This is a great place! The employees are very friendly, and the subs are fresh and delicious. A nice spot to eat a good meal that will fill you up for around $10. I like getting a regular sized club sub. If you join their Shorepoints rewards club, you can earn free eats as well. Get some! read more

I love this jersey mike's location! The food is delicious and the employees are so nice!

I have to say that its been a long time since I've been to a Jersey Mike's. I went there today for lunch and luckily for me, I was there just before the lunch crowd and didnt have to wait very long for my food. I ordered the turkey club wrap with lettuce, tomato and onions and it was very good. I'm such a sucker for wrapped sandwiches. The only negative thing about today's visit was that the wheat wrap that I got today was a little dry. By the time I finished the second half of the wrap, the sandwich was falling apart on me. But overall it was fantastic. Good thing this place is just around the corner from where I work. Now I know where I want to go if I want a good and delicious wrap sandwich for lunch!! read more

Oh my gosh, most delicious Italian sub I ever had. It was served up all fresh like a deli, and the dressing they used on my sub was fantastic. The staff was extremely friendly. I can't wait to get hungry later since I have left over sub because the giant was bigger than I expected. I was expecting a 8-10" and they served me that, I was happy with it. I will be back again soon. read more

My wife would give this place 5 stars as I walk in and out of here without it sticking above the rest. The good thing about this place is the dining room is very nice and the food is fresh. It just doesn't stick out to me. I like toppings and so I like to have a variety of things in my subs. This place simplifies things for you and that is not me. My wife on the other hand loves this place and has a #9 picked out as she walks in. I got chipotle steak that was ok but could use mushrooms and a little more cheese. The meat was juicy and the sandwich was made pretty good. It was a little light at one end but butter than some sub places. I would rate this place on par with the other sub places in the surrounding quarter mile here. My choices sit closer to 70 on Rome Hilliard if I want a sub. read more

I have eaten here once a week for the last 2 years. The food at this location is always good but there are a couple of things that bother me (yes, I understand this is just a sandwich shop and not 5 star dining). My primary issue is with the employee with the silly long goatee who may or may not be the manager. Thus far I have been able to put up with his sourpuss demeanor and his apparent inability to be able to cut a sandwich all the way through. But today a father with a special needs son politely asked how much longer it would be for his hot subs. Mr. grumpy checked and told him they would be right up. He then said to the next customer, within earshot of the father, "It's an I Want it Now World" and shook his head. This was unnecessary and unprofessional. I think I'll find another Mike's or a Jimmy John's nearby with kinder employees and bread that is sliced clean through. That is all. read more

The subs are fantastic. Most of the employees are friendly. All but that older bitter type lady. She's not so friendly. But she won't stop us from going here. Subs may be made with hate, but they're eaten with love. read more

Our family really love the different sub shops around Hilliard but this Jersey Mike's is definitely a favorite of ours. The subs are very good and the staff has always been very friendly. I have to give a special shoutout to Wayne who is one of the managers there. Wayne makes some of the best subs, I've ever had. I'm a big fan of Philly cheesesteaks with a little twist (add some pizza sauce). Wayne made a simple suggestion to my order and I went with it. I knew if Wayne was doing the cooking, the sub was going to be good. I definitely was not disappointed. I'll be eating the #43(Wayne 's Way) from now on! read more

The first time I came here I actually forgot my wallet. I already ordered a giant sub. They gave it to me for free! What a nice surprise that was! What made it even nicer was the fact that the sub was so delicious! I got a Ham and provolone sub with mayonnaise, onions and lettuce. They have some of the best mayo I've ever had. The store was very clean and the employees were extremely pleasant. This is by far my favorite sub place. read more

Sandwiches are delicious and the staff is very friendly but tonight was the second time we show up around 8pm to find out they ran out of bread. It's a fifteen minute drive so we are very disappointed read more

Definitely not the best sandwich ever,but everytime I go here I find myself being suprised I dont remember how good it is.Id go there more often if it wasnt so expensive(like 10 for a giant meal).Also its one of the only places I can get my pastrami and corned beef on! read more

Great service and subs. Much better than Subway. Started in business before Subway! Free sub on your birthday. ..sign up online.

