I picked up Sunday breakfast for my husband and me from Bagel Nosh and matcha drinks from Starbucks around the corner. This was my first time going to Bagel Nosh. It's always so busy whenever I drive past that I chicken out braving the private parking lot in the back and the ordering queue inside. But today, I learned that it's all worth it because, true to their reputation, they have very good bagels here! Plus, the people working there are nice! I give a 5 star just for my everything bagel with cream cheese, lox, capers, onion, and tomato. It had all the right proportions of spread and toppings for a very good lox bagel sandwich. My hubs bagel was a cinnamon raison with butter. Their bagels are fluffy and chewy, so I would opt to keep it untoasted (my preference). While there's Starbucks nearby in the same building, next time I'll try the coffee from Bagel Nosh. They also had an assortment of Tropicana orange and fruit juices. The coffee dispensers and drink cold case are to the right when you enter. New Visitor Note: When you enter, head to the right to place orders. When it's packed inside, like when I visited for the first time, it can be confusing. You may need to ask other customers where there the line begins. read more

See all

Bagel Nosh is it! I've been here several times, and each visit is even better than the last. They have so many breakfast and lunch options that it's hard to choose, but the French Toast Bagel is out of this world! This place is always jam-packed on the weekends, so be prepared to wait. There's parking in the back, but it's tight and can get congested, so plan accordingly. There are a few tables inside if you want to eat in, but space is limited. They accept both cash and all major credit cards. Definitely worth a visit. read more

Bagel Nosh - French toast bagel with bacon, egg, & cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

Came here for the first time since they opened about three years ago and ordered my usual - lox cream cheese on an everything bagel, toasted. The portion was super generous: a big, soft bagel with a thick layer of cream cheese that didn't skimp at all. That said, it didn't come out toasted like I requested, which was a bit disappointing, but not a dealbreaker since they were very busy. Everything else was solid! The staff were friendly and the overall experience was pleasant. Just a heads up, there's a 4% fee when paying by credit card. read more

Bagel Nosh - Sandwiches Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

A disrespectful "person-in-charge (not the owner)": Bagel Nosh, a go to place for us when going for starbucks. Owners have always been gracious to their customers, beyond just a smile. The process - order, wait, pay when your item is ready. Me - I make a quick trip next door to pick up my caffeine shot. I pay after placing an order, when there are less people. I come back, pick up my order, and return home for my meetings. Efficient and always accommodated by the owners / folks in charge with a smile. Today is not. The "person in charge" (tallest of them all) just blurted tersely "i dont have a ticket". As i was calmly explaining, she turned her back and did what she wanted to do, in my mid-sentence. Basically ignoring my request, without proper 'conversation'. It was not a text. it was a conversation. It was disrespectful and rude, especially when owner herself has always been gracious in accommodating the request. It will not be my intent to go back and be disrespected. read more

The service at this place is wonderful. Staff is nice. However, they have burnt my bagel every single time! Iv'e ordered 4 times by now, before writing this review and even after asking them to lightly toast it my bagel is burnt every-time! The seeds taste bitter, the bagel is extremely crispy making it really hard to eat. I've ordered regular bagel, as well as Flagel but the experience has been the same-Disappointing. I also wish this place had jalapeño bagel options which it does not. Overall, I would try other local bagel shops instead. read more

Bagel Nosh - Burnt Flagel - Sandwiches Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

I travel all over NJ daily for work. I know the best bagel and deli spots all over the state. This bagel store is by far the most expensive shop I have ever been to. I'm doing a job close by and have given them several tries. Last trip I got salami and cheese on a bagel with large coffee - $21. Yes, over $20! Last week I had a bagel with tuna, bacon and cheese. It was over $18. Complete insanity! read more

My son and Daughter-In-Law brought me a bagel with walnut raisin cream cheese. It was delicious so fresh very fresh. And they are always very nice to my family. read more

