Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Kitty Murtagh's

    3.7 (42 reviews)
    ModerateAmerican, Irish Pub
    Open 12:00 pm - 9:00 PM

    Kitty Murtagh's Photos

    KITTY MURTAGH'S ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Outdoor seating
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Kitty Murtagh's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Authentic
    Joan M.

    Our trip to Nantucket was interesting to say the least. After we walked up & down the pretty streets, we decided to venture away from the hub of downtown and the tourists and meandered through lots of pretty streets we happened upon this Irish pub/ restaurant. Heaven.... So as an Irish person, I am always dubious of the "Irish Pub" scenario here in the US. Today did not disappoint. The pub is large (much larger than most at home) but it was fabulous. Every aspect of the decor was nailed to a T. I loved it here. We sat at the bar, it was super quiet and we had the bar man all to ourselves. We ordered an Irish Breakfast Clam Chowder, Fries with curry sauce... ALL OF IT WAS OUTSTANDING!! Well done to everyone and especially the chef. It was just like home. It actually made me homesick to be honest. So if you are ever in Nantucket seek this hidden gem out. It's about a 30 minute walk from the ferry area and worth every step. Of course you can always call a cab or get an über!

    Kitty's
    Robert W.

    I usually eat at Kitty's about every 10 days. The food is good, the price is reasonable, and because it is located out of town parking is usually not a problem. You've GOT to try the pork schnitzel. I don't even like pork, but this version is great! UPDATE: I happened to be looking at my Yelp reviews and noticed my Kitty's review from 8 years ago. I almost hate to post this here (because I do not want them to be come tooooo popular! LOL) .....but.....Kitty's continues to be one of my go to restaurants on Nantucket. They never disappoint!

    Burger and beer. A complete meal.
    CC C.

    Kitty's won my heart today and all they had to do was serve me a good sandwich. The first visit here I got a burger. Good, but not the best I've had. On a whim, I decided to stop in again and try something new. Every place deserves a second visit before I pass judgement, and considering the lack of cheap options on the island, i have to. Ordered a French dip with Swiss on sourdough with a house salad and house made Au jus. And the skies opened up, the angels sang, and I uttered a hallelujah when I took my first bite. Good. So good I considered getting another to have for dinner. The bread was toasted perfectly, the beef tender, the Swiss a great addition... We don't have enough time to talk about why I loved this sandwich. The ultimate is the fact that my wallet didn't weep when the bill came. $11.77 after tax and a decent portion for the price. If you've gathered anything from looking at my page, you know I eat out a lot. So if the food doesn't hook me, I won't return. Kitty's did a great job hooking me. For life. I guess some people come to Kitty's for the down home, neighborhood bar feel. Really, I don't go to any place for that "Cheers" feeling, but if you're looking for that, it can be found here. I'll be back! I'll even do the unthinkable and try something different.

    Shepherd's pie, yum!

    See all

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Kitty Murtagh's

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    The Club Car Restaurant - Roasted Chicken

    The Club Car Restaurant

    3.8(158 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$$

    I seldom write bad or negative reviews, so this one flummoxed me a bit…read more The appetizer was this wonderful cold mussel dish, with spices and a light oil. Just a nice, artisan dish akin to something you'd get in New Bedford or Fall River. Fantastic. 5-Stars. Now their lobster roll. Imagine a hot dog, OK, and now imagine one of those little Jimmy Dean breakfast sausage links for size comparison. The volume of finely shredded lobster meat, that was also warm in that hot dog roll was smaller than the Jimmy Dean link. 0-Stars. My recommendations for a "good" lobster roll is to go anywhere else on island. I'd recommend Sayle's Seafood, The Nantucket Lobster Trap or Stubby's. In fact, I'd just stay clear of the Club Car altogether, it is one of those places for the self-focused New York / Miami new [vulgar] money jet-set that treat the island like their play-thing... you know, you see their empty beer cans in the morning around town. That's my story, and I'm sticking to it.

    Club Car Nantucket is an absolute 5-star go-to me. It's such a unique, lively vibe in the historic…read moretrain-car setting, with that classic Nantucket energy that feels special whether you're popping in for lunch or settling in for a full night out. The service is always on point (Bridget always takes care of us--she's genuinely so nice), and the food never misses: the lobster Cobb salad is fresh, loaded, and perfectly balanced, and the croque madame is pure comfort (savory, cheesy, and even better with the egg). And don't sleep on dinner, Club Car turns it up even more, and their steak frites is the best!

    Photos
    The Club Car Restaurant
    The Club Car Restaurant - Bouillabaisse

    Bouillabaisse

    The Club Car Restaurant

    See all

    O’Brien & Brough - Caramel Apple - O&B Blended Bourbon, apple cider, caramel syrup, butter, served warm

    O’Brien & Brough

    4.3(15 reviews)
    67.1 mi

    We love coming to O'Brien + Brough when we're home visiting!…read more Great date night spot or meeting up for classy drinks with friends. We've been here a few times and my drinks are always on point. The Clover Club Punch is one of my favorites. It's a great spot with friendly staff in an awesome location.

    What a classy, romantic, high quality addition to Bristol! Parking is usually easy to find in the…read moreplaza lot or on Wood Street if needed. Staff was very friendly and genuinely interesting to talk to the most recent time I visited. The atmosphere is perfect for a date night, with sexy, low mood lighting, trendy flower decor on the tables, even quirky and fun wallpaper in the bathrooms. The cocktail list is unique and has a little something for everyone. My drink had notes of rose which I found so different and delightful, though I ordered mine without egg white in it since I can't quite get into that cocktail ingredient trend. Everyone I've brought here has enjoyed their drink - glassware is pretty and photogenic but I do feel the portions are on the smaller side. What a great, "vibey" little spot to take a date, a friend on a bar crawl or quick afternoon catch up, and so on! Lots of other great stops in this plaza too, you could make a whole day out of this area without ever having to move your car. I feel I've traveled somewhere far away and a little exotic when I come here - a class act that hasn't let me down yet.

    Photos
    O’Brien & Brough - Agua Fresca

    Agua Fresca

    O’Brien & Brough - O'Brien & Brough and Pivotal Brewing Co shared patio

    O'Brien & Brough and Pivotal Brewing Co shared patio

    O’Brien & Brough - O'Brien & Brough Absinthe #1

    See all

    O'Brien & Brough Absinthe #1

    Kitty Murtagh's - tradamerican - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...