Never again! I've loved Jersey Mike's for years and after the bread recipe changed about three years ago after Covid, it's just never been the same. Gave it another chance last week and was served a paper thin sandwich for $22 on rock hard bread. What a waste of time & money. It's a little annoying that they want to make your sandwich while ringing you out so you have no way to see what they're putting on your sandwich. They absolutely drench their sandwiches in oil and vinegar adding at least another 500 to 1000 calories and then proceed to get frustrated when you ask them to go light. What a shame because this place used to make the best sandwiches ever! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

Customer service was horrible. I went in to pick up a sandwich that was ordered on line, and the young girl that was working there was so rude. She literally threw not only my sandwich in the bag, but did the same to two other customers waiting next to me for their orders. She yelled out our names and threw the bags on the counter without even looking at us and she just walked away. She was this young blonde obviously having a very bad day and taking it out on the customers. This happened this evening in Castle Rock, February 18th at 7pm. I mean, if she hates her job, don't work there. Whoever the owner is of this shop should be ashamed of the service that is provided by the kids that are hired. read more

My favourite sandwich at the moment. Fantastic service. Great job by the employees here- they really make a difference, and in Castle Rock- that's saying a lot! read more

Wheres the meat? Our #9 was noticeably short on meat today. First time this has happened, better be the last!

The food sandwiches are real good- bread / meat / condiments. Of course no French fries, as is common for sandwich shops. That is a shame. Why should burger joints have the monopoly on this most popular food item? The atmosphere is not real good- cold- bland- chilly- bus stop seating. Would rather just treat this place as a pickup and take home or eat in my rangerover and listen to Sirius XM. A tad better than jimmy John's. The local owner of Jersey Mike's is a good man and the corporate founder is philanthropic. All good reasons to patronize. read more

I ordered takeout with a friend of mine recently. This Jersey Mike's is located in a strip mall shopping plaza, near the Outlet Mall in Castle Rock. You can see the backside of it as you drive down Meadows Parkway. There is plenty of parking in this lot. The interior is clean and ordering is seamless. I ordered a Mike's Famous Philly. It comes with grilled onions, peppers and white American cheese. I also ordered a regular size. This size was sufficient and filled me up. I didn't feel stuffed after eating it. This cheesesteak was good. However, I feel another sandwich shop in CR offers a better cheesesteak. I will most likely return here and order the Portabella Grilled Cheese Steak. They also offer fountain drinks here. I believe they're Pepsi products. I've always been a fan of Jersey Mike's so no surprises for me here. I also love their Original Italian. It's probably one of the best I've every had at a chain restaurant. Keep up the good work! I plan on being a returning customer. read more

I've never had a bad sandwich from any Jersey Mikes, but this is my favorite location. The sandwich always seems fresh. The service has been great and fast even during the busy hours. Give them a try, you'll like it because I said so! Don't pay any mind to Beth A's review, she's obviously PSYCHO!!! read more

Been ordering delivery from this Jersey Mikes for around 2 years now, about 1-2 X per month. Usually 4 sandwiches every time. Sometimes 5-6 to feed any workers helping us. For the most part, everything has been great. Had one mixup where they delivered someone else's order, which was a bit disappointing, but overall the quality was good. Which brings me to this afternoon. Placed delivery order through Jersey Mikes App at 3:27 pm. (Ordered early during light traffic period as previous mixup was around 5 pm.) App said order would be delivered at 4:11 pm. Called Jersey Mikes at 4:30 pm when no delivery. They said the order had not been picked up by Door Dash. I said I ordered on jersey Mikes app, not Door Dash. They said they use Door Dash. Called Door Dash. They said the order was just picked up. Not believing Door Dash, called Jersey Mikes to confirm at 4:45 pm. The order still had not been picked up. Jersey mikes said they'd deliver the order themselves and give it to us free. We thought this sounded reasonable. At 5:25 pm still no delivery. Called Jersey Mikes. They said they could not legally make deliveries and that the order had been cancelled. We asked why they had said they would then with no satisfactory reply. We said we definitely did not cancel it. At this point, we asked for our money back. They refused. We called Door Dash. They said the driver had cancelled the order. They said it should be Jersey Mikes who refunded our money. After 2 hours of runaround, Jersey Mikes finally agreed to provide a refund but needed ALL my card info, including the 3 digit code, which made me wary, but which I provided. Waiting to see what if any refund is provided. Nothing has hit my card yet. What a nightmare. To be treated this way after all the money we've spent there? Never going to any Jersey Mikes ever again. read more