3.5 stars rounded up. Pretty sure I got overcharged in the pandemonium of the checkout line. Waited 5 minutes to order and then 15 minutes for two bagel sandwiches, one of which had no meat but somehow came out to over $10. It seems like odd pricing can happen easily in the chaos because you are shuffled through. Bagels were delicious but it's incredibly expensive to begin with, and was a really crowded and unpleasant waiting experience. read more

We had an awesome experience last Saturday. Livingston Lancer Softball had a team brunch before a game and we ordered our sandwiches from here. The 18 sandwiches were all done correctly and clearly marked with each person's name. We got a great price, and the customer service at the counter was extremely pleasant! Thank you so much!! read more

service food and atmosphere was amazing, customer service is behind great, atmosphere and hospitality is great, we ordered egg breakfast platters and was so delicious I will be back for sure read more

Food was amazing as always and the customer service was very good.And the place was clean. read more

Bagel Nosh - Pumpernickel bagel w chive cream cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

I stopped in here for the first time this week to pick up a sandwich. Went with one of my favorites; bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel. I found the bagel a bit too soft and doughy. The sandwich was disappointing to me. I rarely complain about the cost of a meal, especially if it's very good. I also understand that the cost of ingredients has gone up, especially eggs, but still $9.05 is a bit much for this sandwich. read more

Bagel Nosh - Sandwiches Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

See all

Food is always amazing. The bagels are amazing. I really love the Asiago Bagel w Veggie Cream cheese but you can order anything and it's always delicious! The baked goods are 10/10 as well. My personal favorite is the blueberry crumble read more

I cannot recommend Bagel Nosh enough. We are regular customers but I wanted to share one particular experience from January 2026. My mother in law passed away and we used bagel nosh for our shiva. As always, the food was terrific and plentiful. Dee was able to provide a server to help and everything went well. But where Dee really shined was the next day. She arrived at our house to check on all of the platters, re-mold the cream cheese and butter, and make some cute characters out of fruit. That level of service to ensure a grieving family had one less thing to worry about is what endures Dee to our town. We cannot thank Dee and her team enough for their support. Best bagels and best service around! read more

i'm not joking when i say this is the best bagel place within 10 miles. me and my friends drive here everytime we want bagels and it's 20 minutes out of our way. SO GOOD. owner is so nice too and all the workers are awesome. read more

This is a fantastic place, starting with location, which is close to the corner of Mount Pleasant Avenue and S. Livingston Ave. in Livingston. Very easy to get in and out of the parking lot. I went in today and ordered a rainbow bagel with lox cream cheese spread. What I got was one of the best bagels I've ever had... Beautiful large bagel with the perfect amount of cream cheese/lox spread ratio. The bagels are very crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The bagel spread was great also. The woman that helped me at the counter was very helpful and pleasant. She did a great job putting my order together. I highly recommend Bagel Nosh as the best bagel store in the area. I have nothing whatsoever to do with this restaurant except being a loyal customer. The staff is extremely friendly. read more

A very nice bagels shop Hot BIG bagels and lot of varieties... Their veggie cream cheese is really good We tried the onion, multigrain bagels and French toast bagels with strawberry cream cheese .. all of them were good- a little hard for my taste but good taste.. They also have egg sandwiches with meat- we tried two eggs and bacon on a croissant and really liked it Will be back to try more varieties read more

Bagel Nosh - Eggs and bacon on croissant .. - Sandwiches Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

See all

This bagel spot is honestly the best part of my morning. The bagels are always fresh, warm, and perfectly chewy--the kind that don't even need extra toppings to taste amazing. You can tell they care about what they make, and the staff always make you feel welcome. It's one of those places that just makes your day better the second you walk in. I've tried other spots, but nothing compares to this one read more

Stopped by to grab a bagel for later. Arriving fairly early on Saturday morning, I was able to place my order immediately. Shop was small with a few tables around the sides. Staff was friendly and had smiles on their faces. Bagels were fresh and delicious. Think that they forgot to toast mine, but very good. Definitely a nice place with convenient parking and worth a visit. read more

