(This is from 5/11/26) Had a tremendous experience! We had 6 people and wanted to eat in. The 2 girls working were spot on! We didn't have to wait to order and our orders came out fast and delicious! It's a pizzeria and it has pizzeria ambiance. Have gone back multiple times since. read more

Excellent pizza!!!! We get the kind with just the sauce and grating cheese on it. It brings me back to the old days when my Grandma made it! Their salads are delicious also... reasonably priced too read more

Ordered a large Old Fashion Pie. I didn't check it before leaving. Took it to a friend at work. It was burned. I emailed company but no reply. Don't leave without opening the box. read more

See all

Where do I begin? Snobby manager, overwhelmed cashier, inflated prices, or just terrible food? All of the above! Went in for a couple of slices and was totally ignored, even by the female manager who 'pretended' she was working but really wasn't. Never coming back here again! Going to John&Marys down the road for better food and prices! See ya Favorites!!! read more

Favorites is my go to pizza place. It's a thinner crust pizza which I love. If you order a 1/2 it's a little thicker. I started ordering their version of a white pizza with tomato basil and a balsamic vinegar sauce. read more

So where do I start. First let's start with fact that the pricing isn't consistent. They always say there online menu isn't right. It's been four years and they have yet to fix that? Four years and its still wrong. Then one day they are open til ten then they aren't. . All that for them to be rude anyway. It's like we should feel grateful for their presence . I have no choice but to order somewhere else. They just have bad business sense and no sense of customer service. They actually get upset that they aren't consistent and rude. Like it's the customers fault. With a new manager this place would do well. In the meantime we are better off paying more somewhere else. At least I would get treated right for the same price. read more

Just horrible.. after i call at 10 after 3 thay tells me there busy, witch i live down the steet thay tells me it won't be ready till 5:30...... So i call around 4:30 she says oh it just came out. get home chicken was hard pizza as cold. WHY FUCKING LIE. I SPENT OVER $50 . I WILL NEVER GO BACK read more

Ordered a 1/2 tray of pizza and chicken fingers to go while hanging with a group of friends. I have visited the Lewiston Location many times and was excited to try out this new location which is generally more convenient based on geography. Based on preferences of those in the group we opted for a basic pepperoni pizza with banana peppers on half. It was good overall but I was a little disappointed. Typically I ordered specialty pizzas from Favorites, so maybe I was just disappointed because they were always fantastic. The fingers were delicious. I am usually more of a wings person myself, but based on the mood of the group we opted for fingers and I was pleasantly surprised that we did. We got some medium and some honey garlic. I opted for the honey garlic, they were syrupy and sweet, I did not detect much garlic but it was yummy. Would definitely be willing to try them out for pizza and fingers. I will def try a specialty pizza next time! read more

Favorite's Pizzeria - 1/2 of 1/2 tray - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

See all

We tried their cheese and pepperoni pizza. I thought it was good. Next time, I will add extra cheese. Pepperoni and sauce were good. The counter girls were nice and friendly. The parking lot was shared and very littered, but I would blame that on the businesses that share the parking lot. I think it would be all of the businesses' responsibility to keep it cleaned. The kitchen is open. You can see the employees preparing the food which I liked. read more

We accidentally found this place while looking for lunch while car shopping. The slices were not only original/unique but also excellent. Staff was very friendly and the value was good (2 slices and a drink for about $7). read more

Favorite's Pizzeria - Big Mac slice, cheese and pepperoni slice and garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

Stopped in for lunch today again with my fiance since we were in the area and hungry. I love stopping here because everyone is so friendly and the slices are amazing. There are so many different options so I keep trying different kinds and have never been disappointed. Today I tried the big mac & honey garlic. Both were delish. The honey garlic might be my new favorite! I noticed they have daily specials and one of the ladies working handed me a calendar of their specials mapped out by the month and let me know they're also online. I grabbed a calendar to bring to my office and I'm really excited because the specials sound great but I'm worried I'll be here every day read more

See all

Decent pizza for a good price. I like that they have a huge selection of many slices, and that I was able to order and be out of there in less than a minute with the slices reheated. A cool spot that I'll check out again. read more

