Visiting friends in this neighborhood and discovered this classic NYC pizza shop. Nice counter service. Families dining at the tables. Good neighborhood feel. I pointed to the pizza with bacon and chicken and it is served with some stripes of ranch dressing. I would have preferred it without the ranch, but otherwise good crust, textures, and flavors. Over $5 for one slice though. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Ranch Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Pizza. GOOD. Enjoyed a classic Cheese Slice at this local spot. LIBRETTO's has been around for a couple of decades and they didn't skimp on the Cheese, which was perfect for me. RECOMMEND. read more

See all

This place has the perfect NYC pizzeria vibe. The service and food was amazing. This place exceeded my expectations. Hands down the best pizzeria I visited while in the city. read more

I strolled in around 4ish pretty quite but was helped right away, the place is clean and the pizza was great! Def one of my favorites now when I come into the city and stay in or around midtown read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - pepperoni slide and meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

3.31.25 approximately 11:30am - Didn't get to eat here. Just before paying was told by the person at the register that one cheese slice and a Snapple was $12. Disappointing. read more

Libretto's is a great pizza place and definitely worth a visit. The service was fast and friendly. It is very comfortable with a good amount of seating They had a variety of pizzas sitting to order. I had a couple of slice of sausage. They were excellent. It has a thin, crunchy crust cooked to perfection. I also loved the sausage. Others in the party also really like their pizzas. Definitely worth a visit. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Best BBQ Chicken Pizza I've ever tasted. I love everything about this place. Great atmosphere, fast service, kind employees, and a very nice dining experience. I would definitely recommend anyone who enjoys a good slice of pizza to come check this place out. 10 out of 10. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Their service is terrible and everything is overpriced even for manhattan rates not to mention the pizza looks like it's been sitting out since this morning! read more

First dinner while in NYC! Hotel recommendation that was good! We flew up from NC and didn't eat lunch so we were STARVING when we got checked into the hotel. We had a pepperoni pizza, meatball parmesan hero with fries. WOW! Hot, fresh and delicious! NY pizza at its best! Really enjoyed it! read more

See all

Pizza was good. The highlight was being given a cup of ice for no charge. In this era of being seemingly nickel and dimed everywhere, this was quite nice to be treated like a human. read more

Above average pizza slices in NYC during a time when quality is decreasing. The atmosphere is friendly and the surroundings is very old school classic Italian. The service is attentive, prompt and friendly. read more

I came in with my mom and sister on Christmas Eve while we were waiting for our reservation at another restaurant. We were really hungry, so we decided to stop in for a quick slice, and we were pleasantly surprised! It's a cozy spot with quite a few seating options. The staff is nice and quick to bring your food out. They had so many different pizza options! They also had pastas, salads, and soup. On our first day there, we each grabbed a slice of pepperoni pizza and really enjoyed it. The crust was thin and had the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. We ended up going back for lunch the next day. That day, we tried the Margherita, white sauce, chicken pizza, and a soup. All of which were delicious. I'm not a native New Yorker, but in my opinion, this was some great NY style pizza! read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The pizza is great with a large selection of flavors. The service is fine for a pizza place and the ambiance is warm.

Pizza was hot, fresh and delicious!! Would definitely stop in again when in The Murray Hill neighborhood.

My favorite pizzeria in NY. Ambiance 5/5: Cozy spot that transports you away from the hustle and bustle of the city. TV playing, the smell of great pizza, subtle sounds from the back of house...it's magic. Service 5/5: quick and lively. The manager is a stand up guy! Food 5/5: Pretty much had everything but the alla vodka and chipotle chicken are my go-to. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Chicken Chipotle and BBQ chicken - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My boyfriend and I are locals who have been loyal to this spot for nearly two years. We bring our friends here and loved telling people about this spot. Unfortunately last night was my last time bringing my business here. My friends and I came for pizza after a night out. My two friends ordered garlic knots and two slices. I separately ordered one slice. The worker HANDED us our orders and we realized they accidentally gave us an order of garlic knots with my slice that I had not ordered. Out of courtesy I let them know that I had not ordered these. I expected them to just say it's on the house as my order is already IN MY HANDS. The worker REACHES OVER with a spatula and literally took out the garlic knots from the pizza box in my hands. He then asks me if I want to keep the marinara sauce that came with the knots. I absolutely said no. I cannot believe he had the idea to reach over and take food off of a customer's plate. If he wanted the garlic knots back that badly, request my pizza box back and go do that behind the counter. That is such cheap and dirty behavior and I am so shocked and disappointed that this behavior came from this establishment. We truly loved libretto's so much. Most of the workers here are very kind and we've come to even say hello to some of them. This review is not written out of anger, but sheer disappointment. So sad that I can no longer give business to this establishment as we truly were so loyal to this spot. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Absolutely disgusting. They did not even bother packing the food items for delivery. Item arrived in an open container, with no lid, with spaghetti noodles and meatballs thrown into a plastic bag like someone had vomitted it up. When I first called the store, they hung up on me. When I called back the second time, a person said: "Maybe someone ate your food on the way and threw it back in the bag" with no admittance of the fact that they did not even PACK it with a LID as anyone would, when packaging FOOD items. Disgusting and heinous, in both food and attitude. There are several poor reviews of this place. Take note and beware. It is best to not waste your time here. read more

