I came here hungry. I left humbled…read more This sandwich has strips of flank steak stir fried with peppers and red onion like the cook had something to prove. Not aggressively. Confidently. The kind of confidence that doesn't announce itself, it just delivers. Then there's the crema de cilantro and aji, which basically tag team your taste buds and ask, "You good?" Yes. I'm great. Mind your business. This is not a, "Instagram made me do it" sandwich. This is a composed, disciplined, shut up and eat sandwich. Every ingredient is there on purpose. No freeloaders. The owner is a Peruvian chef who lived in Canada and now cooks in New Jersey, which explains why this sandwich has flavor, restraint, and zero patience for mediocrity. This isn't fusion, it's life experience on bread. Fair warning: eating this will ruin weaker sandwiches for you. You'll start asking questions. You'll judge more. You'll be disappointed elsewhere. Peruvian soul inside, llamas, Incas, Cusco, with Maplewood graffiti keeping it honest.

I came here with my son for lunch, which I originally planned to have at home. What a great…read moreexperience: friendly service, very attentive to my son's allergies, nice atmosphere and, most importantly, great tasting sandwich. Would definitely come back and recommend.

Was walking around South Orange and noticed this establishment. Reminded me of a local deli in NYC…read more The place is well lit, staff is super friendly! This is like I one stop shop, cakes, sandwiches, smoothies, fruits, chips, juices, etc. OMAR was awesome, answered all my questions. I love a good deli with great service. They have a seating area in the rear of the deli. I got a good ole chopped cheese and it didn't disappoint! Also, got me a slice of a Dubai chocolate cake: moist and yummy!!! The cool thing here they give you a mini buzzer when you order!!

Great new addition in town. The owners and workers are so friendly which makes you want to continue…read moreto patronize their business and see them do well. They have a great variety of options.

Tried millburn for the first time today. My coworker and I aren't from around here. In short, the…read morestaff were kind of sidelining me because I didn't take a ticket. My coworker didn't either, but he was able to make his order and get his food before anyone ever looked at me. Well I guess the owner noticed that I was being very patient and piad for my food. The food is really good and I love the old school deli aesthetic.

Over the weekend I made my at least 5th order here. Every time it is very predictable no matter…read morewhat I get., excellent!!! They have to put a lot of thought and love into everything that they put out. Home of the best Sloppy Joes!! From sandwiches to salad to iced tea and desserts I highly recommend this place. I had to take the time to leave a review this time because I felt it was very overdue. The gobbler sandwich is yummy, The Godfadda, The Gossip Girl, I also have had an egg salad with layer of tuna salad Sloppy Joe-that is amazing! The Cobb salad is also a fave. My friends rave about all the sandwiches they have tried. They are very friendly behind the counter and the order takers are fast and efficient. It gets crowded but moves fast.

I am new to the area, but have wandered up and down Maplewood Avenue several times in the few…read moremonths here. I had overlooked this place 'til now as it sits in a row of more obvious eateries with sidewalk seating. A cold case with interesting and tasty looking salads convinced me to give them a try and I am not sorry. I ordered through the kiosk and was tickled to see my favorite fish sandwich on the menu. Served on a nice hamburger bun, the crispy fresh white fish was perfectly cooked and piled high with fish. All the condiments--lettuce, pickle (hold the tomato) capers and tartar sauce set the fish off wonderfully. Staff is friendly and efficient. Everything is prepared as a "to-go" order and served up in a nice package, but there are tables where you can sit and eat your "to-go." I was eager to get back home to my pup, so I did take it home and it was still hot when I got there. The corn salad I had as a side was awesome and in a lovely light lemon dressing.

Amazing sandwiches and soups! The chopped Italian is a monster. Love it. If I could afford it, I'd…read moreeat here all the time. I'd love to try all their sandwiches -- I've had a few so far and all were excellent.

Wow what a superb breakfast Sammy! The layers of my Becky were absolutely scrumptious, and I made…read morean excellent choice of adding a hash brown. Everything was so flavorful. Don't sleep on the donuts either! The Nutella Cronut was a delightful treat. Parking near here can be tough on the weekend.

My friend picked up this sandwich for me while I got my hair done and WOW did it hit the spot! From…read morethe sauce to the crispy hash brown and bacon to the soft bun - it really was delicious. Messy but worth it.

After phoning in my order yesterday, I looked at my call history and hadn't been here since July…read more2025. So here is an updated review. I ordered an italian chicken cutlet sandwich (chopped), fries comes on it of course, along with mayo, ketchup, pepper (hold the salt), and grilled onions (hold the peppers). I usually go with a half portion is more than enough; a whole could easily feed two or more people. I am glad to see that that hasn't changed, despite the prices going up and the 3% surcharge if you do not pay in cash. Pro tip: if you can, pay in cash!!! My sandwich was delicious! Better than the last time. It was made precisely to my liking, just the way I ordered it. The service over the phone was friendly and in the store for pick up it was efficient and swift. I was in and out, thankfully, because it was crowded. If ever the craving strikes again, I'll be back!

