Great service and Good food. The toppings and sauce were really good. The crust needed a hotter oven or stove it was a little greasy and chewy but over a good experience. read more

Ran in quick fior a Pepperoni Pizza to go; crust was thin and amazing, pepp was not greasy, tons of fresh cheese and I didn't order extra. Nice surprise at the end, waitress told me about their cheesecake made from scratch- OMG...!!! Got two slices to go as well, made points with my wife. GREAT wait-staff as well, great! read more

Very nice family run business. Great service and nice atmosphere. The ingredients used for the pizza were outstanding. Fresh! We had the pizza with everything on it. The only reason for the 3 stars was the pizza sauce. It was honestly lacking any flavor or character. In my humble opinion the sauce is key along with the crust. Crust was good and on the crispy side. Just wish the pizza sauce was flavorful. read more

The pizza here is outstanding! The best you'll find in Port. They are very generous with the toppings, especially the cheese, and everything has a true homemade taste to it. The crust is delicious, personally I prefer the double dough but everyone else in my house is a thin crust fan and they cannot get enough. My favorite thing on the menu though, even above the pizza, is the cheesy garlic bread. It is a delicious loaf of fresh Italian bread, covered in cheese and bursting with garlicky goodness. It is a must order in my house. Do not expect to pay the prices that Pizza Hut and Domino's offer, you have to pay more to get better quality as with everything. Worth the money and the trip and will make you look forward to pizza night even more than you already do. read more

Decently priced. A little too much cheese and not enough sauce. The sticks we got were really tasty. I will def. go back and probably would give it 4.5 stars. Very local and chill place too. read more

If you are looking for a pizza in Port Washington, John's is the place to go. Their pizza is always amazing! My wife and I often order carry out, and have never had a bad pizza from John's. They also have a heart stopping garlic cheese bread that is top notch. I highly recommend a John's pizza to everyone!! read more

great pizza in a small town, pizza is great too, and the sandwiches hit the spot, just cant go wrong at Johns guess why they have been around so long! its all good! read more

They burned our first pizza, called to tell us they were making another one and offered nothing in return. After another half hour I called and they offered us only $5 off because they said the pizza was already on its way to our house. Very displeased with the service! Downtown Pizza Grafton gets my vote! read more

Yikes this was truly horrible. My husband and I sat in the dining room and did not order any pizza. That may be good, but I won't be trying any soon. We had a quesadilla appetizer which was so tiny! Not the typical large shell used by every other restaurant. My husband had the shrimp. He said it was awful (and he is not picky when it comes to shrimp). I had the chicken alfredo. Where was the sauce? There was a large amount of mozzarella cheese melted over the top of plain noodles. Geez, if you're out of sauce let me know and I'll order something else--you're not pulling one over on me with that mess! The dish had a plastic taste to it so it was obviously stored in plastic and reheated in plastic. Finally, the waitress only paid any attention to my husband. Hahaha, this was humourous and gave us a good laugh all night because she so blatantly ignored me but really, how unprofessional! read more

Went there randomly looking for something new. Great pizza, had the Hawaiian style. Also try the delicious Green Apple Riesling. Didn't expect it to be so small but it's a very quaint mom n pop-esque establishment and we had great service. I can't stress how great the pizza was. read more

I have ordered from Johns for many years. Just realized I haven't given them a review. They have consistently delivered a top notch pizza. Keep up the good work! Just had a pizza last night from them and it was hot , delicious, and arrived early. What more can you ask for? Garlic bread, that's what you can ask for. We didn't get any last night but have in the past, very good, buttery, garlicky goodness. read more

Just moved to the area and went to John's on a friend's recommendation. Pizza was AMAZING, and I'm not a pizza fan at all. Well worth your time! The only drawback was the expensive ($4+) piece of cheesecake - very good but pricey. read more

Here's the skinny! We ordered carryout, delivered on time as promised. Pizza (double crust) was fabulous! Chicken wings were atypical, boneless...more like nuggets, they were good as well. Forego the $6 junk salad, it's value is more like $1.99. Delivered salad without forks, and no crushed red pepper or parmesan to top the pizza. read more

Came in pretty late but the server was incredibly nice and the food was excellent. Definitely a great place to get pizza in Port Washington!

We've ordered take out from here for years. Consistent quality - very cheesy. The egg roll wrapper mozzarella sticks are awesome.

Some of the best Pizza I have had!!! I travel a lot for work I usually treat myself to Pizza on Friday where ever in the country I am . I jumped on Yelp to find a place close to the hotel and found this place nice little place clean and inviting. The staff were friendly and the beer was cold. Pizza was amazingly good I had eaten half the pizza before I even realized. I will be back next time I come to town. Thank you. read more

Excellent pizza plenty of toppings and always delivered hot we've had their chicken and plenty of other items on their menu and never had a bad meal I would suggest you give it a try read more

We recently moved here and we were looking for a local pizza place so this seemed to fit the bill. The girl who answered the phone was rude and not helpful at all. The center of the pizza was undercooked and the crust in that area was soggy and limp. The pizza was cut in a traditional pie shape but then it seemed like someone also cut a ring about six inches in diameter in the center?? Every time we tried to use a spatula to get a piece it came apart half way thru... The delivery guy was friendly and deserving of the extra tip I gave him. The garlic bread with mozzarella was very good and the cheesecake was good as well. Given our experience I think the place should be called Johns Cheesecake because the pizza was not the star here. Very disappointing. read more

The delivery was 40 minutes late. The pizza was COLD. The crust was CHEWEY. And the pizza (once we REHEATED it) was BLAND. This once favorite local spot has lost it hospitality (delivery person was not friendly), and quality. Will not recommend this place ever again. They should not have gotten complacent and lazy just because they're known locally. read more

Not a very welcoming atmosphere. My husband stopped at the counter, on the way back from the bathroom, to check out the beer selection. The guy (owner?) sitting at the counter gruffly asked, "what are you doing?" My husband didn't realize a beer list had already been delivered to our table but the guy was not very pleasant to him. There was one other table occupied, and they already were eating, when we walked in. We ordered our pizza and waited. People came and went for carryout orders. After about 50 min of waiting our server stopped by our table and told us, the ONLY dine-in customers, that she would check on our pizza. "Glitch in the new system, the order didn't go through but they were going to make our pizza right away"...how did the two people eating when we arrived ever get their food? In her defense, our server was new and this will hopefully be a learning moment for her. We told her to forget it and she proceeded to ring up our two beers & cup of soup. We told her how disappointed we were and she said she was sorry & counted out our change. When my husband said we were posting our experience online, someone then came up from the kitchen, apologized, gave us our $20 back and offered to have our pizza delivered. It had been a long day and we were hungry but were now no longer in the mood. We are out-of-town visitors but know where we will not go to eat next time we're in Port. One star is for the pretty good beer list and my husband thought the soup was good. read more