Favorites is still doin it to em 5 years later! They're just as good as when I posted my initial review, if not, better. I ordered a Chicken Philly sub last night and it was so good!! I requested to have the souvlaki chicken in the sandwich instead of the chicken strips and I highly recommend that you do the same. We also ordered a Bacon Cheeseburger, which was hefty enough to feed 2 small humans. The burger came with a huge portion of fries, cooked until GBD and perfectly crispy, as well as a dill pickle spear. The kids' chicken finger meal always goes over well and is a great value. It comes with 3 big chicken fingers, a massive portion of fries and a package of cookies! The cookies that they include have historically been Grandma's (brand) chocolate chip cookies, but last night they were Oreo's and I'm not mad about it. ( I mean, my child is not mad about it, cough cough. I definitely did not eat those Oreo's. Nope, not me.) Service is always top notch and last night was no exception! Our order was taken quickly, made to perfection and ready on time. The staff is always friendly - from the front of the house to the back of the house and the delivery drivers, too. What more could you ask for, except for....more??!! read more

So this place is best known for their variety of pizza slices. I'm a very simple man who loves the old traditionals such as, cheese and pepperoni or sausage and mushrooms. Right away you notice how much thicker the pizza dough is. Also the plethora of different types of pizza available is quite impressive. You can choose the Big Mac, teriyaki, seseme chicken, and chicken finger just to name a few. The prices is pretty fair as well, two slices and a pop/water for $9. In all I think the pizza is ok, I would come gain if I was in the area. read more

See all

It's 11:30PM and I've got to be up for work at 5:30AM. Here I am writing a review for a pizza place (when I SHOULD be sleeping) just to offset the negative review I had to write. (I hate having to write a negative review, but I truly wanted to save my Yelp sisters & brothers from the same bad experience I had!) I don't have any pictures of the pizza or the wings from this place, but those are already on here, so do you really need more? Let me tell you what I know. I had never heard of this place until my manager ordered their pizza and wings for us at work. I don't know whether it can be called THE BEST I've ever had, but on a Saturday, I texted my team lead to ask the name of the place where the wings came from. On. A. Saturday. Not cool. But I needed those dang wings (and I won't forget the name ever again!) We have ordered them a few times at work since then, but there's a wing shortage right now (did all the chickens get Covid? Why do we have a chicken wing shortage?) so there's a limit on how many we can order, which seems savage if you ask me. I mean, if the boss is willing to shell out premium dollar, TAKE HER MONEY!! Also, I'm trying to do keto here, and NOT eat the delicious pizza. But when you limit the wings, I don't get enough to fill my belly, so I have to resort to pulling cheese & toppings off the crust like an animal. (I hope the coworkers aren't reading this because I blamed Allan for the naked crust in the box.) So whatever you do, order their pizza & leave the wings for me, please. read more

The pizza is to die for frfr. The honey garlic chicken bacon slice was delectable - very juicy and nice bread to chicken to sauce ratio with the perfect amount of bacon!! Very good vibes inside the restaurant. Great service! read more

Favorite's Pizzeria - Honey Garlic Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

Food is good, prices are reasonable. Would recommend, 5 stars. The pizza is fresh and delicious.

Placed an order for two pizzas. One specialty and one pepperoni. The pep was cooked fresh and the specialty was an old pizza boxed up. Not hard to figure out what happened when one pizza is hot and the other was warm and tastes reheated. First and last time ordering there. Cannot trust a business that operates like this. read more

My brother and I came from Los Angeles and were looking for a place in the neighborhood to get some nice, real local food. This was a fantastic choice! The food was delicious with huge portions, the prices were great, but most of all the service was amazing! They helped us with the menu and were super cordial and friendly. We tried a slice of pizza, the buffalo wings, and a sub (which was huge!) and everything was delicious. read more

New local pizzeria that we had to check out. We decided to try them out with delivery and just got a regular pizza. It was pretty good; their crust could use a little extra work and little crispier. They have a huge menu and we plan on checking them out again. read more

