One of the best burgers I've had in years, perfectly put together and cooked. Food here is all…read morefresh and made in house, if you like sweet potato fries these are the best, hand cut, not frozen from a bag. This is a neighborhood watering hole since 1912 and the inside shows the bumps and bruises that create the character of this bar. Drinks are poured with a heavy hand and are priced right. Service is outstanding and may come with a story or two. I really enjoyed it here and with so many places selling burgers this one serves some of the best. Great specials as well, definitely going back

My wife and I came in here a couple of weeks ago, and I ended up winning a free 1890 burger because…read moreof a promotion they were running for its anniversary. The burger was delicious. I had eaten most of it before finding out about the promotion, so I know that the fact it was free isn't swaying my opinion on it. I would definitely come back the next time we are in the area.

Fast service, great music, and truly a tucked away gem. I always come late at night and wish that I…read morehad come sooner. This is definitely a great dive bar with a bit of a twist. A true mix of all ages are there, which is usually hard to find a spot that all gravitate towards and fit seamlessly.

Nice spot in the village for drinks when it's not packed out. Lots of beers on tap and mixed…read moredrinks to chose from. Nice outdoor space in the back with a bar. Bar definitely has a "college" feel. TV's by the bar are tiny :( Worth checking out if you're in the area.

Cavan was an incredible server. We tried to give her some shit and she gave it right back. Plus she…read moremade excellent recommendations for food and throughout the city. This place is lucky to have a server like her, honestly. The ambiance of this place is great, right off the main road and electric vibe. Great find.

Went to the bar for a basketball game and the service was fantastic, Jackson and Keenan tended the…read morebar and were very respectful and served us very quickly!

Been to this spot a million times and it has been fine. Nothing fancy, just a nice small saloon…read more Never had a problem until Saturday night when the tool they hired to play bouncer chose to not let me in "just because ". His words. I was sober and dressed so those aren't the reason. Not sure who pissed in his cornflakes that morning but I hope he adjusts his attitude and is better in the future. I WILL be returning as it's a nice small saloon

It's very rare that I get out to concerts in Long Island since I am relying on mass transit but…read morewhen its a band like Judas Priest you make the proper arrangements and mobilize to the event. This Yelp however is about the place to pregame before the show and since I am unfamiliar with the area, I had to ask friends who have been there often what the available options were for me to explore. The biggest recommendation was the bar a few doors down from The Paramount Theater called Huntington Village Tavern. So far I have been here twice and since I don't know when I will be in the area again I wanted to Yelp something up. Spatially speaking the bar is nicely laid out. You have some hightop tables at the front of the big bay window that looks out onto the avenue, the main bar (which is rather long) and a back area that I think houses a pool table. I didn't go back there so am not 100% sure. Now my standard fare at a bar is a couple of pints of beer and not much else. I am not a spirits guy but the tavern appeared to be stockpiled with all of the needed good stuff for the customer who requires that. There is no food being served at the bar, but they allow you to bring in stuff to eat and right near by is pizza, some burgers and a wonderful Spanish food place. I went to that last one but that it for a Yelp of its own. The bar staff was congenial and served my party their drinks nice and fast. This was great since the time frame that I had to get into the show was not really much. I had a WiFi signal when I was in there so am assuming it was theirs but I cannot confirm that this is the case. I will definitely go back there should I be planning on an event at the Paramount. You should do the same.

Fabulous little watering hole! Attentive Staff, Cold Beer, great drink specials, Juke Box, Pool…read moreTable and.... Some of the Best Burger Sliders I have had in ages!!! Very Friendly and Cool Vibe.

Well, I think saying i'm a fan is a bit strong. It's more like i'm a fan of the times that I've had…read morethere. But in any case, this place is a dive. It's exactly what you would think of when you think ghetto bar in the 'burbs. BUT, the bartenders are always super friendly, and surprisingly trustworthy. I gave the bartender my card, asked him to only give me $50 worth of booze for the night, and I had all I wanted, bought my friends plenty of drinks, and then still had enough to give him a $15 tip. Now, I advise young good looking women to NOT go alone. I'm sure it's fine, I'm sure nothing will happen, but if you want to be oggled in not a particularly pleasant way then, go alone. But, if you're in a group, it's perfect. 30 of your nearest and dearest friends, and it turns into the best place to be in in Commack/E.Npt for miles around! Cheap drinks....i've never eaten there, but apparently it's pretty good. Plenty of parking...... KARAOKE night is on Friday! It's a new thing, and again, the place is usually empty so you'll have to bring your own possie, but it's worth it!

Wow, what a surprise! Definitely a hidden gem for sure!! We went here on St Pattys Day, even…read morethough it was very crowded we were welcomed literally seconds after entering! Took a while but we finally got a seat at the bar. Bartenders were working hard yet found the time to quickly ask what we wanted! My husband had a beer (easy), I had a margarita made "my" way, and it was perfect!!! . Good size menu. Husband ordered a St Pattys special and I had a Ruben. The food was totally amazing, we both cleared our plates quickly, lol. This is a must try restaurant/Irish pub!! The restaurant was incredibly clean, beautiful wood work, service was impeccable, and the food and drinks were outstanding!! What more could you ask for?!?!!!! We will be returning... next week!!!

Consistently excellent food and excellent service!…read more Love our waitress, JILL! Food was great- love the atmosphere- the whole vibe... My skirt steak was PERFECTION!!! Spinach/artichoke/cheese dip was the best we have ever had.

The food was phenomenal. The food looked good and tasted even better. The serving team was…read moreprofessional and friendly. I've enjoyed The Shed in Sayville. It was good to see the other outlets were of equal quality. ( Now, you need to put one in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn! )

This spot was ok. I just needed a quick bite…read more Picked up their sea bass sandwich and a small Caesar salad. Um the Caesar actually tasted bland. Usually, I would complain that places put too much dressing. Oddly, this time they didn't put enough. They over cooked my fish. I did enjoy the slaw though. I feel like they make better drinks than food. I sat at the bar and the bartenders were pretty awesome. Knocking out drinks and they seemed to just genuinely care it was right. They checked on me a few times. I didn't have time to fix my food. Honestly, if you can't get a Caesar salad right... It'll be a waste of time hoping it would be better a 2nd time.

Good beer. Good burgers. Good Mac n cheese. Good wings. Good fries! What's not to like?…read more It's always a good time with good food and drinks. This place always hits consistent home runs!

10 years later, they must be doing something right. Sunday…read moreevening, it was not crowded at all but still very very noisy. The waitress was nice. We started with the pretzel and the artichoke dip, they were both ok. I shared a burger with my mom, it was a 2 patty smash burger, no cheese. It had cooked onions, pickles and some kind of sauce, we both liked it. We also had truffle fries. Everyone at our table got a burger and everyone liked them. We had to get out of there because it was so noisy, even the staff were pretty much screaming. Next time I'll sit outside!