I can't believe I haven't posted a review before because Koi is one of daughter and son-in-law's 'go to' dining out locations in Tom's River. We have enjoyed sushi and other dinner menu items. Honestly I would have given them four stars (With an actual rating just about 3 1/2.) but that was before going HIBACHI-Style at KOI! First, I don't need the show and have never been wowed by the food until my Koi experience. Our chef, Jacky, was great and funny! He realized that my 5 year old grandson was not into the experience and he focused on on the adults. He made sure we enjoyed all the traditional fun. A side note, it was really nice sharing the hibachi table with strangers! As the saki squirted out we cheered for each other and there in an evening around the stove we verified that humans can really enjoy each other's company as strangers. I will admit I was disappointed in getting clear soup, which everyone else loved. I missed whether or not I could have chosen Miso and I really love their Miso at KOI. The food was more than plentiful but more importantly it was delicious. Three of the group had scallops and they were so perfect... imagine the best scallops you have ever enjoyed because these were a match for the best! The diner getting steak gave a thumbs up and everyone was happy as take-home boxes were handed out. I had room for green tea ice cream ... We all kept thanking my son-in-law on the way home ... hibachi was his idea but next time it will be mine. read more

See all

Doordashed--Very good sushi rolls. Got B&W roll, Philadelphia roll, & Bull of Demon King roll. All were very good read more

See all

We went to Koi last night for my daughter's birthday. There were 8 of us so definitely a decent size group to have a good time. I was completely shocked by the lack of enthusiasm by the hibachi chef. He had little to no interaction with us and basically just stood there and cooked the food! You go to hibachi for fun and entertainment by the cook! We got zero from this guy. So if you are going with a group make sure you ask for someone who will be lively and fun. If not you might wind up with a dud. read more

As always, a warm welcome, excellent food and service, and generous portions. It's on the regular rotation - especially for their great lunch specials. read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Pricey but worth the money. The variety of premium maki rolls available is astounding. There's something for everyone. This time I got the Love Potion filled with lobster meat, shrimp tempura, and avocado wrapped in soy paper and topped with mango sauce and black roe. Totally delicious! read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - Love Potion - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

The seafood/fish in our appetizers was amazing! So fresh, with amazing flavors! The whole roasted duck was incredible!!! Service was excellent. Nice atmosphere in the dining room. Can hear the excitement from the Hibachi side. This restaurant is consistently great! read more

See all

We came here randomly. Unfortunately, we didn't get to eat here we ordered take out. I was able to peak inside for a hot sec. It's huge! Looks clean and the decor was nice and inviting. Our order came out quickly. I ordered chicken and the hubs got steak and chicken. I got bonus shrimps in mine! Total win! Everything comes with a soup, salad, rice, noodles, and veggies. The portions are ridiculous btw! A lot of food, but it's really good food! We would like to go back to experience the habachi here. We'll eventually make our way back! Definitely a must try when in Toms River! read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - Hibachi Chicken and Steak Dinner - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Another great meal. As always. This is the best in Tom's River and surrounding areas. Ivee (sp), great server. Manager Nicole a pleasure as usual always with a warm friendly greeting and a sincere goodbye. All the staff is amazing And the chefs are so consistently preparing delicious food. read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Big portions Very nice place when you walk in Service was fast and checking on us Has a sushi area see them make sushi and seating in front Lots of tables and hibachi tables Food was really Poke bowl had some heat Hibachi was big portions Highly recommend to go if in the area read more

See all

Kids mad reservations for Mother's Day at 5:30p so 7 of us. We sat in the large dining room and it's BYOB so that is good. We ordered appetizers which in hind sight was a winner, because after ordering our food didn't come out until almost 7pm, guess who was last on that... me, lol. But the service was attentive, what can you do??? It's one of the busiest days of the year and the food was really good. It's not our first visit here, was it as good as it gets? Sure, if I wrap up all my other visits , into this visit it's still 5 stars!! Late food on Mother's Day, I won't take stars away, because I shared the day with the people I love and who love me, and THATS what the day is all about. read more

