I've been to Jeremiah's in the area before and have always had a fine experience. Great place to go to for quality wings. I ordered the wings and was very pleased with the quality and flavor of sauce. They were saucy and crispy. The only thing I don't like is you can't choose more than one sauce for an order of 10, they ask you to order two 1/2 orders which costs more than the order of 10. The menu itself is very limited, wouldn't mind seeing an upgrade with some newer items as the menu has been the same for as long as I can remember. The service was great. Our server was very helpful and consistently checked on us to make sure we had all we needed. Typical bar atmosphere; the restaurant is split into two with a bar area and then a seated area away from the bar. There are TVs all around so you can catch a game from any seat. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Bars Near Me - Fairport, New York

A friend and I went to Jeremiahs Friday afternoon for a late lunch. We were seated promptly and Meg was our server. We had the soup, salad and garlic bread combo and Kenny's Salad with steak. Everything was delicious and service was great. We would have appreciated being offered refills, a minor detail, but I mentioned this on my Google review and the manager replied right away that they would address the issue. I would definitely recommend, especially on the great menu selections! read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Kenny's Salad with Steak - Bars Near Me - Fairport, New York

Service was great, drinks were great. The food was ok, typical bar food, done a bit under typically well read more

See all

Took 40 minutes from the time we sat to get an order of wings as an appetizer. The main food came out a minute later and all of our fries were cold. Our waiter never checked in on us or refilled our drinks. Later that day I got a terrible stomach bug. Not sure if it was connected to the brisket sandwich but it was brutal. I hope this place comes back around and gets better. read more

We enjoyed our dinner at Jeremiah's Tavern. Our server was very friendly and attentive. The meal was delicious and prepared as we ordered.

Nice place and staff. I do miss the chicken and biscuits. Also, there, take out is pretty good, but i have had them goof it up once or twice , but most of the time it's good. read more

Ordered a order of wings at 12:34 and I'm still waiting on the order now this was to go being I was delivering them to my friend who is blind they finally came out at 12:54 not the best service also there was only 12 people in the bar area read more

Service was okay on busy night but servers were lukewarm compared to hostess. Food was just fine as it typically is there. Ambiance was also fine as we sat in bar area. read more

First of all service was AMAZING. I spilled all my hot buffalo sauce but my waiter asked if I was ok helped clean it up and got me a new sauce I got sick from eating the food which was my only downside but I think the food just wasn't sitting with me and it wasn't food Poisoning because I only threw up once and I felt fine after a day. Food was crispy and tasted good while it lasted though read more

Yesterday I had the worst nachos of my life at Jeremiah's. They should take this off the menu immediately. I could do better even if I was very drunk. The nachos came out looking like they had been sitting in the window for a half hour- they probably were. The chips were burnt. The cheese was concealed. I opted to pay the extra $5 to have pulled pork. That was dried out. It came with salsa on the side. The one ounce cup of salsa was only half full. I wondered if they had taken it off someone else's plate. In general their food is decent, but really it's hit or miss if your order will come out right, depending who is working that day. read more

Good atmosphere. Food came out promptly and well prepared. Bar service is pretty poor. No one checks if you need anything.

Very sad. A favorite place for family gathering has slipped considerably. Met whole family for a day after Thanksgiving lunch. Have been to Penfield location maybe 30 times. Service friendly and ambiance great as always. Food was horrible. Wings so overcooked the meat was crunchy, salads mediocre and missing flavor / fresh ingredients. Chili was not the same, very flat flavor. Dropping $230 on a low quality meal stings. Won't be back. read more

My waitress was so nice! her. She recommended all the good items on the menu. She had a great personality and checked on us often. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Chicken wings are amazing! Nice and crispy. Garlic parm - Bars Near Me - Fairport, New York

I worked with food for 30 years. The service I had was so terrible that I waited a full week to compose my suggestions for improving the Jefferson Road location. Since not one food or beverage item was fit to be served to a customer (1 flat beer, a replacement beer that was stale, and 3 different food items) I recommend demoting the restaurant manager, the manager on duty that day, and the entire back of the house staff. No customer should have been served an entire meal, including a replacement item for the initial item that was that bad. The food and beverages were not a little bit off, they were just plain awful. Please note the two of Jerimiah's signature items were not good enough to leave the kitchen door. My "go-to" will not see me return for several months. If I am ever served a meal that bad again I will never set foot in any Jerimiah's. I have been a faithful customer at two locations for decades. I'm not putting up with anything like that again though. Yes, it really was that bad. What a horrible shame. read more

Definitely a sports bar with TVs everywhere. Service was on the slow side but this is not a complaint; we had more time to chat. The Morgan Melt was cooked medium - no option for medium rare was offered (or asked). The broccoli side was excellent- not at all mushy which can happen. The chicken salad wrap was a hit. The soup was tasty. The restaurant was clean. Prices are average for this chain store. read more