Shared a Chipotle Cheese Steak and a Meatball and Cheese. Not sure of the price as I didn't pay. Both were alright - kinda bland, squishy and greasy as hell. I prefer Subway's meatball sub tbh, and I'm not a fan of Subway by any means. Guess I'll stick with Quizno's when I'm in the mood for a sammich. read more

Subs are good....not great...but pretty good. More subway than penn station but better than subway. But a little more expensive too. Service is mediocre and it doesn't seem like anyone is real motivated. Great pepper relish sauce and their italian is a family favorite. Overall good but could be great. read more

I've tried enough of their sandwiches to confidently deem Jersey Mike's as the best sub/sandwich chain. It's not the fastest, but that can be accredited to the fact that they freshly slice the meats and cheeses for each sandwich & grill everything up as it's ordered. The cheesesteaks are hot and sloppy, as is intended. The deli meats are juicy and delicious. I prefer to orderr sandwiches "Mike's Way", which consists of drowning the sandwich in oil and vinegar. The bread can get pretty soggy, but I like to think of it as a flavor absorber. Overall, the sandwiches taste like you're committing adultery. Sweet, delicious adultery. I only have one gripe, and it's that they never put napkins in the bag, so make sure you grab them, as you'll need them. read more

Service here was fast and friendly. This place has really good subs made fresh! The bread is also fresh! I got the Hawaiian cheese steak and it was delicious! I will definitely be going back. read more

This is a great location, awesome friendly employees, good subs as usual

Subs are delicious. Service is quick and friendly. Always a reliable spot for lunch or dinner.

Sandwiches are good, staff was really friendly. Turkey & provolone is my favorite. Better than most sandwich chains, but also more expensive. I miss having the Dublin location, that was closer to my home, but it's worth the short drive to Hilliard. read more

Fantastic subs. The sandwiches are great and the staff is even better. Everyone who works here is friendly and polite.

Awesome! I love the food and the service is amazing, I'm not a regular but a regular walked in right behind me and the guy cutting the meats already knew what he wanted. Defiantly gonna be a regular now! read more

I am in love with the sandwich I got on October 25, 2018. It was a buffalo something and it was very messy! That is my only complaint:) I loved that thing. Thank you employees from Jersey Mikes. Also, one of the gentlemen saw me dancing and danced along with me! That was nice, customer service 100% read more

While the subs were ok, the service left a lot to be desired. We ordered online at 3:47. The website said our order would be ready at 4:27. Walked in at 4:20 to get the order and it wasn't ready (due to the social distancing we left the store and returned to our car). Went back inside a few minutes later to the woman saying in a loud, rude and irritating voice that she was going to lock the door if people didn't stop coming in. There was no sign on the door to not come in, and the table they were using to sit the orders on for pick-up was inside the store. The 2 guys working seemed to be a bit more friendly. We were surprised that none of the workers were wearing masks. No one greeted us, gave us any instruction nor thanked us for ordering. We ordered today specifically because of Jersey Mike's ads saying that 20 Percent of Sales would go to Feeding America this Weekend. We probably will not use this location in the future. read more

You can't really go wrong with Jersey Mike's Subs-but this location did a great job when i ordered last minute catering for an office meeting. I called in because the website says they need 24+ hours notice and the employee who answered the phone was super friendly and accommodating about my needs. When i picked up the order everything was organized super well and the sandwiches were a hit. I loved that they gave us our own vinegar and oil bottles. I misplaced my receipt and when I called back hopeful they could forward me another-they faxed it to me within 5 minutes just after a busy lunch rush. Again, even though they were busy they all were very helpful and friendly. read more

Just went into Jersey Mikes, ordered and the boy making our sandwich wipes off the counter with a filthy old wet stinky rag and lays our bread directly on the counter. I asked him to replace our bread and he had a tantrum. Told him he could keep the sandwich and left. read more

This is the best sub place in Hilliard, hands down. (Subway and Jimmy John's don't compare.) The wide variety of subs are made entirely with fresh ingredients and are so delicious. I always prefer mine "Mike's Way". Consistently, the staff are genuinely super-friendly, My reason for taking off one star is that I feel they should offer a veggie hot sub and hope that's soon to come. Also, I wish they directly delivered rather than via GrubHub. read more

Our office ordered catering for today from this location. The subs were great! Everything was perfect except one sub, but that happens and no one was upset. One member of our team has a food allergy, so they made her sub first, which was very thoughtful and very appreciated! The friendly staff was on top of our order and had everything waiting when we arrived to pick it up. The subs were delicious as were the cookies! Thank you very much for a wonderful experience on all levels! read more

today my wife and I thought we would try out there subs, this was the worst place we have ever gone in. music so load we could not hear what the counter help were saying. handled our subs with bare hands from money to food. food to money. so I got a roast beef sub they couldn,t heat it up no cheese lettuce that was old and rusty,and all for 38.00 bucks, I could,nt believe it. don.t stop at jersey mike,s on wellington rd. London. oh ya and the beef was not cooked,blood soaked bread. I should of just walked out,and refused to pay. total disappointment .never again for jersy mik,e they won,t last . read more