The restaurant is nestled on the side of a golfing hole. Hence the clients are mainly golfers. Having side rooms available there is always some type of medical dinner happening there or the booths in the back. As far as sushi goes, this place is just ok. The fish was fresh as of that morning, but they are very fast to get you food. And so sometimes the quality is not there on the dishes. The rolls looked to be rushed and did not appear well put together. I can down 3 rolls, and I was done after 1. The prices are at the high end and so make it not worth it for the quality of the food. The restaurant is busy because of all the golfers and medical dinners. This makes it hard place for anyone else to get good service. The bar is busy with golfers and the servers are covering all the doctors and pharmacists from the local hospital. And the decor is from the 90s. Feel like you are in the Scarface movie... nice, but very dated. read more

See all

Absolutely awful Pad Thai. Wrong type of noodle, hardly any tamarind sauce, 4 tiny pieces of chicken. I should have known. You don't order Thai food from a Chinese restaurant...and definitely not worth $19. read more

Good food, good service and good prices. Many unusual combinations of rolls. Highly recommended.

The food was amazing! Great service by our chef, he was so funny! The place is also great with a mini exhibit in the restaurant. read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - Hibachi Steak and Shrimp Lunch - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Ordered thru DoorDash. While most items were good to very good, my entre of filet Mignon and scallops was disappointing. Very little Mignon mixed with ?steak. I ordered medium rare and it was medium well at best. Too salty over- all. read more

Service was good, Food was very good. Only thing if you order lunch specials there's no substituting. I had to pay extra for Lo Mein noddles . In replacement of the rice. Didn't try the Hibachi mate next time read more

Apparently there is a sister Koi in Brick. These restaurants serve Asian fusion food: Japanese, Chinese, and Thai. We dined at this one in Toms River early last evening. It is a BYOB and we brought a bottle of Saki, which our attentive server Jenny kept heating up. The ambiance is nice in the dining and hibachi rooms (lots of tables and seats) and make sure you check out the mini-museum to the right as you enter. I like the menu, which is basically a book with pictures of dishes. We started with an appetizer Pandora Lobster, $14, lobster salad and avocado wrapped with rice paper, deep fried. Tasty. Our entrees came with soup and salad. You can order hibachi at regular sit down tables too. For entrees we had Hibachi Scallop with two shrimp, vegetables, noodles, fried rice and ice cream, $30. and Phoenix Roast Duck with fried rice and bok Choi, $30. Everything was delicious, and generous portions. We will return. read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - Entrees 6/24/23 - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I met an old friend here last night. The service and food was excellent. We stayed for about 3 hours talking . The servers were very friendly and didn't try to rush us out . Would definitely go back read more

Fun, clean and reliable dinner spot for groups. I liked it's flexibility, service and servings. read more

See all

Great lunch fun and delicious. Hibachi was great. Had the chicken filet mignon and shrimp. This is a hidden gem

it's really good! but they don't have enough gluten free options. I get that it's not supposed to be gluten free but THEY CAN MAKE IT! it's honestly not that hard! but anyway it's not bad read more

If you are looking for a great hibachi show this is not the place to go. The hibachi chef was not very exciting. However the portion sizes were great and food was very good. The restaurant was very quiet and clean. read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

We ordered the hibachi steak and chicken. Unlike my other experiences, this place food doesn't leave my dehydrated with the amount of sodium. It was simple and tasty. I recommend the appetizers as well, rangoons and calamari read more

See all

Food was delicious.... Chef Ricky was amazing and portions were big.... Green tea ice cream was one of the better ones I've had in a while... go visit them asap! read more

I really don't wanna leave a positive review for this place because I don't want it to become overcrowded where I can't get in and enjoy it. Services is excellent not super crowded. Laid out well not very noisy. Just the perfect hibachi place for me. read more

I've been here for both dine in (before Covid) and take out (after Covid). Quality is similar for both. Dumplings are definitely better eating in, as they were pretty cold by the time we got home. We got a sushi set and a couple of rolls the last time we did take out and the only thing I didn't like was that the tuna tasted a bit mediocre. Tuna is one of my favorites but I would stick to the salmon sushi here. read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Been here twice - 5/5 both times! Food, staff, and atmosphere is great. Sushi is fresh and the hibachi is full of flavor without feeling like they overloaded it with salt! Highly recommend. read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - Salmon Belly Salad - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Very good food whether it's sushi , Japanese or the fun of Hibachi . Excellent service, good atmosphere and reasonable prices too