See all

I come here all the time and enjoy the bagels and chicken salad. Today I was ignored by 3 employees and I was initially the only person waiting. When I was helped it was very unfriendly but others were asked politely if they needed help. I ordered about 18 bagels and the majority of my everything bagels were basically burnt. I asked for the softer ones because my Dad can't chew the tougher ones and I am driving to North Carolina today with them on a visit since he loves these bagels. The employee dumped them out clearly irritated but still put 4 burnt ones in the bag which I discovered at home. My first bad experience here and I am quite disappointed. I was polite in my reasonable ask as usual but felt uncomfortable the entire time I was in the shop. read more

A must do when we're in NJ. I had the cream cheese with lox and hubby had a plain bagel with Taylor ham. Nothing beats a Jersey bagel when you live in Florida where the bagels just suck lol. Attentive staff. read more

I've tried all the other spots and these are hands down, the best bagels in the area and it's not even close. Big, always fresh, airy not dense, and crispy on the outside. Best bagels. Best service. What more do you want? read more

Have to be the best bagels I've ever had. I work on pleasant Ave and come here multiple times a week for lunch. The staff is amazing and friendly and always creates a pleasant environment to hang out in. The bagels are authentic and always fresh. I usually get Taylor bacon egg n cheese and it's . Today I asked for a healthier option and the owner Dee made me a special wrap that's not on the menu. She has to add it, look how good it looks! If you come here, ask Dee for "Dees wrap" and she'll make it for you. Epic read more

Bagel Nosh - Dee's Wrap - Sandwiches Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

We have been customers of Bagel Nosh for our usual weekly trip (both for us and family members in Monmouth County), as well as the occasional breakfast sandwich. Their bagels are what my grandmother would call "pluchy" -- soft on the inside, crunchy outside, large and they take a schmear of butter or cream cheese that would make the old Carnegie Deli proud. We needed quite a few platters for a shiva two months ago, and Dee and her crew came through beautifully -- an amazing assortment of fish, spreads and bagels, nicely arranged, and kept us fed for a few days. read more

Highly recommend Bagel Nosh!! We catered from here for my son's fifth birthday party and we were extremely impressed by the spread! Many parents commented on the spread, asking where we ordered from! Great quality food. Gorgeous presentation. So easy to order! 10/10 !!! read more

See all

Food was great, I loved the spinach croissant. Very relaxed atmosphere. The owner is the best. I will definitely make this my new bagel goto spot. read more

Bagel Nosh - Spinach croissant with fruit cup. - Sandwiches Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

I keep having to update my personal list of best bagels in the area. Since this spot opened up, it's consistently been the #1 place IMO. Their bagels are a little crispy, a little doughy and a lot of delicious! They have garlic bagels too...and their spreads are yummy. Strawberry CC on a CinnRaisin...yes please! THC on an everything, why yes! The owner is the nicest guy and remembers his customers! He even takes care of them with a complimentary this or discounted that. His old crew is back too (he owned a spot in Chatham). Welcome to Madison! ENJOY! read more

Perhaps one of the best bagel places I visited. Bagels are done fresh, and some of them are very unique. The price of the bagels was right too. Delicious. Awesome place. Customer service was great too. I will definitely return if I am in this area. The parking lot was full as well. Glad that I visited here by accident. Awesome place. read more

See all

I don't like writing reviews like these but it's important to inform others of what they may encounter. I came in yesterday for two Taylor ham egg & cheese sandwiches. If you'll see on the menu here, the total price would be $7.49. I was charged $18.64 at the register and when I checked my bank statement, that price rose to $19.39. When you do the math, ~.50c of tax on each sandwich doesn't add up to the almost $5.00 extra I was charged. Putting price aside, these bagels are okay. Nothing to write home about, and certainly not worth $20 for two breakfast sandwiches. read more

