Best pizza around. I ordered from here a lot when I was working in Archbald. The drivers are friendly. The boneless wings are great. I highly recommend the medium sauce. There is not much difference in heat between the medium and the hot but they melt butter into the medium, I guess to cool it down, which gives is a great flavor. The lady who answers the phone has good days and bad days. She could use a bit more training on what to say to customers. Things like delivery time and total are left off on a regular basis. Just make sure to specifically ask for these things. read more

Another trip to the NEPA means another stop at Jessup Pizza. I tried something different this time and can finally say I really enjoyed the eggplant slice. It was pretty heavy and fully but had great flavor. The calzone and mushroom slice were enjoyed by mom & brother. read more

See all

Jessup pizza was the only place I ever got pizza from 1 love it 2 the cost that is until yesterday 2/26 I was waiting for my pizza when for 2 hours it sat outsde my apartment door according to the driver he knocked 3 times I never heard him knock and my dog did not bark so im not sure what happened all I know is 2 boxes of pizza was cold so I will be looking for another pizza place to get my pizza from read more

Good to have this place to come back home too and enjoy some great pizza. Houston has yet to hit the mark so being back in NEPA, I had to come here. They are always friendly and I enjoy eating outside across the train tracks. read more

Jessup Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jessup, Pennsylvania

See all

Hate doing 1 star reviews but this was pretty bad. The wings are a mess. The worst wings in NEPA. Low quality meat and tasteless greasy liquid which can't even be called a sauce. Pizza is just average New York style grease. Low quality. A lot better options in NEPA to spend your money on. No love went into l making this food and it shows. read more

Jessup Pizza - Really bad wings - Pizza Near Me - Jessup, Pennsylvania

Very bad at answering the phone, also their menu should not be screenshots on a Facebook page. Their website only displays pizza options. Needs to be improved big time. read more

Ordered from here plenty of times with no issue- just got a hoagie that was completely soggy (literally dripping) and the chicken was undercooked and chewy. NOT WORTH IT. Also, nearly $30 for two hoagies is nuts. read more

Jessup Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jessup, Pennsylvania

Payed $25.00 for a steak and cheese Stromboli!!! It was a cheese Stromboli with a sprinkling of steak! I called before posting. The manager was incredibly rude and kept calling me darling. He said " I made it and that's what you get darling ". I said is this how you do business and he said yes darling that's how I do business. Wow! Never again and I will now tell friends. Receipt also did not indicate the 20% tip that I left the delivery person. read more

once again I got a terrible pizza from here. I wont even waste my money on this place, but my family bought it so I tried a slice! cardboard crust, the sauce is too sweet, the cheese is low quality and they charge a lot for this garbage! I will talk my family out of ordering it again!!! read more

Loved the pizza! Reminded me of back home in NYC. We got 4 individual slices, 2 ham and pineapple, bruschetta, and eggplant parm. Bruschetta was my fav! Crispy NY crust and great amount of cheese. Sauce was well balanced, not too sweet, not too much oregano. We sat outside across the tracks under the gazebo to eat and had a fantastic afternoon! Highly recommend! read more

I enjoyed Jessup pizzawhen I lived here before, so I looked for when I came back, it's difficult to order online, they don't support any of that average delivery systems and you can't place your order on their website you have to call. After I called to place, my order I had a waitress ask for my order and # when I told her that I wanted to pay for credit card, she put me on hold and put me on the phone with some dude that asked for every number on my credit card, everything that Paypal could've answered...with security questions read more

1st time ordering tonight. Very pleased. The pizza and wings were delivered to us in a good and timely fashion. The driver was prompt, courteous,, dressed neatly and followed the safety protocols. And Uhm, uhm uhm...DELICIOUS! The Pizza and wings tasted soooo good. And the price was right too.. We are definitely going to order from Jessup Pizza again in the future. read more

I Have dealt with Jessup Pizza for a long time, until today, The worst part of this complaint was when I called to report being delivered the wrong things that was ordered, . I called to complain about the wrong things being delivered, was I angry yes because 1st I was told it would be a half hour-45 min.which I didn't believe but then I got into an argument with this simpleton, granted I was angry for the amount of time we waited for the delivery,then the wrong order....now comes the best part ..The man I was speaking to about getting my money back said he didn't care about my money, WAS ACTUALLY THE OWNER! I will never spend another dime @ this business. read more

It's absolutely disgusting. It's like eating grease with a side of crust. I never seen a pizza so greasy in my life. It just tastes like a mouthful of grease in every bite!! It's so soggy too. read more

Soup was good. Ordered meat and asked if it was red and it was . He lied. Also pasta wasn't good either. I don't recommend.