Okay, I'm writing this while finishing the rest of my lunch because this place deserves the review…read moreimmediately. A content creator's video popped up on my timeline, and I'm so glad it did. I immediately looked this shop up, and it absolutely did not disappoint. I ordered the #4 Half Italian Sub (pictured), and my fiancé got the Unlimited Cheeseburger Sandwich (not pictured), which was HUGE. Both sandwiches were incredibly fresh and packed with flavor. The experience was even better because of the staff. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted so warmly. They could tell it was our first visit, recommended their favorite sandwiches, and shared a little about the shop's history and how long they've been in business. Between the genuinely friendly service and the delicious food, they've already earned two repeat customers. This place is officially a new staple for us, and we can't wait to come back!

I ordered from here, and I have to say, I really enjoyed it. I got a turkey sub with the works:…read morelettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar, salt, pepper, and oregano. Everything was fresh, the bread had just the right amount of crunch, and the sandwich was made perfectly without being soggy. It was honestly chef's kiss! The prices were reasonable, and the customer service was friendly and welcoming. I'll definitely be back!

This place has become absolutely ridiculous. Imagine placing your order ahead of time and still…read morewaiting more than 20 minutes to get your food. What's the point of ordering in advance? Anthony, if you read this, you seriously need to check what's happening at this location. You either need to replace some of these employees or take their phones away, because they seem far more interested in being on their phones than preparing customers' orders. And don't even get me started on the customer service. It's practically nonexistent. There is no sense of urgency, no accountability, and no respect for people's time. Customers shouldn't have to stand around watching employees ignore them while orders pile up. I've known the history of Tony Boys Sandwiches and Anthony for years, which makes it even more frustrating to watch this location decline. It's hard to believe this is the standard that's now being accepted. Poor management, unprofessional employees, constant mistakes, and a complete lack of accountability are driving loyal customers away. A successful business depends on discipline, customer service, and competent staff--not employees who seem more interested in their phones than doing their jobs. Anthony, if you care about your reputation, it's time to clean house and restore the standards that built this business. This location needs a complete reset. .

I stumbled across this place and I absolutely ended up loving it. They have a nice small menu with…read morea little seating area inside so you can order some food. The main highlight of this place is the little marketplace inside the shop. There's all different types of fair trade homemade organic items in here that are just so great to be able to have all in one place. It definitely is your charcuterie board go to center. They were so nice letting us try all different flavor of their cheeses before we purchase the one that we liked. I'm definitely going back to get there cheese again. Their staff were soak accommodating. It's so nice and welcoming. Highly recommend checking this place out with some friends.

My boyfriend and I came here Saturday night looking for a cheese board to have with a bottle of…read morewine. This spot is byob so we were able to bring our new favorite Pinot noir, which paired amazingly with the drunken goat Reserva cheese, the vegan cashew sharp pimento cheese, and the sheep's milk secret de compostelle cheese. Jacob at the cheese counter was more than helpful, answering all of our many questions and going out of his way to help us make our own spread. He let us sample everything we asked about and offered to cut up an apple and baguette for us to enjoy with our cheese selections. He really made the experience special for us with his effort and kindness! We grabbed a bag of candy grapes and crackers they had for sale and got to munching on the cheese. I have to say, it was one of the best cheese experiences we've ever had. There was a vinyl DJ setting the vibes and the dining area felt elegant and clean. If you are a looking for a fun shopping experience or to try some high quality cheeses, The Wheelhouse is the place to be!

Good subs, good value,…read more fast service even during a busy time they make the sandwiches to order in a timely fashion.

W when they first opened up, it was unbelievable, the owner was there, the food was fresh, and very…read moregood tasting. I went yesterday and got a tuna sub. I had more pepper on it than what was in the pepper shaker itself. It was an edible and I threw it away. Times are tough and money is tight I will not be going back.

The taste was Ok. I think I need to try them again, after all, everyone deserves a second chance…read more I discover this place while hunting for a location that delivers to my office. I ordered the Big Fat Moya and Onion Rings for delivery. The Big Fat Moya is a fat sandwich that comes with cheesesteak, mozzarella sticks, fried ravioli, perogies, yellow america, and marinara sauce. I requested chicken cheesesteak instead of regular cheesesteak. First off, they took quite a bit to deliver, but then again it was a serious sandwich, so I'm not holding that against them. Secondly, they forgot the onion rings. I had to call and let them know. The redelivered it. Thirdly, the fried ravioli taste HORRIBLE! I had to pull them off and toss them. SOOOO DRY and I don't, the filling just didn't taste right. All of this really ruined my first-timer experience. I'll be giving them another try though because I really thing this place has some potential. Don't be afraid to give them a try but until next time, ~~Keep a Big Fat Smile on your face!

Decent wrap and sandwiches. Like that you can order online but the times provided are not accurate…read moreso that needs to be updated. I had a grilled chicken wrap with avocado which was a $2 surcharge for, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella. Would recommend this place.