Shout out to Jersey Mike's Plymouth location! My husband and I work across the street and come by for lunch regularly. We always have a positive experience here. The staff (especially the manager) remember the small things, like preferred toppings etc, and always treat us like family! You don't typically get this experience at a chain restaurant. Sandwiches are great and dine in is always clean! read more

It took 25 mins to get a sandwich made with about 6 people in front of me. I understand being overwhelmed or bummed out that its so busy, but you still have a job to do and customers to please, and moving as slow as you all were just insured me that I will never go there again read more

Love their sub in a tub. Don't know what that is? It's their sub, but in a bowl. Fresh and Delicious! Highly recommend if you're watching carbs. read more

This is my second time ordering from this place for ordering for myself and them messing up they gave me a mini sub instead of a regular disappointment read more

Smaller rolls with no meat. It used to be good. We miss it, but its awful now Check the dates on the good reviews...that place doesn't exist anymore. Maybe new management would help read more

What a joke transparent sandwich meat and cheese I kid you not you could see through the meat and cheese the giant sub is a joke it's mediocre sub not worth the money spent do not waste your money subway os much better also the bread is just as gross read more

Even though they're always so busy the service is always great, the staff is awesome and we love their sandwiches

I live in the Plymouth area 158 restaurants/ food places. I know Mikes repetitively say they have fresh food, but I go to many places in Plymouth that carry fresh food that is actually better than this overpriced gouging place its way too expensive for what is is ., as many sub places there have in Plymouth selling the same great food at half the cost. Between the hit and miss service and the food that isn't always fresh. Let me say add that I choose not to go here any longer. The roast beef taste like dry, not seasoned beef so cutting it in front of me doesn't change it. read more

Everyone that was making my sandwiches were incompetent to the point where I had the same sandwich remade three times and it was still wrong to where I had to get a refund to only get backtalk sass and disrespectful comments while trying to get the refund the sandwich was genuinely made in the wrong multiple times by multiple people. I don't recommend this specific location and I am beyond baffled. With the way they treat their customers. I've been coming to this one for years no longer. I also left a message to the general manager to see what she will do about this most likely nothing it was borderline to the point of an alternation until I decided to just leave and let them have the win, there sandwich makers and barley that. read more

Completely messed up my order. Couldn't even get 2 subs correct. Ordered 2 subs and they gave me three and none were what I ordered. Come on, gotta be better. read more

Finished food really quick I got chicken bacon ranch sandwich looked good it tasted amazing no joke the BEST sandwich I've ever eaten

The employees at those store are exceptional every time I go in. They are always friendly and I have become a regular because the subs are so good! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #14 The Veggie - Sandwiches Near Me - Plymouth, Massachusetts

They don't change their gloves after touching things other than food like the register paper bags etc.

Great subs. Better than all the rest. Worth it to pay a little more. Others following with fresh cut meats......forget-about-it !

I always get the #13 Mike's way no lettuce and every time it's delicious and fills me up with the regular size. Sometimes I get the giant and treat it like two sandwiches. This place is consistent and delicious. The staff recently aren't as surly as they have been in the past. I order exclusively on the app and my order is always correct. Doing it this way I've never waited for my sub it's always ready and waiting for me. I'm not sure if it's me but the sandwiches do seem to be getting smaller. You pay a premium but it's so much better than the other big chain. read more

This place..the plymouth location specifically is terrible!! They are always claiming they are short staffed I ordered a simple club sub that's it a hour ahead of time because ibwas at work and went to pick it up 5 min later than the pick up time I chose and they never even made my sub then they proceeded to just throw some stuff together and give it to me because I had to get back to work...short staffed? There was 4 people there and 2 customers no pick up orders waiting so explain to me how they never even started making my sub even worse she wasn't even gonna tell me I had to ask what was goin on because she just started making someone else's sub smh iv had it with this location it happens all the time read more

Good food for that grab and go. Sometimes the lines can get long so I recommend the AP. To the people advertising. Take some better pictures. That steak and cheese up close? No bueno man. read more

Ultimately the subs are usually great, but their service leaves a lot to be desired. They have no idea how to handle a digital order. 45 minute wait time is the usual. They don't even start to make your order until you arrive, so you have to wait another 10 minutes. If you give them a custom sub topping order they screw it up half the time. I didn't want Mike's way but that's what they did anyway. I ended up opening a soggy #10 mess when I got home. Ask them to use American cheese, not for you, we use provolone. I'm not sure why I continue to give them one more chance? read more

If I could give them no stars at all, I would. Was in the store, ordered 3 steak and cheese with provolone, tomatoes and lettuce. Got home only to find I had 3 chicken steak subs with peppers. Called the store three times and was on hold each time for about 10 minutes only to lose the connection. Tried talking to someone who took phone orders and she could not connect me to anyone. Don't go there. They need to get there act together. read more

What a joke of management! I placed a call in order at 12:25, told it would be ready at 12:54. Arrived at 1:00. Manager said she needed to "top it off" There were 4 people in front of me, all told the same thing. After 10 minutes, some of them got their orders. Not me, Then a door dash person walked in: manager made her order on the spot! Then a guy walked in behind me who had ordered at 12:40. She made his order. I watched people walk in Store after me, and order in person. 4 of them got their orders and walked out. At 1:20, I asked manager if she had forgotten me. She said "I just need to top it off". So you place a phone order at 12:25 and they have not started to make your order at 1:20, after I asked for it at 1:00. Nice prioritization and customer service NOT...Manager tried to blame it on power outage. That has nothing to do with why I can place an order at 12:25 and watch someone walk in door at 1:00 and get their order before mine that was phoned in at 12:25. I will never go back. If she had admitted she made a mistake, I would. But this Manager should not be running a store..Learn how to have some integrity read more

