This is a very unique looking restaurant, with a 1950s vibe. As far as food goes, for me, it's been hit or miss. I wasn't crazy about the pizza the first time I had it, but all the sandwiches have been delicious. The food comes out of the kitchen pretty fast. When I ordered over the phone, they said 15 minutes and it was ready in 15 minutes. read more

Ok, so this is really a 3.75 stars out of 5 but Yelp doesn't do half or quarter stars! I don't think Knuckle Sandwich is quite a four but it's not a three either so we're somewhere in between. The place is super cute. All the decor is really fun and when you see the location from the outside, you wouldn't expect how great it's going to look inside. Nice job with all the decor and theming. The menu has what you would expect from a diner - burgers, tenderloin, chicken and the food is solid. My tenderloin was very large and cooked the way I like them. They even found a bun that was almost large enough haha! I did think the tenderloin needed a little more seasoning. Just something else so I added Cajun seasoning to my leftovers and that was quite good. My husband got a grilled chicken sandwich and also enjoyed it. He really liked everything about this place and is talking about bringing his dad and going back another time. read more

Knuckle Sandwich - Hubcab Tenderloin - Diners Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

I love a good diner! It's so cute inside and exceptionally clean. I stopped in for breakfast on a Sunday. Their breakfast menu is the smallest part of their menu but they still have a good variety of items. My mom and brother both got an omelet and I went with the Classic Camaro breakfast which was eggs, bacon or sausage, hash browns or home fries, and toast. Everything was delicious! We got food quickly and the server was friendly. She checked in on coffee refills multiple times. read more

Knuckle Sandwich - Classic Camaro breakfast - Diners Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

They do not offer anything for those of us who can't have all the high cholesterol foods! They need to offer turkey or chicken sausage and turkey bacon and sour dough toast! read more

This is a very cute 1950 diner. My wife, daughter and friend were promptly greeted at the front door we were set in our server. Was there in seconds the decor is awesome with old advertisements from the 1950s and pictures. We ordered a house salad the hubcap tenderloin and a BLT they were all delicious. The BLT came with fries and the wife and I split The girls ended up taking half of the hubcap tenderloin home cause it was too big to eat even for two splitting it all in all this is a fantastic family diner with polite people excellent service we will definitely come back read more

See all

Great food and service. Cute 50s diner vibe. Nice selection of sandwiches had the breaded tenderloin with the works. Fresh lettuce tomato a d onion. Hubby loved his cheeseburger. read more

We've been many times. Never had a bad meal. We had the pizza tonight and it was great.

Looking for a fun vibe? Knuckle Sandwich is the place! Tons of memorabilia on the walls and TV sets showing old shows like Gomer Pyle. Music on the jukebox has you singing along without even realizing it. After reading other yelp reviews, we decided to share the hubcap tenderloin. It was fully loaded with mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles and a huge beautiful bun. The tenderloin was hand pounded and was a little thin for my taste but it was still delicious. The fries were hot and crispy, a welcome change from cold or soggy fries. I also ordered a milkshake which was served in the metal cup. Other tables had great looking salads and burgers so we will be back. FYI cash prices are listed on the menu, a 3.5% of charge for credit card usage. read more

See all

Food was good! Fun decor if you're in to the 50's theme. ____________________________________________ ____________________________________________ read more

Love their tenderloin. the decor in this place is amazing. And the service is always great.

The atmosphere here is immaculate. They normally have 50s-60s music playing and the decor is amazing. The food is also very good and fresh. Its probably the best retro diner I've been to. I highly recommend read more

Knuckle Sandwich - Chicken tenders and fries - Diners Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

French fries terrible..cold like rocks..sandwich a greasy mess, could not stomach, so bad. Wife's also equally bad.. Sitting in booth with people behind us constantly moving and seating unsecured moving booth up and down. .. Will not be back..... read more

Very good food and really large portions. The service was good. Cute decor. We had a 12 year old boy with a bottomless appetite but after the large hot dog and huge banana split-- he was full! read more

See all

My husband and I stopped at knuckle sandwich during the week for dinner. Such a cute little place that had lots of old pictures and signs. Service was great, food was really good and a fantastic milkshake for dessert! When my in-laws come for a visit, we will be taking them here. read more

Love the atmosphere of walking in to the cool decor Our waitress was helpful with suggestions on what to order. She was on top of our needs. My huge tenderloin was seasoned and battered perfectly. The bun was also amazing as you can see it almost covered the tenderloin. I cut that in half which gave me 2 meals. Can't wait to go back. We were to full to try dessert but the milkshake and sundae looked mouthwatering read more