My kids love this place! The kids sandwiches are the only food that I can get them excited to eat out. My son said he would give this place 10 stars :) The food is great. The service is friendly. The place is clean. read more

Made fresh and to order delicious from end to end! Great service immediately warmly greeted and attentive. Clean restaurant simple plenty of room to sit and enjoy your meal. read more

He likes this place for sandwiches. When faced with a choice between two places be always picks this one. I tag along because I need to eat too. Love the hand sanitizer for those who want it. The servers are friendly and made our sandwiches quickly. I couldn't decide between the tuna and BLT sandwich until I was asked at the counter. I chose the BLT because always choose bacon. When in doubt choose bacon. They made my sandwich really well. Crunchy bacon and not too much mayo or tomatoes and lettuce. Biggest pet peeve is lots of lettuce that you can't even taste the tomatoes. Good meal. Clean place. Would recommend. read more

See all

Sandwiches never disappoint and staff is always friendly. Our go-to for subs on concert nights.

We visited the Castle Rock store. It was empty with 6 staff hanging around in the back. The store had trash all over, the trash cans were overflowing, the bathrooms were dirty and there was so much debris in the food prep area (floors and counters) that I'm pretty sure there was a health code violation happening. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - food debris all over the floor - Fast Food Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

See all

Employees have always been nice to me and go above and beyond to give good customer service. I think that it's kind of a shame these guys don't get any awesome attention for how much of a good job they do. I wish that so many more people would know about these guys. You don't have a lot of employees nowadays who are willing to strictly make sure that the customers have a good experience. read more

Just had a great experience with the manager of the Castle Rock location. The gentleman's name is Richard and he gave me such great service on a catering order. He was so personable and I enjoyed him as well as the service I received. I am sure if you go there you will get the same great service I received. Thanks Richard!!! read more

Last weekend I walked in then walked out. None of the teenagers behind the counter had masks on, even though this location's been pretty good about it all this time. It was very disappointing, I love their food, but NO thanks, not in this climate, I took my sammich lovin' self elsewhere. read more

Love their sandwiches! Go there at least once a week and get my usual sandwiches!! The service is also good

Usually love jersey Mikes, but I recently went in and had a not so great experience. The costumer service was not great, but this wouldn't have been much of an issue. I'm not one to complain, but when I got back to my job with my sandwich there was a huge hair wrapped in it that can't be mine. I called asking for a refund because I didn't want to eat it, and I was told nothing could be done because I used a gift card to pay. That's understandable, but I was offered no further solution. Not even to come grab another sandwich. Guess I'm out $13. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwich with hair. (I have blond hair it can't be mine) - Fast Food Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

We have loved jersey mikes for years but my last two experiences at this location have been enough to make me not want to come back. Last time they charged my card twice for the already pretty over priced sandwiches. Fine, I called them they credited my account the extra charge. But today, at 7 weeks pregnant, I CANNOT eat undercooked anything or deli meats because of the risk of neural tube deficiency in my growing baby, so I ordered a hot chipotle chicken sub. Well after a few bites I knew it was off. Sure enough, the sandwich is full of raw chicken. So not sure if it will be morning sickness or food poisoning that I'll be throwing up from tomorrow. I have tried to call them (23 times) and their phone is off the hook. It is unsafe to be serving customers not just undercooked but completely raw chicken. Ironically, the same employee who charged me twice last time was the one on the griddle. I am incredibly unhappy and at the very least, I want a refund on our $30 sandwiches. read more