Very hit and miss experience. The restaurant was very nice, clean and well maintained. I ordered a cheese steak and the gentleman who took my order was very polite and respectful. The sub itself left a lot to be desired. I will say that it was very tasty and cooked right. The big problem, its all bread. I felt like a regular size sub that cost almost $9 could have had more meat. Had I gone for the large that is over $14 I would have complained. I will say that the other subs that were being made definitely looked like they were packed with meat and toppings and looked delicious. I will return but unfortunately it wouldn't be for the steak and cheese. read more

Best subs from a chain that I know of. The regular subs are literally a large cut in half and their subs are a bit pricy, but the quality merits the extra cost. The Steak and Cheese is one of the best from any sub shop, not just a chain. The other subs are also excellent and I have liked every sub I have tried. read more

The service was sort of fast. The prices are high for just a sub sandwich. I can get a large sub sandwich for half the price! I don't know what all the hype is about? It's just a sandwich! It might be that things need to be worked out since the place just opened not to long ago. Might give it a second chance after a while? read more

Jersey Mike's in Plymouth has been well anticipated. I Can't get enough! Everything to spec really makes it extra fresh. There's a bunch of workers on all hours of the day in the beginning stages of new restaurants so you know it's going to be on point and very quick/ efficient. No matter where you see Jersey Mike's just stop on in. Moon's better than Subway! read more

Just moved here & tried this location for the first time. Friendly staff! But I'm writing this review because the cookies are AMAZING!!!! We will def be back to this location! read more

I really love their subs, I just wish that the prices were not so high. But the subs are amazing.

Wanted a sub bad. Had my heart set on a steak and cheese when I found out danglos closed I was pissed. But decided to try here. Best steak and cheese I've had in a long time. Got a large but next time I'll get a large on mex bread too much bread. Will be back read more

The greasy sizzle and the sound of the deli meats being sliced while the assembly line of sandwiches are being made are two things that are in sync whenever I walk in here. It's always packed and a lot of folks use the app to order ahead of time for take out. The prices are steep, but you're getting what you paid for based on the freshness and guarantee of a delicious tasting sub. I have had the Big Kahuna Steak and Cheese a handful of times, but I paid $17 for a giant sub and it's worth it to get the regular size which comes out to about $10 after tax. I think I'd rather eat a roast beef sandwich made by moi or get a steak and cheese sub elsewhere that won't cost so much. I truly get it, the freshness and guarantee of a delicious tasting sub like I mentioned...but I won't break the bank. read more

Keeping this short and to the point: The subs are always delicious, but the staff is always unwelcoming.

First time here. Not impressed. So they slice the sandwich meat instead of pulling out of a wrapper. Overpriced for sure. No difference between this and Subway. No reason to return. Too many other choices read more

Stopped in yesterday for a sub on my way home from the Cape. Mentioned to the staff that I used to eat at the original Jersey Mike's on the Jersey Shore (where I am from). They wanted to know if their sandwiches were as good - they are! It's definitely the best sub sandwich I've had in MA. I got the rosemary parm roll and it's so good. The turkey and provolone were fresh. I will be back on my next visit to Plymouth! read more

The food is always excellent but you have to wait FOREVER! I can't take it. The staff are nice and friendly but they have one speed and fast is NOT it. Can we get 2 people making subs? And 2 people slicing the meat?? People do not have 20 minutes to wait in line for a sub. This is my 3rd experience here and every time is the same. So good but so slow!! Happy you guys are busy but could you do anything to speed up the service? read more

Good grilled subs - the way D'Angelos used to be. I'm partial to the Phillie cheesesteak. The staff is always friendly and quick. I call ahead to avoid the line. I rarely wait more than a minute or two for pick up. Good rewards program too. Easy to enroll at the store so you don't have to give them your cell phone number, which is required if you enroll online. I eat here 3 times a month. Service and quality are consistently strong. read more

Subs are huge and always full. Everything made to order so takes a little longer then normal sub place but worth it. Had cold and hot subs here. Always good. read more

Went to the New Plymouth store I ordered a number 26 can out nice and hot. Service was excellent took my order quickly and order came out fast. Wish you have American cheese as another option. Please put up solar shades to block out the sun very bright read more

The place is a cluster. The staff are so soft spoken you have to constantly have them repeat themselves. There are 13 staff and the line is longer than it should be. Two customers didnt get what they order. Waited more than 10 minutes to receive our order. You would think the orders would be correct and made quicker with all the staff they have. Tables are so close together that it makes for an uncomfortable eating experience. read more

Understanding people are short staffed but that was not the issue they were poorly trained staff. With two people in line for sandwiches, The person making the sandwiches never looked up and continued to make 12 online orders. Thinking she would at least acknowledge us she never did. 10 minutes went by with one person ahead of us who was never helped so we walked out. Went to market basket for half the price and a great fresh sub. They had people helping in store customers and people taking call in orders. read more

Had the club sub turkey ham provalone cheese on rosemary Parmesan bread it was delicious! Meats are sliced fresh right in front of you, bread was super fresh adequate amount of meat and tons of toppings I could only eat half of the regular size! Yes it's busy!!!! So be patient it's new to the area! But you'll get a great sandwich! Don't go to yuckway!!! read more

See all

This is by far the best sub sandwich on the south shore. Fresh cut meats, fresh baked bread, fresh veggies, fresh everything... The prices are good. The place is clean. The app works great. Love the Italian with the store-made roast beef a close runner up. My kids love the cheese steaks and my wife is a big fan of the turkey. So glad they are now in Plymouth!! read more

I found it appalling that managers are making food without masks and or not keeping their nose and mouth covered. 2 separate managers in the same location. I had to walk out based on this care free attitude. During this pandemic time this can not be tolerated. read more