See all

We were looking to try a new place for pizza and thanks to Yelp this local place popped up, so we gave it a shot. The pizza we got was a thinner crust pizza, (the kind you wanna fold in half to eat). Sauce was tasty, not too much and not so little you couldn't appreciate the taste, ample pepperoni and cheese on top. We went with an everyday combo that included chicken fingers. We sampled the honey BBQ and the sweet & spicy sauce. Both were very good and the spicy was not really that spicy IMO. The fingers were good sized (we did get a couple that were on the small side, half the size) and they came with 2 small blue cheese cups and celery that was fresh and crispy. All in all we will be ordering from here again as it's not that far from home! read more

Favorite's is a solid pizzeria that has a wide variety of items on their menu. The food is perfectly prepared to your liking every time. They have many different kinds of fresh slices readily available daily. I really enjoy the old fashioned, stinger, and honey stung speciality slices. The price is extremely reasonable for two slices and a canned soda from the fridge. I've had their original steak hoagie and also the ham & cheese sub. Both were very delicious! I like the fact that they put the oil on the side for my ham sub. My sub roll was nicely toasted as I asked. The staff has always been really friendly when I've ordered over the phone or as a walk in order. I look forward to trying other items on their menu in the future. Give them a try if you haven't yet and make them one of your Favorite's! read more

See all

Excellent customer service, from the minute we walked in. I planned on buying a half sheet pepperoni pizza, and they had just put a fresh one in their slice counter, so Instead of waiting the woman offered to give us that one - Great timing! They do sell slices here which is nice. The location is in a small plaza, I've actually passed it dozens of times and have never even noticed it.   As for the pizza, I was very interested in the flavor from their coal oven. While it wasn't a stand out pizza, I did like it. I thought it was a little bland, and was hoping for more of a Smokey flavor from the coal oven. Still a good place, and since they have slices I'll probably be back to try more. read more

Favorite's Pizzeria - Favorites - Half Tray Pepperoni & Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

I love favorite.they have fresh food and are very sweet people and very good price for a lot of food,They are my favorite

I was told by someone that I should find a pizza place that makes Big Mac pizza and try it. so I tried Favorites from the Yelp reviews. The customer service was good but I wasn't a huge fan of the Big Mac pizza. This place offers several different kinds of specialty pizza that they serve by the slice which is a good thing because it allows you to try something née without buying an entire box of pizza. I will try something again if I'm in the area but I wasn't a big fan of the Big Mac pizza.. read more

See all

Quality Buffalo style pizza is now in Amherst. The 2 slices for $5 with a drink is something you almost only see with the NY style pizzerias, so it's very welcomed. The Mac and Cheese pizza is done well here and the staff is seasoned coming from the busy Lewiston location. The highlight is the 14oz burger that never disappoints. Generous portion of crinkle cut fries comes with it. read more

Favorite's Pizzeria - 14oz burger - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

See all

Favorites on Sweet Home has a good idea. It's smart marketing to sell pizza by the slice and unlike other pizza joints Favorite's sells several different kinds at all times. For the people who live in the nearby rentals walking to Favorite's is an event, On a night with nothing to do you can walk to favorite's for a slice. I prefer the old-fashioned which is like a DiCamillo's Romano, I should've had it cold though, it's the best that way. Also tried the tomato basil which was very good. If you only want a slice, favorites is a good choice. And they have Vernors in the cold drinks fridge! read more

Great food. Great service Very timely and everything packed correctly. The food was very good

Let's see my adventure began in the parking lot . I went an ordered my food a car pulled up next to me . 4-5 people got out one threw a rock and it hit my car . I was pissed but they were just screwing around . The fat one replied with "so"then dreadlocks replied with I will fuck you up and your car . My reply was laughter and rolled the window up . They mouthed some words but couldn't here them . Three or four cars pulled up meeting dreadlocks which had out of state plates . They pulled up did there business and left . Should called the police but I was well protected if you know what I mean . I would of had no hesitation if it got worse . They kept saying shit I just ignored with my hand firmly on my protection . Finally order done went in and got it idk if my protection was showing they just shut up or the fact they saw what they were dealing with . I told the counter people a little of my story which they could give two shits . Got my food and left . As I was leav read more

I found this place by mistake actually. Sometimes an unforeseen detour leads to a new discovery. First, I must say the creative pizza options are great. Loved the macaroni and cheese pizza. Carb City but the buttery breadcrumbs were well worth it. There was this Korean BBQ chicken finger pizza that if I want traveling, I would have ordered a whole pie of it. The staff was friendly and actually, even with the specialty pizza options, relatively inexpensive. Pity, I'm not closer. I definitely recommend making a pit stop on your lunch or if you're driving through. read more

