This small down gem, located in an old dairy bar, has great food. The portions are large. You can…read moreseriously get two days worth on an order or feed two people. They have a select menu plus a menu that rotates weekly. Everything is fresh and flavorful. The owner and his staff are amazing and will bend over backwards for you. I can't recommend this place highly enough!

We were in Bellfountain and stopped here for lunch. This place is take out only, no tables. It's a…read morehealthy option. I had the Mediterranean bowl. It had grilled chicken (chewy but tasted good,) brown rice, Kalamata olives, diced tomatoes, cuke bees, chickpeas, and roasted red peppers. A serving of good tzatziki sauce came with it. I had a side of the slaw which was way too creamy. My son had the Asian bowl. Same good chicken he said he liked it. He also had a side of hot potato salad which was just ok. I'll try some other things next time.

A BBQ place smack dab in the middle of nowhere. They open at 11:30 and had a line at noon when we…read morearrived. The ladies at the counter are so kind, sweet and friendly! They explained things to us as it was our first time there. The pulled pork and brisket was decent, loved the Blackberry BBQ sauce, baked beans and Mac & cheese was just meh....to be honest, we've had much better BBQ at a food truck we came upon not long ago. I will say the cornbread was phenomenal though. Not saying we wouldn't stop again if we were ever in the area but wouldn't make a special trip

Walked in and instantly hit in the face with the delightful smells of well prepared foods. The…read morejalapeño corn pudding was amazing!!!

Stopped in after a museum tour. Sat at the bar. Very good service, fantastic bartender! Spinach…read moreartichoke dip was amazing! Smaller on the inside, but there are more rooms and a nice patio!

This is such a gem! We sat on the outdoor patio, which was an excellent area on a warm summer day…read more The service was fast and friendly. I was amazed at how quickly our order came out. The food was delicious. I had the grilled chicken pesto sandwich. It as messy, but sooo good. I would definitely come back if I was driving through town again.

After hearing so many good things about Don's Downtown Diner in Bellefontaine, we finally made it…read morein--and I'm glad we did! This super cute little diner is family-owned and operated, and from the moment we walked in, we felt right at home. We had the pleasure of meeting Tania and her granddaughter Maddy, who were both incredibly friendly and genuinely excited that we stopped by. The diner is absolutely oozing with personality. It feels like you're visiting family... if family charged you for a great hamburger! I ordered the Body Bearded Burger, a smash burger topped with your choice of cheese, crispy bacon, peanut butter, and the option to add jelly for just 99 cents. They offer grape or strawberry jelly, and of course I had to try it. All burgers come with fresh-cut fries, though you can upgrade to onion rings for a small additional charge. The burger was outstanding. Cooked perfectly on the griddle and served on a nicely toasted bun, every bite was packed with flavor. The peanut butter added a rich, nutty taste, the bacon brought a salty crunch, and the jelly added just the right touch of sweetness. It sounds like an unusual combination, but trust me--it works incredibly well. The fresh-cut fries were a great side, and the whole meal felt like classic diner comfort food done right. If you're anywhere near Bellefontaine, do yourself a favor and stop by Don's Downtown Diner. Great food, great people, and the kind of hometown atmosphere that's becoming harder and harder to find.

Stopped here today for lunch. We had tried two times in the past but they were closed both times…read more We were hoping the 3rd time was a charm and it was! This was a cute family owned restaurant. We met the owner Tanya and her granddaughter Maddie. Both were super nice and told us a lot about the customers, the history of the place and the food everyone loves! We came for their fresh local meat hamburgers. I got the portobello burger. It had swiss cheese, fried portobello mushrooms, and horseradish sauce. I opted to not get the horseradish sauce. The burger came with handcut fries that were hot and fresh. The burger was hot and tasted very good. This is a very family friendly place that serves good home cooked food. I highly recommend coming here and make sure you talk to Tanya. She is super friendly! You will really like her and the food is GOOD!! Take a walk downtown after you eat. Bellfontaine is a super cute town with quant shops!

Great atmosphere and even better drinks. The signature drinks are well prepared and have a lot of…read morevariety. The house coffee is also excellent if you just want to sip and relax for a bit. Also great service.