I got the 3 roll lunch special for takeout and it was comparable to lunch specials I've had at other sushi locations. The ginger dressing on the salad tasted a bit less flavorful than I'm used to, but the fish quality and miso soup were good. read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - 3 roll lunch special - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I had the Chilean Sea Bass roll. Definitely great tasting! Filled with the sea bass and asparagus and topped with caviar. Yum! Staff is always attentive. Watch out on the soda refills....they cost. read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - Chilean Sea Bass Roll - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

The first time had a problem,Lucy is the nastiest waitress !!! Made my meal not enjoyable!!We ordered duck and in the brick location they give buns this location no they don't understand a thing suddenly! read more

See all

We took my sister visiting from out of state. She ordered a Thai mango dish and I ordered a flounder dish. Both were delicious. My husband who isn't a fan enjoyed his beef dish. They only had green tea to drink for teas. I was only able eat half and enjoyed the rest next day. The appetizer of fried calamari was nothing great. Too chewy. Looked more like well done onion rings. I was glad we called ahead for a reservation as the place filled up fast and if you are a Hibachi fan they do fun Hibachi experiences.the menu is huge and varied. Something for everyone. Nice waitstaff. read more

What a great place! Food was delicious service fantastic. Plenty of room, your not sitting on top of each other. My wife had a Flounder dish I had a sushi sashimi combo with a tuna roll. I was here three years ago and loved it and today was even better. Note: after we sat they realized they needed our spot for a reservation and asked us yo move. We gladly accommodated the request. After we moved a very sweet greeter brought us a $10.00 voucher. This gesture was greatly appreciated. I would definitely recommend this establishment. read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - Our dinners - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Disclaimer: Covid Takeout Review Small and safe gathering with friends, we took out Koi because it was close to friends home. We picked up. The staff was extremely friendly over the phone and in person. Prices were fair for sushi. The Rolls were about average in size and everything seemed fresh. On a critical level, the presentation of everything was nice as you can see from the picture but we didn't know what was what. Trying to figure out who's sushi was who's proved a small challenge. From a food critique, tempura was fried a little too hard and it left me and my fiancé with ingestion all night. I would have this again if I were in the area. read more

Koi Hibachi & Kitchen - They packed almost all the rolls into one big platter. - Teppanyaki Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Always an excellent experience here. The hibachi AND the sushi are very tasty, and there's plenty of variety!

Best food ever! Highly recommend. Had vegggie dumplings and mango sticky rice. Both taste extraordinary.

My family's favorite hibachi place ! Food and service is great ! Huge portions , prepare to go there hungry! We usually get the filet mignon with scallops and the meat is always cooked to your liking . Only thing I have to complain about is the soup that comes with the meal - it tastes like hot water ! read more

A-MA-ZING!!! Only way to describe this hibachi!! Made reservations and arrived on time. There were 5 of us, they took our temperatures and we were escorted to our table. Our waitress greeted us, took drink orders and brought them right over. I'm a vegan so I do have to be careful when I order, I asked the waitress about vegan options and she knew the menu as if she wrote it. We all had a delicious salad and soup (no soup for me as none are vegan) I had eggplant with tofu in garlic sauce with a (huge) size of vegetable fried rice with no egg. Everyone else had steak hibachi, with different requests--add chicken, med well, well done, no mushrooms etc -- all orders were made as requested. My husband is allergic to shell fish, the waitress took note of this to left the chef know. I polled the group and the feedback is: delicious, the meat was tender, we will definitely be back. The portions are also large, I had 2 boxes of left overs that I can't wait to eat! I hate to say this with such a positive review, if I could make one recommendation....the menus are literally a book and some of the pages were stuck together. I recommend they clean the menus. Other than this the place is VERY clean and welcoming. read more

See all

Fresh and tasty sushi. Creative rolls with lots of flavor. Attentive service and friendly staff. Favorite sushi spot in Ocean County!

koi is great. so many options, a bit pricey but big portions. lots of seating great for big gatherings. the workers are always nice.