The godfather sub 7/10 Asked for light onions, apparently a whole handful is light??? Also wish it was sandwich pepperoni and not pizza pepperoni. Chicken finger sub 8/10 Asked for extra blue cheese. And there's barely any on it. Medium, was a little more mild. read more

See all

Excellent pizza! Good service! Hit the spot Thank you. We'll be back. The crust was tasty. The pizza was thin crust, and the sauce was just right. read more

Christine answered the phone to take my order and she was the happiest person over the phone. She was more excited about the chicken finger sub and fries than i was ordering for my son! Not only was she professional and patient but she repeated my order and gave me the total which many places do not. I picked up my order in person and met Christine and she was just as bubbly and personable in person. For a small family run business on Grand Island they hit the jackpot with Christine. read more

THIS IS INSANE YET AGAIN! This is a DOUBLE FINGER!! (Minus the carrots and celery)THE SIZE is just crazy So over cooked EXTREMELY EXTREMELY SMALL this & a small cheese pizza was $45 Unfortunately my husband is a doctor we work medical hours sometimes we rely on this type of food. TRUST ME GO DOWN THE STREET OR OFF THE ISLAND BEST BET UNFORTUNATELY . We tried this place so so so so so many times hoping it was just a fluke but nope worse and worse! read more

John's Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Grand Island, New York

severely disappointed. my turkey club sub was covered in hot sauce and blue cheese on the outside of the sub. roll wasn't toasted and the lack of turkey on it was surprising. when I called they said sorry and that was it. never ordering anything from there again. read more

AMAZING!!! Some people are leaving 1 star reviews. DON'T LISTEN. Customer service was through the roof. Food was amazing and nothing was wrong with my meal. The atmosphere was awesome in there. read more

The antipasto salad was extra good today! It had all the standard meat, cheese and veggies, and had capicola and a sliced hard boiled egg too. Nice little extra. In a nice bowl to boot! read more

See all

Johns is on Grand Island and I've also noticed there's one in Amherst too... I wonder where else there is a Johns at? Anyways, it's a local / regional kinda place. Pizza up here in WNY seems to be (and by dream to be I mean absolutely is), different than anywhere else I've ever lived. That isn't a bad thing... just saying it's totally different. I'm used to living out west... west Texas... gods country. Pizza is prolific everywhere in the world, but out in west Texas it doesn't have like its own style. It's just normal chains like Pizza Hut, Dominoes, Papa Johns and my fav (fuckin fight me): Little Caesar's. Johns has legit pizza. I've had it a few times now. They also have subs! The Stinger is one of my favorites. Not much to say, but I will say, this place is worth going too. Fast. Friendly. Equal pricing as other places offering similar items in the WNY area (where everything is crazy expensive). Food is quality! Staff is legit. Check Johns out y'all read more

Delicious subs! Home of the famous chicken finger sub! It is truly a buffalo treat!! I recently tried the pickle chips as well and they are my new favorite app/side when getting a sub. I have always ordered ahead for easy and fast pickup. The staff is friendly as well. read more

Best subs period. Fast friendly service. Restaurant is clean and has a local flair. Specialty pizzas are also awesome. read more

John's mouthwatering spicy pepperoni is the thing I miss the most about Buffalo food. I crave it all the time. Their pizza has a hearty, oregano heavy flavor that tastes like a football game. Lather that bad boy with some blue cheese and some wings on the side and you got yourself some EATIN. The sauce is sweeter than other pizza places and the dough is a bit thicker. It's been a classic since I was a little kid. They have excellent subs too. You can't get a chicken finger sub like theirs anywhere in the world. Their turkey and steak subs are also great. Stop in and let the flavor grow on you if you haven't came around to it yet. That's the ticket. read more

John's Pizza & Subs - My dog begging for Johns pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Grand Island, New York

Found this place on my yelp app. I was tired eating at the usual spots close by like the Chineese place, BK and Wendy's. When I noticed they had a Online order thing, I placed my order. The first time I tried it, I got the stinger pizza and I was hooked. The stinger pizza has been my favorite so far. I have tried the House special, the Big Mack and my buddy got the steak pizza. Out of all the gourmet pizzas I tried, the Stinger was the best and the House special comes in a second. The steak pizza my friend had didn't have any taste. If it wasn't for the banner peppers, the pizza would have been pretty bland. I'll definitely be back at least once a week during my lunch break to get the stinger pizza and try other things on their menu. read more

See all

Good pizza and wings (this area has *very* high standards - so this is high praise:) Took off a star for the balky online ordering process read more