Always great food, but they don't stand behind mistakes and can Never be in the wrong even when it's on a receipt..I don't know?¿

Egh went here and tried the hot wing pizza & Italian Stromboli. It was a bit pricy and honestly I've had much better food before. Wouldn't waste my money here again. Yuck! read more

Lived in the area for 2yrs now & so far this is the best since moving out of N/E Jersey.

I once used to come to this place from Clarks Summit because the brick oven pizza was so good. This was at the old location. Then they moved to the new spot and I worked at the power plant in jessup. The amount of food ordered from this job from there daily brought them a lot of business but it seems like it was at the cost of the pizza quality. Try it in store rather than taking it or delivery. read more

Being new to an area and having a love of Pizza, it is always critical to find my Family's go to Pizza Place. Friendly staff, great selection of specialty pizzas, my favorites being the sausage and peppers and the tomato basil. prices are reasonable, and if you have a family of 5 like me, it is a great place to take the crew. Take the drive into Jessup and enjoy a great pie. read more

I ordered 3 hoagies, one of which was an Italian hoagie that I had asked them to not put any sauces on, just meat, cheese, and veggies. They said it would be an hour, it was an hour and a half when it arrived AND the delivery guy handed me the food and stood a foot away from me while I signed the recipe with NO MASK. Then I get inside and open my hoagie to find it smothered in MAYONNAISE. If it was anything else I'd just suck it up, but I can't eat Mayonnaise. So I call them back and politely tell them that the order was wrong and didn't even complain about the lateness or lack of mask. The man proceeded to argue with me for over 5 minutes telling me that I didn't tell them no sauce and I was wrong and that if I wanted a new hoagie I could come get it myself. Then he tells me to order it slowly and like I'm talking to a baby so I can't mess it up. I've never been so disrespected by a restaurant in my life. I ended up telling him never mind and just hung up. If they are that disrespectful over the phone I wouldn't be surprised if they spit in my food over it. I'll never be ordering from them again. 0/10. read more

No stars - but had to choose 1 Iwas a lover of this place until tonight- horrible delivery - no sauce with wings, mozzarella sticks were horrible, garlic bread is a hoagie bun- we got to eat over 1 & 1/2 hrs. after we ordered - owner doesn't care if he loses customers - I have had issues before. I promise I will never order from here again. When they deliver pizza, when it gets to you the cheese has all fallen off into the box - not held level in the vehicle delivered in - STAY AWAY!! read more

The best pizza ever!! The staff is very friendly and helpful and the food is delicious and quickly prepared! Highly recommend!!!

This place is hit and miss tonight was the worst. I will never come here again, never !!! we got two trays of pizza that tastes like cardboard with sauce on it and no cheese this is like the second or third time this happen to us . I'm done. read more

Well, I like Jessup Pizza. The pizza is very tasty and so are the salads. Many times we have ordered dinners from them including eggplant, chicken and shrimp, all very yummy with very large portions. We've been ordering for about 10 years and I see no difference between "old" and "new" location. The food is really good, the delivery is on time and the food was always hot. I recommend this place, the pizza is great and the price is reasonable for the quality (better than dominos) that you get. read more

Such an absolute disappointment! From delivery to ownership.. I ordered pizza for my 3 year old daughter and her friend, asked for delivery.. When delivery guy dropped off my food, most of the cheese slid off my pizza... my daughter and her friend were so hungry that I gave each of them a slice of pizza... I called Jessup Pizza back to let the owner know about the situation and how I was displeased with his delivery guy.. and he said that the delivery guy is his son and I would have to return the pizza so he can give me a new one.. I told him how I gave my daughter and her friend a slice each, he told me he couldn't help me then..bad business! I got disgruntled and I told him I won't be ordering food from his establishment ever again nor will I ever recommend it.. his response.. "That's fine, I don't care...". For a business owner, a food establishment, none the less, say this to a customer means that's he doesn't care about rectifying any issues caused by their place of business and surely doesn't care about his business or customers! Please save yourself the trouble for anyone who wants pizza or any food from this place.. There are other pizza places close by that DO CARE ABOUT THEIR BUSINESS AND THEIR CUSTOMERS! read more