Ordered delivery. Got the Jamaican jerk wings and didn't expect them to be dry rub but actually loved them. They were perfectly crispy and I'd get them again. But the blue cheese was very watery and I'm like 90% sure it was crumbled feta cheese in it, not crumbled blue cheese or Gorgonzola. The chunks were pure white and the dressing had no flavor. :/ read more

He menu was ok. The Onion soup Was mediocre, the California chicken sandwich was boring. The restaurant itself was pretty clean until my partner went to the mens room and it was disgusting. It was way too cold inside for the temp outside. Our server was great and very attentive. Probably won't go back. read more

We came in about 5:30 Friday with no wait, and started with chips and dip. Pretty good creamy queso, although cheap salsa and unseasoned bland chips. Server was pleasant, yet she was so slow. Took forever for ANYTHING, an order to be put in, the check, and didnt really check in much. Food was delicious though! I got a Bees Chicken Sandwich, with fries. Sweet and spicy sauce, with crispy seasoned fries! My partner got a ruebon and also thought it was delicious, but caught a little bit of fatty corned beef. Definitely shaved too far, should've stopped before catching that fat. Overall yummy food and beautiful restaurant, just wish our server had some fire under her. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Bars Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

Fabulous staff. Limited parking. Food was good. Complaint that the place looks like a dive. Tables and floors sticky. Dislike places my shoes are sticking to the floor. Cleaning should be a priority for all restaurants. Poutine was good. Drinks were good. It's your typical bar. Offers food late which is nice after attending a local event. read more

See all

Good food and very friendly waitress-good experience. Their Cole slaw was great as well as the Schnitzel sandwich. Chicken wings were good too. We'll be back. read more

I was Jones-ing for some Fish and Chips to celebrate the Big F1 race that happened in Britain earlier today. I prefer to call it Britain over great Britain because I feel like calling it great Britain is a little "braggy", but that's just me. Anyway, Jeremiah hooked it up with some fresh fried haddock and chips, although I was a little disappointed you don't get one large fried chunk of fish, but 4 separate pieces. With that being said, the flavor and crunch were there, which is ultimately what I'm looking for in a good fish and chips. I was also stoked to see they had the ellicottville blueberry wheat beer as I've been trying to get this for a little while now. Recommend the beer and the place. Hats off to Jeremiah himself. read more

Since the early 80's I have had countless meals at Jeremiah's on Monroe Ave. Today I visited Jeremiah's in Penfield. I ordered what was supposed to be boneless wings but instead I was served round chicken nuggets. They were not made in house by any means. I was served frozen pressed and formed fried chicken scraps that were thrown into a fryer to heat them up. They tasted like garbage. Jeremiah's used to be the gold standard for wings in Rochester. Boneless chicken wings were made from fresh chicken breasts which were cooked in house and were delicious. Very disappointed! Horrible experience. read more

Had lunch with a girl friend who suggested Jeremiah's for lunch. I was never there before and was pleased with the casual, tavern ambiance. The food was very good. I had French onion soup with an order of chicken wings. Both were delicious. My friend had her usual bacon cheeseburger and really enjoyed it. We were both hungry when we got there and were happy with ease of ordering and how quickly our lunch order was served. Looking forward to going back. read more

We have had reliably good meals at the Fairport location of Jeremiah's. The only negative we had on our last visit was our kids macaroni and cheese came out cold, and she commented on it, which meant it was really cold because she otherwise would just scarf it down. Prices are very reasonable, service is good--not great. The dining area is moderate noise wise. The bar is always busy when we have gone. read more

The staff is always friendly and efficient. The food of coarse is the best. Always a pleasant to come meet friends and relax. Thank you read more

Came here after church at 1145ish. Was seated quickly and our waitress, Joanna, was friendly and attentive. We ordered the starter, pretzel for my bf's son. It came out quickly. We had two wraps and shared them. Good food, and good service. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Apple-Pecan Chicken Salad Wrap with a side of Mac salad. We shared both wraps and ate 1/2 each :) - Bars Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

Kids mac and cheese wasn't up to par. It was literally cavatappi pasta, dry with some cheese thrown on top. No creamy mac and cheese, just dry. Kid was disappointed. Service was ok, it could have been better. No one screamed enthralled to be there. Waiter seemed annoyed that the restaurant was out of some things. Ambiance was meh. It was a little bit warm inside. Wings were good. read more

Bar food! Buttery pretzels and the Reuben had a lot of meat to it. Very busy place. Somehow we were seated with no waitress assigned but one of them finally wondered over to us and took care of us even thought she was taking care of a very large party of teen volley ball players lol read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Reuben and garbage plate - Bars Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

