A no frills counter service excellent sandwich shop. We didn't have a long wait because there wasn't anyone ahead of us. Anyone after us had to wait in line outside the shop. Owner runs a one-man show and works hard at it. I enjoyed my turkey sausage and havarty and watching the owner make it. Weather was nice so we sat outside and enjoyed our breakfast. read more

See all

Stopped in for an iced coffee! Got a small iced coffee cake - was good. We had to wait a bit, but the guy making sandwiches was doing a great job efficiently taking orders and getting sandwiches out to a hungry breakfast crowd! They had a ton of options- excited to try a sandwich next year. read more

so good!!! if there is a line, it is soooo worth the wait. my friend and I were in town for a wedding and we are still thinking about our sandwiches weeks later! I got the fat cow on a sourdough roll and she got the Massasoit melt. Incredible and great service! read more

Delicious sandwiches. We got the secret handshake and brisket special with a couple of coffees. There's one guy making everything fresh by himself so be patient, it's worth it! read more

Visiting Plymouth and found this cozy little place with a great sounding menu. Definitely a grab and go place, just enough room to order and move aside so the next person behind you can order. I elected a classic breakfast sandwich with pork belly made on a bagel. Got a cup of coffee as well because your day hasn't really started until you've had your first cup. The owner does a phenomenal job of turning out these hearty and delicious starts to your day. The eggs and cheese are HOT and well seasoned with a simple combo of salt and pepper. The pork belly was a delicious bit of protein and completed a well made sandwich. The bagel has a crust on the outside but isn't chewy, just the way it should be. The coffee, not the star of the show and adequately does the job but I like a cup with a bit more strength and vigor! Definitely worth a re-visit and this time, based on a recommendation from a local, will be trying the short rib as the protein. read more

Portly Pilgrim - Classic Breakfast Sandwich on a Bagel with Pork Belly. - Sandwiches Near Me - Plymouth, Massachusetts

So i wanted to love this place so many options they all sounded good. Until I sat there and watched the sandwich get made. The amount of butter put on that sandwich could give anyone a heart attack greasy and not good. I don't recommend. read more

See all

After first checking out The Portly Pilgrim on a solo visit back in October I ventured back today with orders for the whole family. Today we got the Burial Hill (without bacon), the Patuxet Pastrami, and the John Alden Club. The family consensus? -Excellent! -Amazing! -When can we go back? -Does he do any specials? -One guy makes all of this? Thanks for making our Friday, Portly Pilgrim! We're sorry you're temporarily closed for the season but we're looking forward to visiting when you re-open in March after a much-deserved rest! read more

Portly Pilgrim - Burial Hill Thanksgiving-style sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Plymouth, Massachusetts

Another hidden gem in Plymouth mass great sandwiches great owner who works very hard to bring fresh and exciting menu items

Sandwiches are the best in town. Highly recommend. Excellent selection and service. Bradford is my favorite.

These sandwiches were filling and tasty. We had the classic for breakfast We added some spinach and turkey sausage it was yummy. For lunch we had the skinny pig and skinny bird and took them to the beach. It didnt dissapoint. The owner was very nice and moved so fast for him to be the only person. 10/10 recommend. read more

The reviews I'd read about this place had me super excited to eat here when visiting for the day... and it did not disappoint! My mom and I got some sandwiches and headed down to the water to sit and eat (this place does not have seating inside; there were some areas outside but not specifically designated for this restaurant. I'd recommend finding a spot just across the street and down a bit to eat by the water). The Governor Bradford panini was a large and filling sandwich. It had turkey, stuffing, mayo, and cranberry sauce on a cranberry bread. The bread was delicious and perfect for the sandwich. I personally thought the cranberry sauce (more like jelly) was a little too sweet. I'd wanted gravy instead but the owner said he didn't have any at that time. It definitely had that after Thanksgiving feel and the sweet, salty, soft, crunchy that makes for an addicting meal! My mom got the Brown's Bank BLT but without the cheese or arugula (it had 8 strips of crispy bacon, Roma tomato, green leaf lettuce, and mayo). It came on a roll but you could get it on a different bread option if you wanted. This is such a cute place. It's in the Village landing shopping area. If you park in the farm end of the lot near the hotel, you'll see the sign telling you to walk around and enter in the front of Portly Pilgrim. You can't see this place from the street. It's near B's Ice cream. They offer breakfast sandwiches as well. Just take a look at my photos of the sandwiches and that should convince you to stop in!! read more

See all

Great spot for a fresh homemade sandwich Quality ingredients and a nice local vibe Highly recommend read more

An absolutely wonderful sandwich shop. I visited the Portly Pilgrim two times this week. Once for breakfast and once for lunch. Both times the food was amazing and the owner was kind and generous. I can highly recommend the Sausage @ Gouda breakfast Sandwich, and the incredibly fresh muffins. I can also recommend the lunch panini Governor Bradford (the Cranberry bread is amazing!) An obvious 5-stars from me! read more

Portly Pilgrim - a coffee shop filled with coffee and pastries - Sandwiches Near Me - Plymouth, Massachusetts