The pizza is decent. Their delivery service will leave you with a sour taste in your mouth. It's a shame they can't get their act together. When they state 45 minutes to deliver a pizza it should be 45 minutes. Not an 1 hour and half. I had this type of experience twice with them about a year apart and it makes me not want to continue to do business with. I thought I'd give them another try but apparently I was wrong. read more

I tried the Sicilian last night. While the pizza was alright I've had better sauces. Their sauce is just bland. I ordered a Sicilian with half pepperoni on it. When I first called I ordered the pizza then was abruptly put on hold where another lady took the rest of my order. I was told it was 45 minutes. After waiting 1 hr 15 minutes I called back to find out where my order was. The lady told me it left a couple minutes ago and should be there any minute. After five more minutes the food finally arrives and it's a completely plain pizza. I just don't think it was worth 27 dollars read more

Order from here four times. Twice the order was wrong. Called after the second time and spoke to the "Owner. Joey". Who really didn't seem to care. Actually gave my wife a hard time like she didn't order it right. How do you forget to put pepperoni on a pizza and then argue you ordered wrong. Never again. Luigis in olyphant is much better anyway. Only they don't deliver. read more

The food was nothing special. Ordered a pizza and mozzarella sticks, pizza was meh while the mozz sticks were ok.... Big plus was the quick delivery. read more

We order from this place at work at least once every week and they mess something up almost every time we order. When they don't mess up, they don't have what you want. Apparently they make certain food a day ahead and you get what they have left over. Their food is just okay. The lettuce in the salads is usually pink and wilted. The garlic knots are decent, but good luck getting them. They're usually out by 11:00 am. If we didn't order it from work, I would never eat at Jessup Pizza. read more

Well I tried a pie for the first time in a few years at the new place over in church street and it was excellent. We will be ordering our pizza from there when we're just in the mood for a hand tossed plain pie :-) Bravo read more

His meals and his specialty pizzas are the best in this whole area and reasonably priced. The owner is from Italy who migrated here from New York City and he knows Italian food inside and out. read more

Plain pizza is just okay. Nothing special, bland, and it is greasy. The wings are gross. They are rubbery not crunchy. The specialty slices are decent and the vodka pizza (Sicilian) is good, but pricey. Actually, I've ordered it three times and each time it was a different price! I avoid it unless I have no other option. The counter service has always been friendly and when I call and place an order they are friendly as well. read more

We ordered the white pizza with spinach and two glasses of water with lemon, and imagine our surprise when a $17 pizza became $23.05 when the bill arrived.... I questioned the waitress, and she told us that there is a $2 charge per glass of water! We have traveled around the world, and we have NEVER paid for tap water.... this was our first and last time in this establishment.... read more

I have given this restaurant , a lot of business unfortunately. If you order slices in house at lunch it's yesterdays leftovers. A fresh pizza, I find really greasy, and nothing special. Do yourself a favor and go to Colarusso's! read more

I called in an order. I asked if they had a two tray special. Lady on the phone said 2 trays and an order of wings for 20.99.....I repeated the price because I thought that was low, I said 20.99, she said yes. I go in to pick up my order and lady behind the counter says that'll be 31.79. I asked about a 2 tray special and everyone in there started screaming at me. Another customer in the dining room told me to get the f^^^ out of here and quit causing trouble. A man from behind the counter, I presume was the owner, went outside and took my license plate down, like I did something wrong. Long story short, They gave me the two tray special which is what I asked for from the beginning. As for the pizza? It's not that great. Crust was like cardboard and not much taste. With all the many pizza options in the valley, I'd suggest going anywhere but here. read more

The pizza doesn't have much cheese. The delivery takes a while. The one time and last time i ordered, they gave me 40 minutes time for delivery. It was over an hour before it came. I didn't tip due to this and when i saw the charge on my bank statement, they tipped themselves $5 on my debit that I paid with. I had to pick a star or i would say 0 stars. read more

Ordered delivery on a sunday, and I know during playoff season it is very busy. They told us 45 minutes. Our food didn't arrive for almost 2 hours. When I called, the owner said there was nothing they could do. When I said there should be a discount, he again said there was nothing he could do. I will no longer be ordering food. If you're that busy, don't tell people it will be there in 45 minutes read more

I'm kind of a pizza snob and with that being said, Jessup Pizza has the best pizza in the valley. So many places in the area have weird square pizza with sweet sauce and American cheese?!...Blick, that's not pizza in my book. The shrimp scampi pizza at Jessup Pizza is ridiculously delish, as well as their salads and calamari. Delivery is very efficient and friendly. Can't compliment them enough! read more