Knuckle Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

See all

This is a new and neat little diner in Bargersville. They have an adequate parking lot that they share with the other businesses in the strip mall that it is located. The diner is a 50s/60s themed restaurant and has a ton of neat and nostalgic decorations. They have classic music playing outside and neat booth inside that is the shape of an old red Corvette. I think seating in that special booth is reserved for those crazy enough to try their food challenge that consists of eating 2-one pound burgers and 2 pounds of french fries. That seems easy enough, huh. They have a couple of televisions in the corners in the restaurant to watch, but they are not easy to view, or at least from where I was seated. The place was slammed packed when I was there. And this was the middle of the day. I had to wait 30 minutes. They just take your name and phone number, then call you when your table is ready. The staff there was awesome, even given how busy they were. They were very friendly, welcoming and attentive. The diner serves your typical diner food including burgers, fried chicken, fish, tenderloins, pizza, soups, salads, and breakfast food. I ordered the Big Booper BLT with a side of fries. It did not disappoint. It took only about 7 minutes for them to prepare and it was fresh, hot and tasty. As advertised, it was loaded with bacon. I highly recommend it. This is an awesome joint that deserves all of the hype that it gets and then some. It has a cool Fonzie type of vibe. It is just missing the bar seating. I highly recommend checking this place out. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all

After seeing people talk about this place reopening we were driving by and decided to stop in and give it try. It's a cute little 50s themed restaurant with 50s music playing. We got got seated promptly and everything came out super fast. The sweet tea is really good We got the half and half appetizer which is onion rings and breaded mushrooms. They were just ok nothing spectacular and the portion was small for 11.99 Hubby ordered the 57 Chevy which is a very large burger however it was dry and lacked flavor. The only flavor was the pepper jack cheese. I ordered the Ruben and the meat was chewy and fatty. The rest of the sandwich was pretty good. The fries were the best part. The menu prices are cash and debit prices. Credit cards they will add an additional 3% of your total bill. I can't honestly say I'll come back. Maybe to try their breakfast which is served til 11am daily. read more

See all

After having to close a couple of years ago for the new interchange at I-69 and Hwy 144, the Knuckle Sandwich has reopened in a new location. Their theme is still the same, a 50s & 60s diner. All new retro furniture including parts of two cars, a Chevy and a Mustang, makes the interior absolutely pop. Their reputation has never dwindled. I've been hearing of one hour wait times this week. I tried to get a table yesterday and it was too crowded for me at noon. So I came today for their 10:30 opening time. Twenty people were lined up to get a table before the doors opened. I ordered my old favorite, the Philly Cheesesteak with fries and was not disappointed. It is a big sandwich on fresh bread with lots of steak and cheese. The fries are the battered style and good. They still have The Challenge where if you eat two fully dressed one pound burgers and two lbs of fries in 45 mins, it's all free and you get a T-shirt, your photo on the Wall of Fame and a trophy. Several people were on the old Wall of Fame but this wall is blank and waiting for you ;-) They still show 50s and 60s movies and TV shows on their screens. There is plenty of parking in the shared lot for the strip shopping center. Sorry I didn't get any menu photos, maybe someone else can post them. Welcome Back Knuckle! read more

See all

The food is okay, but lacks flavor sadly which I found rather disappointing and has me hesitant to return.

The food is decent not great, the service is good, the ambiance has a nice 50's or 60's kind of flair. The 57 Chevy table is cool. It was nice and clean overall. I'll go back sometime when I'm I'm the area. read more

My wife and I had lunch there a second time. The atmosphere and vibe are very appealing and unique. The grilled chicken breast and fish sandwiches are very good and plentiful. The onion rings were disappointing. They were hard, overcooked, some burned on surface. Not worth ordering again. Hence the 3 stars rather than 4 or 5. Service was good but not outstanding. read more

Great place for a fun meal. Loved the vibes, food was very good, especially the chocolate milk shake. The only reason I gave it a 4 was because we sharthe 57 burger and it was super salty in places. I'm assuming this was a mistake. We will definitely be back, I just plan on ordering something else, which there is plenty to choose from! read more

Knuckle Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

The service was fast and wonderful! And the ambiance was a perfect theme for the name of the restaurant. The tenderloin was a little dry but had a good flavor to it. read more

A southside institution! I had not been since they moved to the new location in Bargersville, and I was nervous that it would be lacking the nostalgic factor I remembered. I needn't have worried. Everything is still amazing! From the decor, to the music, the amazing and attentive waitstaff, to the exquisite food...a truly superb dining experience. read more