Stopped in here yesterday for a few slices after attending an event at the vfw a few doors down. For slices, our options were: -cheese -cheese and pep -chicken finger -stinger I went with the chicken finger and my husband decided on the stinger. We also got a bottled drink to share. It took a few minutes to come out, I'm guessing they heat them up when ordered. The chicken finger slice was bangin! It was different than other chicken finger pizzas in the area that use an olive oil or bleu cheese sauce on the crust and then sauce the fingers hot/medium/mild. This pizza had a buffalo sauce base, a little celery in there, cheese, and plain chicken fingers on top. It was refreshing and delicious! I love their take on it and will definitely be back for a whole pie. read more

See all

I was worried when I didn't see many cars parked out front. Usually lots of cars means the food is good. It wasn't till I got inside that I noticed the main parking lot is behind the building. Whew! John's has a traditional WNY pizza/sub/wings menu. Prices are reasonable. The food is good quality. I ordered a cheese and pepperoni and some rings to go. The staff was very pleasant, and my order was filled promptly. The pizza was to be shared between me and mom. I forgot that she steals all the pepperoni and eats that before everything else. I should have ordered double pepperoni. read more

First time ordering. Delivery was in about 15 minutes 4 subs. Steak in the grass, 2 dodfaters, all were excellent. Will definitely use again! read more

We're not from New York, we were there buying a car and some of the locals suggested going there because we were hungry. We got the two piece and a drink special. The pieces were so big I could only eat one. Pizza was really good and fairly cheap as well. If I was in the area again I'd definitely stop. read more

Gave it one more try, won't be going back. I have no idea what is going on,but this place has gone downhill rapidly. Used to be the go to place for a good sub or other things. Not any more. read more

Johns is known for their chicken finger subs and pizza, I got both cus I'm a fatty and they were both awesome!! Yum!! Inside was redone and is nice. They have a wide selection but they don't have Indian food which disappointed me. Staff is fine, and prices are ok. There's a car wash next door too but I felt my car wasn't that dirty so I passed on that. Tops is across the street I get groceries there sometimes. Also a gas station near by if you need gas! read more

Decided to get subs from here while hanging out at the water and, WOW! Best. Sub. Ever. I ordered a chicken finger sub and it was perfect. Really enjoyed it and about to order again for tonight's dinner! read more

So good! Love the pizza so much that I came here twice in a week. The lunch specials are great and they're quick. Highly recommend. Wish I had a pic to share. read more

Just had a delivery order . Got chicken fingers and fries . Let me tell you that was the best I have had I long time . They were kick perfectly the sauce was great and fries were hot and crispy . Thank you ! read more

Ordered pizza from here a couple of times and I am not a fan. It's not good at all. Their subs on the other hand, are amazing! My favorite sub is the chicken finger sub, and they do a great job here. My brother has ordered the Philly cheesesteak and he loved it and it looks quite appetizing, I think I will try that next! Service is quick and friendly, prices are very fair! :) read more

John's Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Grand Island, New York

See all

The most disappointing pizza I've ever had in western NY. They were careless with the whole pizza. The pepperoni was sliced too thick and it looked like they dumped the reject bucket on top of our pizza. The pizza was undercooked so badly that it was floppy. When they threw it in the pizza box, they ruined half the pizza as all of the toppings and cheese flopped over the edge and grease pooled all over that half of the pizza. It wasn't cut through, at all, we had to cut it too. The WORST part is, this is NOT the first time this has happene and the manager couldn't care less. Used to love this place and their food, I will never order from here again nor would I ever recommend it to anyone. read more

Ordered delivery online. It was scheduled for 12:30 and they arrived at 12:10 which was great because I was starving! I ordered a medium pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni. It was delicious. The wings were decent. I was disappointed with the cheesy garlic sticks though. read more

John's Pizza & Subs - Medium pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese. 10 mild wings. - Pizza Near Me - Grand Island, New York

Great place for pizza and subs. I highly recommend checking this local favorite out. You will not be disappointed.

The last five times I have ordered pizza with four toppings it was made missing one of the toppings!!! I even specify the last three times I called in the order to make sure it has all the toppings!! Pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and banana peppers. Again today when I got there my pizza was wrong!!! I had to wait 20 minutes for them to make a new pizza. On top of that I ordered a chicken club sub and when I started to eat it had horseradish mayo on it instead of ranch dressing. Extremely dissatisfied! read more

Johns food is delicious! Very good place to eat in or takeout. The sub sandwiches are great. And very fast service

Driving from Chicago to Boston for college in a packed car and stopped for a last minute detour to niagara falls. Enjoyed the falls so much we didn't realize that most places for dinner would be closed. We were freezing, soaked from the mist of the falls and had not eaten since 10:00am in the morning and this place was a god send. Extremely nice staff and delicious food that hit the spot perfectly. 10/10 would recommend. read more

