Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Legend Larry's

    3.5 (43 reviews)
    Open 3:00 pm - 10:00 PM

    Order Legend Larry's Takeout or Delivery

    Legend Larry's Photos

    Business Info

    LEGEND LARRY'S ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Very loud
    Good for groups
    Outdoor seating
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    More like Legend Larry's

    Recommended Reviews - Legend Larry's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Dining room area. Don't sit next to the window in the winter.  It's a bit chilly.
    Mary Beth D.

    Echoing what others have already said, the food is better than the service. Had to track down the waitress in order to get a drink refill. Filled up with people quickly after we got here. Standing room only by the time we left. The bathroom had cold water only and the exhaust fan was caked with dust.

    Dinner with Teresa and Mom
    Brenda C.

    It was an off night maybe. Hardly anyone there and we had to wait to be seated. The wings were delicious... so that part was great. The shrimp I would save your money... the menu was just a piece of paper actually a half sheet of paper.... so buy the chicken wings and watch some sports.

    a television and a bar
    Amy A.

    Great wings, salads, and apps. I enjoy the atmosphere. It gets loud during sports games, fyi. Full bar. Food can take a long time if busy.

    a woman sitting at a bar
    Clayton K.

    Wings are awesome; that delicate balance between crispy and juicy... Larry seems to have mastered it. If you want sports on all screens like BW's, this may not be your place though (Sheboygan Falls). Perhaps an All Sceens policy and procedure here could help. 60 Minutes on Sunday evening, really? I see enough of world tragedy everywhere else, just want wings and sports. Asked to have it changed, one screen set to sports. Four Stella Artois ordered, all poured into the same glass, hmmmmm... Wings = sticky glass. Yawn... on my way to BW's..

    Hangin' with the crew at Legend Larry's...
    Brian H.

    Great food as usual, but VERY slow service and incompetent staff. I'm disappointed, but I know this place will be great when they work the bugs out! I'll give it another try in a few months....

    Entryway to an experience your stomach, colon, and taste buds will congratulate your sage wisdom for.

    See all

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Excellent wings and great service if your hungry and in the sheboygan area you should definitely check this place out!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Love the wings, atmosphere, servers, and everything about Legend Larry's!! Two thumbs up!! Would recommend to anyone and everyone!!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Legend Larry's

    Review Highlights - Legend Larry's

    Cold beer, delicious wings, and this location is very nice, with restaurant section for seating.....

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 812 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Horse & Plow - Smashburger

    The Horse & Plow

    3.7(246 reviews)
    2.2 mi
    $$

    The Horse & Plow is a routine stop to refresh while enroute from the MKE airport to the U.P. of…read moreMichigan. While living in the Village of Kohler in "my previous life" the American Club was the centerpiece. Many family and visitor gatherings at the "H&P". Nathan greeted us upon opening for an early lunch snack and bloody. We split the Club sandwich (with center bread removed). Delicious and perfect portion. The Bloody Mary screams Wisconsin w the skewer loaded up with snacks, and the cute "Baby Miller" as a back. The Horse & Plow Club sandwich was so good, we stopped a few days later while heading back to the airport. The bar tends to get busy w hotel guests, golfers and tourists. It's the place to be!

    This was a place where you get your typical bar food. I ordered the burger and I actually loved the…read morepatty and the cheese on it was actually very flavorful and added a great flavor profile to the burger, but the bun was very thick and dry. I took the top bun off at some point cause it was too much bread. Came here cause I heard the cheese curds were some of the best in Wisconsin. Honestly they were kind of underwhelming. They served it with a blueberry jam which I thought was interesting and it tasted good together, but nothing special to be honest. The American Club area is super beautiful inside and out and the Horse and Plow fit that same vibe.

    Photos
    The Horse & Plow - Booth ambiance

    Booth ambiance

    The Horse & Plow
    The Horse & Plow - Get a bloody. No, get 2!!

    See all

    Get a bloody. No, get 2!!

    The Blind Horse - Pancetta Wrapped Scallops (Signature Dish)

    The Blind Horse

    4.2(263 reviews)
    2.0 mi
    $$

    Just awful. Really poor service and outright terrible food. We started with appetizers for some…read morereason they came after the entrees (cheese curds were good but you can't mess that up). My daughter ordered the burger medium. What came was literally crunchy it was so over cooked!! My father in law ordered the burger as well and asked for medium rare. His also came wildly over cooked. My other daughter had the Caesar salad. It tasted like someone accidentally spilled an entire container of salt on it. Completely inedible. My steak sandwich much like the burgers was shoe leather. I asked for ketchup for my fries from three separate waiters. All said "no problem" but nobody brought me ketchup. Another table heard my repeated requests and very generously brought their tables ketchup to me. The only thing that was edible was my wife's fig pizza. However a he ordered a drink - it never came but I was charged for it. I have no problem sending an individual dish back if it's bad but the whole tables worth of food?? Complete clown show of food and service. Never again! Shame.

    Updating my review to rave about our recent service…read more Joined by my bestie and her husband who drove all the way from Denver to see us, my partner and I returned to The Blind Horse for a birthday dinner. My bestie is SEVERELY allergic to poultry and her husband was recently diagnosed with Celiac disease which means gluten is no good (even "cross contamination"). This makes finding a restaurant that can accommodate their needs a huge challenge. Our server went out of her way to talk to the chef and check things out. They were able to accommodate these specific diets and still beautifully create their entrees. It has been horrible to adjust life with Celiac, so when the food came out, I really thought there might be some tears of joy. ;) This gave us more reasons to come back! Thank you!

    Photos
    The Blind Horse - Granary bar

    Granary bar

    The Blind Horse
    The Blind Horse - Raspberry Dreams

    See all

    Raspberry Dreams

    Frankies Pub & Grill - Cheese curds, not beer battered like the menu says

    Frankies Pub & Grill

    4.4(126 reviews)
    4.4 mi
    $$

    Sandwiches the size of an adult's head. This local tavern was a fun stop after visiting Road…read moreAmerica in Elkhart Lake. We ordered a club sandwich & a chicken bacon club. Like I said before, the sandwiches arrived the size of an adult's head. Jar dropping is a fitting description of what we looked like when our server placed the sandwiches before us. The homemade bread was soft and delicious. The chicken club easily had half a pound of cooked bacon on it. Before we ever took our first bites, we knew we would need to go boxes. Wait, did I mention we had the most wonderful cheese curbs as an appetizer? Worth ordering but only if you split a sandwich!! There are a handful of booths in the front area along with seating along the bar. TVs in the main room. There is also a back room that would hold maybe another 40 people. This tavern has been in place for years under different names. I would love to hear the history. I could see a set up that would have been particularly useful for gambling & drinking during prohibition. The staff was very efficient and helpful. One person out front & one in back. Never had to wait.

    We went to Frankie's after I saw an article describing it as one of the best burgers. As others…read morehave said, they are huge, 1 lb. on a custom bun. My wife had a reuben burger and I had blue cheese. Both were great. We ate at the bar and split some fries. Our bartender/server was terrific. Usual small bar charm. Their was a back room which I saw when using the restroom. Expect leftovers unless you can eat 2 half pound burgers. They have a 5 1/2lb. burger in one hour challenge which I can't even comprehend trying. We will return.

    Photos
    Frankies Pub & Grill
    Frankies Pub & Grill - Giant Classic Cheeseburger with bacon

    Giant Classic Cheeseburger with bacon

    Frankies Pub & Grill - Inside

    See all

    Inside

    Legend Larry's - newamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...