Favorite's Pizzeria - Korean BBQ and Mac n Cheese pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

Excellent pizza. I went to 6 different local pizzerias today, all highly rated. My Tomato Pie was great! Cooked perfectly with great crust! It stood up to the competition. The 6 people i was with agreed! read more

The 5$ special (2 slices and a drink) is a great deal. The pizza is very delicious and they can have it ready for you very quick. There is plenty of seating inside and sufficient parking spaces as well. All the different pizza types look amazing. I haven't tried nearly enough kinds because the buffalo chicken finger pizza is so good i just keep getting that!! read more

I am not a resident but I use to live in Niagara Falls,NY and there was a bakery named Tusscellos off of pine avenue that had awesome pizza and bread. My sister who lives in Amherst took me to this place on Sweet Home Rd and it is amazing. I ordered a slice of plain pizza and it was as close if not hit the target on Tusscello. I had the Lake Road sub(8in) and it comes with fries. My sister had the steak sub and fries. My sub was Italian sausage, onions,mushrooms and cheese and I added all the fixes. It was light, delicious and fantastic. The fries are crinkle cut and great. My sister steak sub was great. The sub rolls are light and they toast them lightly. The food was fresh and great. No grease! The pizza is some of the best I have had in western NY and I do travel a lot in WNY. In fact I am going to get some pizza to take back with me when I return to Atlanta, GA. The place is clean and the people who very friendly and nice. This is a place I will be going for lunch and dinner when I am in town. You can't go wrong at this place. read more

Well I have to say that even though I live only a few minutes away I was not aware of this pizzeria until my youngest told me all about this amazing BBQ Chicken Pizza. I first checked for a temperature since she is not a fan of chicken or any pizza that is NOT just cheese. Well my wife and I decided to give it a try and ordered it (BBQ chicken with grilled chicken & bacon along with extra BBQ sauce). This pie was off the chart special. The ingredients were very fresh (specifically the mozzarella). There was a perfect cheese, chicken, BBQ sauce & bacon ratio in every bite. We have been back for many of their items and have to say we have never been disappointed with Favorite's. read more

I love bricksquadbobby. Bro 10/10 recommend coming in to see him. Delivers great service. What a guy. I love you bro so much

I do have to say they definitely are about the comunity!!! The best pizza is the balsamic tomato pizza!!!!

This place was really good! I got two pieces of pizza the traditional with just sauce in it and the famed honey garlic. Both really good! I see why people talk about it....I also got a specialty sub. I think it's called a lancer? It's chopped steak with crispy bacon cheese and sweet onion sauce. Very very nice indeed. I got a side of blue cheese which had great flavor. I'll definitely be ordering again! The staff was nice on the phone just as reviewers said. read more

We were looking forward to trying a new place but can't say anyone cared for the deep dish pan pizza we ordered. Not only did it look like a regular old pizza, the top was borderline burned yet the center of the top was mush. Order taker was very pleasant, maybe they had an off day. read more

Favorite's Pizzeria - Deep dish? - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, New York

I used to love this place due to its 2 slice pizza deals for $6. Two years later and they've jacked that up to $9. Their prices have spiraled out of control. I'll be taking my business elsewhere. I have also recently learned that the co-owner treats female workers horribly. I will not support an establishment like this. read more

I order food from Favorite's semi-regularly for myself or my family. It's been one of our favorites for years. The pizzas, especially the toppings are good, the wings are tasty and I enjoy the salads and dressings. Recently their business seems to have taken off. The wait times can be disheartening (45 minutes for a pick-up order at 9pm for something that takes 5 minutes in the fryer), and it's not uncommon to be put on hold for 5-10 minutes before you can even put an order in. If I go into the transaction expecting to wait a long time, I am not disappointed and I usually receive exactly what I am expecting in terms of food quality. If you are stopping in for slices, you don't have to worry about the phone or the wait times. Slices are excellent. It's a nice inexpensive stop in the summer to sit outside with kids. read more