I went in to get a table for myself and 3 friends. At 11:40 AM, it was FAR from busy in the dining area. I waited over 15 minutes for the hostess to come out of the bathroom to seat me. I told her we would need a table for 4. She grabbed the menus and silverware settings, walked me to the table, and put them in the middle of the table. I placed them at each seat and realized she only gave me 3. I asked her for another one, and she said, "I didn't hear what you said." She came back and flung the items at me, and i placed them on the table as i had with the first 3. My friends arrived and we gave our server our drink orders. She was gone for quite a while after bringing them and coming back to take our orders. The food runner or cook brought our food. Still, it wasn't busy... but she came back only once to ask if we needed anything and disappeared again for a long time. She came back and asked one friend if she needed a box to go. My friend replied yes, and the server disappeared again for a while. When she finally returned she handed the box to the friend who asked for it, ACROSS THE FRONT OF our other friend WHILE she was STILL eating. We finished our meals and got our payments out to pay. She looked over at our table once, and we didn't see her again, once again, for quite a while. By this time, it had gotten busy. I had to go over to the POS area to hand her our check and payment. We couldn't just leave the money on the table because I was using my card. We are very patient and appreciate our servers and food service workers, but this experience was abysmal. I can say there were no complaints about the meals. The food saved the rating, making it 3 stars. Our server was tipped well, mainly because my friends didn't have payment closer to the amount of their orders... If it had been busy, we could possibly justify the less than satisfactory experience, but it wasn't, and we can't. read more

Good food and good location. Both our meals were great but these pretzels, WOW! I complimented them to our server and he informed us they were homemade, you don't hear that very often so that just added to it. Good service as well, I cant remember his name but we had a very pleasant time. read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Pretzel app - Bars Near Me - Fairport, New York

Called in a pick up order for 10 people. The food was ready when promised and everything was in the order, nothing missing! Food was very good and hot. The place was very busy when I arrived to pick up the food but the order was ready and waiting and the staff were very friendly. Will be returning for sure. read more

Ok let me say it was really busy ! I got chili and salad to be safe because I'm picking. The chili was cold sent it back when I tasted it I realized it was odd tasting not your normal chili I guess very thick hardly any tomatoes not sure of meat but don't think I'll order that again. The salad had rot spots I didn't want to complain because already sent chili back. My friend got French onion soup it was cold and onions were crunchy textured. They didn't want to complain because they are regulars for wings! I guess if u need good food it should be wings! The waitress is the only reason I gave stars she was great and tried best being busy read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Side Salad - Bars Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

Morgan waited on our surprise birthday party of 10 people and didn't miss a beat . We were all over the place with our balloons and orders and nonsense, but she sailed through it with aplomb . We started with apps and drinks and finished with 10 entries - all presented professionally in a timely manner despite the chaos. The hot nachos were fabulous as were the Mandarin salad, the Cajun fish fry and the Brisket melt. We were allowed to bring in our own birthday cake and decorations which made for a great party. Thanks for providing your special room and an outstanding waitress to make our friend's 80th birthday so memorable. read more

I have tried this restaurant three times and it still falls short. Service is spotty, sometimes you get a nice greeting, other times it's impossible to get service. The food has been too cold, too greasy, and one time served to a toddler scalding hot. Beer selection is good. Bartender service is usually okay. There is a faint odor like a wet cleaning rag used to wipe down tables that isn't clean. There are two dart machines, but it is not a real "game bar" atmosphere. read more

Lindsay manages the bar and bar area and is stellar. Remembers your name and drink and provides overall great hustle and service.

The French onion soup was not good, it had a alcohol taste and the onions were so crunchy.. the cheese on top was hard to get down because it was so mushy, the onion rings were actually really good and the servers were very nice read more

Jeremiah's Tavern - Crock of Ellie's French Onion Soup - Bars Near Me - Fairport, New York

Worst wings in Upstate NY, unless they served me some that were cooked last night and left out overnight.

I would give this 0 stars if possible. We were told a 20 minute wait. That easily turned into an hour, and people coming in after us with the same amount of people were getting seated before us. We even asked where we were on the list, and we were told we were next. We then watched everyone in the lobby get seated, except for us. Then to top off my experience, the young girl behind the counter in the Syracuse hoodie grabbed our menus and tossed them on the table without saying a word to us. She also did not give us utensils. She was so quick and ahead of us we did not even see where our table was and had to double check where the menus were placed. I have never felt so disrespected at a restaurant and as I understand people have bad nights, she was plain rude and the waiting more than double the time was ridiculous. I have been coming here for years and will not be returning for a long time. There are way too many places to eat around here where I am not treated like garbage by the staff. EDIT-- I ordered 12 wings and was given 10, but paid for 12. read more

I stopped by for a burger today while a buddy mine and I were out running errands. First of all, I would like to acknowledge Alicia, our server. She was very friendly, extremely helpful, she's definitely a professional bartender, Thanks Alicia. She is the reason I'm giving five stars. I had a Burger and nachos, everything was delicious! Well done Jeremiah's Tavern! read more

See all

Heard so many good things about this place that we thought we would try it last Saturday evening. Wait staff were wonderful but the kitchen was slow in delivering our appetizers. The quality of all the appetizers were sub-par, except for the one order of chicken wings. Everyone was disappointed and wished we went somewhere else. And my iced tea tasted moldy and the place looked like it needed some cleaning. Unfortunately we will not return. read more