See all

Unexpectedly good! The husband is a Philly cheesesteak fan, or I frankly wouldn't have tried yet another sandwich shop. I was pleasantly surprised. It was clean and cool inside, gave fast and friendly service, and offered sandwich options a little out of the ordinary. Great place if you're thinking "not another burger" or "please no more ham sandwiches." I'm looking forward to trying some of their interesting sounding cold sandwiches. Who puts pepperoni with roast beef? I'll try it. We went with the hot sandwiches this time. I tried the chipotle chicken sandwich. Husband had regular cheesesteak. They were both quite tasty, melty-cheesy, somewhat sloppy, and utterly good. Perfect for a heartily straightforward weekend lunch when we tired of running around the outlet mall. I couldn't finish my "regular" size sandwich, but the husband did! Their side dish is a small bag of chips, like Subway. They have cookies for dessert and a few more options like brownies - kids would love them. If they had another menu option or two as a side, that would bump this review up even more -- but heck, I already couldn't finish the regular sized sandwich by myself and left pretty full. Tip: they have online coupons sometimes (check out couponsherpa.com - we got a BOGO sandwich coupon there a few days ago, and today they have a promo for free chips and drink). If you sign up for their rewards club, you get a free sandwich. We plan to come back. Nicely done, Jersey Mike's! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Half my chipotle chicken sandwich - cheesy and not too spicy - Fast Food Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

This review is about the entire experience I had today with Jersey Mike's. Specifically this location as I have never had issues with others. I called and ordered ahead and after arriving, I was the only individual in the store while other orders were being made. There were approximately six employees working. None acknowledged my arrival or asked what I needed. I waited roughly 5 minutes before one of them asked what I needed which was the sandwich that had already been ordered and was ready waiting on the side. The other issue I had was once I arrived home to eat my sandwich, I began eating and in the middle of my sandwich was a long blonde hair roughly 8 to 10 inches. No one at my home or that I know has that color hair or that length of hair nor is there any possible way for it to end up in the middle of my sandwich. I am not sure what sanitation methods or hairnets are required there, however if hair is falling out and into peoples foods then that needs to be addressed in whatever way necessary. Very dissatisfied with my experience today and discussed with finding hair in my sand which! read more

See all

I LOVE Jersey Mike's, I love all locations and to me this is the sign of a good business. They're all consistent AF and that's what I love about this place. Every location I've ever been to is clean, service is friendly and competent, food is delicious and fresh. This location is no exception, we eat here like once a week at least I feel like and it's always worth my time and money. I love that the bread is almost always warm and soft, meaning fresh baked! They have THE BEST hershey's kiss cookie - at first glance it looks like a normal check out cookie, but they're honestly so soft and so delicious! My 1 and only Jersey Mike's complaint is that they're Pepsi vs. Coke :/ read more

I was here today keep in mind in the middle of a pandemic and saw the man cutting the meat whip sweat off his forehead then continue to cut meat and make sandwiches without sanitization. They also cut my sandwich with the same knife as the sandwich before thus mine had mayo and mustard all over it from the previous sandwich. read more

The sandwiches were good but the order online and pickup were less than desirable. The online order was a 30 minute wait , which is OK, and when I got there no one could find my order which was prepaid so one employee was looking through the computer system and found several online orders that were not printed. When I asked if my order would be ready soon now that they found it he said "NO" like why would I ask? While waiting there for about a half hour I watched the walk in line go through several times which I mistakenly thought that they might want to get my order done which was ordered and paid for an hour earlier? My advice is they are need of training and management that can address these issues. read more

My husband and I ordered the #5 giant size sub. Our sandwich artist's name was Keegan. He did an exceptional job. My photo is blurry because I was sneaking it. But it was the prettiest sub we've ever had made at at Jersey Mike's! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Perfectly made #5 sub made by Keegan at the Castle Rock, CO store. - Fast Food Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

Came in 15min to close and they were out of bread. It was my 2nd time at Jersey Mike's. Pretty disappointed.