Heard about how great the NY-style pizza is here so ordered a whole pie for dinner. It was okay, but nothing to write home about. The sauce was meh to be honest and there was not enough of it. I expected sausage meat when I ordered sausage but got cut slices of sausage. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Large pie with sausage and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

My co-workers love this place, so we came for a team lunch! Honestly, nothing beats New York pizza. They have a good lunch deal for a drink that's included, and two slices is a lot of food for me. I love sprinkling red chili flakes onto my pizza, and I thoroughly enjoyed it. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Lovely place! Immaculate service and the best pizza I've had! We got mushroom pizza and it was so. Good. Would definitely recommend this spot to anybody. A great introduction to pizza in New York! read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Mushroom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I wanted to find a good neighborhood staple and I did !! Loved their pizza Bianca and rice ball. Had been missing good nyc pizzeria staples after being in CA last 4 years so thankful to found this gem read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great slices of pie... crispy and light with a great undercarriage.. can't figure out why some of the low reviews.. we traveled from Ohio and it hit the spot.. nice classic Caesar salad with good zest. Don't be fooled by the ratings. Decent amount of seating as well read more

Order from here a lot and this time got the eggplant parm, whole wheat pasta, chicken roll and they were all amazing, the plain slices are always great as well. Ate like half of the eggplant parm before taking the pic but wanted to show how huge it is! read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Eggplant Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I came here after work with my two year old and a dried asked for two cups of water after ordering a slice and a drink This worker rudely replied " there's water in the fridge" and proceeds to help the next customer while I was at the register to pay. My friend agree to buy a bottle of water and I politely asked for cup of water and he said " you are not the only customers in here" while I was at the front of the register. After I paid for my meal, I asked for a receipt and this man replied "I will cancel your transaction". I politely asked said " I did not ask you to cancel my order, I asked for a receipt. The. I politely asked him his name and he said "I don't want to give your I my name . I have never been so disrespected as a customer in any establishment in my life. I have lived in Murray Hill for years and never had experiences such treatment. At no point was I rude to this man. A after we were served our food, I asked this man a third time for a cup of water and he finally gave it to my two year old. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We ordered delivery from here through DoorDash on a Sunday evening. Our food arrived quickly and was fresh and warm. I ordered the Rigatoni Alla Vodka and my hubby ordered the chicken parmigiana. Both portions were huge and were accompanied by bread. We also ordered garlic knots. The garlic knots were seasoned well but a tad chewy for my taste. I loved the vodka sauce! We each ordered a Cannoli which were delicious! The cream had an almond taste and was so good! We will definitely order from here again or dine in if available. read more

Best slice near our hotel. Definitely get the vodka slice. And the crew were all very nice.

Pizza is OK late night pizza at best. Tonight I go there looks like barely any left and they are closing. I got one slice of pepperoni and I hand him a $5 bill. He looks at me I said what? He says you owe me 17 cents. I said $5 for a slice of pizza? Are you kidding me? I hand him a $1 bill and said keep the change you cheap skate. Seriously going to make a fuss over 17 cents. Absolutely overpriced and they aren't even Italian. Seems like other complaints on here too about reaching over already handed out boxes for garlic knots. What a DISGRACE! read more

Can't use check in coupon during nighttime, vodka slice was half decent. $4.95 for a slice , this is desperate pizza.