Knuckle Sandwich - Cuter than cute diner decor - Diners Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

The food here is okay but nothing spectacular. We had two 1-lb burgers, a 12" pepperoni pizza, and someone in our party also ordered a tenderloin, but it is not pictured. They offer a really huge tenderloin and also a more reasonably sized one on the menu here. I like having two options like this because not everyone gets a tenderloin just for the size. The smaller one is the one we had and it was really good. Why three stars? Here are a few reasons for the lower star rating: *I would have expected a 50's and 60's themed diner to be playing music from that era. When we went, it was cheesy 70's and 80's music playing. *They nickel and dime by up-charging for everything. Tomatoes on a sandwich? $0.60. If the sandwich you order is considered "large", it's $1.25. The tomatoes weren't even very good. Cheese? Same thing. I can understand charging a bit more for cheese because not everyone wants it but it was nasty ol' American cheese. Blech. *Paying with a credit card? Up-charge. Do they put all these charges on the menu? Yes, but it still annoys me when restaurants do it. Will we go back? Not sure. We have a lot of mom 'n' pop restaurants on our bucket list that we want to hit before we will likely head back for round #2 at a place that gave us a "meh" feeling. read more

Knuckle Sandwich - 57 Chevy, their 1-lb burger - Diners Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

See all

Hostess was rude and inconsiderate to new guest. Made the first impression really bad. The building itself is small they do not allow you to wait on the inside of the building it only holds 86 people max. The inside has a nice vibe about it 50-60 themed. Coffee was burnt and the creamer was spoiled. Food over all a little bland. Server was amazing very nice and sweet. Mixed feeling about coming back here read more

Knuckle Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Bargersville, Indiana

The food is just as incredible -- their signature sandwiches are packed with flavor and served with a smile. Friendly staff, great atmosphere, and unbeatable milkshakes. Definitely a new favorite!" read more

Great little diner in retro style. We arrived late and they stayed open for us. Retro decor and music good food and prices. Little off the highway but worth it. read more

There Back!!! We finally got to visit the new knuckle sandwich. They had to close their original site which was at SR 37 and 144 but closed Due to the construction for interstate 69. The new location is down on SR 135 by Whiteland Road. The menu and food is just as we remembered. We ordered half an order of onion rings, and a strawberry shake. Both were delicious. Of course I had to order the hubcap which is a large tenderloin, and that we split it and still got full... maybe it was the shake lol Highly recommend you coming to try the Knuckle Sandwich read more

See all

Great food...great service!! Clean restaurant and they play the best music. Our bacon was cooked perfectly!! read more

Love the ambiance. Great fried tenderloin. Unless you're super hungry, you'll be taking some home. Which was good. Great fries - seasoned and super crispy. Double burger was all it should be. Great meat, fresh veggies and tasty bun. Don't need truffle mayo with this one. I'll be going back. So many good things on the menu to try. read more

Our server was unfriendly AND surly. The food was ALMOST marginal. The decor was the only item worthy of note. Waste of time and money.

Great food at good prices and the mew location is really sharp... we have had most of the meals to Include the pizza... all great. Breakfast and dinner is always a treat here. read more

This is a fun 50's style dinner. Great food with great service. Very affordable for the family.

Fun atmosphere, 1950's vibe & music, server was great, food was very good and a substantial portion. We had a Reuben and a hamburger, both were excellent. Only downside is the 3.5% charge for using a credit card. read more

Great style, Elvis Presley table, Amazing burgers and fries, Overall amazing food, Would recommend to a friend.

What a delight to find this place in Bargersville. Food is ok with their huge burger 57 a highlight. No energy though which is why it's a 4 star review not a 5 star review read more

This is a great 50s themed diner and a perfect place to take the kids! Food is exceptional. Great burgers and ice cream!

We were a party of six on a hot day. It was a 15-20 minute wait to sit inside. The hostess saw we had four kids with us, so they put two small tables together and sat is right away. The waiter's service was excellent as well. I enjoyed my patty melt, my picky kids loved the cheese pizza, and the other kids cleaned their plates as well. We will be back. They also have an eating challenge, which I might try for fun. I think it's two of their 1-lb burgers with 2 lbs of fries in under 45 minutes. read more

Theme is great. Food pretty decent for diner type of restaurant. Service is horrible. Went on a Friday night and it was t busy. Staff too busy on their cell phones and talking about how much in tips they made for the day. read more