Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Keyport Mercantile & Sandwhich

    4.5 (2 reviews)

    Keyport Mercantile & Sandwhich Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Keyport Mercantile & Sandwhich

    Recommended Reviews - Keyport Mercantile & Sandwhich

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ash C.
    73
    18
    7

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 22,154 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Farrelli's Pizza

    Farrelli's Pizza

    3.7(89 reviews)
    4.5 mi
    $$

    Ordered togo again To take to the park for lunch. Have been there a few times over the past few…read moremonths. This time ordered the lasagna which comes with garlic bread (which doesn't taste like garlic at all, but mops up the sauce like bread should) and a small Caesar or side salad. Wife ordered the Burrata caprese. Lasagna is the best we have had here in Kitsap! Lasagna is very tasty and a good sized piece for what you pay! Wife loved her burrata caprese and will order this order again when feeling the need for Italian food. Now for the online ordering, when you mark utensils for 2 people, you would think the utensils would be in the bag......uhhh Nope! Not even napkins! (was the second time this happened here) Glad I had some plastic in the glovebox Or lunch would have been a B to try to eat!

    Edited: See below…read more Horrible service, not sure what has happened to this place but if this is what they are now offering i will not be back. Took 15 minutes before anybody even came to our table and it was the guy running the bar... so apparently they are running short handed. After he finally took our drink order it was another 7-8 minutes before our drinks came. That is at least 20 minutes before we even got drinks. Unacceptable. We saw others getting just as frustrated. I saw an elderly couple who had to clean their own table because no one was cleaning tables and no one came around to clean their table. After receiving our drinks we did not see our waiter again for another 20 minutes or more. This is ridiculous. We are now here over an hour and 15mins and still do not have our pizza. About to pay for our drinks and leave. Finally 1hr and 30 minutes later i go up the bar and very loudly ask the man who had not been back to our table since he brought us our drinks.... Would we be getting the pizza we ordered today or not? He went to the back to check and a couple minutes layer we did get our pizza. Will not be back until i hear some rave reviews because this is unacceptable. Absolutely ridiculous. Oh and the kicker here the man who waited on us, his pants were split wide open in the leg and crotch area!! You could not see anything but wtf!!! This is what you have waiting on people???? Deplorable! EDIT: 9/12/26 I will give Kudos to the Management here. After reading my review they reached out to me and were very apologetic for the service we received. You don't see customer service anywhere any more, so, this was a welcome change. Thank you. They even sent a gift card and asked me to come back and give them another try. I will certainly be doing that as I feel they truly want their customers to have an enjoyable time and will be addressing what happen on my last visit.

    Photos
    Farrelli's Pizza - The bar

    The bar

    Farrelli's Pizza
    Farrelli's Pizza - The fire oven

    See all

    The fire oven

    Sourdough Willy’s Pizzeria - BBQ pizza by the slice

    Sourdough Willy’s Pizzeria

    3.8(332 reviews)
    8.7 mi
    $$

    A group of five of us dined here on an August Sunday evening around 6 pm. We arrived without a…read morereservation and waited twenty minutes for a table. I scanned the walls and noted all the certifications and awards adorning them. My hope for a yummy pizza just went way up. After being seated in the center of the dining room, we were promptly ignored for ten minutes. Perhaps they were short-staffed this evening, but it was not a good start. We decided to order our dinners and drinks together to speed things up. The plan worked. Our food, though, showed up before our drinks, or even plates and cutlery were set up ten minutes after ordering. Boo. We started with a Caprese salad. It was fresh and tasty, but I would have enjoyed a softer cheese with it. Their mozzarella was too firm to my liking. Our two giant Sicilian pies arrived in a staggered fashion, but that was fine. These large rectangles of goodness looked inviting. We ordered a Hawaiian-style and a meat lovers pizza. This pizza was amazing. The thick crust was amazingly light and delish. I have never had a thick-crust pizza like this and not felt weighed down afterward. Great job. Service was terrible this evening, but the pizza was fabulous and made up for it. We will probably do carryout in the future, but we will be back for more of this goodness.

    We did takeout so I can't speak on the dine in experience. We picked up and promptly ate, around…read morethe corner by the water. We had The New Yorker, a large pepperoni and a Caesar salad. Pretty sure the ordering page said it's a large salad for several people, it was not but it was $17 lol dressing tasted sour and not like a real Caesar dressing as it was also watery and an almost honey mustard color. Croutons were soggy and lettuce was not the freshest. Pizza was unfortunately just ok. Nothing special in my honest opinion. The pepperoni pizza had so little tomato sauce/ pizza sauce on it that it was dry. The New Yorker wasn't flavorful or anything exciting. Was it inedible? NO! Was it worth $68 ish? Definitely NO!

    Photos
    Sourdough Willy’s Pizzeria - So cute in here!

    So cute in here!

    Sourdough Willy’s Pizzeria - Caprese salad

    Caprese salad

    Sourdough Willy’s Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza

    See all

    Cheese Pizza

    Damn Fine Pizza - Henny pizza with Soppressata, capicola, ricotta cheese, basil & hot honey yumm

    Damn Fine Pizza

    4.1(88 reviews)
    11.1 mi
    $$

    We planned a post-retirement gathering for my husband's military retirement at Fine Pizza and made…read morea reservation for 16 people. When booking, I specifically explained that I did not want our group seated in the back of the restaurant. The employee helping us was very kind and offered us the patio instead, which we happily agreed to. Unfortunately, the evening before the event, the manager called and canceled the patio reservation, moving us to the back section instead. What made the situation frustrating was not just the last-minute change, but the lack of professionalism in handling it. There was no apology offered despite the reservation already being confirmed. Her communication felt dismissive and confrontational. But she eventually agreed to atleast seat us towards the center or the restaraunt. We were also told the patio was unavailable because of a separate event, yet on that day, the patio still had several open tables during our reservation time. The food here is good. But communication, professionalism, and customer service was signifanctly lacking. Had there been clearer communication, accountability, or even a simple apology somewhere in this process, the experience would have felt very different.

    Pizza! Yes, but Calzones on point! The location is a little bizarre and off the main road, the game…read moreroom, the menu placement and service all a but wonky. But overall not bad for the price!

    Photos
    Damn Fine Pizza - 8 games currently

    8 games currently

    Damn Fine Pizza - Great pepperoni, mushroom, pineapple pizza!

    Great pepperoni, mushroom, pineapple pizza!

    Damn Fine Pizza

    See all

    Keyport Mercantile & Sandwhich - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...