We stopped here on the way to cape cod from Boston. Mostly because of the reviews and the thanksgiving themed sandwiches. The shop is small one guy cooking everything and just enough space to order...which is perfect. We got a DAT Bird (?) and the one with steak, pesto and mozzarella. Everything was really good and the guy working was so kind and a hard worker. Would def stop here again. read more

Portly Pilgrim - Caprese Cow - Sandwiches Near Me - Plymouth, Massachusetts

See all

Grab and go breakfast and lunch sandwiches. Amazing lunch sandwiches... the Massasoit melt was wonderful on sour dough (rye was gone.), and the skinny bird is hearty. Plenty of tables outside to sit down and eat. It's a be man show so you may have to wait to order, and they may close early if they have run out of food. read more

See all

Stopped on a rainy afternoon. Cute little spot with amazing sandwiches. Hidden in a little courtyard. Enjoyed two sandwiches from the water front park across the street. read more

Don't expect good customer service if you aren't a regular here. They do not take online orders so we went in and placed an order for 5 sandwiches. The manager started flipping out in front of other customers that he had to make 5 sandwiches for "us". He was extremely rude, angry and slamming things .The place was fairly empty at the time so we didn't understand why 5 sandwiches were such a big issue. When the regular customers started to come in he would announce they would have to wait because he had to make sandwiches for "these people" pointing to us. We probably should've left but we had already paid. The ambiance was just ok. The place was clean. Even though the manager was so unbelievably rude to us, I have to say the food was good. Kind of reminded me of the soup nazi but sandwich version. lol read more

Awesome sandwiches - there was a little bit of a wait because it's a small operation, but it was worth it in the end. A+

Hard working owners, Making sandwiches from scratch. love to support this local business.

Delicious sandwiches! Yum! Great for lunch and breakfast. Hilarious that it feels like just someone's kitchen. So simple and great.

Popped by before the huge drive back to phila after a very long wedding weekend and could not have made a better choice. Outstanding sandwiches, made to order, easy to sub or change around one of their classics. I got the skinny bird but with havarti and added canceaux sauce (HIGHLY RECOMMEND). I also "made it portly" which is a $3 upcharge to increase the size of any sandwich and turn it into a panini - I also highly recommend this. My husband got the turkey sausage & havarti breakfast sandwich also made portly and was thrilled. The ingredients especially the meats tasted very fresh and high quality. The sauces were all excellent. You really can't go wrong here, these sandwiches kept us happy the whole car ride. read more

Portly Pilgrim - Skinny bird with extras - Sandwiches Near Me - Plymouth, Massachusetts

See all

We stoped here with 3 teenage boys and it was perfect. Sandwiches were hearty and filling. The solo cook, Barry, is nice and friendly. We liked it so much we went back next morning. It definitely is a cute quick spot for take out only breakfast sandwiches!! read more

This little hidden gem should be visited by everyone who comes to Plymouth. Every detail; the bread, the meats and salads to the small touches such as the sauces and fixings were super fresh and delicious! read more

Great sandwiches, quickly made, at a good price and equally important they travel well. Their breakfast sandwiches are delicious and the pilgrim sandwich is a little taste of thanksgiving year round. The owner is also fantastic. read more

Amazing breakfast sandwich, owner was a super nice guy . Going to be my new stop and I will be telling everyone to go there.

Just stopped in to grab lunch for me and the family before going on a whale watch and have to say this place is amazing! Anytime I come back to Plymouth I will be stopping here. Just doesn't show up on Google maps for some reason. Great find! read more

Got the Governor Bradford, tasted delicious. The cranberry sauce and stuffing were perfect.

Everything is always fresh and delicious! Owner is super friendly and polite. Prices are great for the amount and quality of food. Such a great concept to grab a sandwich and eat by the harbor. read more

Don't bother coming here. They're always closed. First it was for a family emergency, then it was for an illness. Multiple days, loads of excuses. Hire people, or don't own a business. read more

Had to Steal this from Patrick G from October 5 (although some words are different): Prompted by a recent post on Tik Tok I decided to treat myself to something new for lunch. Man, am I glad I did! Tucked into a small storefront in the storied Village Landing Marketplace (founded by Elder William Bradford in 1622 to provide a more solemn outlet for commercial interests than that furnished by the decidedly frivolous Ryan's Family Amusements nearby), The Portly Pilgrim is a three-year-old relatively undiscovered haven for those seeking spectacular sandwiches. I inhaled my John Alden Club: Hand Carved Turkey Breast, Thick Sliced Country Ham, Crispy Bacon, Gouda, Baby Green Leaf, Roma Tomato, Mayo, Mustard, and Grilled Sourdough. I can't wait to go back for the Portly Pilgrim, I heard it is worth the wait with the middle bread soaked in gravy!! Barry, the owner, is awesome!! Get your ass there!! It's my new favorite thing. read more

There is no better place to get a sandwich in Plymouth. They're reasonably priced, very large, and delicious!

Amazing Brisket and slaw sandwich. I am picky about my coleslaw but his was homemade and delicious with kale in it. The owner was super nice and I will definitely be back! Plus peaceful meadows around the corner for a raspberry lime Rickey! Bing bang boom! read more

Simple, delicious sandwiches. Something you would make at home, but sometimes it's better when someone else makes a yummy sammie for you. Great service also....wil be back! read more