Had a chicken Hogue yesterday fresh peppers super fresh roll great marinated chicken breast and heavy. !!!!! Great costumer service on the phone while ordering and picking up . Drove from Tonawanda to the island for this so that is saying something new place for subs I think?? Sorry wegmans . read more

It would be nice if this place wouldn't wait 30+ mins. after taking a delivery order to call you and say they don't deliver to your area (less than 3 miles away). Now I get to finish my shift at work without having eaten. read more

Ordered two fish fry's that were pretty terrible. Both came with small condiment cups of coleslaw, both of which were maybe a tablespoons-worth and very bland, mine being dry with no liquid. The actual fish was dry and hard. With so many options for fish fry, I would definitely not recommend Johns. read more

So I went there after buying my car at the HUGE dealership on Grand Island, which is a totally different review, so stay tuned for that. The place was recommended by my sales person, and to be fair he warned me not to get the pizza and to stick to the subs. So we ordered a slice for my daughter and I had a chicken finger sub. And well, it was really good. Like the first one I ever had that set the standard for all chicken finger subs. Baked, messy, with blue cheese, yum. So the pizza was really, really bad, like Chuck E Cheese bad, but that is what my daughter likes so it was good for her, but I would recommend anyone with discerning Pizza taste should stick to the subs. read more

My sister and I used to get the chicken finger sub all the time. Ohhh, I miss you! I moved out of the area eight years ago and haven't found a worthy chicken finger sub since. The prices have gone up considerably since I left. Pretty soon there better be some super high quality ingredients in that sub. read more

the pizzaz is very nice i like pizza i want more cheese on thou pizza but less crust more cheese the subs should be all cheese cheese i want pounds of cheese on my subs and pizza if i dont get the pounds of cheese on my subs and pizza i will get angry and i know that there is enough cheese for everyone . cheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeese. *asks for cheese* *gets cheese in return* *asks for more cheese* *more cheese in return* *pulls out cheese pocket* *puts cheese in cheese pocket* *hugs cheese* *cheese hugs back* read more

John's Pizza & Subs - i want this amount of cheese - Pizza Near Me - Grand Island, New York

I've been coming here since it opened and they still have my favorite Chicken Finger Sub of any restaurant around. It has to be extra hot, with everything on it. The pizza and wings are always good here - when people visit Buffalo, I always recommend this as the place to get all the tasty favorites! read more

I was visiting a friend on Grand Island and I was hungry so he directed me towards John's Pizza and Subs. I ordered a Godfather sub and some hot wings. The sub was very good, clearly worth every penny and then some. I'm really look forward to trying a different one the next time I am in the area. I must say that the hot wings were what really stuck out to me. They were seriously some of the best hot wings that I have ever had. I got 20 of them with the HOT sauce and it definitely has some heat on it! Those wings had me sweatin! But that's the way I like them! They are definitely in my top 3. If your in the Buffalo/Grand Island area, check this place out. You wont regret it! read more

I've been going to this specific Johns for around 10 years at least. But since I have been there lately its been getting worse overtime, ordered Food got charged for cookies but never received them, and every time I get chicken finger sub it was greasy even on the outside of the bag, soaked threw. Overall, there is definitely good food here but they have lost there game.. read more

I am originally from Grand Island, so I grew up on John's pizza and subs. However I currently live out of state, and I have been for quite a while now... But I was recently home and every single trip home I have to order from John's! My favorite is the chicken finger pizza and the chicken finger sub. They are conveniently located in the center of the island across from the Tops plaza on Grand Island Boulevard. I would recommend pizza and subs, and their wings are also very delicious! My favorite wing sauce is the barbecue, as I do not like anything very spicy. I've tried so many places out of state, but I cannot find anyone that compares to John's. Can't wait to go back and get some more John's! read more

Their dough is a bit thicker than most locally, and they could benefit from cornmeal or something on the bottom of the box because the condensation from the heat caused a wet and somewhat soggy pizza bottom. The crust, however, was very flavorful and delicious. Sauce is sweeter as mentioned in other review, and cheese could've been more flavorful. Overall , I enjoyed it, the the soggy crust really was unpleasant. COVID is it there, so when we walked in to pick up it was nice to see that all but one worker wore masks properly. However, there was one guy back there not wearing anything at all, and when I mentioned he pulled up a neck scarf to 'barely' cover his nose. I have no doubt it went down as soon as I left. For that reason, I won't be going back until the pandemic is over. read more