First time at this Jimmy John's and as expected the two sandwiches I ordered were freaky fast! I usually grab a #9 and today was no different. I'm always glad that the quality of ingredients is high and that the experience store-to-store is virtually identical and standardized. Employees were friendly and the store is clean. No issues and no complaints! read more

Fastest made and delivered sub! I get it. But they should take more time and make a better sub! Tasteless, dry and not very good. Best advertisement for Jersey Mikes! Now that's a good tasting sub. read more

Best part of sandwich was the roll. 2 thin slices of roast beef on 8 inch hoagie was appalling. Never again

First time visiting "Jimmy Johns". I get it .. fresh subs - fast. It's similar to all the other sandwich places but less flair (toppings). After reviewing the menu I chose the BLT. It was fresh no doubt but very forgettable and meh. Honestly, I wished I would have waited until I got home and just made a grilled cheese sandwich. This is a popular sandwich shop.. a few customers (males) came in while I was sitting there eating. I did enjoy my reduced fat thinny chips. The place was super clean and the customer service was on point. $9.00 for BLT, chips and drink - average. read more

Jimmy John's - the outside of the restaurant - Sandwiches Near Me - Wexford, Pennsylvania

See all

I'm not a huge fan of JJ's. I work nearby, and it seems like my order is almost always wrong. If the food was good, I'd suffer through the incorrect orders, but it's just not worth it. I'd rather have Subway. At this point, I'll only order JJ's if there I'm starving and I have no other option. I would have given the review one star, but they have some of the nicest delivery people I've ever met. They are always friendly and patient. read more

Yesterday's offer in the app was for a free 8" sub for National Sandwich Day. Took a very rare lunch break to pick up a sandwich & was told the app wasn't working so they wouldn't honor the deal. I'd rather pay for Chickfila than deal with that mindset. At the very least, I'm sure they have coupons on hand that would've worked but that must be complex thinking in that location. read more

I don't understand how hard it is to mess up a sandwich. If you'd open your ears a little more at the cash register and repeat what the customer ordered than maybe you wouldn't have messed up both my sandwiches...fast but not reliable...if you mess up sandwiches people might as well go to subway so I at least know what They're getting...terrible cashier...over priced and now I payed for a sandwich I didn't get so thanks Jimmy Johns you truly are sh*t sometimes! read more

I love Wexford Jimmy Johns they have the best employees and their drivers are definitely Freaky Fast

Absolute GARBAGE service!!!! Randomly decided to close "early" after I placed an order online. My order was confirmed via email and when I arrived there was a sign on the door saying "closed early". When I called the store, some punk gave no explanation for closing and said they wouldn't be making my order. I told him my order had been confirmed by the store and he tried to lie and say he "tried to call me". Absolutely not. Drove 25 minutes into town to pick up this order for my family. Wasted an hour of my time. I love JJ and will continue to order but not from this location. If you have the option, choose anywhere but here! read more

What a disappointing service experience. We ordered food and drinks to be delivered to our office for 12 people. Food got here but they forgot the drinks. They were trying to locate our drinks and after waiting for over an hour, our drinks were delivered. It was bad enough that we had to wait over an hour after we received our order, but when the delivery person asked for a tip and we declined, he copped an even bigger attitude. There are plenty of options in our area and if we order again we will pick up our own order. read more

Refused to put mayo on sandwich, no power outlets to charge my iPad, and last but not least...did not cut my giant 16inch sub. How do they suspect my little boy to bite into a 16inch uncut sub. I will definitely not be returning... read more

Basic sandwiches. Food is fresh; staff capable. But I still orient to other outlets for fast food. The location is easy off from Monaca and that makes the place accessible and attractive. Close to a shopping center. Better location would give them a lot more business. read more

The last 2 times I've been there they've got the order wrong. Today I said "no tomato" and when I got home there was No Mayo and lots of tomatoes The last time I ordered salami and tomato only. Got home they had put dressing on it. When a 7 year old gets something like that the whole sandwich is not any good. Food is good but they need to play closer attention to what people are ordering. There was no one else in the store today so they weren't busy and can't use that as an excuse. read more

We've ordered from here several times. I don't know that they've ever gotten our order completely correct, but tonight was ridiculous. They brought my daughter the completely wrong sandwich (turkey instead of tuna), my unwich was less than half the size it usually is, and my husband's sub was missing some of its meat. We ordered through the app, so there couldn't have been any miscommunication. I think we might be done with Jimmy John's. read more

I was very excited when this place opened. It was near my work and they delivered SUPER FAST. Unfortunately super fast does not always equal super quality. I was okay with this for a while. They would mix up a few orders and sandwiches would be sloppy. I love that they have the lettuce wrap option but some of them were barely "wrapped" and covered in an insane amount on condiments. Again I looked past this for awhile ... Until I got the strange looking turkey ( Turkey Tom on the lettuce wrap). They obviously use luncheon meat but this meat was covered ( I mean covered) in clear jellied fat. So gross! As I was pulling the meat out ( using the term meat loosely here) I had to unravel the paper covering the lettuce wrap... And what do I find... Lettuce covered in fruit flies/small gnats! They are embedded into the lettuce! Little black bugs that would have gone into my mouth if I wasn't carefully examining my lunch. I'll stick with taking my own lunch to work. No more jimmy johns for me. Ick!!! read more

Great subs and fast. Nice guys working there. Very helpful. Will deliver within 2 miles. Good selection. Offered a menu. Open later which is good. I was there at 8:30 pm. I will be back. read more

These are my favorite subs anywhere. The sandwiches are all well made, extremely quick, have the best meats but most of all the bread is amazing. The staff at this location were all very nice and accommodating. Great place. It's a once a weeker for me read more

Presentation was great but the 2 sandwiches we ordered had no flavor at all. One was supposed to have guacamole and they barely put any on at all. Mine was supposed to have extra cheese and did not. The bread was hard and seemed old. To top it off we each had a 30oz soda and they filled both up with ice mostly. So I don't think we will be calling this J.J.s back unfortunately. read more

Ok. Meat tastes manufactured or processed. There are plenty better places. More like college food, if you know what I mean.

Love jimmy Johns. Staff was quick and made everything perfect this first time. I also had the opportunity to meet the owner, great guy, made sure everything was up to my standards. read more