Awesome wait staff! Meatball sub is a 100/10…read more Garlic bread, pretzel bites and popcorn were all delicious as well

We are new to the area and was told to try Buckeye Family Pizzeria by our new friends since my wife…read moreand I really love Benny's. I ordered the BLT pizza and my wife ordered the Parm and Garlic Wings. We noticed everyone received complimentary popcorn and we weren't even asked if we would like some. The place was not really busy at all, probably because it felt like it was less than 60 degrees inside and everyone was wearing coats. One person at the bar had gloves on. We asked our server if they could turn up the heat and we were told that this is typical this time of year in here. The bathrooms were dirty, freezing, and the water never even got warm washing my hands. The service was slow and it took what seemed like forever to get our food. When we finally received our food the pizza's lettuce had a little brown texture to it. The pizza was extremely greasy and taste-wise didnt hold a candle to Benny's. My wife's wings were slimey on the inside. We told our server and she told us that happens when customers don't ask for them twice baked. She took the wings back for the second baking. This made a big difference and she said the flavor was a little better prior to them being twice baked. Her soda was fine and she was offered a refill. I had a Coors Light that tasted flat so I switched to water after that. Probably would have had 2-3 beers but not when it tasted flat. Overall we were very disappointed with the experience. Not a clean restaurant, food was not good, service was mediocre, restrooms were cold and dirty, and we froze for the hour and a half we were there. We will not be returning and will just stay at our staple. Bennys!

The pizzas were fabulous. Service was great…read more Nice dining room. Great place over all!

Marysville is overrun w/pizza joints, but I'd put them in top 3, great balance of quality vs value…read more It the cheapest, not most expensive (Bennys). Not dog food...not gourmet.

Every time we go here, the staff is always friendly. This time they had a band inside playing…read moreChristmas music which made the environment super fun and the food is phenomenal. They messed up our order and gave us that pizza and remade another one because they felt so bad and both were delicious.

Wonderful pizza and a huge space. Live music every Friday and Saturday. Lots of parking space…read more Separate beer garden. Not a great selection of beer was a disappointment. I ended up with a white claw.

Rough experience for takeout here. First time ordering and the menu looked promising but the result…read morewas quite disappointing. Cesar salad was just shredded ice berg lettuce instead of romaine and looked pitiful and our wings were so unbearably salty. We ordered three pizzas and I would say they were just subpar. The jalapeño popper pizza was pretty mediocre in flavor compared to other places I've ordered that pizza. Same for the taco pizza, definitely lacking in flavor. The only pizza we really liked was the pepperoni with banana peppers and mushroom. The red pizza sauce was pretty tasty. Wasn't enough to redeem this place though. Also, why is square cut pizza the default? Who likes to eat pizza this way lol

The vibe is great, it's a chill spot with a huge patio! They do live music which is always an added…read morebonus!! On to the food... the pizza slaps every damn time which ever one you get! As for some of the other items, I don't prefer them being cooked in the pizza oven and wish they had an air fryer! The service is always great, everyone seems to work together and has a great attitude! Will definitely be back!

This has been our go to since being back in the area. Pizza always arrives hot and fresh…read more Tubby's is a hidden gem of the area.

We ended up ordering a large cheese pizza and two side salads. If you're looking for something…read morequick and easy, this is your place! We enjoyed the pizza, but we are pizza snobs. I would probably rate this pizza 7/10. The crust was delicious... we just weren't super impressed, but will definitely eat it again! The salads are just your typical pizza shop salads... shredded romaine, cheese and tomato. We definitely want to try their subs and wings next. Everyone was super friendly when I picked up my order. You could tell they were very busy! Our food came out piping hot! It's a very small shop with a few chairs inside while you wait for your order. It was very clean and organized. You can tell they pride themselves in this business!

With so many pizza places in the area and moving back to the area after.several years I had…read moreforgotten about East of Chicago. Placed an order last week via the website for a standard pepperoni pan and was not disappointed. Can see why they were voted a favorite at the Marysville Pizza Challenge.

Great place, became a home staple for my family weekly. We recently moved to Ohio last year and…read morehave been finding a good place for pizza and settled on East of Chicago and are pretty happy after trying lots of other places nearby. Good prices and even some unique pizzas like the taco pizza. Staff is friendly when you call and always happy to help you with your order/delivery as well.

We were meeting up with some friends who live close by and suggested this place and I was happy…read morethey did. Very nice staff and great atmosphere. We eneded up getting their ultimate pepperoni pizza and it was delicious. Our friends got the spinach dip and that was pretty good, too. Will definitely be back.

We went during a slow time so service was quick and the server was helpful, he gave me the pizza…read moreburger recommendation which was good but I wouldn't get it again. The fries were fresh and overall it was about a 7/10 experience. I also have to admit I did not like the ranch they give you with the fried pickles. Big and clean restaurant with a nice sized parking lot, right off the freeway and a huge bar with TVs!

My Pepsi was so cold it had little ice shards in it, and this delights me to a silly degree and…read moremakes me very happy. I know that's dorky, but it's the little things. Other than that, this location is always very clean as a rule, the staff professional, and I have never had an issue with an order. Food has always been on time and perfectly as-ordered, regardless of dine in or take out. I really like their drive up window, which makes things convenient.

great pizza and service. keep up the super good work Glad we live close now instead of farther…read moreaway

One of the few pizza places in town that I haven't tried. And I didn't get the pizza, because I've…read morehad it at other locations, and it's fine. Good not great. But, I needed some things for dinner and then for lunch at work the next day, so I thought I'd try several things. First the crustless pizza. Basically meat or vegetables in a dish. No pasta, no carbs really. It was good, but obviously very definitely not healthy. Greasy and salty, but good on a cold day. Next I tried the wings. Also OK, but nothing special. I did polish them off. They were meaty, but not very flavorful until they were doused with sauce. Finally I tried the Italian sub. A pretty standard sub, decent bread, decent meat and veggies. Nothing special. Service was good on a busy day. Prices are reasonable. I think I'll stick with the pizza buffet at other locations.

I'll start with a positive - the pizza is always consistent and the prices are reasonable. I'm…read moretypically not a person to leave reviews but after this evening I've had enough with Marco's in Marysville. Over the last couple years we have ordered from here many times despite having several issues with some of our orders, specially around timing. There have been a minimum of 10-12 occasions where we have ordered, shown up to the store after the time specified on our confirmation, and our pizzas had not yet been put in the oven. A few of these occasions were after an hour wait/lead time. We would occasionally stop ordering from here because of the delays but then be mailed a code for a credit/free pizza because we hadn't ordered in some time so we would order again because who doesn't love free pizza. This evening, we placed an order which went through online at 9:03pm according to my confirmation. I show up to the store 15 minutes later (I'll also add here that there was a person sitting at the lone table in the waiting area with no shoes or socks on. How is this allowed in a place that prepares food?! It's bizarre but I can't make it up) and was told that our pizza was not made as the order was received after their closing time. I was puzzled as; 1 - My order processed and my card was charged. 2 - Google maps (where I started my order) said the closing time was 10pm. 3 - THE CLOSING TIME PRINTED ON THE DOOR SAID 10pm. 4 - The neon "open" sign in the window was lit up. I was told that they attempted to call me but was given some excuse as to why the call couldn't go through. I have no problem if you decide to close earlier, but you can't just do it without first properly updating the most basic and necessary things needed to do so. It's beyond clear that there is a serious dysfunction in the management of this place and this was the last straw for us. No amount of free coupons can get us to order from here again.