I ordered a wrap, when the girl handed it to me, I specifically asked if it was a wrap, she answered yes. NOPE, on bread. Plain and simple- lazy! read more

Good consistency in both food and service. The team of young people serving are both well trained and courteous . Thank you to making my monthly sandwich run always perfect. read more

Jersey Mike's is now my goto place for a Cheesesteak! I love the Big Kahuna with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and mayo... Yum yum! The Big Kahuna comes with double cheese which is just the right amount for a sandwich of that size. And the grilled onions and mushrooms are tasty! I always ask them to leave out the jalapeno's and the green peppers -- not to my liking. You won't find a better Cheesesteak in Castle Rock! read more

Excellent food! Always tastes fresh. Store manager is very helpful in finding something you would enjoy! What a character too! Funny guy. Store seems very clean and well kept. Bathrooms have never been dirty on my visits. Floors clean, tables wiped and cleaned. Overall a great place and well managed! read more

We usually love Jersey Mike's but this location is terrible. Last time we ordered, our pick up order was 30 minutes later than promised and none of the sandwiches we received matched the ones we ordered. Don't come here. read more

We usually like it here. Though today was like giving instructions to toddlers. There was not one person that seemed to know what they were doing. My order was completely wrong and not on gf bread as I asked. I get it if these are teens on their first job, but there seemed to be no order to anything. These guys need more training. read more

Love their tuna. Fresh and tasty. Have tried their Reuben, their Meatball, their Cheese Steak, and their Italian. All were excellent, four star. I would have preferred Cheese Whiz on the Cheese Steak but I have been spoiled by many visits to Philly. I tailored the Italian to own taste ... not a big fan of capacuolli so they put on extra salami and pepperoni. Highly recommend it for delicious subs. Must try the BLT! read more

Not only that, but we've been back last week twice since (~$120) and those two experiences were equal to the first. Excellent quality and quantity for the money, fresh rolls (great Udis gluten-free), and consistently exceptional service. Great food and a fun buying experience. Your crews are obviously well trained. They act as a team, are very knowledgable with suggestions and options, are friendly, smiling and efficient, AND actually enjoy working at your store. What a concept! Whatever you're doing, keep doing it. This store beats 95% of all your competition hands down. read more

Sandwiches are usually an "at home" venture for me, but good to have found a sandwich shop that makes it worth leaving the house for. I've determined to never set foot in another Subway (sorry guys, but NOT fresh and plastic bread make that any easy choice), and Jimmy John's has turned me off more and more....time for a new sub shop. Jersey Mike's Club Supreme (done Mike's way of course) was delicious (the roast beef was a nice touch to the standard club) and filling. Cost wasn't too shabby considering the amount of food and the freshness of the meat. I'll be back to sample another sandwich with eyes on a hot offering next time. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Jersey Cup - Fast Food Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

See all

And sliced meats. Piled high. Good tea. Kids meal pretty good with cookie included. Staff friendly bathrooms clean. Lots of selections.

This shop has great customer service, it's fast, top quality, and team of employees with great attitudes. It's always a treat to get a great Jersey sub. If you haven't ever tried it your missing out. read more

Always order online orders and nearly every time i have they always screw up the order. Never pay attention to the order, there's at least 2-3 things wrong with the order every time. If I did something wrong at my work I would be scrutinized. Do better. Read the order and get it right the first time so you don't get bad reviews like this. read more

Pretty decent place to get a sub sandwich. The restaurant isn't that busy so ordering is a breeze and I have never gotten my order messed up! Also you can add toppings to anything on your order which is pretty nice! The prices are super cheap and it's way better than subway or jimmy johns! I do believe that they could have more options for their crisps they serve with the sandwiches but that's not a big deal! Also you can get a really good deal with a coupon. I got a sub, a bag of crisps, and a soda for only $10! So good place to eat a good sandwich sub in Castle Rock :) read more

I've been in other locations, but Castle Rock is always staffed with super friendly people! The owner is awesome & so is the Manager Noah! Every week I'd order the same sandwich & the manager noticed that. He kindly suggested I try his favorite sandwich & when I did It opened my eyes. Everything on the menu is delicious & the people are very professional! read more