Bagel Nosh - Sandwiches Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

Masters of all things sandwich. Bagel Nosh, as the name suggests, specializes in bagels, and things to spread on them. From assortments of cream cheese to tuna and egg salads, they'll make you delicious sandwiches made from freshly baked bagels and then smothered with delicious toppings. I cannot stress the quality of the bagels. At no time during my first visit over a Sunday brunch was there a period where I didn't see bakers toiling away in the kitchen. New bagels were being brought out every few minutes, replacing a quickly dwindling supply. The bagels come in every flavor imaginable, with their asiago bagel being one of the best I ever had, with a massive amount of perfectly crispy cheese baked right into the tops of the bagels. They even have "flat" bagels, which are shorter but wider bagels, giving you more surface to add your toppings. Bagel Nosh makes bagels with cream cheese, bagel breakfast sandwiches, and other bagel sandwiches. They also have wraps, burritos, and traditional sandwiches, with everything they serve on a bagel also coming with other bread choices. Though if you are a true bagel fanatic, you get the bagel every time. I enjoyed their bagel with lox sandwich, the most expensive thing on the menu. My bagel was STACKED with lox and the green onion cream cheese paired perfectly with it. I had my bagel topped with refreshing tomatoes and bitter red onions, and if I had any complaint, it's the lack of capers as an optional topping. Capers add a bit of sour bite that helps bring out the best in the lox. If I had to nitpick, I'd point out two things. First, Bagel Nosh has mediocre coffee, but this is most likely due to being located next to a Starbucks. They don't mind people bringing in their coffee from next door, so I recommend you do the same if you want coffee with your bagel. Second, there is very limited seating, with most of it being outdoors. If it's raining, don't plan on eating at Bagel Nosh, and if it isn't, bring someone to hold a table as soon as it opens up. Well priced, good service, and delicious food makes Bagel Nosh my new favorite brunch stop in Livingston. read more

I am so glad to see a great bagel shop on the north side of Livingston. I went on Saturday at around 11:45am. I am grateful that I could find parking. When I went inside the store, the line was really long. I waited around 30 minutes to receive my order and left. People were patient while waiting. The owner (lady) was really nice. I could tell she was really tired, and with so many things sold out, it was difficult to please all customers. The bagel sandwiches were very good. The muffins and croissants were very good too. I will definitely come back again. Highly recommend. read more

so funny and such good bagels! the everything bagel is actually so good. will definitely be coming back soon.

The most amazing food! The most amazing catering! The greatest bagel store ever! We recently had a family celebration and were so impressed and happy with the platters, the presentation, the quantity of food...nothing short of fantastic!!! Thank you Dee for providing us with the absolute "best"!!! xoxo read more

Ok so update your menus? Not looking for excuses, looking for accountability and transparency.

a great bagel place in town! staff and owner were super friendly. I got their flagel and lox and they were both delicious. Will definitely be coming back. read more

The bagels are excellent The Flagels are great but Dee and the staff are the best!!

Love: they seem to make bagels constantly during peak times and will let you know which ones are hot/warm. Those are the best! Also, bagels are huge. Dislike: prices don't match the menu, there should be transparency like prices listed on drink case, items not on menu etc because it's crazy and seems different every time. There is a small discount if you use cash. read more

Started going to bagel Nosh past year,and glad I did. Everything i order is always fresh. The salads well prepared and most of all the staff is extremely courteous. The owner always makes you feel at home, and wants to make sure everything is perfect.The place is always immaculate, and all around ,terrific in all aspects. Gary K read more

If you haven't visited the Bagel Nosh in Livingston,NJ it is a MUST! They are the best in the area for fresh bagels, sandwiches, and catering any event you may have. Stop in and check it out... read more

The Bagel Nosh in Livingston is the absolute best!! They flawlessly catered my shiva for more than 100 people and every single thing was perfect. All of the platters were gorgeous and beyond delicious! Thank you Dee for your tremendous kindness, professionalism, and for handling everything so beautifully from start to finish. I will never go anywhere else and will continue to spread the word about your outstanding food and service. read more