the time to explain the menu and how it works. It's just a service window in the wall- no interior and a few seats outside to sit at, with a bathroom accessible from outside. They offer lots of flavors of Italian ice (30 plus ranging from mint to mango to cotton candy to cookies and creme) as well as soft serve ice cream in chocolate and vanilla. You can get them stacked together in what they call a "gelati" like we did. I wasn't sure how that would taste but it is so delicious. Hard to describe so you just have to go and test it out for yourself. The soft serve itself is the most creamy I've ever had. This is our go to spot and we will be back again and again. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Stacked Italian ice with soft serve GELATI - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I love bringing my friends and family here! I've been a regular since 2017 and haven't had a bad experience. Their customer service is unbeatable, the girls are very genuine and always offer plenty of samples. I would recommend cookie butter with horchata and swirl ice cream, it's mouthwatering goodness! (Just so you know, you can get multiple flavors together, up to 4 in the same cup!!) Also, the strawberry lemon is the perfect treat for a hot day, sweet and refreshing! Finally, bring your furry friends! My dogs are obsessed with the pup cups from Jeremiah's. They're free and safe for consumption, plus you can get them to-go if you're headed home. Seriously the best soft serve and Italian ice in Jacksonville. Perfect treat for all year round! read more

See all

I would of gave it a 5 stars because I love icecream and then the icecream and icee mix is the at to go. But when I got there I asked for a scoop of icecream and a scoop of icee. The girl at the window laughed and asked if I been here before. I said no. She said it's called a gelati. Okay whatever it's called I want it. Then she asked what size and I asked to see the size cups and she laughed again. I repeatedly asked what the joke was because I'm confused as to why she was laughing. I never been as I told her so I want to see before I order something. But she laughed so hard and walked away so another girl came to the window and took the order. I asked her what was so funny because it's rude to be laughing at someone. She wouldn't tell me the joke. Needless to say if u have someone in customer service, they should be respectful of customers especially new ones. read more

Delicious ice, I usually frequent Rita's since I'm from up north. But this place may be better than them. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Cookie butter ice with cookie crumbles - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

There are a lot of rave reviews about this place so we decided as a family to check it out. They're locally owned (from Winter Park, FL) and have Italian ice and soft serve ice cream. They also have what they call a "Gelati" which combines Italian ice AND soft serve ice cream into a tasty treat! The soft serve comes in chocolate or vanilla and the Italian ice comes in over 40 flavors. You can pick how you want to combine them or they have a popular menu list up front. The staff here is super nice and will explain the menu if it's you're first time. (Which I love! Everyone now-a-days just assumes you've been there before.) We got cookies & cream and the p-nutty. There's several sizes to choose from but don't underestimate it. The small is definitely enough for one or even two people! There's a lot to pack in that cup so save room for dessert when you stop by! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Peanut Butter & Chocolate - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Yummy!! All plus's from me! The frozen ice is smooth and has great flavor and tons of different flavors! The ice cream (custard) is so creamy and you can get chocolate or vanilla! My favorite is to get the gelati, where the two are mixed together in layers! The prices are affordable! A small is $3 and was a good size! The girls working the counter were super friendly and fast! Very happy they opened this one on San Jose (near Outback) :) read more

See all

Is there anything more refreshing on a hot summer's day than Italian Ice?! I think not!! Today was no exception. On our quest for the best afternoon treat, Jeremiah's definitely scores a spot high on the list! Our party of three had several different options: a "gelati" layered with black cherry, vanilla, watermelon, vanilla & peach; a peach and watermelon Italian ice and then a lemon Italian ice. Refreshing and cooling, all were flavors we would try again. So glad we took the opportunity to check Jeremiah's out. We will definitely be back!! read more

WOW! This is amazing! Especially during the blistering heat in the Summer, Jeremiah's Italian Ice is exactly what everyone needs. The "Gelati" combines the delicious crispness of Italian ice with the creamy addition of soft serve. I am SUCH a fan. I originally thought this was going to be an odd combination but it really worked together. The nice thing about the gelati is that you can mix and match different flavors of Italian Ice within your single gelati. I really enjoy this because it allows me to branch out and try new things but at the same time it allows me to keep ordering the flavors I like. Another really nice thing about Jeremiah's is that there is a rewards app that you can download. The coolest part about this rewards program.When you sign up you get a free small treat. I'll say it again. FREE. SMALL. TREAT. Once you have your first taste of Jeremiah's you won't want to stop. These are the flavors that I have tried: Cherry, Key West Tropical, Lemon, Mango, Orange Smash, Passion Fruit, Peach, Strawberry, and Watermelon. Go check them out! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Gelati with Key West Tropical, Cherry, and Orange Smash Italian Ice. - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Summer or winter it doesn't matter. I'll go get some Italian ice. The lemon ice is so refreshing and not super sweet. I love the coconut flavor because it has chunks of coconut in it. Also it's not super sweet and the flavor doesn't taste like those artificial coconut flavor. I like how they have a patio up front to enjoy your ice and the sun. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Bahama freeze - Desserts Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida