Joe's Brick oven pizza was , hands down , one of the best pizzas we have ever had!!! We ordered a…read moreSiscilian pizza with 2 toppings. It was cooked perfectly with a great ratio of yummy sauce to cheese ! It was huge ( 16 pieces) and fed us for 3+ meals. The chicken parm sandwich was also delicious. It was real ( not breaded , pattied chicken ) with lots of cheese , sauce and toasted in the oven. Way to go Joe. ! We will be back. Meg

Excellent Pizza just like you get in NY. Great side dishes. Everything tastes great. Eat in or take…read moreout, plenty of parking.

Perfect hole in the wall restaurant in the middle of no where farm land. Stace is the best waitress…read moreever and always makes my Sunday mornings when I'm grumpy. Love it here. Affordable as well for the area.

We ordered take out. Got the food and my sandwich was on extremely moldy bread. They refused a…read morerefund and would only remake it. I refused to trust the remade one as I'm highly allergic to molds and not risking it so tossed it. Lost money and had not food. They were extremely rude about it and they only commented " oh how was that not caught".

Stopped in for takeout and had a great experience! The pizza was delicious -- fresh, hot, and full…read moreof flavor. While we waited, we grabbed a couple of drinks and they were excellent. The staff was friendly and the atmosphere made the short wait really enjoyable. Definitely coming back!

I got here to grab a to-go pie based on the quoted 15-minute pickup time, and I arrived within that…read morewindow. However, by the time I got home 8 mins later, the pizza was completely cold--not even warm--which was unexpected given the timing. The pizza itself was average across the board: the crust, toppings, and sauce were all just okay. It was edible, but nothing stood out in terms of quality or flavor. The space appears family-friendly, with both indoor and outdoor seating, and a casual fire pit area. It also looked like there's a fairly full bar available.

We got there just past 12!. 9of the 10 tables were filled. Server was sweet and service was spot…read moreon. The bf ordered a cheese steak which was good but different than he was expecting. More like chop meat than minute steak. Still tasty. I ordered the loaded GIANT baked potato. Pulled pork w/bbq sauce smoked cheddar, sour cream, topped with an amazing amount of crispy fried onions.

The best best best gluten free pizza ever!!!! Friendly staff.... Love how they joke around with…read moreyou... every thing we tried was amazing... nothing bad to say.

Actually pizza not bad for being in the boonies Will be…read moreback when lunch in the boonies is needed

I gotta admit this is some of the better pizza I've had. He makes it just how I like it - thin and…read morecrispy, not too much cheese or sauce. You're probably not going to find better pizza in Sullivan county. It's just a standard take out pizza joint, but there are a few tables and a bar for dining in. 10/10

Best Tuna Melt I've ever had (besides some I've made myself). Clearly made with love. Worth the…read moredrive from anywhere.

A Hidden Gem! A quaint historic building filled with…read moredelectable delights and friendly customer service. Very well thought out grocery and etc. The meal choices from the deli showcase are creative and all the items I've tried have been delicious. BEST PIZZA EVER!!! Give the Milanville General Store a try. You will not be disappointed!

Ordered the eggplant with red peppers and mozzarella. Eggplant was very thin, I really am not a fan…read moreof that style because it lacks eggplant flavor. So I will stay away from that one on my next visit! I should have gone with my usual pesto "hoagie" which is really good I just get a side of red peppers with it.

Dry unflavored chicken parm hero. No sauce no flavor too much bread for hero and no sauce on ch…read moreparm.

I enjoyed the shrimp scampi with linguine with a side of salad yesterday! The salad was served…read morechilled with the italian dressing that was just the right ratio of oil vinegar and herbs, the shrimp was cooked nicely with garlic and the linguine was cooked perfectly. It even has a few slices of garlic toasts on the side! I enjoyed it very much!

The service was very good. One server had the whole restaurant and she didn't miss a beat. Casual…read moreatmosphere with red tables and photographs for sale hangs on the walls. Huge selection on the menu from Greek, Italian, pizza, Burgers, wraps and a ton of appetizers. The food was ok. It was tastier as leftovers a few days later. A lot of the tables were dirty because they were busy and only had one server. They serve until 10 pm. No alcohol served.

Had the Margerita pizza, worth the 46 minute drive. Real brick oven pizza, fresh mozzarella…read more Excellent tomato sauce fresh basil, crust crisp and perfectly cooked.. Home made meatballs, as good as nonas 4 good sized, perfect meatballs served with fresh ricotta and basil. Under $11, amazing. Only open on weekends during summer. I hope weather holds up will be back next week. Top line food at crazy low prices

It's not often I give a 1 star but the only reason this place gets any stars from me is due to the…read morebuffalo chicken pizza being so dang on good. I completely understand this is a family ran business but the hours of operation on Yelp and Google are not correct/have not been updated so on a Sunday I wanted to grab pizza and they ran out. We drove there from our weekend rental after seeing reviews of call-in orders not being accepted. It's a mess and if you don't live in this town there would be no way of knowing when it's last call for pizza. And for those reading this be sure to order pizzas by 4pm on Sundays to make sure they actually have pizzas available. We dined in on a Friday evening because it was the only open space dining spot in town and luckily we got our pizza within the hour (we were abruptly told the pizza would be a long wait before we were greeted) and since we had no place to be we grabbed some beers and waited. Our waitress was very nice and being that she was the only one serving I had sympathy for her but the guy making the pizza which I assume is the owner is frankly not nice. Maybe he needs to hire someone to work the front so he can focus on making the pizza's.

Great clean restaurant service is also great. But best of…read moreall the food is good quality and lots of it at a decent price. We come here now after hitting the moosic theater on the way home. Realized we are only 20 minutes away so will be ordering takeout more often.

While on a trip, we stopped here for lunch--and wow, we're so glad we found this gem! The food was…read moreincredibly fresh, and everything tasted amazing. What really stood out, though, was the friendly and attentive staff. My son accidentally spilled his soda, and a gentleman quickly came over, kindly cleaned it up, and brought him a new drink without hesitation. That level of care really made our visit special. We'll definitely be back if we're in the area again! The restaurant is very clean and well lit.