HEALTH AND SAFETY HAZARD!!! I ordered delivery from Libretto's via Uber Eats. Part of the order was a slice of tiramisu. After taking a bite, I noticed there was a large, sharp piece of black plastic in my gums. It was cooked right into the cake and blended with the dark chocolate, so I didn't notice until it was too late. I reported the issue to Uber Eats but they refused to deal with the matter. A photograph of a piece of plastic outside of the cake apparently isn't enough evidence that it was inside the cake before I bit into it. It took a few hours to hear back from Uber, and by then the restaurant was closed. I called the next morning and the employee was rude and dismissive. He was angry that I first tried to deal with the issue through Uber instead of calling the restaurant directly. There's nothing they can do, ... I need to call back in a few days when the manager is there. All for a piece of cake under $10. I highly recommend ordering from another one of the thousands of other pizza places nearby. This one has poor quality and horrible service. read more

Review brought to you by a guy born and raised in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. :) Great pizzeria in Murray Hill. Their sauce is fresh and their crust is great. Also, the staff is friendly - which I can't say about most pizzerias in Manhattan. I would recommend their vodka slice. read more

This is a super cute pizzeria with amazingly delicious pizza and cannolis. We highly recommend the New Yorker pizza and the classic cheese pizza. The restaurant staff is very friendly and our server was very nice and friendly and made us feel super welcomed. read more

See all

This small pizza joint in the Murray Hill neighborhood was close to our hotel part of what drew us here were the positive reviews from Yelp. It did not disappoint, the cheese pizza was hot and tasty and the Caesar salad was good. We did not expect the dressing to taste like it was from scratch but what a suprise. We came here to eat here twice during our visit and each time we had a friendly server and good service. Recommend, read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Indoors - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I have to say this is the worst chicken parm I have ever had from Libretto's, I'm a doorman around the corner and I'm not sure if it was a new cook or what but chicken parm had noooo sauce and tiny piece of mozzarella. We have a short dinner break so wasn't really able to go back and complain for the 2 chicken parm's we ordered on Sunday 12/29 at 650 pm , you really need to do something about this cook, he may cause you to loose good long term customers ... read more

Love Libretto's!! Order from here at least once a week. All their pasta is amazing and I love their sandwiches as well. Highly recommend. Very efficient and quick service. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Veal Parm Hero - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Librettos is my FAVORITE pizza in Murray Hill and I'm not embarrassed to say that I grab a slice every week. Huge selection of different toppings ready by the slice, but I usually stick to plain (sometimes pepperoni, margarita, vodka sauce, or white). These guys have worked so hard during Covid-19, please go and support them!! read more

If you're in the area looking for a quick slice, Libretto's is exactly the spot. Not only does it have a crunchy crust, but the taste is spectacular and even a bit unique. Super sizable and delicious, and it all comes out quite fast. A bit more expensive than the dollar slices you can get in NYC, but I'd for sure recommend. Great soundtrack too, and great seating available. read more

Came for lunch during work. Had a craving for traditional Sicilian pie. Took about 10 minutes to make, and came out piping hot. The problem is, this was very cheese heavy more so than saucy. So after a few minutes, the cheese was almost difficult to eat as it became cool and hardened. Flavor was good, but I'd prefer them to have a heavier hand on the sauce. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This is my favorite pizza in the city. First discovered this place around 2016 and it's still great. I enjoy the seating area in the back too. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped in for a quick snack. The pepperoni slice was your standard NY slice. The garlic knots were okay, but were probably sitting out too long and the quick trip in the oven couldn't save them. I drowned them in the marinara sauce and they were ok. I will try these guys again during the day to nab something fresher. read more

Libretto's Pizzeria - Pepperoni Slice Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This is my first time at librettos pizza. The place is adorable! exposed brick walls Burnt orange coverings on the booths and Italian paintings and pictures on the walls. it's incredibly clean the staff are nice and the food came out quickly. the prices are very reasonable as well. they have specials as well.. get two slices of pizza and get a free drink. I ordered a margarita individual pizza It had four slices and it was delicious! I've never had a better margarita pizza anywhere else not even in Italy. all the ingredients tasted fresh & clean The silverware was clean the bathrooms were clean the place was pretty spotless. And I loved the decor and Ambiance. I will definitely be back. read more

See all