A very clean restaurant. I felt very safe. I had the buffalo chicken panini and a chocolate chip…read morescone. They were very good. They have a picnic table outside on the sidewalk next to them. A great stop when you are visiting the area. And don't miss Marie's Chocolates just down the street.

Ambiance is minimal. A fair amount of table groupings. A TV playing the food network and nothing to…read moreblow you away with related to decor. Local OSU stuff on the walls. The kid at the counter was helpful. We wanted some onion rings but their fryer was down so we pivoted to order wings. I don't remember what sauce we had but we ordered 8 and it looked like the most pathetic basket of wings ever seen. Super small wings. They tasted good but it could be just because they were drenched in the sauce. Waited a while for the wings and even longer for the pizza. The pizza was good. Good amount of toppings. It wasn't bad pizza but it wasn't great. We couldn't tell why we weren't overly impressed with the pizza but it was just pizza. Pizza came out screaming hot, which was nice because the restaurant was chilly because it was below zero outside. So one upside is the pizza was hot and stayed hot for a while as we ate it. Hard to see as it sat at the end of a strip of other businesses as the end of the building away from the road. All in all, it wasn't bad pizza but we probably won't drive to Bellfontaine for Fat Boys. Gave it a 3 out of 5 because of what was mentioned plus the one menu on the Yelp site was old and the pizza we thought was going to be $19.99 ended up being almost $10 more than the new menu listing. Didn't think a medium pizza was worth $28 bucks...especially when two shared it and we only took a couple of pieces home.

We love Fat Boys pizza. We quit ordering for awhile because toppings were no where near the edge…read more And the price was one of the highest around. Which we don't mind paying for quality but can't justify it when you are not getting a complete product. After a couple of years we decided to give them another shot. Still great pizza and it seemed like they were finally getting the toppings to the edge until last night. And I understand prices are crazy on everything now but $49 for this pizza and 14 wings when the pizza was missing toppings.

The last 2 visits to this restaurant have been less than satisfying. This used to be a friendly…read moreplace to pop in for a sandwich. Lately the staff is just rude! I don't expect to be snapped at while spending my money at a business. I will not bother coming back again!

Food looked good but they were rushing us 2 employees asking us questions at same time very rude…read morewanting us to checkout and tell them are toppings at same time I felt like they were trying to push us out the door

We have been back several times since our first visit. They continue to impress with customer…read moreservice and quality of food!! Keep it up!

Always have had a good experience when stopping here, this time was no different! Subs are always…read moreas ordered and stuffed to the brim! The atmosphere if staying in to eat is very casual. Actually enjoyed eating in because we had fun talking to a nearby table of folks who lived nearby! Great lunch spot!

I like Firehouse for a couple reasons. They support our first responders, and they have a wonderful…read moresandwich with corned beef and pastrami. Last time I got take out, sandwich bread was bit soggy for some reason. Not sure if it was caused by pickle juice or too much vinegar and oil. Still a good sandwich. I prefer to eat there, but sometimes my walking takes me to takeout. I prefer Firehouse over the competition that is out there.

I personally witnessed an employee being publicly humiliated by the owner…read more I stopped into Firehouse Subs in Sidney, Ohio on Friday, July 24, 2026, and a blonde female employee had just begun taking my order when the owner, Tom Martin, came out of nowhere and started yelling, cursing, and degrading her in front of multiple customers and another employee. The public humiliation, intimidation, and imbalance of power were difficult to watch and reminded me of the dynamics often seen in emotionally abusive relationships. I was in shock. My hands were shaking after witnessing a man old enough to be this young woman's grandfather openly attempt to intimidate and bully her in front of customers and another employee. If he was willing to speak to her that way in front of customers, it left me concerned about how employees may be treated when no one is watching. After he finished yelling at her, she returned to taking my order with kindness, professionalism, and a smile. Despite what had just happened, she remained polite, respectful, and focused on providing excellent customer service. She handled herself with far more professionalism than anyone should have been expected to under those circumstances. That young woman deserves recognition for her professionalism and composure. She represented the business with far more dignity than the person who owns it.

Food and service are awesome…read more Ambiance: Recommend sitting inside. The seats open to the outside and facing the street are unfortunately facing west and the sun. In back the seats are picnic tables.

So good! Great vibes, playlist was great and the food and drinks were awesome!!! We will definitely…read morebe back!